Laptop or Tablet with Keyboard?

Laptop or Tablet with Keyboard?

Author
Discussion

Mark300zx

Original Poster:

1,370 posts

254 months

Sunday 19th May
quotequote all
My pile of poop Lenovo laptop has died again, so my question is there a reliable brand of laptop or would it be better to get a tablet and keyboard as it would be more flexible to use and repair?

Mr E

21,769 posts

261 months

Sunday 19th May
quotequote all
What do you do on the machine?

Mark300zx

Original Poster:

1,370 posts

254 months

Sunday 19th May
quotequote all
Just net surfing and the occasional bit of work.

98elise

26,869 posts

163 months

Sunday 19th May
quotequote all
We have a Samsung Tablets with a Samsung Keyboard covers. They still function too much like a tablet to properly replace a laptop, but for general usage it's fine.

Samsung have a "Dex" mode that makes them behave a little more like a laptop, but even that's not great. My wife's one seems to lose the keyboard format when in dex mode so certain keys don't correspond to the keyboard characters.

Mr E

21,769 posts

261 months

Sunday 19th May
quotequote all
Mark300zx said:
occasional bit of work.
With the best will in the world, that could be anything from writing a quick email to cfd modelling a F1 car.

Mark300zx

Original Poster:

1,370 posts

254 months

Sunday 19th May
quotequote all
A few word and excel docs.

FMOB

1,055 posts

14 months

Sunday 19th May
quotequote all
I can throughly recommend avoiding Dell, if you think Lenovo is bad..

I would stay with a laptop if working on, if you are just surfing, social media, etc then a tablet is way more convenient than a laptop.

You probably need 1 of each.


Phil.

4,841 posts

252 months

Sunday 19th May
quotequote all
Mark300zx said:
A few word and excel docs.
Using Word and Excel on a tablet (ipad) is painful from experience. A laptop is a must for anything work related.

I’ve had a few Dell laptops and currently have one, and they have been fine.

grumbledoak

31,588 posts

235 months

Sunday 19th May
quotequote all
Repair? LOL. The various manufacturers are all much of a muchness. Business machines more robust than consumer. Apple more than PC. But you pay for it.

For maximum flexibility I have a desktop (PC) and an iPad. Depends how much you need to work on the train, I suppose...

Glosphil

4,390 posts

236 months

Sunday 19th May
quotequote all
I recently bought a HP Pavilion laptop which has a touch screen. I also added a wireless mouse. It replaced a 12 year old Samsung laptop.

The HP has the same size screen as the Sumsung but is smaller & lighter, but also flimsier.

I would recommend the HP.

Mark300zx

Original Poster:

1,370 posts

254 months

Sunday 19th May
quotequote all
Ok, so I've ditched the idea of replacing my laptop with a tablet, so the next question is what's the most reliable laptop?

David_M

378 posts

52 months

Sunday 19th May
quotequote all
Mark300zx said:
Ok, so I've ditched the idea of replacing my laptop with a tablet, so the next question is what's the most reliable laptop?
Lenovo Thinkpad

FMOB

1,055 posts

14 months

Sunday 19th May
quotequote all
Mark300zx said:
Ok, so I've ditched the idea of replacing my laptop with a tablet, so the next question is what's the most reliable laptop?
Probably a question for things you always wanted to the answer to thread.

In my experience that is a Macbook.

Mark300zx

Original Poster:

1,370 posts

254 months

Sunday 19th May
quotequote all
FMOB said:
Mark300zx said:
Ok, so I've ditched the idea of replacing my laptop with a tablet, so the next question is what's the most reliable laptop?
Probably a question for things you always wanted to the answer to thread.

In my experience that is a Macbook.
Probably right but allergic to apple!

FMOB

1,055 posts

14 months

Sunday 19th May
quotequote all
Mark300zx said:
FMOB said:
Mark300zx said:
Ok, so I've ditched the idea of replacing my laptop with a tablet, so the next question is what's the most reliable laptop?
Probably a question for things you always wanted to the answer to thread.

In my experience that is a Macbook.
Probably right but allergic to apple!
In truth go and try one, I do not want an Iphone but I use windows, linux and Macbook computers, I have the most problems with the windows machine.

pherlopolus

2,092 posts

160 months

Sunday 19th May
quotequote all
I have a MS Surface pro 8, (not the arm chip!) it does everything I need and is about the same size as a iPad Pro. Has a keyboard case, and stylus.

I do some fairly hefty excel stuff on it and it is just about powerful enough. I had a gaming laptop before with 17” screen and never took it anywhere and used my iPad instead, but the surface pro is brilliant now and can fit in a small messenger bag easily.

Mr Pointy

11,347 posts

161 months

Sunday 19th May
quotequote all
David_M said:
Mark300zx said:
Ok, so I've ditched the idea of replacing my laptop with a tablet, so the next question is what's the most reliable laptop?
Lenovo Thinkpad
This. Get a cheapie refurb from ebay. Here's a guide to the different models & types:

https://www.howtogeek.com/119825/whats-the-differe...

FMOB

1,055 posts

14 months

Sunday 19th May
quotequote all
David_M said:
Mark300zx said:
Ok, so I've ditched the idea of replacing my laptop with a tablet, so the next question is what's the most reliable laptop?
Lenovo Thinkpad
You may wish to review the opening post of this thread rofl

TotalControl

8,113 posts

200 months

Monday 20th May
quotequote all
A few thoughts.

I'm getting quite tired of windows as of late but for office, there isn't really anything better. I do use Google docs occasionally too and have been fine dealing with simple word or spreadsheets, one example is watching and updating stock for my brother was simpler on sheets as once updated, a quick message over and he had the latest version of stock whilst he was away instantly.

For operating system, I've found over the last few years Linux actually is incredibly stable for most days to day tasks, but if you need office, then there's some alternatives to use. Truth be told, that's my next step as I already have a Lenovo machine (Yoga i3 - good specs but the CPU lets it down when working a little harder. Still is fine for 90% of my work) but find the battery life doesn't quite cut it.

You could get a Mac and install parallels on it (is that still a thing with the new M based chips?) then slap Windows on. Battery life is the best on these and will only really catch up on the Windows front when the Snapdragon chips are released.

Or, find a used ThinkPad from yesteryear that's powerful enough, which I think are better built than other Lenovo models frankly. Keyboard is miles better too. For work, they work. For entertainment, personally, they suck.

Asus make good laptops. If you're willing to have a look at their models. They do sometimes have offers on.

The surface Pros are also an option. Looking into this myself but some have had battery life issues again.

Alternatively, stick to a PC for work at home and an iPad or Android tablet (Samsung are really the only other who make higher end tablets) for entertainment and occasional work. There was a really good thread a few weeks ago for a chap going iPad only for most things and it seemed he found a decent way around most of his job issues.

Other options are to buy an older laptop and install the latest Linux. Ubuntu has come out with their latest version that has support for 10 years apparently.

Overall, depends on how many devices you're willing to put up with. If it's just one device, then a portable Windows with touchscreen might really be the only thing. Don't expect amazing battery life though.

Riley Blue

21,078 posts

228 months

Monday 20th May
quotequote all
FMOB said:
David_M said:
Mark300zx said:
Ok, so I've ditched the idea of replacing my laptop with a tablet, so the next question is what's the most reliable laptop?
Lenovo Thinkpad
You may wish to review the opening post of this thread rofl
I'm replacing my current accidentally damaged Lenovo with a Lenovo Thinkpad as it's been by far the best, i.e. most reliable, of the various laptops I've owned over the years. The only thing that has let is down has been the build quality hence why I'm now going for a Thinkpad.