RE: Alpenglow concept returns as hydrogen-powered Hy4

RE: Alpenglow concept returns as hydrogen-powered Hy4

Friday 10th May

Alpenglow concept returns as hydrogen-powered Hy4

Four-cylinder and 340hp for now, but Alpine is also working on a new V6...


There’s no faulting Alpine’s commitment to the future. Far from resting on its laurels, it seems determined to embrace what’s coming and (hopefully) still deliver some great sports cars that don’t rely on petrol power. We’ve already seen the A110 E-ternité concept, which demonstrated that EV sports cars don’t have to be heavy and weird, and now there’s this, the Hy4. It’s an evolution of the stunning Alpenglow concept seen a couple of years ago, and is powered by a hydrogen-fuelled four-cylinder engine. Note that’s not a hydrogen fuel cell, as used for a very small amount of electric cars like the Toyota Mirai; it’s a sports car that looks like this, with an engine, that uses hydrogen as a fuel. Also as Toyota has been exploring with its race cars, GR Yaris and Lexus V8

It’s not necessarily something anyone saw coming from Alpine, particularly given the wider Renault Group’s long standing commitment to battery electric vehicles, but the Alpenglow Hy4 is said to mark something of a turning point. Of course there’s the usual line about motorsport influencing road cars - ‘Alpine firmly believes in the role of motorsport as an accelerator for the development of future mobility technologies’ is the soundbite this time - but also a declaration of support for hydrogen from Renault. A joint venture with Plug called HYVIA is promising hydrogen charging stations (with liquid hydrogen being explored also), fleet financing and maintenance for a hydrogen fuel cell commercial vehicle will be in place, there’s going to be a hybrid using a hydrogen range extender, and there are engines in development specifically designed to be powered by hydrogen. They will be for ‘high-powered extra-urban commercial use and specific sportier purposes.’

Cars exactly like the Hy4, then. For the moment, this rolling prototype - it’ll be demonstrated at the Spa 6 Hours this weekend - is powered by a 340hp, 2.0-litre four-cylinder turbo; but this is just a stepping stone to the next version, which will be seen before the end of the year, that’s going to feature a V6 engine. An all-new unit, no less, with the focus on hydrogen power. Nothing if not interesting. Ultimately Alpine sees the fuel as ‘a new approach to decarbonizing motor racing and a possible avenue for sports cars’. There are no guarantees, of course, though anything that can keep engines in cars as visceral as sports cars surely has to be explored. 

Here the engine revs to 7,000rpm, the gears are changed sequentially and the Hy4 can reach 168mph; but doing that is the easy bit compared to storing and using hydrogen. Petrol is a liquid, obviously, and is far easier to create a homogenous combustion mixture from than hydrogen gas. Though it can burn in both lean and rich mixes, hydrogen must avoid what’s called ‘abnormal combustion’, which means paying very close attention to the mix and the temperature of the combustion chamber. The gas is stored in tanks around the Hy4 at 700 bar, which is then brought down to 200 bar by a pressure regulator, before entering the combustion chamber at 40 bar. Alpine has a range of measures in place for best safety practice, with Regulation 134 certified storage chambers, pressure sensors, a ‘rigorous’ start up procedure and, of course, lots of checks. Alpine really wants this work, and a track demo in front of sportscar racing fans is the perfect place to show it off; anything going wrong would be a disaster.

As for the car itself, the Hy4 has evolved a little since it was the Alpenglow, said to bridge a gap between motorsport and road (it uses an LMP3 carbon chassis for now). By making this car a two seater where it was just single occupancy before, the Hy4 inevitably looks a little less like the futuristic racer, but still with some dramatic design details. It’s going to make passers-by gawp, that’s for sure, at 5.2m long, just 1.1m high and more than two metres wide, plus with that long tail like the old Alpine A220 (that’s now being resurrected by Zagato). But it perhaps now looks just a little more like a viable concept than a crazy Vision Gran Turismo car. Design Director Anthony Villain says the Hy4 is “a true racing car with all the visual and acoustic expression you would expect."

While it’s easy to think of hydrogen still as a future fuel, it’s worth remembering that hydrogen-powered racers will be permitted at Le Mans from 2027 onwards. That’s surely a race that Alpine has its eye on. Formula 1 could make the switch in the 2030s as well. For the French brand, it seems very keen on the hydrogen path; as well as negligible CO2 and significantly reduced NOx, it means a ‘very similar feel of the engine for the driver and a sound ideally suited to Alpine's racer philosophy.’ So don’t expect an Alpine Formula E car very soon, by the sounds of it. As for the Alpenglow Hy4, it will be driven this weekend by Guillaume De Ridder, an Alpine Racing engineer and rallycross champion. on track at Le Mans next month, too. Could this be the future of sportscar racing?


Author
Discussion

Geoffcapes

Original Poster:

712 posts

165 months

Friday 10th May
quotequote all
Any minute now the EV evangelista's will be along to say that hydrogen won't work as a fuel for cars because........


