EVs... no one wants them!

EVs... no one wants them!

Author
Discussion

ben5575

6,359 posts

223 months

Friday 19th April
quotequote all
740EVTORQUES said:
Matt Farrah disagrees…

https://apple.news/A9ZLHhJGSS7Of-rytAOh1NA


‘The Hyundai Ioniq 5 N Is by Far the Best Sports EV I've Ever Driven
It's so good that it could save the future of race tracks in the United States, if it comes to that….


There are so many ways that Hyundai could have gotten this wrong, and only one way it could go right. They’ve hit a hole-in-one on a par four. Because the lie is so convincing, after a few seconds, I didn’t care that it wasn’t real. The lie gave me what I needed in order to have fun in a car on a racetrack or a canyon road: engagement. Its mimicry of a gasoline-powered rally machine is literally as good as to be the real thing. Only if it was the real thing, for this kinda scratch you’d never be going as quickly.?‘
I have no doubt it's a great car and great fun to drive - I'd love one, it's my perfect daily - I actually looked at one (before I saw the price!)

But it's not a small two seater open top sports car, which is my particular need at the moment.

Chasing Potatoes

213 posts

7 months

Friday 19th April
quotequote all
BlackTank said:
I wish the EV supporters who have made a type of propulsion their identity would just stop with the nonsense that EVs are exciting, engaging, thrilling to drive. They are not which is why Hyundai is trying hard to figure out how to make the Ioniq 5 N drive more like an ICE.

Let's discuss the ease of use, driving simplicity and economics of EVs - don't try to bullst driving enthusiasts on a driving enthusiasts website. It destroys any credibility and harms the discussion on EVs.
I wish that people would stop thinking that only by driving an ICE could you possibly be a driving enthusiast. They’re different, and some people prefer that point of difference.

You’re not better than someone because of your car.

740EVTORQUES

653 posts

3 months

Friday 19th April
quotequote all
I’m waiting to try an Ionic N to see if I should change my EV6 GT for one, they sound incredible.

I do rather like the alternative form of involvement that the pure EV gives though, I agree in trying to ape a traditional powertrain with all its inherent flaws, that seems to me to be backwards looking.

I prefer the looks of the EV6 as well

I turned off the synthetic engine noise (which is a bit V8 like) in my car after about 5 minutes

Edited by 740EVTORQUES on Friday 19th April 08:57

soupdragon1

4,197 posts

99 months

Friday 19th April
quotequote all
BlackTank said:
I wish the EV supporters who have made a type of propulsion their identity would just stop with the nonsense that EVs are exciting, engaging, thrilling to drive. They are not which is why Hyundai is trying hard to figure out how to make the Ioniq 5 N drive more like an ICE.

Let's discuss the ease of use, driving simplicity and economics of EVs - don't try to bullst driving enthusiasts on a driving enthusiasts website. It destroys any credibility and harms the discussion on EVs.
Ever seen a sex enthusiast? Some people have questionable ideas on what good sex is

Ever seen a golf enthusiast? Keep hitting their balls into the water and into the trees etc, yet they go back every week?

Ever seen a train spotting enthusiast? I mean, each to their own

If someone on here claims to be a driving enthusiast, maybe I should ask them why they are driving a passenger car? If its all about the driving, why are you driving a car designed to take passengers and by default, a compromised vehicle? Not much of an driving enthusiast IMO. Driving enthusiasts generally take single seater vehicles around a race track.

Tongue in cheek of course, but, the point is pretty obvious. You could get a CHEP pallet, couple of axles, 4 pram wheels, a piece of rope for steering and put yourself at the top of a hill and call yourself a driving enthusiast. Each to their own. I doubt Lewis Hamilton would get all warm and fuzzy behind the wheel of a 4 seater BMW M3 but, like I say, each to their own. If you find enjoyment going from A to B in a vehicle, then you can call yourself a driving enthusiast IMO. There is no line in the sand to define what that is.


heebeegeetee

28,922 posts

250 months

Friday 19th April
quotequote all
BlackTank said:
I wish the EV supporters who have made a type of propulsion their identity would just stop with the nonsense that EVs are exciting, engaging, thrilling to drive. They are not which is why Hyundai is trying hard to figure out how to make the Ioniq 5 N drive more like an ICE.

Let's discuss the ease of use, driving simplicity and economics of EVs - don't try to bullst driving enthusiasts on a driving enthusiasts website. It destroys any credibility and harms the discussion on EVs.
"the EV supporters who have made a type of propulsion their identity" Can you actually show me anyone here who is like that? I'm interested in the EV scene (simply because I am a motoring enthusiast) but I have never come across anyone like how you describe, and certainly not here on Pistonheads.

--

A few weeks back I was driving a car with two mates onboard. All 3 of us are lifelong car/motoring enthusiasts, my two pals being far more hardcore than me. One has had a long life in rallying, he has built some lovely cars over the years, his family were out on the Rallynuts stages last weekend, his two sons competing on the event. The other guy has done all sorts of things including motorcycling to China and across Russia to Vladivostock, has been involved in karting and all manner of things, is currently building a car for a Historic Monte.

