Test Drive Unlimited (PC)... DO NOT BUY!

Test Drive Unlimited (PC)... DO NOT BUY!

Author
Discussion

ThePassenger

Original Poster:

6,962 posts

236 months

Friday 11th May 2007
quotequote all
marfgtxx said:
Nah buggrit, if I wanna higher frame rate I'll play on my little bro's PC, that manages 35fps with the ATI card it has installed.


What else are little bro's for other than stealing their stuff? hehe

xiphias

5,888 posts

228 months

Saturday 12th May 2007
quotequote all
ThePassenger said:
marfgtxx said:
Nah buggrit, if I wanna higher frame rate I'll play on my little bro's PC, that manages 35fps with the ATI card it has installed.


What else are little bro's for other than stealing their stuff? hehe


Fighting with

R1 GTR

2,152 posts

214 months

Saturday 12th May 2007
quotequote all
So do i buy the PS2 version (heard its not a good) or risk it and buy the pc version?

Edit: im going off to buy it right now so which one?

Edited by R1 GTR on Saturday 12th May 12:57

ThePassenger

Original Poster:

6,962 posts

236 months

Saturday 12th May 2007
quotequote all
R1 GTR said:
So do i buy the PS2 version (heard its not a good) or risk it and buy the pc version?

Edit: im going off to buy it right now so which one?

Edited by R1 GTR on Saturday 12th May 12:57


To be blunt. The PS2 version. It bypasses the whole god damn palava. I wouldn't get the PC one unless the patch is out (ETA 4th week May).

Civpilot

6,235 posts

241 months

Saturday 12th May 2007
quotequote all
This simply must be a driver/PC compatibility issue.

Not only have I been able to run the game fine since launch but last week I bought a force feedback wheel set (Thrustmaster Ferrari GT, don't play enough games to justify the G25) and not only is the wheel fully supported, but the force feedback side of things works an absolute treat. Holding power slides and drits is second nature with no frame rate drop, while the wheel tugs and pulls nicely.

So from the initial post:-

"- Zero support for wheel input" - Wrong
"- Game crashes or drops to 1fps when using a force feedback wheel." - Wrong again

In fact in the official forums there was a poll on what gave the better control, Steering wheel or game pad. The wheel won with 79+% of the vote. So saying the game has zero wheel support was also incorrect, hence I think the problems being had are even more so individual PC/driver related.

As for the first statement that there is zero support for wheel input. Well this is the Atari/eden statement:-

Atari said:

These devices are not officially supported by Test Drive Unlimited. However, DirectInput-compatible devices can have their functions mapped to functions inside of the game by going into the Options panel. The following DirectInput-compatible devices have been tested:

Thrustmaster RGT PRO Clutch Edition (3 pedals)
Thrustmaster Rally GT PRO Force Feedback
Thrustmaster F1 Force Feedback
Thrustmaster NASCAR Pro Force Feedback 2
Thrustmaster Ferrari GT 2-in-1 Rumble Force
Thrustmaster Ferrari GT 2-in-1 Force Feedback
Thrustmaster ENZO Force Feedback
Thrustmaster ENZO 2-in-1 Racing Wheel (Note: No Force Feedback on this wheel)
Thrustmaster ENZO Wireless Racing Wheel (Note: No Force Feedback on this wheel)

Thrustmaster Dual Trigger Wireless PC
Thrustmaster Dual Trigger 2-in-1 Wireless Rechargeable
Thrustmaster Dual Trigger 2-in-1 Rumble Force
Thrustmaster Dual Trigger 2-in-1
Thrustmaster Firestorm Dual Analog Version 1, 2, 3, 3.2 and 4 (Note: No Force Feedback on these gamepads)
Thrustmaster Firestorm Dual Power Version 1, 2, 3, 3.2 and 4
Thrustmaster 360 Modena Force UPAD
Thrustmaster T-Mini 2-in-1
Thrustmaster T-Mini 2-in-1 Rumble Force
Thrustmaster T-Mini Wireless 2-in-1
Thrustmaster T-Mini Wireless 2-in-1 Rumble Force
Thrustmaster Run’N’ Drive 3-in-1
Thrustmaster Run’N’ Drive 3-in-1 Rumble Force



So maybe not officially supported, but loads of wheels tested and work.

I initially bought the Ps2 version on release day but took it back the following day to upgrade to the PC version. PS2 version is nothing but a pale shadow arcade racer missing loads of cars and having crap graphics in comparison.


Edited by Civpilot on Saturday 12th May 14:59

ThePassenger

Original Poster:

6,962 posts

236 months

Saturday 12th May 2007
quotequote all
Civpilot said:
This simply must be a driver/PC compatibility issue.

