'Jewish patrol cars' in North London

'Jewish patrol cars' in North London

Author
Discussion

Muntu

7,635 posts

200 months

Sunday 11th January 2015
quotequote all
Yazar said:
Muntu said:
Are our security services voicing any concerns about this?
Sorry, you are going to have to find somebody else to argue with, I can't keep up! thumbup

Muntu

7,635 posts

200 months

Sunday 11th January 2015
quotequote all
paranoid airbag said:
Muntu said:
paranoid airbag said:
I really can't blame them for wanting to protect their own in the face of attack. But when you say "they're not enforcing their own archaic laws" you really should be adding "...yet". There's nearly as much potential for Jewish nuttery as there is Islamic, it's just geopolitical coincidence that means it's not actualised. Nice right now but circumstances change.
Unless Jewish people start publicly decapitating soldiers in the streets of London, or blowing up people on the Tube or London buses, I would think that you need not be concerned about the "yet" bit
So how do we tell a Muslim group wanting to "politely inform" residents of sharia law that they cannot when the Jews can? Because the latter.... are nice?

Good luck but in a court of law I don't see restricting the rights of one person, based on the actions of a different person linked solely by belief in the same sky fairy, flying. Either everybody gets to claim this authority, that is almost completely devoid of checks against abuse, or only the police, who should be protecting all citizens who need protection regardless of belief, do.
Erm, one group is trying to enforce rules that have no standing in British Law, and the attempted enforcement of these rules actually breaks British law.

The other group is actually working with British law enforcement

Fartomatic5000

558 posts

156 months

Sunday 11th January 2015
quotequote all
andy ted said:
Fartomatic5000 said:
Will they be ascertaining the religion of a victim before they help out or intervene?

"Drive on Hiram, he's a towel-head"
did you read this article posted earlier?

http://muslimvillage.com/2013/09/13/43902/uk-jewis...
So they're helping Muslims as well. Will they be helping Christians, Sikhs, Buddhists, equally? If not, why not? ...and if they are treating everyone equally, what's the point? Don't we already have a police force that protects and serves everyone equally?

mph1977

12,467 posts

169 months

Sunday 11th January 2015
quotequote all
paranoid airbag said:
Muntu said:
paranoid airbag said:
I really can't blame them for wanting to protect their own in the face of attack. But when you say "they're not enforcing their own archaic laws" you really should be adding "...yet". There's nearly as much potential for Jewish nuttery as there is Islamic, it's just geopolitical coincidence that means it's not actualised. Nice right now but circumstances change.
Unless Jewish people start publicly decapitating soldiers in the streets of London, or blowing up people on the Tube or London buses, I would think that you need not be concerned about the "yet" bit
So how do we tell a Muslim group wanting to "politely inform" residents of sharia law that they cannot when the Jews can? Because the latter.... are nice?

Good luck but in a court of law I don't see restricting the rights of one person, based on the actions of a different person linked solely by belief in the same sky fairy, flying. Either everybody gets to claim this authority, that is almost completely devoid of checks against abuse, or only the police, who should be protecting all citizens who need protection regardless of belief, do.
this all depends on the actions of the group rather than a nebulous connection.

Shomrim and hatzaolah while meeting a want / percieved need of the Jewish community happily involve themselves in the wider community if things present and do so without ramming Jewishness down peoples throats, much as various other faith based groups do ( e.g. Sally Amry, Street Pastors...)

Tannedbaldhead

2,952 posts

133 months

Sunday 11th January 2015
quotequote all
jeff m2 said:
Muntu said:
Yazar said:
Imagine if Israel in the future US/UK went and bombed Israel, which side would UK orthodox Jews support and would you forsee extremist Jewish nutters bombing the tube too?
No.
Actually they bombeD our Police stations and the Hotel King David in Palestine when it was a Protectorate.

The Jewish extreemists today are a bit of a handful for the Israeli army.
http://www.jta.org/1950/07/31/archive/mayor-of-jerusalem-denounces-religious-extremists-who-molested-u-n-cars-on-sabbath

http://jonathanturley.org/2014/12/31/delta-flight-...

