Dr Who… Awesome News If You're A Fan

Dr Who… Awesome News If You're A Fan

Author
Discussion

dundarach

5,116 posts

229 months

Monday 13th May
quotequote all
chemistry said:
Apparently Dr Who isn't for straight white men anyway, according to Metro rolleyes



https://metro.co.uk/2024/05/11/sorry-straight-whit...
That's that cleared up then, back to TV made for me:

Tycho

11,655 posts

274 months

Monday 13th May
quotequote all
chemistry said:
Apparently Dr Who isn't for straight white men anyway, according to Metro rolleyes



https://metro.co.uk/2024/05/11/sorry-straight-whit...
So it's inclusive but not if you are straight, white and male. Got it. It's like the whole Star Wars Sequels when they tried to turn the fanbase on itself by trying to make it look like a racism thing rather than a "This storyline is rubbish" thing. Classic squirrel behaviour.

otolith

56,444 posts

205 months

Monday 13th May
quotequote all
chemistry said:
Apparently Dr Who isn't for straight white men anyway, according to Metro rolleyes



https://metro.co.uk/2024/05/11/sorry-straight-whit...
They've realised how stupid that was and edited the headline.


RustyMX5

7,245 posts

218 months

Monday 13th May
quotequote all
chemistry said:
Apparently Dr Who isn't for straight white men anyway, according to Metro rolleyes



https://metro.co.uk/2024/05/11/sorry-straight-whit...
I'm not having a dig at you personally here....

I don't care if the Doctor is male, female, black, white, asian, gay, lesbian, transgender, straight, binary, non-binary, gender queer or whatever. I care that the stories and acting are good. It's obvious that Ncuti is a colourful character who's going to bring a new slant to the role in the same way that every other doctor has and he's obviously got plenty of acting ability to deliver a great Doctor. The plot lines for the first two episodes have been dreadful and babies and someone who steals music is not what Doctor Who is about.

I can live with colourful characters, like a drag queen for example, if that character supports the narrative of the story but to add a colourful character just for the sake of it is annoying and pointless.

Maybe I'm old (started watching Dr Who in the 1970's) but as it stands at the moment, I'm not encouraged by what I've seen so far in terms of narrative.

zarjaz1991

3,501 posts

124 months

Monday 13th May
quotequote all
It’s funny how “inclusive” actually means “excluding anyone whose world view we don’t like”.

I-am-the-reverend

685 posts

36 months

Monday 13th May
quotequote all
ThomW said:
A bunch of grown men getting their panties in a twist because of a fictional character. Good grief have a word with yourselves.
A bunch of grown men watching Doctor Who, period. biglaugh

chemistry

2,182 posts

110 months

Monday 13th May
quotequote all
RustyMX5 said:
I'm not having a dig at you personally here....

I don't care if the Doctor is male, female, black, white, asian, gay, lesbian, transgender, straight, binary, non-binary, gender queer or whatever. I care that the stories and acting are good. It's obvious that Ncuti is a colourful character who's going to bring a new slant to the role in the same way that every other doctor has and he's obviously got plenty of acting ability to deliver a great Doctor. The plot lines for the first two episodes have been dreadful and babies and someone who steals music is not what Doctor Who is about.

I can live with colourful characters, like a drag queen for example, if that character supports the narrative of the story but to add a colourful character just for the sake of it is annoying and pointless.

Maybe I'm old (started watching Dr Who in the 1970's) but as it stands at the moment, I'm not encouraged by what I've seen so far in terms of narrative.
No offence taken and I have no issue with Ncuti being cast as the (entirely fictional...) Doctor. Nonetheless it's a shame that some sections of society, such as the Metro journalist, see it as another opportunity to turn inclusion (good thing) into identity politics (bad thing).

RTD making some of the Doctor Who storylines (as opposed to casting) pointedly woke, such as with the pronouns thing and him not being able to "let it go whilst as a male-presenting timelord", doesn't help.

Anyway, I don't want to derail the thread...the politics of it call can be discussed in N,P&E!

simonrockman

6,869 posts

256 months

Monday 13th May
quotequote all
The inclusivity metric they are failing on is the one where the original description of The Doctor succeeded. In the original casting he was described as "A crotchety old man".

