2011 XJ Supersport X351

2011 XJ Supersport X351

Author
Discussion

GeniusOfLove

1,380 posts

13 months

Tuesday 19th December 2023
quotequote all
Patrick Bateman said:
How did you haggle to get your supersport for £11.5k?

On the face of it based on advertised prices, that'd involve offers likely to result in a reply that rhymes with cluck off.
Trade auction at BCA, I was the only bidder and that was the reserve. Of course there is an exciting element of risk involved in that, but if there is an issue I could have used some of the £10,000 I'd saved over retail to fix it hehe

Today a SWB 2010 on 80k miles got a single bid at £8,200 and a LWB 2011 on 100k miles got a single bid at £6,800. I'd have bought the SWB if I was after a car, it looked a very nice one.

A private buy should be 10% - 20% or so over trade value, as someone buying from a private seller you need to be mindful that his alternatives are the likes of WBAC or trading in at a dealer for a bag of Skips and a cup of bad coffee, a lot of private sellers seem to think if a Specialist like QCT or Parkway can ask £20k+ they'll sell their car if they are £500 cheaper.

It's quite common to see them advertised privately at very hopeful prices and then turn up at BCA via WBAC, last week a 2011 55k mile XKR convertible that had been advertised at a dealer since March at £25,000 went through the lane at BCA for the 5th time and they took less than £14,000 for it. In the last 3 months I could have picked up half a dozen 40k - 80k mile 5.0 XKs and XKRs for £10k - £15k each.

It's not 2021 anymore...

ETA - another example

This car sold the same week as mine, so the end of April 2023, from memory it got £10k - £11k.

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202303034...

8 months later he still has it advertised, it's droped from £18,879 and has been at £16,999 since October and he still has it. If you went in and offered him £14k and no part ex to deal with I think a deal could be done. I wouldn't though, drab colours and that carbon fibre is a bit Audi A3 for me. The point is that it is very much a buyers market, and while the guys like QCT and Parkway can sit on a car forever without worrying smaller non specialist dealers and private sellers can't or won't.


Edited by GeniusOfLove on Tuesday 19th December 12:59

MOBB

Original Poster:

3,622 posts

128 months

Tuesday 19th December 2023
quotequote all
Great info thanks guys!

There seems to be a real X350 vs X351 "rivalry" - people seem to love one and almost hate the other.

I'm going to try both over the xmas break

MOBB

Original Poster:

3,622 posts

128 months

Tuesday 19th December 2023
quotequote all
GeniusOfLove said:
X351, like a lot of German cars, does get scabby rubberised buttons. You can clean the coating off and end up with a regular old smooth button, I spent 15 minutes now and again doing mine until they were all done. It does look horrific but I'd use it as a haggling point rather than avoid the car.

Edited by GeniusOfLove on Tuesday 19th December 12:26
So just to clarify, you can remove the coating off the buttons and it just becomes a plastic button, still with the graphic showing? Would I just use some kind of solvent to achieve this.

And also, tell me about the 1200w B& W system, that is a real plus for me......................

GeniusOfLove

1,380 posts

13 months

Tuesday 19th December 2023
quotequote all
I don't hate the X350 at all, I have enjoyed the ones I have owned over the years but they feel very old and behind the curve now, but not in the charming way an X300 does, but in the "times have moved on" way an old Toyota does. Great car for £3000, terrible car for £15,000.

GeniusOfLove

1,380 posts

13 months

Tuesday 19th December 2023
quotequote all
MOBB said:
So just to clarify, you can remove the coating off the buttons and it just becomes a plastic button, still with the graphic showing? Would I just use some kind of solvent to achieve this.

And also, tell me about the 1200w B& W system, that is a real plus for me......................
You can scratch it off with a fingernail, or use a plastic scraper. Lots of people use makeup wipes to soften it. Yes you get a nice smooth button with the writing still on it when you're done. Lots of stuff on the internet about it on cars ranging from Audis to 90s Ferraris.