The three of us were in the car because we were returning from an all-nighter marshalling on the Lands End Trial. These two guys both currently own hybrids, amongst many other cars, and have had other EVs prior. The three of us discussed EVs in length, the other two going into the nitty gritty of their BMW i3s they currently own. And yes, how they drove was very much discussed.

I think the way you are talking BlackTank, is of the way people do when they see their petrol head credentials as some kind of badge of honour. This kind of talk/behaviour leads people to buy all kinds of unsuitable and impractical cars (the kind that are usually sold with few miles on the clock, because they're not a great drive) , again like they're some kind of badge of honour of hardcore-petrolheadship-one-upmanship.

What you call 'driving enthusiasts' is what I often question - I think many 'driving enthusiasts' are completely full of bullst, I think the whole ethos and thinking around a particular genre of enthusiasts car is indeed just bullst.

REAL enthusiasts don't speak as you do, in my very own honest and personal opinion. Certainly not the real enthusiasts I've come across in my lifetime anyway.

And I'd still be interested to see who it is that you think "have made a type of propulsion their identity."



otolith

56,785 posts

206 months

Friday 19th April
quotequote all
BlackTank said:
I wish the EV supporters who have made a type of propulsion their identity
Are there any of those? I certainly see people whose objection to EV is that they have made ICE part of their identity and viscerally resist change, I'm not really seeing it from the other side.

Harry H

3,451 posts

158 months

Friday 19th April
quotequote all
otolith said:
BlackTank said:
I wish the EV supporters who have made a type of propulsion their identity
Are there any of those? I certainly see people whose objection to EV is that they have made ICE part of their identity and viscerally resist change, I'm not really seeing it from the other side.
Type in VW tattoo into google. There are some strange people out there.

cj2013

1,409 posts

128 months

Friday 19th April
quotequote all
Harry H said:
Type in VW tattoo into google. There are some strange people out there.
Having worked in a VW dealer at one point, and spoken to a lot of those VW types, I typically find that people who are obsessed with VWs have not actually owned any other marque at any point.

So, rather than preference, it is closer in definition to a cult

clockworks

5,462 posts

147 months

Friday 19th April
quotequote all
I currently drive a plug-in hybrid XC40. Some say plug-ins are the worst of both worlds, others think they are the dog's danglie's. For me, it's a no-risk way of trying electric motoring. I'm convinced, and full electric is on the cards for me next.

As for "driving pleasure", I've been there, done that. I used to love thrashing around on motorbikes. Same with cars - just driving for the sake of it in the evenings when the roads cleared. I even got pleasure from driving my first "car" - a Reliant Robin 750.

I did the hot hatch thing, variety of Fords (XR2s, 3s and a 4i), a Westfield and a Mini, before getting a company car.
Having to do 40k miles a year for work in succession of repmobiles tucked all the pleasure out of driving.

I tried to rekindle the passion with a 964 911, 987 Boxster S, Z4, couple of MX5s, Cooper S, etc., but either I was too old, or there's just too much traffic and too many cameras around these days.

I'm content to mostly just potter around, with the occasional bit of rapid overtaking.
An EV will suit me just fine.

Oilchange

8,533 posts

262 months

Friday 19th April
quotequote all
NDA said:
Can you show us on the map where the nasty EV overtook you?
Can we move away from this ‘my ego has been hurt by being overtaken’ nonsense please.
I’m overtaken often in my Esprit, its fine, I would rather be overtaken than have some muppet sitting on my bumper expecting me to speed up for him/her, especially if I’m giving them room by pulling in a bit.
Too many egos on the road nowadays… rolleyes


NDA

21,761 posts

227 months

Friday 19th April
quotequote all
Oilchange said:
NDA said:
Can you show us on the map where the nasty EV overtook you?
Can we move away from this ‘my ego has been hurt by being overtaken’ nonsense please.
I’m overtaken often in my Esprit, its fine, I would rather be overtaken than have some muppet sitting on my bumper expecting me to speed up for him/her, especially if I’m giving them room by pulling in a bit.
Too many egos on the road nowadays… rolleyes
I was responding to the "the brainwashed cultist EV loons" comment - which I assume you think is an acceptable view? rolleyes


FiF

44,415 posts

253 months

Friday 19th April
quotequote all
NDA said:
Oilchange said:
NDA said:
Can you show us on the map where the nasty EV overtook you?
Can we move away from this ‘my ego has been hurt by being overtaken’ nonsense please.
I’m overtaken often in my Esprit, its fine, I would rather be overtaken than have some muppet sitting on my bumper expecting me to speed up for him/her, especially if I’m giving them room by pulling in a bit.
Too many egos on the road nowadays… rolleyes
I was responding to the "the brainwashed cultist EV loons" comment - which I assume you think is an acceptable view? rolleyes
Frankly neither of the comments are appropriate content, neither the cultist loon twaddle nor the where were you touched single line attempt at being a smart arse.

