Anyones spouse got an Irish passport?

Anyones spouse got an Irish passport?

Author
Discussion

Bill

52,889 posts

256 months

Wednesday 21st February
quotequote all
Can you just do a day in another country to reset?

PF62

3,671 posts

174 months

Wednesday 21st February
quotequote all
Jordan247 said:
Can I just double check, If I travel with my Wife who is Irish and has an Irish Passport I can travel with her through the short EU queue rather than having to queue up with the Non-EU passport holders?

Her passport has a different surname to mine (UK) as she hasn't changed it yet but I do have the Marriage certificate.
Correct. The non-EU spouse and non-EU children aged under 21 can accompany the EU citizen through the short EU queue.

My wife and I have done that multiple times ever since I got my Irish passport, and her British passport has her name on it as she didn't want to take my last name when we married - she didn't want to spend the rest of her life spelling it like I do!

As I mentioned before, there has only ever been one mention from a Border official along the lines of 'you need to be married' but that was after they had processed my passport and stamped hers, and I had a scan of our marriage certificate on my phone just in case.

When she renews her passport she intends to use the 'also known as' facility that you can have on British passports, so the headline name is my last name but that it also shows her name that she uses in everyday life.

PF62

3,671 posts

174 months

Wednesday 21st February
quotequote all
Bill said:
Can you just do a day in another country to reset?
Technically, probably, but as you might be arguing the issue of 'residence' so say you had rented a place for six months in Spain would you really want to argue with a Spanish border guard that popping over the border into France or Portugal for a night meant you were not resident in Spain even though your rental continued during your day trip.

However in reality, given there are no checks between the EU countries then the border guard on exit after you have been there for six months is likely not interested as you could have been anywhere since arriving, and more likely any residency checks are going to occur from any documents involved in renting property, or other things with living somewhere long term.

Boxster5

681 posts

109 months

Wednesday 21st February
quotequote all
Our rescue dog has an EU Irish dog passport as we rescued him from County Monaghan. I don’t suppose that counts does it?
I wish we still had EU freedom of movement…..

gotoPzero

17,299 posts

190 months

Wednesday 21st February
quotequote all
My Mrs is Irish and I am British. Different surnames.

We carry our marriage certificate with us just in case!


croyde

23,000 posts

231 months

Wednesday 21st February
quotequote all
Boxster5 said:
Our rescue dog has an EU Irish dog passport as we rescued him from County Monaghan. I don’t suppose that counts does it?
I wish we still had EU freedom of movement…..
hehe

PF62

3,671 posts

174 months

Wednesday 21st February
quotequote all
gotoPzero said:
My Mrs is Irish and I am British. Different surnames.

We carry our marriage certificate with us just in case!
I just have a scan of it on my phone.

However once ETIAS and EES is turned on it won't be an issue as the non-EU spouse will record on their ETIAS that they are married to an EU citizen.

Then when the passports are scanned in and out of the EU, the EES system will know when the EU citizen is in the EU at the same time as the non-EU citizen to ignore those days for the 90/180 for them.

gotoPzero

17,299 posts

190 months

Wednesday 21st February
quotequote all
PF62 said:
gotoPzero said:
My Mrs is Irish and I am British. Different surnames.

We carry our marriage certificate with us just in case!
I just have a scan of it on my phone.

However once ETIAS and EES is turned on it won't be an issue as the non-EU spouse will record on their ETIAS that they are married to an EU citizen.

Then when the passports are scanned in and out of the EU, the EES system will know when the EU citizen is in the EU at the same time as the non-EU citizen to ignore those days for the 90/180 for them.
When does that system come into use?

Jordan247

6,371 posts

209 months

Wednesday 21st February
quotequote all
PF62 said:
Jordan247 said:
Can I just double check, If I travel with my Wife who is Irish and has an Irish Passport I can travel with her through the short EU queue rather than having to queue up with the Non-EU passport holders?

Her passport has a different surname to mine (UK) as she hasn't changed it yet but I do have the Marriage certificate.
Correct. The non-EU spouse and non-EU children aged under 21 can accompany the EU citizen through the short EU queue.

My wife and I have done that multiple times ever since I got my Irish passport, and her British passport has her name on it as she didn't want to take my last name when we married - she didn't want to spend the rest of her life spelling it like I do!

As I mentioned before, there has only ever been one mention from a Border official along the lines of 'you need to be married' but that was after they had processed my passport and stamped hers, and I had a scan of our marriage certificate on my phone just in case.

When she renews her passport she intends to use the 'also known as' facility that you can have on British passports, so the headline name is my last name but that it also shows her name that she uses in everyday life.
Fantastic, thank you for your response.

N111BJG

1,087 posts

64 months

Wednesday 21st February
quotequote all
gotoPzero said:
My Mrs is Irish and I am British. Different surnames.