Dave Hedgehog

14,587 posts

205 months

Friday 10th May
quotequote all
Geoffcapes said:
Any minute now the EV evangelista's will be along to say that hydrogen won't work as a fuel for cars because........
because if it did work it would already be here biggrin

SDK

904 posts

254 months

Friday 10th May
quotequote all
Geoffcapes said:
Any minute now the EV evangelista's will be along to say that hydrogen won't work as a fuel for cars because........
This is a race car (Concept), which is mostly not impacted by the negatives of hydrogen powered engines.
e.g. Hydrogen leaks out of the tank - Over a few days to a week, most of the hydrogen in the tank will be gone ! so you can't park underground or in an un-vented garage.




Edited by SDK on Friday 10th May 11:35

steveb8189

479 posts

192 months

Friday 10th May
quotequote all
Geoffcapes said:
Any minute now the EV evangelista's will be along to say that hydrogen won't work as a fuel for cars because........
I'm a firm believer we'll see hydrogen fuel cell cars in the future unless wireless charging infrastructure proves to be scalable. Hydrogen combusion cars like this will not make it mass market and will be reserved for people like us who still like the feel and experience of an ICE. They're just too complex, with too many moving parts and have all the downsides of hydrogen without the upsides of fuel cells

GT9

6,830 posts

173 months

Friday 10th May
quotequote all
Geoffcapes said:
Any minute now the EV evangelista's will be along to say that hydrogen won't work as a fuel for cars because........
Nice looking car!
However...
Look at the size of the 10,000 psi fuel tanks, one on each side.
This is a racing car, despite the stupidly high pressure in them, those fuel tanks are storing the same amount of energy as a single petrol tank one quarter of the size of one of them.
This is a laws of physics thing, i.e. it's not negotiable.
Good luck building a powerful road car with that set up.

SDK

904 posts

254 months

Friday 10th May
quotequote all
GT9 said:
Nice looking car!
However...
Look at the size of the 10,000 psi fuel tanks, one on each side.
This is a racing car, despite the stupidly high pressure in them, those fuel tanks are storing the same amount of energy as a single petrol tank one quarter of the size of one of them.
This is a laws of physics thing, i.e. it's not negotiable.
Good luck building a powerful road car with that set up.
Yep smile

Engineering Explained did a video on Hydrogen engines a few years back.

All of this is based on physics : People !!! watch it and make your own mind up !



Bladedancer

1,298 posts

197 months

Friday 10th May
quotequote all
Dave Hedgehog said:
Geoffcapes said:
Any minute now the EV evangelista's will be along to say that hydrogen won't work as a fuel for cars because........
because if it did work it would already be here biggrin
If you look at the actual argument it's "because there aren't enough fuel stations", which is true. Same was true once, a long time ago, for petrol.
It's not that they don't work. It's that with the infrastructure now it's really annoying to own one.

Harry_523

360 posts

100 months

Friday 10th May
quotequote all
If you think EV fires are bad wait until one of these catches a spark biglaugh

Also, lifecycle efficiency is st, as is the amount of package space required for hydrogen tanks in cars. Non-starter.

SDK

904 posts

254 months

Friday 10th May
quotequote all
Bladedancer said:
If you look at the actual argument it's "because there aren't enough fuel stations", which is true. Same was true once, a long time ago, for petrol.
It's not that they don't work. It's that with the infrastructure now it's really annoying to own one.
Hydrogen combustion engines work BUT there are massive challenges and blockers. Many of which are based on limitations of physics and cannot be overcome.

Mainly - The hydrogen gas is compressed to 10,000 PSI, and when filled into the same space as a 77L fuel tank, you'll only get about 50 miles (based on the WLTP range). So, to travel 300 miles (WLTP) you need the equivalent space of six 77L fuel tanks (about 460L), plus packaging to ensure the tank is safe if involved in a crash.

Hydrogen can be stored as a liquid, which reduces the space requirement for storage but you need to get the hydrogen temperature down to -250c for that that to happen, and keep it there rotate

Realistically - the best way for Hydrogen vehicles is a Fuel Cell. Which is basically a hydrogen powered EV, so no noise, plus all of the other challenges that come with hydrogen.

Edited by SDK on Friday 10th May 13:06

Yarlsberg

89 posts

98 months

Friday 10th May
quotequote all
In English we say racing car. We’re not American…

pheonix478

1,383 posts

39 months

Friday 10th May
quotequote all
Geoffcapes said:
Any minute now the EV evangelista's anyone with at least a basic understanding of the physics will be along to say that hydrogen won't work as a fuel for cars because........
Edited by pheonix478 on Friday 10th May 14:35

u9ge

57 posts

60 months

Friday 10th May
quotequote all
steveb8189 said:
Geoffcapes said:
Any minute now the EV evangelista's will be along to say that hydrogen won't work as a fuel for cars because........
I'm a firm believer we'll see hydrogen fuel cell cars in the future unless wireless charging infrastructure proves to be scalable. Hydrogen combusion cars like this will not make it mass market and will be reserved for people like us who still like the feel and experience of an ICE. They're just too complex, with too many moving parts and have all the downsides of hydrogen without the upsides of fuel cells
I'm not too sure, we've gone from the technology for 7kw charging to 350kw in 10 years, while battery density per £ drops threefold in the same time period, once wear at 600kw its the same time to fill up as standing about on a forecourt pumping decomposed dinosaurs into you tank, something we prove daily we're very willing to do. Sadly, except for some exceptions like quirky race cars and maybe niche haulage vehicles, cost curves and technological progress, when there clearly is a market is just too great.