Being gender and colour aware is seen as fine, but the part calls for someone who is old. He is as he points out 900.

TGCOTF-dewey

5,294 posts

56 months

Monday 13th May
quotequote all
I think an interesting contrast is the latest episode of Inside #9.

It's a superbly scripted and acted story, that just so happens to represent the wide selection of folks who travel on a tube.

I'd love Pemberton and Shearsmith to have a crack at a few Who stories. I think they'd make a great job of it.

tangerine_sedge

4,841 posts

219 months

Monday 13th May
quotequote all
RustyMX5 said:
The plot lines for the first two episodes have been dreadful and babies and someone who steals music is not what Doctor Who is about.
Indeed, it should have more 3 hour long stories about Marco Polo or the Romans... hehe

BossHogg

6,037 posts

179 months

Monday 13th May
quotequote all
The Doctor asking everyone if they're local and fighting twelvety daleks! Shouting at the Cybermen, well have no trouble here! laugh

anonymoususer

5,942 posts

49 months

Monday 13th May
quotequote all
Is it too much to hope that they will do a story about a gay Cyberperson ?

Zad

12,710 posts

237 months

Monday 13th May
quotequote all
anonymoususer said:
Is it too much to hope that they will do a story about a gay Cyberperson ?
Aren't they all non-binary anyway?


defblade

7,454 posts

214 months

Monday 13th May
quotequote all
Just to balance out the presumably mainly straight white middle aged male population on here, my daughter is now 22, is autistic, recently diagnosed with ADHD, and gay; she grew up with and loved Tennant, enjoyed Capaldi...
...and thinks the new stuff, from Jodie onwards, is dreadful - entirely down to the clunkiness of the writing forcing a tick into every box that she should, in theory, be applauding.

TGCOTF-dewey

5,294 posts

56 months

Monday 13th May
quotequote all
BossHogg said:
The Doctor asking everyone if they're local and fighting twelvety daleks! Shouting at the Cybermen, well have no trouble here! laugh
hehe You're my companion now!

To be fair, #9 is nothing like TLOG.

BossHogg

6,037 posts

179 months

Monday 13th May
quotequote all
I could never get into 9, too dark.

98elise

26,761 posts

162 months

Tuesday 14th May
quotequote all
otolith said:
chemistry said:
Apparently Dr Who isn't for straight white men anyway, according to Metro rolleyes



https://metro.co.uk/2024/05/11/sorry-straight-whit...
They've realised how stupid that was and edited the headline.

It's still stupid. I watch TV I like, and that's not defined by my colour or sexulity.


W12GT

3,549 posts

222 months

Tuesday 14th May
quotequote all
Just watching the second episode. I think Ncuti could be a really good Dr. But what utter rubbish this is thus far. It isn’t Who.

Edited to say:-
The bouncing apprentice though still isn’t enough to make it watchable! The ending is so sad and pathetic.

What utter utter rubbish. Whoever signed this off at the BBC should be sacked.

Dr Who is an institution of British TV. This series and particularly the second episode has taken a huge great turd on top of it.


Edited by W12GT on Tuesday 14th May 21:35

JoshSm

289 posts

38 months

Tuesday 14th May
quotequote all
I'm not sure anyone should have expected different, it's just what you expect as the distillation of the worst recent habits from Disney and RTD's fairly limited range of pet ideas & themes.

They're making the show they want to make and whether an audience (especially the legacy audience) comes along for the ride apparently doesn't matter.

Maybe they'll carry on, maybe they'll change tack, maybe they'll kill it, but I'm fairly sure no lessons will be learnt along the way as they certainly haven't been before. And I'm not sure there'll be much of an audience left to care.

ThomW

1,129 posts

29 months

Tuesday 14th May
quotequote all
Just watched the second episode myself, and honestly I thought it was brilliant. Fun, fast paced and funny.

Maestro was a fantastic villain, unhinged and scary enough while still being PG friendly.

The only thing that stuck out to me was Ruby mentioning her mum’s girlfriend and then the song for her mate who had a girlfriend too. It’s just pushing that aspect too hard.

But I love the new Doctor, he’s a breath of fresh air.


Edited by ThomW on Tuesday 14th May 22:34