We carry our marriage certificate with us just in case!
In case of what, perhaps that one of you forget that you are married

It happened to my XW1, a bit of paper seemed to make bugger all difference


JQ

5,756 posts

180 months

Wednesday 21st February
quotequote all
N111BJG said:
gotoPzero said:
My Mrs is Irish and I am British. Different surnames.

We carry our marriage certificate with us just in case!
In case of what, perhaps that one of you forget that you are married

It happened to my XW1, a bit of paper seemed to make bugger all difference
I can't speak for gotoPzero, but we flew from Switzerland to Manchester on Sunday and idiot here checked his wife in with her married name, not the name on her passport. It was picked up and the marriage certificate tied my wife's married name to her passport name and they let us through, but without it we'd have really struggled. It being further complicated by the fact my wife's name before she married is not the name on her passport due to the complexities of Scandi surnames, so the marriage cert actually tied together all three names.

Whilst it was the first time I'd made this error in 25 years together, no allowances were made and I was in the dog house for quite some time.

PF62

3,671 posts

174 months

Wednesday 21st February
quotequote all
gotoPzero said:
PF62 said:
gotoPzero said:
My Mrs is Irish and I am British. Different surnames.

We carry our marriage certificate with us just in case!
I just have a scan of it on my phone.

However once ETIAS and EES is turned on it won't be an issue as the non-EU spouse will record on their ETIAS that they are married to an EU citizen.

Then when the passports are scanned in and out of the EU, the EES system will know when the EU citizen is in the EU at the same time as the non-EU citizen to ignore those days for the 90/180 for them.
When does that system come into use?
Theoretically mid-2025 but it keeps being kicked back.

PF62

3,671 posts

174 months

Wednesday 21st February
quotequote all
N111BJG said:
gotoPzero said:
My Mrs is Irish and I am British. Different surnames.

We carry our marriage certificate with us just in case!
In case of what, perhaps that one of you forget that you are married
When my wife and I travel her British passport is stamped in and out, but obviously my Irish passport isn’t.

With different names it is possible that an awkward Border guard might not believe we are married and therefore that she has overstayed from her stamps.

Now a scan of a marriage certificate may not resolve that, but it certainly can’t do any harm.


Mr Magooagain

10,037 posts

171 months

Wednesday 21st February
quotequote all
PF62 said:
gotoPzero said:
My Mrs is Irish and I am British. Different surnames.

We carry our marriage certificate with us just in case!
I just have a scan of it on my phone.

However once ETIAS and EES is turned on it won't be an issue as the non-EU spouse will record on their ETIAS that they are married to an EU citizen.

Then when the passports are scanned in and out of the EU, the EES system will know when the EU citizen is in the EU at the same time as the non-EU citizen to ignore those days for the 90/180 for them.
I can see some complications for some with the ETIAS and EES.
I’m an Irish passport holder but only recently and I still hold my British Passport but my wife holds only the British one. I wonder that if her passport is scanned it would show me also holding only the British one.

We also live in the EU so unlikely to have problems as any travel is mainly into the uk.

PF62

3,671 posts

174 months

Wednesday 21st February
quotequote all
Mr Magooagain said:
PF62 said:
gotoPzero said:
My Mrs is Irish and I am British. Different surnames.

We carry our marriage certificate with us just in case!
I just have a scan of it on my phone.

However once ETIAS and EES is turned on it won't be an issue as the non-EU spouse will record on their ETIAS that they are married to an EU citizen.

Then when the passports are scanned in and out of the EU, the EES system will know when the EU citizen is in the EU at the same time as the non-EU citizen to ignore those days for the 90/180 for them.
I can see some complications for some with the ETIAS and EES.
I’m an Irish passport holder but only recently and I still hold my British Passport but my wife holds only the British one. I wonder that if her passport is scanned it would show me also holding only the British one.

We also live in the EU so unlikely to have problems as any travel is mainly into the uk.
From my reading about the ETIAS process when your wife completes her application she will declare that she is married to an EU citizen and provide your EU citizen details, then when approved that ETIAS information is held on her British passport.

Therefore every time she scans in and out of the EU with EES it records her, and the system also looks for you.

Now obviously you living in the EU is a bit different, but for most dual nationality British and Irish (or other EU nationality) spouses, they will be normally in the UK and travelling into the EU.

And that is where there could be a problem if they use their British passport, as the EES system will potentially not see them arriving but will see their spouse arriving.

I say potentially because the documents I have read about EES and ETIAS don’t seem to have considered that someone might have an EU and a non-EU passport and be dumb enough to apply for ETIAS and use it with a non-EU passport even though they don’t need to.

