When is a classic car a classic car?

When is a classic car a classic car?

Author
Discussion

crankedup

25,764 posts

243 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
absolutely said:
crankedup said:
Vintage cars are only classed as such if said car was built from the end of veteran era up to 1930. After 1930 they are classic cars apparently. I have considered for some while that a post vintage classification needs to be formally agreed upon and an modern classic group also. I know this won't help the OP much, sorry.
Big hairy bks! You cannot say a 1931 Phantom II is not a Vintage car!
Sorry mate, its not my definition. Its always going to upset some people when they find that thier 1931 car IS NOT CLASSED as a vintage car. (My self included with my 1931 Austin 7 'Swallow' Saloon)

Its a can of worms which could be discussed adinfinitum and still not be resolved. As mentioned earlier, just enjoy your car/lorry/bus/tank or whatever it is you drive biggrin

Edited by crankedup on Wednesday 21st May 17:31

absolutely

3,168 posts

192 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
crankedup said:
absolutely said:
crankedup said:
Vintage cars are only classed as such if said car was built from the end of veteran era up to 1930. After 1930 they are classic cars apparently. I have considered for some while that a post vintage classification needs to be formally agreed upon and an modern classic group also. I know this won't help the OP much, sorry.
Big hairy bks! You cannot say a 1931 Phantom II is not a Vintage car!
Sorry mate, its not my definition. Its always going to upset some people when they find that thier 1931 car IS NOT CLASSED as a vintage car. (My self included with my 1931 Austin 7 'Swallow' Saloon)
Who says?

The Americans call all old cars "antique cars", they're nothing like a granfather clock or a cupboard!

plasticpig

12,932 posts

225 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Gretchen said:
plasticpig said:
You can if you are the VSCC. The CCOA reckon the vintage cut off is 1925 IIRC.
So, in effect, they could also say anything post 1973 (ie not tax exempt) should not be considered a 'classic'... ??

Dictionary defines 'classic' as;

a. Belonging to the highest rank or class.
b. Serving as the established model or standard: a classic example of colonial architecture.
c. Having lasting significance or worth; enduring.
Well they could. The problem is there is no definition. Its all subjective. There are plenty of 80's and early nineties cars that many consider to be classic. Insurers now have the concept of future classics. These are cars that are not old enough to be considred classic but considered to collecticable enough to be a classic when they are older.

Gretchen

19,037 posts

216 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Simes205 said:
williamp said:
A Classic car is a car which leaves and indelible impression on you
It could be any vehicle, from any age which qualifies as a classic, simply because you remember it well. Of course its different for different people. Thats the joy of our hobby.
Perfect.
I'd go with this.

I'd also interpret 'Indelible impression'...as good or bad, thus making the Allegros and 2CVs of this world classics in their own right.

Doesn't help your arguement much though does it dinkel?




a8hex

5,830 posts

223 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
austin said:
a8hex said:
I wouldn't even use the "not in production" test. Some cares remained in production for years. How about Morgans? are they classics straight off the production line? It's possible that there will be more C-Types built this year than at any time in the 50s, admittedly most of them won't be aiming at qualifying for FIA papers, but do they count as classics?
Who are the C-Types made by? It's not Jaguar so they aren't even Jaguar C-Types...
Of course they aren't Jaguar C-Types (note I didn't say they were) but most people would consider them as classics, even purists would probably consider them on a scale from a welcome recreation to what the heck does that think it looks like (See Tony Dron's column in Octane recently). But most people would think they were classics.

austin said:
Personally I wouldn't class a new Morgan as a classic either, in fact I would say nothing pre 1980 as an absolute minimum.

The problem is that it is a personal thing.
That is the whole point, I'd consider the +4 a classic, but not an Aero.
But why 1980? would a Fiat 126 made in December 79 be a classic and Aston V8 Vantage made in January 1980 not? Why not 1960 or a rolling 50 years?


austin said:
The other question is why do we need to answer the question at all, they are after all just old cars. Just enjoy them and stop arguing the toss about what you call it.
beer I can drink to that.
Kick back, chill out and enjoy

PS, love your car.