Possibly. But which driver? Their are issues on the official Atari forums where it can't possibly be a single driver version for a specific peice of hardware. You see issues with Intels and AMD's, Nvidia and ATi... it's wildly differing hardware and drivers. But. If, CnC3 runs sweet as a nut, along with SupCom, NWN2... as well as NWN2 can run it's another Atari game :S... which one is the odd man out?
If I was trying to do something daft like run it in WINE (which doesn't work due to the games very strange usage of a D3D function) then yeah fair enough... but i'm not. This is XP-SP2 at the current patch level.



Civpilot said:
So from the initial post:-

"- Zero support for wheel input" - Wrong

Actually, I'll give you that one but I will amend it.
VERY LITTLE OFFICIAL support for wheel input.

Civpilot said:
"- Game crashes or drops to 1fps when using a force feedback wheel." - Wrong again

Actually the force feed back system causing massive drops in frame rates is a known bug in the game. Especially as the bug is not related to just the old Microsoft wheel, several people with Saitek units have reported the same issue.

Civpilot said:
In fact in the official forums there was a poll on what gave the better control, Steering wheel or game pad. The wheel won with 79+% of the vote. So saying the game has zero wheel support was also incorrect, hence I think the problems being had are even more so individual PC/driver related.
As for the first statement that there is zero support for wheel input. Well this is the Atari/eden statement:-
So maybe not officially supported, but loads of wheels tested and work.

Having spent a lot of time lurking on the 'Official Atari Forums' I would take any poll results with a healthy dose of scepticism. I've seen at least one moderator acting in a very unprofessional manner towards people (in essence calls them a n00b and bans them for kicks), it is not such a major leap of faith to think that the polls are often rigged. The only official Atari/Eden statement I've seen on those forums is that a patch is being worked on, the only control method stickyed is how to use a 360 pad. Those in itself are quite suggestive. Actually saying there is "zero support" is correct, with the number of DirectInput wheels on the market those officially supported (not just happen to work) is in effect such a low percentage as to be zero.


Civpilot said:
I initially bought the Ps2 version on release day but took it back the following day to upgrade to the PC version. PS2 version is nothing but a pale shadow arcade racer missing loads of cars and having crap graphics in comparison.

But it a) works flawlessly b) misses out on the twisted minefield that is getting the product home only to find it not working.

Right. To settle this matter give me 5 min to reboot.

Sorry about the delay needed to be in Windows. This is what happens when you double click the icon to run the game. This is repeatable, this is the only action the game takes after the videos have played:



And just to prove this isn't Test Drive: Unlimited 'Tortuga Edition':



So, buy the PS2 version or the PC version? Well there's your 'worst case' with the PC version running the latest stable drivers for everything.


Edited by ThePassenger on Saturday 12th May 16:55



Edited by ThePassenger on Saturday 12th May 17:15

marfgtxx

22,907 posts

242 months

Saturday 12th May 2007
quotequote all
xiphias said:
ThePassenger said:
marfgtxx said:
Nah buggrit, if I wanna higher frame rate I'll play on my little bro's PC, that manages 35fps with the ATI card it has installed.


What else are little bro's for other than stealing their stuff? hehe


Fighting with


hehe

I must say tho that the Atari TDU forums are plagued by a huge number of incredibly whiney, rude and small minded yankee teenagers.

I went on there last night for the first time in a long while and was quickly reminded why I stopped going on there. A young girl had posted a question about the game in relation to her Dell PC and was then abused and shouted down till she left, deleting all her posts in the process.

Edited by marfgtxx on Saturday 12th May 16:50

ThePassenger

Original Poster:

6,962 posts

236 months

Saturday 12th May 2007
quotequote all
marfgtxx said:

hehe

I must say tho that the Atari TDU forums are plagued by a huge number of incredibly whiney, rude and small minded yankee teenagers.

I went on there last night for the first time in a long while and was quickly reminded why I stopped going on there. A young girl had posted a question about the game in relation to her Dell PC and was then abused and shouted down till she left, deleting all her posts in the process.


If one of the people joining in had the name "tenebra" then that's a moderator...
But yes, I'm rather glad I only visit infrequently and stay long enough to confirm suspicions.

Mr Whippy

29,113 posts

242 months

Saturday 12th May 2007
quotequote all
ThePassenger said:
Well there's your 'worst case' with the PC version running the latest stable drivers for everything.


Think thats your problem. I always stay about 6-12 months back on drivers and hardware because it's always crap when it's new/un-tested etc.