D4rez

1,414 posts

57 months

Friday 10th May
quotequote all
By the time you’ve locked on a hydrogen refuelling nozzle, temperatures are balanced and pressure checks completed and then filled these massive tanks you will have recharged a BEV…

Theoretical anyway because a hydrogen ICE isn’t allowed under Uk regs due to the NOx

pheonix478

1,383 posts

39 months

Friday 10th May
quotequote all
u9ge said:
I'm not too sure, we've gone from the technology for 7kw charging to 350kw in 10 years, while battery density per £ drops threefold in the same time period, once wear at 600kw its the same time to fill up as standing about on a forecourt pumping decomposed dinosaurs into you tank, something we prove daily we're very willing to do. Sadly, except for some exceptions like quirky race cars and maybe niche haulage vehicles, cost curves and technological progress, when there clearly is a market is just too great.
Either way ou're still going to spend 10 minutes queuing behind Waynetta while she buys scratch cards, 10lb of Cheetos and a gallon of diet coke.

GTRene

16,713 posts

225 months

Friday 10th May
quotequote all
I'm not a fan of such high pressure storage things, let alone in a car.

maybe its an idea to make use of all those patents that oil compagnies have stolen and hiding, because if those came out the world would have been less dependent on oil companies.

you know, those supposed inventors from many years ago, that made inventions so cars that did say 1 L every 10km before and say 40km after.

or those who could let a car run on water... those inventions were what, 40 plus year or so ago?

if those inventions were true, why not use that? I bet a lot of car makers know those? but they are I guess patented? if true... just like free energie... not believing all 100% but I guess some are at least partly the truth, and then we won't need those crazy dangerous or expensive changes...

but I guess other factors are behind a lot, to much freedom = less dependable from governments/globalists who wants to rule over us...? hm.

But nice to see Alpine does something different, maybe they can use partly things of it without the hydrogen pressure things.

kambites

67,656 posts

222 months

Friday 10th May
quotequote all
Just... no.

If you're going to put an internal combustion engine in something, run it on petrol or a synthetic liquid fuel if you want to feel you're doing your big for global warming. If you're going to power something by hydrogen, use a fuel cell. Hydrogen ICE is just idiotic.

pheonix478

1,383 posts

39 months

Friday 10th May
quotequote all
GTRene said:
I'm not a fan of such high pressure storage things, let alone in a car.

maybe its an idea to make use of all those patents that oil compagnies have stolen and hiding, because if those came out the world would have been less dependent on oil companies.

you know, those supposed inventors from many years ago, that made inventions so cars that did say 1 L every 10km before and say 40km after.

or those who could let a car run on water... those inventions were what, 40 plus year or so ago?

if those inventions were true, why not use that? I bet a lot of car makers know those? but they are I guess patented? if true... just like free energie... not believing all 100% but I guess some are at least partly the truth, and then we won't need those crazy dangerous or expensive changes...

but I guess other factors are behind a lot, to much freedom = less dependable from governments/globalists who wants to rule over us...? hm.

But nice to see Alpine does something different, maybe they can use partly things of it without the hydrogen pressure things.
Dear god.

MountainsofSussex

287 posts

187 months

Friday 10th May
quotequote all
For starters, it's a nice bit of PR - we're talking about Alpine, which is the idea. The problem with hydrogen cars is they simply didn't mature as quickly and effectively as battery cars. For 90% of people, the new BEVs will slot into their lives perfectly. They've won. Game over. Most people will charge at home, or from a lamp post near home (school run mums and local commuters will need to charge every week, so shouldn't be too much of a bun fight for chargers). I'd suggest selling any shares in petrol stations... At about £1M per hydrogen station, we're not going to start changing over to electric, then backtrack and go to hydrogen. This does pose some interesting economies of scale problems for the heavy duty vehicles that will benefit from hydrogen - they need passenger car volume to do the learning for them, as far fewer trucks get sold. Sorry for the long post, I deal with this stuff for work, so tend to ramble on...

dvs_dave

8,706 posts

226 months

Friday 10th May
quotequote all
Geoffcapes said:
Any minute now the EV evangelista's will be along to say that hydrogen won't work as a fuel for cars because........
….basic maths and physics proves it.

HTH

nismo48

3,793 posts

208 months

Saturday 11th May
quotequote all
Wow that's a clean and green stunner wink