Mr Bates vs The Post Office

Author
Discussion

simonrockman

6,869 posts

256 months

Tuesday 7th May
quotequote all
mikeiow said:
LimmerickLad said:
IMO - "(2) in-house ability to prosecute - losing the necessary objectivity" was a major factor above all, as they just felt they had all the power...and at that time in fact, they did!
AFAIK, they somehow still have that power.
Not sure I have seen it stripped?

Clearly they should NO LONGER have that power, and indeed I hope and pray that the Police take action against those who have so clearly shown themselves to have been complicit in ruining so many lives.

I still feel there might only be one scapegoat, which makes me fume: it is one thing to suggest that it is a culture issue, or that they were only assuming people above knew and did the right thing, but so many SPMs (& their families) lives were utterly ruined by the actions of so many individuals, they really do need holding to account: in many cases it feels that jail is too good for them: SPMs have died or taken their own lives over this.
I went to Nick Wallis' talk at Hays. It transpires that the exceptional prosecution powers belonged to The Royal Mail, and after the separation in 2013, POL didn't have the powers, but no-one realised this and they just continued.

Edited by simonrockman on Tuesday 7th May 20:24

Short Grain

2,829 posts

221 months

Tuesday 7th May
quotequote all
Stussy said:
She was a total waste of time today, just making up random nonsense sentences as she went along, pauses between every word as she tried to concoct something believable
Yep, noticed the pauses did get quite long at times as she carefully thought of how to phrase the least incriminating reply. Seemed to get an easier ride than if Mr Beer was doing the questioning! The lady who questioned her in the afternoon was more aggressive which made things a bit more interesting and seemed to shock her a bit! hehe

732NM

4,710 posts

16 months

Tuesday 7th May
quotequote all
Stussy said:
She was a total waste of time today, just making up random nonsense sentences as she went along, pauses between every word as she tried to concoct something believable
Indeed, another professional who hasn't got a bloody clue, yeh right.

Speak slowly, annunciate, don't miss any T's and don't know anything, not even what your directed role is. laugh

Stupid idiot doesn't even know her own CV.

Stussy

1,878 posts

65 months

Tuesday 7th May
quotequote all
I did have to laugh at that bit... yeah they said I was head of the department, but they got that title wrong. I wasn't actually in charge jester

eliot

11,465 posts

255 months

Wednesday 8th May
quotequote all
seems to have done a Jarnail - “I was just a postbox - I didn’t read anything”
Are all these ex-pol employees getting legal support from the post office? Does that mean more taxpayer money spent defending the indefensible?

vaud

50,713 posts

156 months

Wednesday 8th May
quotequote all
eliot said:
seems to have done a Jarnail - “I was just a postbox - I didn’t read anything”
Are all these ex-pol employees getting legal support from the post office? Does that mean more taxpayer money spent defending the indefensible?
Officers will be insured - part of the discussion yesterday - will probably cover issues that arose whilst they were employed?

Dermot O'Logical

2,612 posts

130 months

Wednesday 8th May
quotequote all
Dermot O'Logical said:
Do we know why Nick Wallis' blog hasn't been updated since Thursday (2 May)?

Have I missed something?
Good news - the blog has returned.

Bad news - He hasn't covered Jarnail Singh's turn in the spotlight ffrom last Friday. Pity, I was looking forward to that.

LimmerickLad

1,001 posts

16 months

Wednesday 8th May
quotequote all
Doubt any serious blows will be landed on Altman but he may be able to dig the hole a bit deeper for others perhaps?

Wills2

23,007 posts

176 months

Wednesday 8th May
quotequote all

Another witness that can't recall unless the answer won't land him in it then he suddenly gets total recall.


Tye Green

665 posts

110 months

Wednesday 8th May
quotequote all
Beer should have twisted the knife then....

Brian Altman KC "yes, I should have considered it for disclosure".

Beer should have said "so, you are a leading barrister, a KC, what was your thought process at the time - why did you not consider it?"


Wills2

23,007 posts

176 months

Wednesday 8th May
quotequote all

Clearly just another hired gun willing to take the fee and ignore the smell.


LimmerickLad

1,001 posts

16 months

Wednesday 8th May
quotequote all
Must be hard to X-exam another KC when you know he's trapped himself.

Wills2

23,007 posts

176 months

Wednesday 8th May
quotequote all

Mt Altman getting a bit shirty as Beer exposes him without Altman having to say a word

simonrockman

6,869 posts

256 months

Wednesday 8th May
quotequote all
I wonder if anyone will try the tactic “yes, it was a complete screw up, we all behaved diabolically, and I throw myself at your mercy”, then bursting into tears.

Short Grain

2,829 posts

221 months

Wednesday 8th May
quotequote all
BA has the 'Selective Memory' gene that seems to have afflicted a lot of the POL people and their advisors! Sir Wynn did ask for a bit of clarification on that earlier. This guy seems to be squirming a bit now.

BA "I can't recall....."

Mr Beer "Let me help you with that" and produces the transcript of a call! hehe

And we're back to that call again!

It's a real shame I don't like popcorn!

Blib

44,300 posts

198 months

Wednesday 8th May
quotequote all
Ooh, he got energised there!

hehe

Earlier, he held his hands in a steeple. Now, he's rubbing his thumbs in agitation.

Stussy

1,878 posts

65 months

Wednesday 8th May
quotequote all
I love how JB turns the thumb screws very slowly and subtly

LimmerickLad

1,001 posts

16 months

Wednesday 8th May
quotequote all
Stussy said:
I love how JB turns the thumb screws very slowly and subtly
He's as sharp as a razor and so calm and collected...........impressive indeed.

Maxdecel

1,251 posts

34 months

Wednesday 8th May
quotequote all
It's such a shame Mr Altman didn't apply his huge legal expertise to what was happening under his nose and become whistle blower, could have saved a lot of suffering & grief for many.
Testimonials - https://www.2bedfordrow.co.uk/barrister/brian-altm...

"Over the years Brian has consistently been acknowledged to be ‘a leader in his field’ by both Chambers & Partners and the Legal 500. In 2007, Brian was nominated by Chambers & Partners as ‘Crime Junior of the Year’ and in 2011 as ‘Crime Silk of the Year’. In 2013, he was nominated by Legal 500 as ‘Crime Silk of the Year’ and in 2022 as ‘Public Inquiries Silk of the Year’. Brian was also selected by Lawyer Monthly as winner of the 2015 ‘White Collar Crime Barrister of the Year – UK’.

The Times has named Brian in its Law 100 list as one of the country’s 100 most influential lawyers. He was also listed by The London Evening Standard in the law section of the list of London’s 1000 most influential people for 2011, and in 2012 he was named by The London Evening Standard as one of London’s top three ‘Golden Legal Eagles’ in crime."

LimmerickLad

1,001 posts

16 months

Wednesday 8th May
quotequote all
He's trying to take charge........he wont browbeat beer.