All the issues seem to be on super new systems with people who worry more about 3D Mark scores and will install beta drivers for 0.5fps more on some test or another...

Sweeping generalisations aside though

Honestly, try some older drivers. New doesn't always equal better after 10 years of building my own PC's. I actually find my PC better when I don't try too hard to maximise it's performance.

Dave

ThePassenger

Original Poster:

6,962 posts

236 months

Saturday 12th May 2007
quotequote all
Mr Whippy said:
ThePassenger said:
Well there's your 'worst case' with the PC version running the latest stable drivers for everything.


Think thats your problem. I always stay about 6-12 months back on drivers and hardware because it's always crap when it's new/un-tested etc.

All the issues seem to be on super new systems with people who worry more about 3D Mark scores and will install beta drivers for 0.5fps more on some test or another...


Ahh sorry, I should clarify. These aren't bleeding edge just released. They're what Intel, Nvidia, Rioch (card reader) and Co. say are their most current stable release... so not like the 1xx.xx series of Nvidia drivers

The only older drivers I've got are the ones that come with the XPS... and to be honest their Nvidia drivers are an old unstable release... it texture flashes all over the shop :-/



Edited by ThePassenger on Saturday 12th May 17:48

Civpilot

6,235 posts

241 months

Saturday 12th May 2007
quotequote all
ThePassenger said:


.....
Right. To settle this matter give me 5 min to reboot.

Sorry about the delay needed to be in Windows
....


erm... are you running a dual boot system, the highlighted statement above appears to imply that you are?

If so then maybe that might be a major something to do with it. I'm running XP sp2 and no other operating system and experience none of the problems you speak of. I know the game has online issues with corrupting save games etc, but off line mine runs very well indeed with no frame rate drops for force feedback etc.

If your PC is within the operating requirements (which I have no doubt it is) then there is no reason why you cant run the game. However, if you running dual boot maybe (just maybe) there is something there. Can you think of any other reason why I can run the game with no problem but you cannot even get it to start? I can't. Adn the only real difference between our machince is that you appear to be running dual boot.

ThePassenger

Original Poster:

6,962 posts

236 months

Saturday 12th May 2007
quotequote all
Civpilot said:
ThePassenger said:


.....
Right. To settle this matter give me 5 min to reboot.

Sorry about the delay needed to be in Windows
....


erm... are you running a dual boot system, the highlighted statement above appears to imply that you are?

If so then maybe that might be a major something to do with it. I'm running XP sp2 and no other operating system and experience none of the problems you speak of. I know the game has online issues with corrupting save games etc, but off line mine runs very well indeed with no frame rate drops for force feedback etc.

If your PC is within the operating requirements (which I have no doubt it is) then there is no reason why you cant run the game. However, if you running dual boot maybe (just maybe) there is something there. Can you think of any other reason why I can run the game with no problem but you cannot even get it to start? I can't. Adn the only real difference between our machince is that you appear to be running dual boot.


Problem is when booted in to Windows, none of the Linux code is running in the background nor is it in memory. I've tried, just on the remote off chance this was the problem powering down the laptop, removing the mains AND battery then going in to windows, that way total clean slate. True GRUB runs but exits cleanly after selecting the OS run run. Now, having several games that are using the same version of SecuROM the multiple partitions on the disk aren't causing an issue, nor is the Windows EXT2 driver (I've tried with and without it).

The fascinating thing is that for me, the game doesn't even run in WINE (despite being set to any version of Windows from 98 - Vista), it bombs instantly after the videos have played... that's freaky as we're talking two utterly different sets of drivers and an emulation layer that's trying to smooth out the bugs. Needless to say this is two separate installations but both failing at the exact same point, in different OS's.

So, it's not drivers as everything else works. It's not XP-SP2 as WINE gets the same treatment. The disc is fine and checks out, besides which you'd expect the installer to be CRCing as it goes. The drive optics check out both for reading/writing CD's and DVD's. It's not 3rd party software (AVG-Free, DeamonTools, et al) as I've tried it each way. It's not heat as I've tried it from a cold (sat on top of the AC cold) boot. And the hdd is fine too.

Before I tell someone not to buy something, I am nothing if not bloody thorough in checking everything out first.


ETA: 'Tortuga Edition' has been tried and does the same.


Edited by ThePassenger on Saturday 12th May 20:35

sadako

7,080 posts

239 months

Saturday 12th May 2007
quotequote all
Civpilot said:
ThePassenger said:


.....
Right. To settle this matter give me 5 min to reboot.