The B&W system really is really very good indeed for an in car system and the quietness of the cabin helps no end. I found the XF B&W system to be a muddy lead footed thing, rather disappointing, and the B&W in my X150 would be considered good as the upgrade choice in a 5 series but is a mile off the X351 system for volume, bass extension, separation and so on, it also has an annoying tendency towards harshness on certain types of music. I enjoy the stereo in the X351 enormously.

I have also used the later Meridian system, both the "Surround" badged one and the "Reference" that was a £3k+ option or standard in late Autobiography cars and was really surprised to find that I didn't like it nearly as much, it was unpleasantly shrill. Maybe some more time spent fiddling with it could have got better results, but I didn't find it in any way superior to the 2010 B&W system on initial acquaintance.

I also think Tata knocked quite a lot of cost out of the X351 (and X250 XF) over their life, an early car "feels" much nicer than a later one, I looked at buying a 2018 Autobiography but was really disappointed in it. The cabin in a facelift XF also feels a bit low rent compared to the launch models too.

You can also see it in the specs, and by the time the X260 XF turned they were making loads of stuff optional that was standard in a high spec X250. We all know how the Tata "like BMW, but not as good" strategy worked out.

Patrick Bateman

12,189 posts

175 months

Tuesday 19th December 2023
quotequote all
Where's the cut-off for that with an X351?

The first 8 speed cars? (2012 IIRC)

GeniusOfLove

1,380 posts

13 months

Tuesday 19th December 2023
quotequote all
Patrick Bateman said:
Where's the cut-off for that with an X351?

The first 8 speed cars? (2012 IIRC)
Yes think it came in for the '13 MY with the ZF8 so cars registered from September-ish 2012 I suppose.

I should add that audio is very much a personal thing, and you could doubtless find people who think the Meridian is a huge improvement over the B&W. You also get used to what you have, so there is a built in confirmation bias.

Stick Legs

4,929 posts

166 months

Tuesday 19th December 2023
quotequote all
MOBB said:
So just to clarify, you can remove the coating off the buttons and it just becomes a plastic button, still with the graphic showing? Would I just use some kind of solvent to achieve this.
Isopropyl Alcohol.

I used Mr.Thinner modelling stuff because I had it in stock.

Range Rovers suffer the same.


As regards the XJR I have driven all generations and an X351 XJR & it was brilliant. Check the rear bushes as they are expensive, but honestly you’ll have no regrets.



dbdb

4,326 posts

174 months

Tuesday 19th December 2023
quotequote all
MOBB said:
Great info thanks guys!

There seems to be a real X350 vs X351 "rivalry" - people seem to love one and almost hate the other.

I'm going to try both over the xmas break
I don't have a chip in the game - I have an XJ40 which though rather crap by any modern metric other than the way it rides is so wonderfully charming that I love the thing!

I like the X350 but feel the X351 is quite a lot better - indeed surprisingly so. Of course there is more to car choice than the car's ability and if you prefer the style of the X350 then that is the one to buy.

Simpo Two

85,504 posts

266 months

Tuesday 19th December 2023
quotequote all
dbdb said:
I don't have a chip in the game - I have an XJ40 which though rather crap by any modern metric other than the way it rides is so wonderfully charming that I love the thing!
I had the 4.0 Sovereign version. A wonderful car, and my first Jaguar. As I'd only been in business for 15 months I was quite pleased with myself smile

__CA__

63 posts

230 months

Tuesday 6th February
quotequote all
Thread resurrection...

Did you try one MOBB?

I used to work at Jag and borrowed a X351 Supersport for the weekend when they were new, I took it all round Wales and was blown away, it did the wafty barge thing very well but could really hustle down a back road. The cliche of the car seeming to shrink around you and being surprisingly agile is true.

My personal 'high point' Jags were always the supercharged saloons, and I think the duality of limo / sports car is key to the appeal.

Anyway I am now looking to get rid of my E46 M3 and find one. Thanks for the buying tips Genius, this one is perfect but what would you offer? 13,500?

