Garden Tax on the cards?

Author
Discussion

Randy Winkman

16,382 posts

191 months

Tuesday 14th May
quotequote all
tangerine_sedge said:
Biggy Stardust said:
tangerine_sedge said:
I'll personally file this under 'grrr Labour, more taxes', in the misinformation wars in the run up to the General Election...
Nevertheless I anticipate them taxing everything they can see to fund a long campaign of wasteful spending, pretty much as per every labour government in history.

I need some way of hiding assets from them.
I'm amused that you're panicked into this by the thought of a Labour government, whilst ignoring the current level of taxation and wasteful spend of the current government hehe
Exactly - a strange argument.

oyster

12,648 posts

250 months

Tuesday 14th May
quotequote all
Biggy Stardust said:
tangerine_sedge said:
I'll personally file this under 'grrr Labour, more taxes', in the misinformation wars in the run up to the General Election...
Nevertheless I anticipate them taxing everything they can see to fund a long campaign of wasteful spending, pretty much as per every labour government in history.

I need some way of hiding assets from them.
Child benefit higher income charge
Quadrupling of Air Passenger Duty
VAT increase from 17.5% to 20%
Income tax thresholds freeze
Corporation tax increases
Oil & Gas windfall taxes
Second homes tax
Sugar tax
CGT rates increased
CGT thresholds reduced
Dividend tax threasholds reduced
Buy to let tax offset removed
IR35 restrictions increased

etc
etc

The above is why, as a hard-working professional, I do not fear the Labour party anymore.
The Conservatives have attacked me for way more taxes than Tony Blair or Gordon Brown ever did.

Yertis

18,112 posts

268 months

Tuesday 14th May
quotequote all
oyster said:
Child benefit higher income charge
Quadrupling of Air Passenger Duty
VAT increase from 17.5% to 20%
Income tax thresholds freeze
Corporation tax increases
Oil & Gas windfall taxes
Second homes tax
Sugar tax
CGT rates increased
CGT thresholds reduced
Dividend tax threasholds reduced
Buy to let tax offset removed
IR35 restrictions increased

etc
etc

The above is why, as a hard-working professional, I do not fear the Labour party anymore.
The Conservatives have attacked me for way more taxes than Tony Blair or Gordon Brown ever did.
The difference, I would suggest, is that the Conservatives have raised taxes because they have to (ie to pay for all that pandemic largesse) whereas Labour raise taxes because they want to. The Conservatives, in general, want to reduce taxation, even if circumstance dictates they do otherwise. Labour in general want to raise taxation as a point of principle.

oyster

12,648 posts

250 months

Tuesday 14th May
quotequote all
Yertis said:
oyster said:
Child benefit higher income charge
Quadrupling of Air Passenger Duty
VAT increase from 17.5% to 20%
Income tax thresholds freeze
Corporation tax increases
Oil & Gas windfall taxes
Second homes tax
Sugar tax
CGT rates increased
CGT thresholds reduced
Dividend tax thresholds reduced
Buy to let tax offset removed
IR35 restrictions increased

etc
etc

The above is why, as a hard-working professional, I do not fear the Labour party anymore.
The Conservatives have attacked me for way more taxes than Tony Blair or Gordon Brown ever did.
The difference, I would suggest, is that the Conservatives have raised taxes because they have to (ie to pay for all that pandemic largesse) whereas Labour raise taxes because they want to. The Conservatives, in general, want to reduce taxation, even if circumstance dictates they do otherwise. Labour in general want to raise taxation as a point of principle.
The ones in bold above were from way before Covid.

As to increasing taxes in principle, the windfall tax, sugar tax and BTL/2nd home taxes were all applied because of principle and nothing to do with requiring additional tax revenue.



PS. The pandemic largesse was of their own choosing. They were the government at the time.

MrBarry123

6,031 posts

123 months

Tuesday 14th May
quotequote all
Red9zero said:
We live in a typical new build. We should be getting a rebate then laugh
hehe

Rayny

1,215 posts

203 months

Tuesday 14th May
quotequote all
simon_harris said:
if you live in a big house with a big garden you are already paying more.

Why does it need a drone survey, the info is all there in the land registry, google maps etc etc etc.

it is an absurd suggestion that needs to go into the bin.
Black, Green, or Brown bin ?
Nobody wants to be fined for putting anything in the incorrect bin ...


Jasandjules

70,012 posts

231 months

Tuesday 14th May
quotequote all
I paid more to buy my house, more in Stamp duty etc. and it costs me a lot to maintain as well... They can FRO.

surveyor

17,891 posts

186 months

Tuesday 14th May
quotequote all
We already have a garden tax.

Council tax bands are based on market value on some dreadfully historic date.

The size of the garden impacts market value.


98elise

26,861 posts

163 months

Tuesday 14th May
quotequote all
Chrisgr31 said:
It’s absolute madness that there has not been a council tax revaluation since 1991. The outcome is that even in the same town homes that are more expensive are in a lower band than cheaper ones nearby.