Sorry about the delay needed to be in Windows
....


erm... are you running a dual boot system, the highlighted statement above appears to imply that you are?

If so then maybe that might be a major something to do with it. I'm running XP sp2 and no other operating system and experience none of the problems you speak of. I know the game has online issues with corrupting save games etc, but off line mine runs very well indeed with no frame rate drops for force feedback etc.

If your PC is within the operating requirements (which I have no doubt it is) then there is no reason why you cant run the game. However, if you running dual boot maybe (just maybe) there is something there. Can you think of any other reason why I can run the game with no problem but you cannot even get it to start? I can't. Adn the only real difference between our machince is that you appear to be running dual boot.


Hah. Bwahahaha! Only a complete muppet would even consider that dual booting would affect how any program runs in windows. Sorry mate it just doesn't work that way.

Civpilot

6,235 posts

241 months

Saturday 12th May 2007
quotequote all
sadako said:
Civpilot said:
ThePassenger said:


.....
Right. To settle this matter give me 5 min to reboot.

Sorry about the delay needed to be in Windows
....


erm... are you running a dual boot system, the highlighted statement above appears to imply that you are?

If so then maybe that might be a major something to do with it. I'm running XP sp2 and no other operating system and experience none of the problems you speak of. I know the game has online issues with corrupting save games etc, but off line mine runs very well indeed with no frame rate drops for force feedback etc.

If your PC is within the operating requirements (which I have no doubt it is) then there is no reason why you cant run the game. However, if you running dual boot maybe (just maybe) there is something there. Can you think of any other reason why I can run the game with no problem but you cannot even get it to start? I can't. Adn the only real difference between our machince is that you appear to be running dual boot.


Hah. Bwahahaha! Only a complete muppet would even consider that dual booting would affect how any program runs in windows. Sorry mate it just doesn't work that way.


Oh do off and learn some manners. At what point was I being insulting to you or passenger? I wasn't, I was trying to offer geniune insights into why I can run a game and he cannot. So dont insult me with some sort of attempt at being superior. WOW.. you know more about dual boot systems than me, woopdee doo, bet that gets the laidees big time.

If all your going to do is reply with insults when I was put pointing out a very real diference between Passenger's and my setups you might as well go away to another thread. I can play the game no problem but passenger can't even get it started. Yet we both have systems well within the ability of the programs requirements.
The only big obvious difference betwen our rigs is that Passenger runs dual boot, I dont. And not running dual boot I have no idea what affects what, it did not require a 7yr old outburst from you.

Tell me, do use the term p3wnd in real life and call people noobs? Just curious laugh

ThePassenger

Original Poster:

6,962 posts

236 months

Saturday 12th May 2007
quotequote all
I'm afraid I have to agree. A little erm... rambunctious there Sadako.

But, anyway, ignoring that. I'm out of ideas. I'm always in the mood to tinker but I'm not about to scratch build the system when it's working fine. To be honest, if Atari/Eden have deployed code that's fiddling/checking with the bootsector of the primary drive (which is the only difference between your system and mine when in Windows) that is a big klaxon going off right there. The only thing that should be in that area is the OS loader(s) not a chunk of game code.

Besides which I'm not convinced just installing XP-SP2 would do it. If installing 'Tortuga Edition' (which fails to run the same way, but has all it's copy protection removed), then scrubbing every last trace of it off (inc. registry) and putting on legit edition results in the same fault... it's got the be the game.

BTW Civ.... it's she not he hehe

Civpilot

6,235 posts

241 months

Sunday 13th May 2007
quotequote all
ThePassenger said:
I'm afraid I have to agree. A little erm... rambunctious there Sadako.

But, anyway, ignoring that. I'm out of ideas. I'm always in the mood to tinker but I'm not about to scratch build the system when it's working fine. To be honest, if Atari/Eden have deployed code that's fiddling/checking with the bootsector of the primary drive (which is the only difference between your system and mine when in Windows) that is a big klaxon going off right there. The only thing that should be in that area is the OS loader(s) not a chunk of game code.

Besides which I'm not convinced just installing XP-SP2 would do it. If installing 'Tortuga Edition' (which fails to run the same way, but has all it's copy protection removed), then scrubbing every last trace of it off (inc. registry) and putting on legit edition results in the same fault... it's got the be the game.

BTW Civ.... it's she not he hehe


oops

It is very strange and to be honest the fact that I (and to be fair, many other people) can run the game without issue I wouln't put it past eden to code something so stupid as the game is pretty much a direct port of the 360version. Ignoring the dual boot situation, say the difference in our system is only that I run service pack 2, maybe its worth a shot? Stranger things have happened?