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202312214...

reddiesel

1,964 posts

48 months

Wednesday 7th February
quotequote all
Personally I would be nearer £10k and I suspect the Genius would be likewise . Its the getting out of it further down the road that's the issue for me . You end up having paid too much for a Jaguar that for many has the appeal of a turd in a swimming pool .

tobinen

9,231 posts

146 months

Wednesday 7th February
quotequote all
MoT runs out this month. The mileage is nice. The price is punchy for a private sale. I see it nearer £10,000.

I watched a tidy one with a few more miles fetch £8,800 at BCA.

GeniusOfLove

1,380 posts

13 months

Wednesday 7th February
quotequote all
It's not had a service for a while and as Tobinen says why doesn't it have a new MOT on it?

He'll think it's worth more as a 2012 because most of them are 2010 registered, but when you're talking about 12 years old vs 14 years old it's really not terribly important.

Given the two that went for circa 8-9k at BCA before Christmas I want to say that should be a £10k private buy but I can't see the seller taking 2/3rds his asking after his ad has only been up six weeks. If you're deadly serious about the car I'd go and take a look and maybe consider going up to £12k if you really like it, it has some nice recent work on expensive consumables, and he will stick a 12 month ticket on it for the price.

When he says no you can just keep an eye on it and call him in another 6 weeks when it hasn't sold. I do take reddiesels point about overpaying, but what I would say is that while paying 12k over a target 10k is a lot in percentage terms in absolute 510bhp car buying and running terms £2k is nothing and will disappear into the running costs soon enough. I wouldn't miss out on a good example of a rare car I really liked for the sake of £2k, although the colours (or lack of them) on this one for me personally would mean I'd want it cheap or not at all.


Mine has just had new ARB bushes, front brakes, and an ATF flush and adaptation reset and I've been using it more. It really is an utterly fabulous car.

Edited by GeniusOfLove on Wednesday 7th February 08:47

__CA__

63 posts

230 months

Wednesday 7th February
quotequote all
Hehe I imagine I would get told to FO offering £10k but I definitely see where you're coming from with regards to resale... turd in a swimming pool LOL.

The photos look very "late summer" although the date on the ad (from the URL) is 2023 12 21. Maybe it came off the market and went back on again.

My ideal spec is:
LWB
Black
Black headlining
Bordeaux leather (very deep almost purpley-red... saw this in a XJL in a showroom in China years ago and I was "OMG that's gorgeous" ... one day)

I think there might be one UK car out there in that spec, but if howmanyleft is correct there are only 31 LWB Supersports in the country so the car I linked to is close enough.

The other shortlisted cars would be a W221 S63, but it's a bit too bargey, and shouty, and every d1ck in a S-Line / M-Sport whatever will want to race. Bentley Flying Spur, too much VW content, don't like the image. Audi A8 too much like an inflated A6, ditto 7 Series. The only exception might be a super-spec Exclusive / Individual example. Quattroporte, hmm... probably fragile. I've driven S63, Spur and Quattoporte and the Jag blends the best attributes of all of them. I love the fact a Supersport is subtle - it looks like any other X351 but doesn't shout. I've driven the later XJR and whilst it might be a smidge faster it looks like its drowning in bodykit and the quad pipes look naff compared to the tailored-to-fit Supersport finishers.

MOBB

Original Poster:

3,622 posts

128 months

Wednesday 7th February
quotequote all
[quote=CA]Thread resurrection...

Did you try one MOBB?

I used to work at Jag and borrowed a X351 Supersport for the weekend when they were new, I took it all round Wales and was blown away, it did the wafty barge thing very well but could really hustle down a back road. The cliche of the car seeming to shrink around you and being surprisingly agile is true.

My personal 'high point' Jags were always the supercharged saloons, and I think the duality of limo / sports car is key to the appeal.

Anyway I am now looking to get rid of my E46 M3 and find one. Thanks for the buying tips Genius, this one is perfect but what would you offer? 13,500?

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202312214...
[/quote]

Well, me being me it went a bit weird.