Others may think differently.

HTH

romft123

521 posts

6 months

Friday 19th April
quotequote all
monkfish1 said:
740EVTORQUES said:
monkfish1 said:
740EVTORQUES said:
trumpton7291 said:
I don’t think most prefer ICE because we’re some stuck in the past unwoke Dinosaurs. Most people prefer ICE because currently it’s a far better technology than EVs in terms of day to day useability and who would ever want to take a backward step? Forcing people into inferior products is never going to end well. Let the market decide, if EVs are superior people will buy them. But that’s not currently the reality despite the continual protestations of the brainwashed cultist EV loons.
Well this ‘cultist EV loon’ has a flat 6, a V6, a 2.5l 305bhp track car, and an EV.

I’ve got comfortably in excess of £250k invested in ICE vehicles.

From my real world experience I know that for 95% of situations the EV is hands down the best car, and it’s also a very engaging rewarding drivers car.

But obviously I’m brainwashed?
Brainwashed? Probably not. But and engaging rewarding drivers car? Really?

Maybe a different phrase would be more fitting. I'll let you decide.
I already did. I meant what I wrote. The EV is a really engaging, rewarding drivers car. Even when judged against some pretty desirable ICE machinery.

Hard to believe I know, but that’s real world experience for you.

One day you’ll try one and find out I expect.
I have. And it was ludicrously fast. See what I did there?

But, as before, no engine, no interest.

Simply not possible to be engaging or rewarding. iMO.
Top tip and its free.......dont buy one! Easy innit

biggbn

24,052 posts

222 months

Friday 19th April
quotequote all
BlackTank said:
I wish the EV supporters who have made a type of propulsion their identity would just stop with the nonsense that EVs are exciting, engaging, thrilling to drive. They are not which is why Hyundai is trying hard to figure out how to make the Ioniq 5 N drive more like an ICE.

Let's discuss the ease of use, driving simplicity and economics of EVs - don't try to bullst driving enthusiasts on a driving enthusiasts website. It destroys any credibility and harms the discussion on EVs.
I'm an enthusiast. I've owned around 200 cars, forgot the exact number. I love driving. I don't own an EV, but I'd love one. Mmmm. I must be an outlier, a one off?....OR just someone who loves cars and driving...anything...let's use the term....erm, enthusiast?

biggbn

24,052 posts

222 months

Friday 19th April
quotequote all
Chasing Potatoes said:
BlackTank said:
I wish the EV supporters who have made a type of propulsion their identity would just stop with the nonsense that EVs are exciting, engaging, thrilling to drive. They are not which is why Hyundai is trying hard to figure out how to make the Ioniq 5 N drive more like an ICE.

Let's discuss the ease of use, driving simplicity and economics of EVs - don't try to bullst driving enthusiasts on a driving enthusiasts website. It destroys any credibility and harms the discussion on EVs.
I wish that people would stop thinking that only by driving an ICE could you possibly be a driving enthusiast. They’re different, and some people prefer that point of difference.

You’re not better than someone because of your car.
You ARE, you ARE. The hypocrisy on this thread, and others, is hilarious. All that's wrong with PH

biggbn

24,052 posts

222 months

Friday 19th April
quotequote all
I can't believe so many people have rushed out and bought one of these new fangled four wheeled automatons. It's so ridiculous. No character, no personality, they're never gonna have a bond with them. Soulless, pointless, characterless. I'm keeping my horse and cart...

Essarell

1,282 posts

56 months

Friday 19th April
quotequote all
biggbn said:
I can't believe so many people have rushed out and bought one of these new fangled four wheeled automatons. It's so ridiculous. No character, no personality, they're never gonna have a bond with them. Soulless, pointless, characterless. I'm keeping my horse and cart...
You don’t find the lack of blacksmiths an inconvenience? Our local one closed down 40years ago……..
Having said that refueling is easier and when it finally gives up and heads to that big stable in the sky you can eat it…..proper sustainability right there…..

biggbn

24,052 posts

222 months

Friday 19th April
quotequote all
Essarell said:
biggbn said:
I can't believe so many people have rushed out and bought one of these new fangled four wheeled automatons. It's so ridiculous. No character, no personality, they're never gonna have a bond with them. Soulless, pointless, characterless. I'm keeping my horse and cart...
You don’t find the lack of blacksmiths an inconvenience? Our local one closed down 40years ago……..
Having said that refueling is easier and when it finally gives up and heads to that big stable in the sky you can eat it…..proper sustainability right there…..
beer

nickfrog

21,426 posts

219 months

Friday 19th April
quotequote all
You guys crack me up!

740EVTORQUES

653 posts

3 months

Friday 19th April
quotequote all
A Tesla model S on its original battery, 12% degradation after 360,000 miles!

I thought they were all going to wear out after 5 years?

https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/285808764752?mkcid=16&a...

Edited by 740EVTORQUES on Friday 19th April 18:13