ThePassenger

Original Poster:

6,962 posts

236 months

Sunday 13th May 2007
quotequote all
Civpilot said:
oops

It is very strange and to be honest the fact that I (and to be fair, many other people) can run the game without issue I wouln't put it past eden to code something so stupid as the game is pretty much a direct port of the 360version. Ignoring the dual boot situation, say the difference in our system is only that I run service pack 2, maybe its worth a shot? Stranger things have happened?


Service pack 2 of what? I'm already running XP-SP2 at the current MS patch level. I admit it is XP-SP2 Pro however (and again, legit OEM version that I specc'd for the laptop, not 'Tortuga Edition'). You see what I mean? As far as oddities go my laptop's as generic as they come, it doesn't even have a wheel attached (i've tired with/without USB mouse)... by rights it should work and work flawlessly. And if they've managed to write a game that doesn't work in XP Pro... there would be even more people screaming blue murder on the forums (when Tenebra and co aren't culling the voices of dissent) than there already is.

It not working on two different OS's (remember, I did attempt in Linux+WINE) and failing at the exact same point when you using two different versions of the game (fresh installing + reg wipe each attempt) points to hardware, which... as we've gone over passes every diagnostic I've got AND doesn't act up in any other working game (CnC3 is a royal resource hog if something was wrong that'd show it up).

Which leaves the only source of the problems being? Test Drive: Unlimited. Which is nearly pointed to by the error message in Windows; the fault is in the testdriveunlimited.exe.

To be quite honest I actually doubt the large numbers of people having zero issue thing. We've both been on the official EU forums and we've both seen how fast the mods ban pretty much anyone who gripes about an issue. I believe that most of the people who have issues are currently banned from the forums for being "novice PC game users" (quote from moderator tenebra).

LukeBird

17,170 posts

210 months

Sunday 13th May 2007
quotequote all
ThePassenger said:

Service pack 2 of what? I'm already running XP-SP2 at the current MS patch level. I admit it is XP-SP2 Pro however (and again, legit OEM version that I specc'd for the laptop, not 'Tortuga Edition'). You see what I mean? As far as oddities go my laptop's as generic as they come, it doesn't even have a wheel attached (i've tired with/without USB mouse)... by rights it should work and work flawlessly. And if they've managed to write a game that doesn't work in XP Pro... there would be even more people screaming blue murder on the forums (when Tenebra and co aren't culling the voices of dissent) than there already is.


To clear up the XP Pro thing, I'm playing (well, I will be when I re-install TDU) it on XP Pro SP2 with the full updates as well. It does seem very odd that it randomly runs on some systems and not on others... confused
Very bizarre....

ThePassenger

Original Poster:

6,962 posts

236 months

Monday 14th May 2007
quotequote all
LukeBird said:

To clear up the XP Pro thing, I'm playing (well, I will be when I re-install TDU) it on XP Pro SP2 with the full updates as well. It does seem very odd that it randomly runs on some systems and not on others... confused
Very bizarre....

Didn't think it'd be XP Pro (I tried it in WINE set to everything from 98 up ) but ta muchly for closing that hole.

This is the point I was trying to make in my first post. Ok, anyway, skipping that... take the bit about wheels needing to be "DirectInput Compatible"... that's pretty much any PC game interface built since the days of Windows 98. So why are Saitek users having issues, with brand new kit? Same with the MS Wheel, which whilst being old should bloody well be DirectInput compliant after all MS wrote it hehe And yes, I've spotted one each of people using 360 pads, PS2 pads and Logitech G25 wheels having issues on the forums.... which is freaky again as its working for others.

Whilst everything about TDU smells rushed, my personal opinion is that on the PC version Eden screwed up their compiler settings, it's either too loose (or more likley too tightly bound to the dev boxes) so anyone who's close 'enough' gets away with it, anyone who's too far either way... splat. It also explains why the game was pushed out with no release day patch to cover this problem, Atari/Eden hadn't got a clue this was coming.

Side: Atari's share price being what it is, the actions of the moderators seems explainable beyond simple 'net-nazi' antics... this game has to be perfect and anyone who says it is not has to be silenced. The utterly unforgivable thing is that people are buying the game AND a wheel, heading to the forums because the games gone bang big time and being insulted before being banned.

ThePassenger

Original Poster:

6,962 posts

236 months

Wednesday 30th May 2007
quotequote all
I figured I'd just dump this here (thus bumping my own thread hehe).

That TDU patch that was due to hit May? 100% for sure, May?

It's now scheduled for mid-June at the earliest.