Official 2024 Miami Grand Prix Thread ***SPOILERS***

Official 2024 Miami Grand Prix Thread ***SPOILERS***

Poll: Official 2024 Miami Grand Prix Thread ***SPOILERS***

Total Members Polled: 134

Perez: 22%
Leclerc: 10%
Sainz: 18%
Russell: 0%
Hamilton: 6%
Norris: 43%
Piastri: 0%
Alonso: 1%
Author
Discussion

paulguitar

23,692 posts

114 months

Tuesday 7th May
quotequote all
Blib said:
Good to see Mercedes on the top step of the podium yesterday.
What race was this then?

cuprabob

14,737 posts

215 months

Tuesday 7th May
quotequote all
paulguitar said:
Blib said:
Good to see Mercedes on the top step of the podium yesterday.
What race was this then?
I assume he's making reference to the engine smile

RichB

51,705 posts

285 months

Tuesday 7th May
quotequote all
paulguitar said:
Blib said:
Good to see Mercedes on the top step of the podium yesterday.
What race was this then?
Come on, it's not that early...

TheDeuce

21,938 posts

67 months

Tuesday 7th May
quotequote all
cuprabob said:
paulguitar said:
Blib said:
Good to see Mercedes on the top step of the podium yesterday.
What race was this then?
I assume he's making reference to the engine smile
McLaren are quite good at beating works teams with their own engine. In 2020 they beat Renault works team in the WCC with the Renault engine, this year, they're looking certain to do the same to Mercedes..

Any other examples?

paulguitar

23,692 posts

114 months

Tuesday 7th May
quotequote all
cuprabob said:
paulguitar said:
Blib said:
Good to see Mercedes on the top step of the podium yesterday.
What race was this then?
I assume he's making reference to the engine smile
We didn't race yesterday though, did we?



BigBen

11,655 posts

231 months

Tuesday 7th May
quotequote all
TheDeuce said:
cuprabob said:
paulguitar said:
Blib said:
Good to see Mercedes on the top step of the podium yesterday.
What race was this then?
I assume he's making reference to the engine smile
McLaren are quite good at beating works teams with their own engine. In 2020 they beat Renault works team in the WCC with the Renault engine, this year, they're looking certain to do the same to Mercedes..

Any other examples?
Didn't the opposite happen when McLaren were the works Ford team but Benetton were faster so requested parity on engine spec (that might have been the other way round)

Adrian W

13,915 posts

229 months

Tuesday 7th May
quotequote all
BigBen said:
TheDeuce said:
cuprabob said:
paulguitar said:
Blib said:
Good to see Mercedes on the top step of the podium yesterday.
What race was this then?
I assume he's making reference to the engine smile
McLaren are quite good at beating works teams with their own engine. In 2020 they beat Renault works team in the WCC with the Renault engine, this year, they're looking certain to do the same to Mercedes..

Any other examples?
Didn't the opposite happen when McLaren were the works Ford team but Benetton were faster so requested parity on engine spec (that might have been the other way round)
Didn't Benetton get caught using traction control?

paulguitar

23,692 posts

114 months

Tuesday 7th May
quotequote all
Adrian W said:
Didn't Benetton get caught using traction control?
Not exactly. It was found to be on the car, they claimed it was inactive...

SoulGlo

94 posts

32 months

Tuesday 7th May
quotequote all
BigBen said:
Didn't the opposite happen when McLaren were the works Ford team but Benetton were faster so requested parity on engine spec (that might have been the other way round)
Benetton was the "works" team. McLaren got those customer V8s late in the day when the Lamborghini/Chrysler deal didn't work out.

But McLaren had a great active suspension system and Benetton was still with normal "passive" suspension. With a well balanced but underpowered car McLaren and peak Senna they got wins with it. They ended up getting the same engine spec late in the season though.

BigBen

11,655 posts

231 months

Tuesday 7th May
quotequote all
SoulGlo said:
BigBen said:
Didn't the opposite happen when McLaren were the works Ford team but Benetton were faster so requested parity on engine spec (that might have been the other way round)
Benetton was the "works" team. McLaren got those customer V8s late in the day when the Lamborghini/Chrysler deal didn't work out.

But McLaren had a great active suspension system and Benetton was still with normal "passive" suspension. With a well balanced but underpowered car McLaren and peak Senna they got wins with it. They ended up getting the same engine spec late in the season though.
That was what I was thinking of. Thanks

TheDeuce

21,938 posts

67 months

Tuesday 7th May
quotequote all
paulguitar said:
Adrian W said:
Didn't Benetton get caught using traction control?
Not exactly. It was found to be on the car, they claimed it was inactive...
It's all here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allegations_of_cheat...

Looks like Benetton weren't provably using anything more than Ferrari or McLaren. Big emphasis on the word 'provably'...

Tbh, whilst cheating was rife in that period of F1, I think the Benetton was just a very good car.

Reading that wiki reminded me of the reason Jos V was set on fire during re-fuelling, they were definitely cheating in order to speed up the rate of refuelling. Did that swing the balance in overall performance through the season? I doubt it.

honda_exige

6,058 posts

207 months

Tuesday 7th May
quotequote all
paulguitar said:
cuprabob said:
paulguitar said:
Blib said:
Good to see Mercedes on the top step of the podium yesterday.
What race was this then?
I assume he's making reference to the engine smile
We didn't race yesterday though, did we?
Depends on timezone - it was yesterday to me for eg.

CanAm

9,290 posts

273 months

Tuesday 7th May
quotequote all
TheDeuce said:
paulguitar said:
Adrian W said:
Didn't Benetton get caught using traction control?
Not exactly. It was found to be on the car, they claimed it was inactive...
It's all here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allegations_of_cheat...