Plus what doesn’t help is the mistaken belief that a dual nationality British and other must use the British passport to leave and enter the UK, and the Advance Passenger Information only allowing a single passport number, all of which likely results in people using the ‘wrong’ passport.


Shnozz

27,514 posts

272 months

Wednesday 21st February
quotequote all
PF62 said:
Shnozz said:
Strictly speaking, even EU citizens staying in another country should register within 90 days as I understand it. However, if the intention is to travel from one country to the next then that wouldn’t apply in your example.
Art 7 of Directive 2004/38/EC gives any EU citizen (and their family) a right to reside in any other EU country for up to three months without needing to do anything.

So yes there is no need to register for residency or do anything else if you are moving country to country and not spending more than a continuous three months in any of them, even if the total time spent in EU countries other than your country of EU citizenship is more than three months, e.g. Irish citizen spending three months in Spain then three months in Portugal then three months in Italy then three months in France, etc. etc. is absolutely fine.

https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?ur...
Indeed. So if you’re just aiming at one country it’s not really assisted by an EU spouse.

I don’t think the 3 month thing is really enforced, but if the EU party is travelling with a non-EU and the latter using the former as a workaround the 90 day rule, I can see greater scrutiny of the EU travellers conduct.

Seems quite risky to me.

weeve

179 posts

17 months

Wednesday 21st February
quotequote all
Hi. Back again. My tiny mind remains blown. Not least as when I went through Stockholm at Xmas with the wife and kids (all using their Scandi passports) I got a proper quiz on entry. Opening line was ‘ you must come here often if you’ve family here, many days, are you counting , etc and let me see your return ticket’ all before he’d opened my passport’. Clearly this particular chap wasn’t so informed and was impatient as I searched my phone for the SAS return booking. Bearing in mind I’d not visited the in-laws for 2 years, I am dull, plain, old and meet the ‘anonymous demographic’ any typical guard would usually ignore I was rather surprised. If the electronic system comes in it would help if this rule is accurately applied.

Edited by weeve on Wednesday 21st February 19:57

weeve

179 posts

17 months

Wednesday 21st February
quotequote all
And I should add that last summer we all got a telling off at Hull ferry port on arrival back to UK from biking when I couldn’t provide both passports (uk as well) for my kids. Apparently I was supposed to have carried both … despite them going out on their EU one and their EU mother of the same name was sitting next to me in the bloody car.

Everyday is a learning day eh?

PF62

3,671 posts

174 months

Wednesday 21st February
quotequote all
Shnozz said:
PF62 said:
Shnozz said:
Strictly speaking, even EU citizens staying in another country should register within 90 days as I understand it. However, if the intention is to travel from one country to the next then that wouldn’t apply in your example.
Art 7 of Directive 2004/38/EC gives any EU citizen (and their family) a right to reside in any other EU country for up to three months without needing to do anything.

So yes there is no need to register for residency or do anything else if you are moving country to country and not spending more than a continuous three months in any of them, even if the total time spent in EU countries other than your country of EU citizenship is more than three months, e.g. Irish citizen spending three months in Spain then three months in Portugal then three months in Italy then three months in France, etc. etc. is absolutely fine.

https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?ur...
Indeed. So if you’re just aiming at one country it’s not really assisted by an EU spouse.
Not really. The EU spouse has a right to live there, just needing to do residency, and the process for the non-EU spouse is made easier because if it wasn’t then it would be an infringement of the two EU laws of the EU citizens freedom of movement and their family life.

Shnozz said:
I don’t think the 3 month thing is really enforced, but if the EU party is travelling with a non-EU and the latter using the former as a workaround the 90 day rule, I can see greater scrutiny of the EU travellers conduct.

Seems quite risky to me.
It isn’t a ‘workaround’ but the law.

And at the moment I would agree there is little or no scrutiny, and I think that once EES/ETIAS is turned on the people at risk won’t be those with EU spouses but non-EU citizens who have simply been overstaying.

PF62

3,671 posts

174 months

Wednesday 21st February
quotequote all
weeve said:
And I should add that last summer we all got a telling off at Hull ferry port on arrival back to UK from biking when I couldn’t provide both passports (uk as well) for my kids. Apparently I was supposed to have carried both … despite them going out on their EU one and their EU mother of the same name was sitting next to me in the bloody car.

Everyday is a learning day eh?
Utter utter bks made up by the UK Border Force.

They *suggest* you should enter the UK on a UK passport if you are a dual national, but there is no legal requirement to do so, or carry it with you, or frankly even have one if you are a dual national.

It is a choice to pay for both a UK and Irish (or other non-UK passport) and if you chose to just have an Irish passport then what are they going to do? Give you a British one for free? Say you can’t leave the UK using it? Say you can’t return to the UK on it despite being a British citizen?