Track Day Collisions
Track Day Collisions
Author
Discussion

DanH

12,287 posts

287 months

Friday 13th June 2008
quotequote all
Thinking about it, you wanted to be going through the earlier footage of this muppet. That way if you weren't the first dodgy overtake you could try to hold the TDO responsible as they weren't properly policing.

Frankly the main issue seems to be that people are wrs. You did well not to go back with a wrench and improve his car a bit further.

jleroux

1,511 posts

287 months

Friday 13th June 2008
quotequote all
DanH said:
Thinking about it, you wanted to be going through the earlier footage of this muppet. That way if you weren't the first dodgy overtake you could try to hold the TDO responsible as they weren't properly policing.
That could work both ways. If the driver felt this other guys driving was bad enough earlier on he should have either

a) notified the TDO then, or

b) known to keep his distance from that car in future

it's a sh!t situation that nobody enjoys but the only person who can realistically accept any blame (morally or legally) is the driver of the offending vehicle.

Jonny

Goldeeno

698 posts

222 months

Friday 13th June 2008
quotequote all
Crist, how close was that guy to getting minced by a scooby, after getting out the caterham!!!! redface

petermansell

868 posts

233 months

Friday 13th June 2008
quotequote all
[quote=Pickled Piper]Thanks for the comments guys.

Just to make it clear. I'm not suggesting the TDO is liable for the damage to my vehicle in any way. Taking aside the issue of who was to blame for the collision for a moment, I am appalled at the behavior of the other driver after the collision. I would have considered it a basic courtesy to seek out the other driver and have a chat. If you didn't want to speak to the driver for fear of aggressive behaviour, surely the right thing to do would be to contact the TDO or marshalls and not just try and make a fast exit. I am certain that had the car been road legal and not trailored, he would have been halfway home by the time I reached the paddock area. The main issue is the shoddy behaviour of the other driver and the reluctance of the TDO to do anything about it.

I do feel like I have been the victim of a "hit and run" and the TDO is telling me it's nothing to worry about whilst he also makes a sharp exit.

pp

eek

Back luck PP. I agree that whatever the merits of your particular case people who are involved in an incident should at least behave courteously and speak to the other party involved.

On the case itself I think TDOs should be tough in applying the rules readit because we know from previous cases in law the risk lies with the drivers grumpy and so is much greater if the TDO isn't vigilant.

legaleagleboy

605 posts

278 months

Friday 13th June 2008
quotequote all
pp

I think I was at that track day with you - sorry to hear thjat you had the problem. Two things spring to mind.

1) All overtaking, should be with consent, this is not optional. If my feeble memory can be relied upon, then I am certain this was properly covered in the briefing.

2) From what you have said the other driver is clearly at fault and his actions when you confronted him seem to confirm this. He clearly did not like the idea of a conversation when he in all probability was feeling a bit ashamed of his poor driving. (I guess he had an expensive car and his talents did not quite match the machinery!)

As I see it your only hope for a remedy is to make contact with the other driver and get him to do something honourable ( ie in a situation where the law may not be helpful) , despite what has gone before -- the TDO would probably not help with his details, citing Data Protection!! -- but you could try. I assume you did not get a reg No and in hindsight the VIN would be helpful -- what about the reg of the tow truck? You need some detective work to make any more progress.

all the best

DanH

12,287 posts

287 months

Friday 13th June 2008
quotequote all
jleroux said:
DanH said:
Thinking about it, you wanted to be going through the earlier footage of this muppet. That way if you weren't the first dodgy overtake you could try to hold the TDO responsible as they weren't properly policing.
That could work both ways. If the driver felt this other guys driving was bad enough earlier on he should have either

a) notified the TDO then, or

b) known to keep his distance from that car in future

it's a sh!t situation that nobody enjoys but the only person who can realistically accept any blame (morally or legally) is the driver of the offending vehicle.

Jonny
To be honest I'm a bit disappointed with the TDO in this case. The least he could have done is ban the guy and tell the customer that he was doing that.

I know its at own risk on trackdays and that's part of why I insure, but you want at least some semblance of justice however minor.

driverrob

4,843 posts

230 months

Friday 13th June 2008
quotequote all
I've only done Novice track days, where the safety precautions and rules are very strict, and only at Brands Hatch. I've never seen a collision but, on one very damp day, several porsches spun off at the hairpin onto the gravel. No damage done.