Looks like Benetton weren't provably using anything more than Ferrari or McLaren. Big emphasis on the word 'provably'...

Tbh, whilst cheating was rife in that period of F1, I think the Benetton was just a very good car.

Reading that wiki reminded me of the reason Jos V was set on fire during re-fuelling, they were definitely cheating in order to speed up the rate of refuelling. Did that swing the balance in overall performance through the season? I doubt it.
Weren't there also rumours that they had automatic launch control, activated by the start lights?

TheDeuce

21,938 posts

67 months

Tuesday 7th May
quotequote all
CanAm said:
TheDeuce said:
paulguitar said:
Adrian W said:
Didn't Benetton get caught using traction control?
Not exactly. It was found to be on the car, they claimed it was inactive...
It's all here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allegations_of_cheat...

Looks like Benetton weren't provably using anything more than Ferrari or McLaren. Big emphasis on the word 'provably'...

Tbh, whilst cheating was rife in that period of F1, I think the Benetton was just a very good car.

Reading that wiki reminded me of the reason Jos V was set on fire during re-fuelling, they were definitely cheating in order to speed up the rate of refuelling. Did that swing the balance in overall performance through the season? I doubt it.
Weren't there also rumours that they had automatic launch control, activated by the start lights?
Yes, but apparently Schumacher didn't know about it so it wasn't cheating scratchchin

Everyone was cheating back then, probably more than we'll ever know assuming that some of them cheated well enough to not get found out..

CanAm

9,290 posts

273 months

Tuesday 7th May
quotequote all
TheDeuce said:
Yes, but apparently Schumacher didn't know about it so it wasn't cheating scratchchin

Everyone was cheating back then, probably more than we'll ever know assuming that some of them cheated well enough to not get found out..
If only we'd had the Internet back then - we'd never have got any work done!

Mark-C

5,184 posts

206 months

Tuesday 7th May
quotequote all
CanAm said:
TheDeuce said:
Yes, but apparently Schumacher didn't know about it so it wasn't cheating scratchchin

Everyone was cheating back then, probably more than we'll ever know assuming that some of them cheated well enough to not get found out..
If only we'd had the Internet back then - we'd never have got any work done!
Who's getting work done? spin

Adrian W

13,915 posts

229 months

Tuesday 7th May
quotequote all
TheDeuce said:
paulguitar said:
Adrian W said:
Didn't Benetton get caught using traction control?
Not exactly. It was found to be on the car, they claimed it was inactive...
It's all here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allegations_of_cheat...

Looks like Benetton weren't provably using anything more than Ferrari or McLaren. Big emphasis on the word 'provably'...

Tbh, whilst cheating was rife in that period of F1, I think the Benetton was just a very good car.

Reading that wiki reminded me of the reason Jos V was set on fire during re-fuelling, they were definitely cheating in order to speed up the rate of refuelling. Did that swing the balance in overall performance through the season? I doubt it.
A software engineer who worked for them at the time told me it was an embedded rise of rate of rpm algorithm, and you couldn't turn it off. He's still working so can't say more than that.

TheDeuce

21,938 posts

67 months

Tuesday 7th May
quotequote all
Mark-C said:
CanAm said:
TheDeuce said:
Yes, but apparently Schumacher didn't know about it so it wasn't cheating scratchchin

Everyone was cheating back then, probably more than we'll ever know assuming that some of them cheated well enough to not get found out..
If only we'd had the Internet back then - we'd never have got any work done!
Who's getting work done? spin
biggrin

I think us and the press not having the sort of online media we have now was a big factor in how much they could get away with!

That and the fact there was a lot of emergent tech they were able to apply to the cars and it took a while for the FIA to figure out detection and banning methods.

PhilAsia

3,889 posts

76 months

Tuesday 7th May
quotequote all
TheDeuce said:
CanAm said:
TheDeuce said:
paulguitar said:
Adrian W said:
Didn't Benetton get caught using traction control?
Not exactly. It was found to be on the car, they claimed it was inactive...
It's all here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allegations_of_cheat...

Looks like Benetton weren't provably using anything more than Ferrari or McLaren. Big emphasis on the word 'provably'...

Tbh, whilst cheating was rife in that period of F1, I think the Benetton was just a very good car.

Reading that wiki reminded me of the reason Jos V was set on fire during re-fuelling, they were definitely cheating in order to speed up the rate of refuelling. Did that swing the balance in overall performance through the season? I doubt it.
Weren't there also rumours that they had automatic launch control, activated by the start lights?
Yes, but apparently Schumacher didn't know about it so it wasn't cheating scratchchin

Everyone was cheating back then, probably more than we'll ever know assuming that some of them cheated well enough to not get found out..
With a floor clutch Schumi was often slow off the line. By comparison Coulthard was blistering. Paddle shift and clutches came just at the right time...and light activated LC if rumours are to be believed.

740EVTORQUES

482 posts

2 months

Tuesday 7th May
quotequote all
HardtopManual said:
740EVTORQUES said:
But that’s why you pay PR people (including at weekends) to help handle your media.

Saying it’s ok because your driver is uneducated and ignorant of the world around him is not a good look.

Bring an F1 driver is about a lot more than just driving fast. Vettel and Hamilton show that it’s possible to aim higher.

There’s no excuse, doing something like this that would be predicted to alienate large numbers of your audience is inexcusable and amateurish.
Lando does have PR people, so they will have advised him what to say. I imagine they said - mad as it is, Trump is a former president and likely to be the next one, so be respectful and no more. What would you have advised?
I’d have done a Kimi
https://youtu.be/nbxYZbs97t8?si=fPFcs--IyTmekNxL