The Jewish extremists possess a very Islamic like view on life. Starting to become very problematic to the Israeli Government with regards to forcing others to adhere to the Sabbath, separating genders, treatment of Israeli Arabs and Palestinians, accommodating any compromise to achieve peace etc. Quite happy to take to arms if they don't get their way and see moderate liberal minded Jews as much their enemy as any Muslim. Many liberal minded Jews see them as a very dangerous threat to the future of the state of Israel.

andy ted

1,284 posts

266 months

Sunday 11th January 2015
quotequote all
Fartomatic5000 said:
andy ted said:
Fartomatic5000 said:
Will they be ascertaining the religion of a victim before they help out or intervene?

"Drive on Hiram, he's a towel-head"
did you read this article posted earlier?

http://muslimvillage.com/2013/09/13/43902/uk-jewis...
So they're helping Muslims as well. Will they be helping Christians, Sikhs, Buddhists, equally? If not, why not? ...and if they are treating everyone equally, what's the point? Don't we already have a police force that protects and serves everyone equally?
No idea - not sure how you expect them to tell what religion people are tbh? Like I said, it is the least threatening part of Hackney I have spent any time in. Just based on my experience I would take a educated guess that If for example I was getting mugged and one of these cars came past, they would do something to help even if it was just to call the 'proper' police.

Wouldn't you do the same?


anonymous-user

55 months

Sunday 11th January 2015
quotequote all
Where is the failing with the regular Police force?
The Police chief mentioned in the Independent article that I posted was not consulted and was dismayed that this suggested his Police Force was failing in some way.
The quality of and respect for the regular police must not be eroded or undermined, in my opinion.

andy ted

1,284 posts

266 months

Sunday 11th January 2015
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
The article you posted was 5 years old though, since then it seems they have the support of the police. There are loads of private security companies (like the one I posted) who offer much more of a 'serious' security service. These guys look like they are a glorified mobile neighbourhood watch!

eccles

13,740 posts

223 months

Sunday 11th January 2015
quotequote all
andy ted said:
These guys look like they are a glorified mobile neighbourhood watch!
That's just it, they don't look anything like neighbourhood watch.

Fartomatic5000

558 posts

156 months

Sunday 11th January 2015
quotequote all
If they aren't armed, what's the point? What good will they be? If they ARE armed, then great, I'll be applying to start my own private armed security force tomorrow. I will be protecting goatee-wearing directors only, gotta look after your own.

andy ted

1,284 posts

266 months

Sunday 11th January 2015
quotequote all
eccles said:
andy ted said:
These guys look like they are a glorified mobile neighbourhood watch!
That's just it, they don't look anything like neighbourhood watch.
How would you say they compared to neighbourhood watch compared to the private security dog van I posted earlier?


anonymous-user

55 months

Sunday 11th January 2015
quotequote all
andy ted said:
The article you posted was 5 years old though, since then it seems they have the support of the police. There are loads of private security companies (like the one I posted) who offer much more of a 'serious' security service. These guys look like they are a glorified mobile neighbourhood watch!
I know it's old but it shows the point that that particular club was set up, apparently, without consulting those in charge at the police force.
It also mentions requirements for that particular team, must be Jewish, male and married.

Again, I'd much rather the regular police forces, which allows applications from Jews or non Jews, single men, gays, women even(!) was supported.

W124

1,545 posts

139 months

Sunday 11th January 2015
quotequote all
It's madness. A precedent is set that we could really do without. It doesn't matter how helpful, useful and effective these people are. That could not be less relevant. It encourages sectarianism. There is nothing, nothing to stop any community from doing the same. And that will not end well.

turbobloke

104,014 posts

261 months

Sunday 11th January 2015
quotequote all
Guardian Angels use distinctive clothing, are Street Angels / Street Chaplains / Street Pastors etc not doing similar? In terms of the OP, one difference is a liveried car. The other is a specific religious faith and the resulting mostly specific targets for protection or assistance.