Jderh

6,225 posts

207 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
I believe that it depends entirely on a car. I think that pretty much any Jag, Aston, Lotus, Alfa, Maserati or low volume car is a class failry soon after it's been made, but some cars of 30 years old I still would'nt consider a classic. It's completely subjective in most cases, but I think that pretty much anything made before the 70's could be generally conisdered a classic now.

lowdrag

12,893 posts

213 months

Thursday 22nd May 2008
quotequote all
Oh dear, what a can of worms! Vintage was defined in 1934 when the VSCC was formed - pre 1931. A classic though? Well, a Morris Minor is a classic in most peoples eyes but is a Marina or Allegro for example? Both have their supporters and one make clubs. Now let me quote Gretchen's dictionary definition:-

a. Belonging to the highest rank or class.
b. Serving as the established model or standard: a classic example of colonial architecture.
c. Having lasting significance or worth; enduring.

Now that means that I personally am a classic but not two of my cars! Is my Lynx D a classic? personally I think not but the make does seem to have taken on a kind of mythical existance of it's own somehow. A car that is still in production isn't? Well a Morgan has been quoted but surely when the Mini and the Minor finished production the earliest models of their ranges were already classics, especially the Cooper versions. A Toyota Crown or a Talbot Tagora? Both very rare now but classics? Hmmm. Will my C type be a classic one day? I doubt it, more a curiosity even if it will have FIA papers.

No, you'll get a different answer from every person you meet, especially depending on their age. I guess some youngsters consider a 911 a classic even if it is a 993 because it is and was the car of their dreams as they grew up whereas we older farts look at a completely different range of cars.

Personally I try not to make a definition or dividing line; if I like it it's a classic and one of my favourite classics is a Bristol which can be defined as a classic the day it is registered, just like Morgan!

dinkel

Original Poster:

26,951 posts

258 months

Thursday 22nd May 2008
quotequote all
So what can we expect at the Ace Cafe Classic Car Night? Folks interpretations?

austin

1,282 posts

203 months

Thursday 22nd May 2008
quotequote all
dinkel said:
So what can we expect at the Ace Cafe Classic Car Night? Folks interpretations?
People that love their own cars beyond financial sense...

bigbadbikercats

634 posts

208 months

Thursday 22nd May 2008
quotequote all
austin said:
People that love their own cars beyond financial sense...
You know, I think that's the best definition I've seen yet smile

--
JG

tvrgaas

1,460 posts

270 months

Thursday 22nd May 2008
quotequote all
absolutely said:
crankedup said:
Sorry mate, its not my definition. Its always going to upset some people when they find that thier 1931 car IS NOT CLASSED as a vintage car. (My self included with my 1931 Austin 7 'Swallow' Saloon)
Who says?
The VSCC (of the UK) for the purposes of better organising their events have an eligibility scheme which includes a vintage class which is before 1931. They also have Post Vintage Thoroughred (PVT) class for cars from the 30's which are considered "eligible" for events. (This includes all 30's Rolls Royces) This can be debated at length in the club and the list is added to every few years. Last year they added short chassis A7 and MG TA to their PVT list. Many people consider Veteran to be pre 1906 - eligible for the Brighton run. The VSCC has used an Edwardian class for cars pre 1920 (ish). I think the VCC now accept "edwardians". The VSCC also inivite "Historics" to race meeting, these are considered to be Post WWII. The MSA (FIA) have adopted many of these period definitions. In practice the VSCC Welsh trial and the LC&ES are now the only events which are now for pre 1931 cars only. Even the VSCC Welsh Rally this year is to allow PVT entrants. So David I think your Swallow could get an entry. We did it in a chummy a few years ago, and a Phantom 1 has done it, but a Riley or 12/50wink is better to get round the lanes and up the hills.

Edit to correct quote attribution

Edited by tvrgaas on Thursday 22 May 10:35

tvrgaas

1,460 posts

270 months

Thursday 22nd May 2008
quotequote all
Back on Topic: the original poster asked about classic cars - I think one of the classic cars magazines said if it is listed in their price guide it is a classic. One could also argue if there is an owners club and they sit in a field comparing polish - it's a classic. Or it needs an enthusisastic owner. Perhaps a better definition is what would you cross the road to look at? (Allegro or F40?)

dinkel said:
In Holland if a car is over 25 years old you don't need to pay roadtaxes anymore .
Yep we used to have that here, but it stuck about 10 years ago and the historic tax class is pre 1973 (ish).

williamp

19,261 posts

273 months

Thursday 22nd May 2008
quotequote all
And also, in the UK an insurqance company refines any car older then 10 years as a classic, and you can get classic car insurance for it.

austin

1,282 posts

203 months

Thursday 22nd May 2008
quotequote all
williamp said:
And also, in the UK an insurqance company refines any car older then 10 years as a classic, and you can get classic car insurance for it.
Not sure that is always the case, my 16 year old Cavalier for instance.