VTECMatt

1,368 posts

265 months

Saturday 14th June 2008
quotequote all
I came very close to a car on car incident at Bedford earlier in the year, it was mostly my fault under estimated the fact that the other car was letting me by when he clearly didnt think he was. Fortunately I noticed and hatched an escape plan again fortunatly didnt need to, as he saw me at the last moment.

Unfortunately it can happen I would say I am experienced and it certainly was'nt delibratly trying to nip past and happy to apologise as I did, but like Dan one of the reasons I use a policy that includes Trackday cover.

I have never attended a day where it has happened and I have done a fair few in the last 8 years.

Edited by VTECMatt on Saturday 14th June 21:50

fridaypassion

11,457 posts

255 months

Sunday 15th June 2008
quotequote all
I've done a few track days with Lotus on track in my VX220 and never seen or been involved in any shennanigans/bumps etc. The good thing about LOT is that it limited to lotus/VX/caterfields etc so without wanting to sound patronising you do tend to get a more experienced driver on those days.The only issue I had was with an old git in an exige who got the teddy out of the cot because he had his pride dented by me staying in front of him on an NA VXwink

I've done other days where its clear that its a lot of peoples first time on track and its a nightmare. With the best of intentions of you get a load of novices on track who are not checking their mirrors or even worse driving with their egos in the car with them its a recipe for disaster.

Pickled Piper

Original Poster:

6,451 posts

262 months

Monday 16th June 2008
quotequote all
Thanks for the input everyone.

My main reasons for posting were to vent my frustration and then to glean any information from others that have had similar experiences. In answer to the questions about what I hope to achieve. I would like to come away with the feeling that the other driver and /or the TDO did the "right thing". Like most people, I assessed the risk of taking my car on track and then tried to manage the risk by choosing an owners club track day, adhering to the rules etc. My car is my P&J but I am not precious about it. It's meant to be driven, especially on track.

Jleroux - Thanks for stepping up as TDO. I take on board your comments about defensive driving and acknowledge that had I been a bit sharper, I could have anticipate the other driver's actions and made allowances for them.

Legaleagleboy, Yes we were on the same trackday. Thanks for arranging the instruction and thanks for the advice. I have a photograph of the driver, his car and his towing vehicle complete with reg plate. His vehicle is quite distinctive and of a particular type. I'm obviously disappointed at his behaviour but more so at the TDO, as the organisation presents itself as having the highest standards of marshalling and driver etiquette for all its events. I would have expected the TDO to jump on the situation rather than sit on the fence and quote Ts & Cs.

pp



tony.t

927 posts

283 months

Monday 16th June 2008
quotequote all
PP. It's rather a sad tale you tell and I'm sure it leaves a bad taste. IMO the other driver acted with a mix of cowardice and arogance but such is life; Unfortunatley people with poor character are to be found everywhere.

My view is that a simple "sorry" would have gone a long way to make you feel better about the whole incident. The TDOs prevacation just makes things worse. Again if they had sent him home ( even though he was going anyway) would have helped satisy you.

I've had a number of occasions where there's been a bit of "closeness" going on. Mostly others ignoring the rules and overtaking in braking zones and corners but some due to me misjudging another cars lack of speed and some by me barging past drivers who just won't get out of the way.

Ultimatly now I wouldn't pay for another cars damage even if it was my "fault" and nor would I expect to be compensated for anothers error. For me it's the risk you take and defensive driving ameliorates such risk to being minimal. You're far more likely to damage your car on track furniture than another car and if you do enough days it will happen.

Once we start suing each other and the TDOs for accidents trackdays become unworkable IMO.

norasport

66 posts

236 months

Monday 16th June 2008
quotequote all
As a motorsport organiser, as far as I am aware, the Road Traffic Act applies to all forms of driving and in all areas, unless a permit has been issued by a controlling authority.

Don't underestimate your liability under the law at a track day when, if the police where to be involved prosecutions for dangerous driving, for example, could potentially result.

I have never seen this info put to potential track day drivers, would a TDO wish to comment?

mmm-five

12,254 posts

311 months

Monday 16th June 2008
quotequote all
Maybe we should all think about insurance for these events. Did you have track day insurance in place?