JensenA

5,671 posts

231 months

Sunday 11th January 2015
quotequote all
Tannedbaldhead said:
Whilst not every UKIP voter is a nasty shaven headed, Union Jack worshiping, EDL supporting, Mosque burning racist (in fact a sizable majority aren't) you will probably find most nasty shaven headed, Union Jack worshiping, EDL supporting, Mosque burning racist will vote UKIP. That being the case my description is without error and, thus, you can consider your apology for calling me a brainwashed idiot is accepted in advance.

It's a very similar principle to not every Muslim will shout "Allah Akbar" before loosing an AK47 down a crowded street (in fact the vast majority would be abhorred by such actions) but every terrorist who shouts "Allah Akbar" and kills a street is a Muslim.

It's not nice for a whole community to be looked upon in the same light as its very worst members. Is it?

UKIP is primarily an anti EU party, and perhaps a very small minority of racist idiots attach will attach themselves to UKIP, but I actually have no fear of these idiot racist extremists, they are not trying to undermine the way of life in the UK, they don't go around bombing and shooting innocent civilians like Muslim extremists do, and even moderate Muslims seem to resent our Western culture, and if they don't, and they are happy with our way of life, then FFS stand up and make it clear that they are happy with obeying our laws, and living in our decadent society. Until that happens, I and many others will continue to have a distrust of Muslims, probably quite wrongly, but it's there.
When 'The Life of Brian' was released no one went around machine gunning to death any one connected with the film. 'Evan Almighty' even stared God himself, there were no shootings or killings. Can you imagine what would happen if a film was made depicting Allah? It will never happen, and why? Because we are $hit scared of a Muslims, and we shouldn't be. We live in 2015 they live in 1515.

goldblum

10,272 posts

168 months

Sunday 11th January 2015
quotequote all
Utterly stupid and short-sighted. Will breed resentment amongst other ethnic groups and probably inspire more unpleasantness.


mph1977

12,467 posts

169 months

Sunday 11th January 2015
quotequote all
turbobloke said:
Guardian Angels use distinctive clothing, are Street Angels / Street Chaplains / Street Pastors etc not doing similar? In terms of the OP, one difference is a liveried car. The other is a specific religious faith and the resulting mostly specific targets for protection or assistance.
exactly

and various NTE projects have marked vehicles used in delivering service or have used marked emergency services vehicles as an adjunct to delivering service ( usually Ambulance vehicles rather than lookalike police vehicles)

eccles

13,740 posts

223 months

Sunday 11th January 2015
quotequote all
andy ted said:
eccles said:
andy ted said:
These guys look like they are a glorified mobile neighbourhood watch!
That's just it, they don't look anything like neighbourhood watch.
How would you say they compared to neighbourhood watch compared to the private security dog van I posted earlier?
Do those dog vans patrol the streets, or just the industrial sites they are paid to?

andy ted

1,284 posts

266 months

Sunday 11th January 2015
quotequote all
eccles said:
Do those dog vans patrol the streets, or just the industrial sites they are paid to?
http://www.totalguardsecurity.co.uk/vip-street-pat... There are lots of companies like this. Not all with dogs though.

I have seen them before in residential London streets. Along with men stationed in the street all night. paid for by the residents of the street.

citizensm1th

8,371 posts

138 months

Sunday 11th January 2015
quotequote all
Tannedbaldhead said:
http://www.jta.org/1950/07/31/archive/mayor-of-jer...

http://jonathanturley.org/2014/12/31/delta-flight-...

The Jewish extremists possess a very Islamic like view on life. Starting to become very problematic to the Israeli Government with regards to forcing others to adhere to the Sabbath, separating genders, treatment of Israeli Arabs and Palestinians, accommodating any compromise to achieve peace etc. Quite happy to take to arms if they don't get their way and see moderate liberal minded Jews as much their enemy as any Muslim. Many liberal minded Jews see them as a very dangerous threat to the future of the state of Israel.
and que the screams of anti Semitism (sarcasm on) you fking Nazi bd you (sarcasm off)