I shortlisted the following types of cars, not exactly a normal list but these are what I was interested in;

- X358 XJR
- X351 Supersport
- GR Yaris
- Boxster

Over Xmas I looked at;

- X358 XJR- I was underwhelmed and the prices being asked are crazy IMO. I looked at what seemed the nicest on sale and it just came across as old and needing work. It didnt wow me at all
- GR Yaris - epic little car, was close to buying, but;
- Boxster - I've had one before (987) and tried a 981 near me. Exactly what I was after

I didnt look at an X351 in the end - I am still convinced they are utter bargains but it seems hard to find ones that have been cherished (unlike Boxsters) and every one of the X351's for sale at Xmas seem to be still for sale, which makes me nervous come resale.

When I told each dealer what I was cross-shopping for, they thought I was odd lol






flibbage0

202 posts

142 months

Friday 9th February
quotequote all
Thought I would chime in, that Jag XJ has been on the market for a long time, well over 6 months. I know this because I have been looking at the XFR/XJ/XKR market for the last 2 years. Some of these cars have been sitting on there for a year now and if I'm being blunt they are somewhat deluded.

I've recently seen an XJR (this week) and XKR and even an XFR-S (last week) sell within 18-24 hours of being posted on Autotrader, the reason why is because they were up at a good price.

Private sellers need to understand they cannot be charging prices like it's 2022, unfortunately the market has dipped.




GeniusOfLove

1,380 posts

13 months

Friday 9th February
quotequote all
flibbage0 said:
Thought I would chime in, that Jag XJ has been on the market for a long time, well over 6 months. I know this because I have been looking at the XFR/XJ/XKR market for the last 2 years. Some of these cars have been sitting on there for a year now and if I'm being blunt they are somewhat deluded.

I've recently seen an XJR (this week) and XKR and even an XFR-S (last week) sell within 18-24 hours of being posted on Autotrader, the reason why is because they were up at a good price.

Private sellers need to understand they cannot be charging prices like it's 2022, unfortunately the market has dipped.
100%.

X100 and X150 sellers particularly appear almost to the last man to be heavy users of the crack pipe when they set their asking prices. I wonder if that XFR-S is the same one I saw go through Bridgwater BCA 3-4 weeks ago, it was low on coolant and needed a pump IIRC. Whoever bought it flipped it fast and made £3k I'd wager, vs the dreamers sitting on their imaginary £25,000+

Euro6 300bhp XJ 3.0d prices have cratered in the last 3 months too.

flibbage0

202 posts

142 months

Friday 9th February
quotequote all
GeniusOfLove said:
100%.

X100 and X150 sellers particularly appear almost to the last man to be heavy users of the crack pipe when they set their asking prices. I wonder if that XFR-S is the same one I saw go through Bridgwater BCA 3-4 weeks ago, it was low on coolant and needed a pump IIRC. Whoever bought it flipped it fast and made £3k I'd wager, vs the dreamers sitting on their imaginary £25,000+

Euro6 300bhp XJ 3.0d prices have cratered in the last 3 months too.
Was it the blue XFR-S by any chance?

Also how refined are the 3.0 V6 diesels in the XJ?

GeniusOfLove

1,380 posts

13 months

Friday 9th February
quotequote all
flibbage0 said:
GeniusOfLove said:
100%.

X100 and X150 sellers particularly appear almost to the last man to be heavy users of the crack pipe when they set their asking prices. I wonder if that XFR-S is the same one I saw go through Bridgwater BCA 3-4 weeks ago, it was low on coolant and needed a pump IIRC. Whoever bought it flipped it fast and made £3k I'd wager, vs the dreamers sitting on their imaginary £25,000+

Euro6 300bhp XJ 3.0d prices have cratered in the last 3 months too.
Was it the blue XFR-S by any chance?

Also how refined are the 3.0 V6 diesels in the XJ?
No the XFR-S was OY64 VCJ in dark grey on 88k miles and two owners. Good history if I recall, hammer price was £15,900 against £15,700 CAP. It needed some TLC from a smart repairer and the coolant leak isolated and fixed but I'm sure you could have done it all for a grand and it would have been lovely.

I found the 3.0 more refined in the XJ than the XF where it was downright intrusive, the 3.0 was never as refined as the 2.7 but that was really underpowered. It's as good as any other barge diesel so it's FINE but it's always present grumbling away.