I used to cover my car for every event when I first started, but once I was comfortable with how things worked and sized up who was going to be on track with me I let it lapse.

Targarama

14,742 posts

310 months

Monday 16th June 2008
quotequote all
John D. said:
poshgit said:
been seen a thousand times - but for me the ONLY track day crash video - wait until the end and watch the caterfield get munched!!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MZ0-zkEyHIE&amp...
This is why I'm never ever, ever, ever, doing an 'action day' at Combe!
Agreed, looked like a few of those crashes (Scoobie, white Rover 200 series) were people trying to do oversteery fun stuff by flicking left then right ... and failing. I'm not into people dicking about on the circuit, especially on a corner like that one! All those Cavaliers trying too hard and probably not caring too much doesn't inspire me with confidence either.

Cabana

111 posts

236 months

Monday 16th June 2008
quotequote all
John D. said:
poshgit said:
been seen a thousand times - but for me the ONLY track day crash video - wait until the end and watch the caterfield get munched!!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MZ0-zkEyHIE&amp...
This is why I'm never ever, ever, ever, doing an 'action day' at Combe!
Coincidentally, the only two vehicle crash I've ever seen at at trackday was at a Combe action day last summer, I'm not sure what the outcome of it was but it seemed to be caused by the usual problem at the action days of over-enthusiasm combined with a lack of awareness/talent!

casbar

1,136 posts

242 months

Tuesday 17th June 2008
quotequote all
I do a lot of trackdays, but st happens. If someone took me out, and it wasn't my fault, I would expect the person to a least say sorry. Would I expect them to pay, no, that is why I take out trackday insurance which will pay for my car, regardless of who was at fault.

If you don't have insurance, its your decision.

fergus

6,430 posts

302 months

Tuesday 17th June 2008
quotequote all
[quote=norasport]As a motorsport organiser, as far as I am aware, the Road Traffic Act applies to all forms of driving and in all areas, unless a permit has been issued by a controlling authority.

Don't underestimate your liability under the law at a track day when, if the police where to be involved prosecutions for dangerous driving, for example, could potentially result./quote]

yes

tertius

6,914 posts

257 months

Tuesday 17th June 2008
quotequote all
fergus said:
norasport said:
As a motorsport organiser, as far as I am aware, the Road Traffic Act applies to all forms of driving and in all areas, unless a permit has been issued by a controlling authority.

Don't underestimate your liability under the law at a track day when, if the police where to be involved prosecutions for dangerous driving, for example, could potentially result.
yes
This topic needs a thread all of its own but ... really?

If the RTA applies why do we overtake on the left?

(And dozens of other questions ...)

cirvy

2,331 posts

290 months

Tuesday 17th June 2008
quotequote all
Cabana said:
John D. said:
poshgit said:
been seen a thousand times - but for me the ONLY track day crash video - wait until the end and watch the caterfield get munched!!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MZ0-zkEyHIE&amp...
This is why I'm never ever, ever, ever, doing an 'action day' at Combe!
Coincidentally, the only two vehicle crash I've ever seen at at trackday was at a Combe action day last summer, I'm not sure what the outcome of it was but it seemed to be caused by the usual problem at the action days of over-enthusiasm combined with a lack of awareness/talent!
Thats amazing footage, how long a period was that over??

Munter

31,331 posts

268 months

Tuesday 17th June 2008
quotequote all
cirvy said:
Cabana said:
John D. said:
poshgit said:
been seen a thousand times - but for me the ONLY track day crash video - wait until the end and watch the caterfield get munched!!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MZ0-zkEyHIE&amp...
This is why I'm never ever, ever, ever, doing an 'action day' at Combe!
Coincidentally, the only two vehicle crash I've ever seen at at trackday was at a Combe action day last summer, I'm not sure what the outcome of it was but it seemed to be caused by the usual problem at the action days of over-enthusiasm combined with a lack of awareness/talent!
Thats amazing footage, how long a period was that over??
I wouldn't be surprised if that was one action day. You buy a pass for a 5 lap session for something like £30. Which means that people want to impress their mates but dont have any practise or tallent....

Edited by Munter on Tuesday 17th June 14:34