Definately not a classic whatever anyone says.

williamp

19,261 posts

273 months

Thursday 22nd May 2008
quotequote all
austin said:
williamp said:
And also, in the UK an insurance company defines any car older then 10 years as a classic, and you can get classic car insurance for it.
Not sure that is always the case, my 16 year old Cavalier for instance.

Definately not a classic whatever anyone says.
But you could insure it as a classic car, reagrdless of what you think of it. Besides, it might be a classic one day. If only because people will look at it and think.....my Dad used to have one of those...we went on holiday in one... when we had things called "reps", I once did 40,000 miles in a year in one.....I wonder if it..yes! Yes it does have the original radio, without the DAB function...

This goes back to my definition. Everyones idea of a "classic" will be different, but they will think of it as a classic because it means something to them.

dinkel

Original Poster:

26,951 posts

258 months

Thursday 22nd May 2008
quotequote all
austin said:
dinkel said:
So what can we expect at the Ace Cafe Classic Car Night? Folks interpretations?
People that love their own cars beyond financial sense...
Ah, that's why I can't part from my '95er. A set of new tires has more value than the whole carwink

Good definition though, justifies why a DB4 GT changes from owner for 1m euros . . .

hot metal

1,943 posts

193 months

Thursday 22nd May 2008
quotequote all
Model T FORD, Mini, 2cv, VW Beetle ,Austin 7 ,its cars like these that can truly be called classics .They made a lasting impression on the motoring public ,were popular and were built in very large numbers .There are also cars like the E Type, 911, Cobra etc. which were defining moments in auto history ,classics in the 2nd degree if you like .Thirdly any cars lusted after by general car enthusiasts or which competed closely with any of the aforementioned maybe deemed classics. Age alone however I feel does not constitute a classic vehicle. Austin Maxi anyone?
Andy. IMO obviously smile

a8hex

5,830 posts

223 months

Friday 23rd May 2008
quotequote all

Some interesting points (which I haven't quoted.
hot metal said:
Age alone however I feel does not constitute a classic vehicle. Austin Maxi anyone?
Andy. IMO obviously smile
But
Maxis are probably rarer now than DB5s.
If someone has loved their Maxi enough to have preserved it and still drive it today, then in their eyes it must be a classic. And it can be nice to see these types of cars at classic car dos as well the more exotic varieties. Of course in the case of the Maxi someone must love them a lot, because BMW have gone to the trouble of building a whole new generation of them, of course they weren't quite brave enough to call them Maxis, so they call them Minis insteadwink

Balmoral Green

40,912 posts

248 months

Friday 23rd May 2008
quotequote all
Veteran and Vintage are clearly defined, so there is no problem in understanding what makes a Veteran or Vintage car. There is however no definition for a Classic car, and I think that in itself is the definition, as it's not something that can be defined.

bigbadbikercats

634 posts

208 months

Friday 23rd May 2008
quotequote all
a8hex said:
If someone has loved their Maxi enough to have preserved it and still drive it today, then in their eyes it must be a classic. And it can be nice to see these types of cars at classic car dos as well the more exotic varieties.
It was interesting walking through the car park at last year's Goodwood Revival - More C & D-Types than you could shake a stick at, the only Mercedes 300SL Gullwing I've *ever* seen outside a museum or exhibition (two of them in fact!), every kind of Aston you can imagine (including one of the 'project' racers), '50s and '60s Ferraris sprinkled liberally - well, you get the picture. Amazingly the cars which seemed to be drawing the attention, getting the lingering looks, and drawing comment were the prosaic stuff scattered amongst the exotica, nice clean Hillman Minx's, Ford Consuls, Morris Oxford's and the like - you could overhear (or sometime just imagine from the expressions on peoples faces) the conversations "just like Dad used to have", "our youngest was conceived in one of those", "we went on honeymoon in one like that", "that's like the taxi was took me to my first date", etc, etc, etc. You can't discount that sort of emotional resonance and if someone owns and loves something which used to be considered very ordinary but has significance to the owner I'd have to be in a very harsh mood before I could look them in the eye and tell 'em that their car was just old junk rather than a classic...

--
JG