If there was to be a revaluation then all manner of modern methods would be used to check the survey data already held by the Valuation Office. Yes if you have a large garden you may pay more than someone with a smaller garden but only in the same way as you’d pay more for the house in the first place.

How can it be right that the owner of a house in Kensington and Chelsea costing £220 million pays less council tax than many people living in fairly standard 4 bed houses in many areas of the country?

There are plenty of complaints about business rates being too high but that could be solved by a council tax revaluation with those in the most expensive houses paying more.
How does a newer property pay more in the same area? New builds get put into the same band similar value properties. The original valuations were just to establish the bands.

What's the relationship between a house in Chelsea vs one in a cheaper part of the country, and what has that got to do with their relative council budgets?

You should be paying for what you consume. By your logic someone in Chelsea and Wesminster should pay more for their food, energy etc just because their house cost more.

Edited by 98elise on Tuesday 14th May 13:52

98elise

26,861 posts

163 months

Tuesday 14th May
quotequote all
worsy said:
Chrisgr31 said:
How can it be right that the owner of a house in Kensington and Chelsea costing £220 million pays less council tax than many people living in fairly standard 4 bed houses in many areas of the country?
There are 2 bed flats worth more than detached residence's up north. Surely you are not advocating that the South pay the greater share of tax because of the disparity in house prices?
Maybe northerners should pay more because of the cheap houses they have access to smile

Terminator X

15,204 posts

206 months

Tuesday 14th May
quotequote all
Getragdogleg said:
How long before we get to the point where we are paid directly to the Govt and they dribble a little bit back to us and we say thanks ?
Close already, highest taxes since WW2.

TX.

Pit Pony

8,817 posts

123 months

Tuesday 14th May
quotequote all
TUS373 said:
She does not have the internet - so it was picked up mostly likely from listening to the radio. That may be the BBC?
Ask.her who told her this vital information. We need to know which hairdresser she listens to.

Terminator X

15,204 posts

206 months

Tuesday 14th May
quotequote all
Chrisgr31 said:
It’s absolute madness that there has not been a council tax revaluation since 1991. The outcome is that even in the same town homes that are more expensive are in a lower band than cheaper ones nearby.

If there was to be a revaluation then all manner of modern methods would be used to check the survey data already held by the Valuation Office. Yes if you have a large garden you may pay more than someone with a smaller garden but only in the same way as you’d pay more for the house in the first place.

How can it be right that the owner of a house in Kensington and Chelsea costing £220 million pays less council tax than many people living in fairly standard 4 bed houses in many areas of the country?

There are plenty of complaints about business rates being too high but that could be solved by a council tax revaluation with those in the most expensive houses paying more.
You think we should pay more? It's already £2.5k for me and I can see nothing for it other than collecting the bins every 2 weeks.

TX.

ChocolateFrog

25,824 posts

175 months

Tuesday 14th May
quotequote all
So the vast majority of us with either no garden or a typical postage stamp have absolutely nothing to worry about.

Bring it on.

Pit Pony

8,817 posts

123 months

Tuesday 14th May
quotequote all
Rayny said:
simon_harris said:
if you live in a big house with a big garden you are already paying more.

Why does it need a drone survey, the info is all there in the land registry, google maps etc etc etc.

it is an absurd suggestion that needs to go into the bin.
Black, Green, or Brown bin ?
Nobody wants to be fined for putting anything in the incorrect bin ...

It's st so can be flushed down the bog.

Dingu

3,892 posts

32 months

Tuesday 14th May
quotequote all
It’s worrying but unsurprising how frothy some Telegraph Tory propaganda gets people.

Halmyre

11,289 posts

141 months

Tuesday 14th May
quotequote all
'Garden' implies a plot of land that is cultivated and well-maintained. So I'm OK then...

BoRED S2upid

19,762 posts

242 months

Tuesday 14th May
quotequote all
I think it’s being considered in Wales they haven’t implemented it yet. And by all accounts it wouldn’t change things massively top end gets a tweak up flats get a tweak down middle is already pretty well screwed anyway as is normally the case.

Electro1980

8,427 posts

141 months

Tuesday 14th May
quotequote all
Terminator X said:
You think we should pay more? It's already £2.5k for me and I can see nothing for it other than collecting the bins every 2 weeks.

TX.
So, you never use the roads? Want your streets cleaned? Who would you call if your house was on fire? Did you never go to school?

oyster

12,648 posts

250 months

Tuesday 14th May
quotequote all
eliot said:
oyster said:
PS. The pandemic largesse was of their own choosing. They were the government at the time.
Remind me who wanted to continue the furlough scheme...when the tories wanted it stopped asap.
Why does that matter?

The Tories were the governing party with a massive majority. ALL Covid policies and decisions were made by them.

Opposition parties oppose, they don't set policy or legislation.