Official 2024 Chinese Grand Prix Thread ***SPOILERS***

Official 2024 Chinese Grand Prix Thread ***SPOILERS***

Poll: Official 2024 Chinese Grand Prix Thread ***SPOILERS***

Total Members Polled: 93

Perez: 32%
Leclerc: 9%
Sainz: 34%
Russell: 1%
Hamilton: 8%
Norris: 14%
Piastri: 1%
Alonso: 1%
Author
Discussion

Aids0G

510 posts

150 months

Wednesday 17th April
quotequote all
Hustle_ said:
RichB said:
Aids0G said:
<clip> apparently there is genuine concern that the cars will be unable to provide peak power for a full lap of the majority of circuits...
Quite pathetic isn't it.
What kind of drivetrain can provide peak power for a full lap?
Williams FW15C? would be pretty much as close as possible, banned in 1993 and never raced.

Big Nanas

1,410 posts

85 months

Wednesday 17th April
quotequote all
Aids0G said:
Hustle_ said:
RichB said:
Aids0G said:
<clip> apparently there is genuine concern that the cars will be unable to provide peak power for a full lap of the majority of circuits...
Quite pathetic isn't it.
What kind of drivetrain can provide peak power for a full lap?
Williams FW15C? would be pretty much as close as possible, banned in 1993 and never raced.
The superb 'Engineering Explained' on YouTube has a brilliant video explaining the difference between the current and '26 PUs.
It's quite techy and a fair bit of whiteboard maths, but it's really worth the watch:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KxDQBVzXWt4

For the sake of the discussion, the pertinent part starts at about 8mins.

Edited by Big Nanas on Wednesday 17th April 17:12

Hustle_

24,772 posts

161 months

Wednesday 17th April
quotequote all
Aids0G said:
Hustle_ said:
RichB said:
Aids0G said:
<clip> apparently there is genuine concern that the cars will be unable to provide peak power for a full lap of the majority of circuits...
Quite pathetic isn't it.
What kind of drivetrain can provide peak power for a full lap?
Williams FW15C? would be pretty much as close as possible, banned in 1993 and never raced.
I was thinking CVT, I didn't know there had been one!

White-Noise

4,353 posts

249 months

Wednesday 17th April
quotequote all
Hah I was thinking of the cvt as well. Not what I originally had in mind for full power the whole lap but it fits the bill

Aids0G

510 posts

150 months

Wednesday 17th April
quotequote all
Big Nanas said:
Aids0G said:
Hustle_ said:
RichB said:
Aids0G said:
<clip> apparently there is genuine concern that the cars will be unable to provide peak power for a full lap of the majority of circuits...
Quite pathetic isn't it.
What kind of drivetrain can provide peak power for a full lap?
Williams FW15C? would be pretty much as close as possible, banned in 1993 and never raced.
The superb 'Engineering Explained' on YouTube has a brilliant video explaining the difference between the current and '26 PUs.
It's quite techy and a fair bit of whiteboard maths, but it's really worth the watch:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KxDQBVzXWt4

For the sake of the discussion, the pertinent part starts at about 8mins.

Edited by Big Nanas on Wednesday 17th April 17:12
Thank you will take a look at that later.

It is a shame the move to sustainable fuels cant allow a move to more exciting powertrain formats, even the current hybrid system but with a turbo V8 would be a step forward no reason for the power levels to not get up to 1200-1300hp to help combat the weight of todays cars.

TheInternet

4,733 posts

164 months

Wednesday 17th April
quotequote all
Big Nanas said:
The superb 'Engineering Explained' on YouTube has a brilliant video explaining the difference between the current and '26 PUs.
Thanks for the link.

Derek Smith

45,806 posts

249 months

Wednesday 17th April
quotequote all
suffolk009 said:
Disqualified on a mere technicality.
Like Senna in Japan?

cuprabob

14,744 posts

215 months

Wednesday 17th April
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
Like Senna in Japan?
I think that fewest number of words I've ever seen you write Derek smile

Derek Smith

45,806 posts

249 months

Wednesday 17th April
quotequote all
cuprabob said:
Derek Smith said:
Like Senna in Japan?
I think that fewest number of words I've ever seen you write Derek smile
An error.

Roofless Toothless

5,729 posts

133 months

Wednesday 17th April
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
I was at Clearways. I didn't see all that much smoke, although the smell came through. I was shocked when I saw the images of damage and the fire. You probably remember those times, when there were few marshals and a fire normally meant severe injuries or death. That's without the faulty safety gear. I was at South Bank, up against the fence, when Chris Kraft had a big accident, in a Cortina I think, and a fire started. The marshals were quickly on scene, although it always seems longer to viewers, and even longer for the drivers, I bet. However, they sprayed the fire with a couple of different concoctions and the smell was so pungent that my friend and I had to move away. There was chunks of stuff in the air. No problem with just moving the crowd, but the marshals were all coughing as well. They had no breathing apparatus that I could see, and every time they got near, they had coughing fits. A couple managed to get up to the car. God knows what their lungs were like.

And Motor Sport magazine criticised Jackie Stewart for pushing for safety, and very low levels of improvement. I didn't renew my subscription. That showed 'em.
Chris Craft’s son Jake was a school friend of my younger son. The family lived on a small holding near Chigwell, and some wild times were had up there by the boys, only a few of which have ever been divulged to me. Sadly, Jake died a few years ago, and Chris passed away in 2021.

By coincidence, Chris’s brother Ian was a celebrated gynaecologist and pioneer of in vitro fertilisation, and was the consultant in the neo-natal ICU at the Royal Free hospital where the same son was born. Ian Craft died in 2019.

Derek Smith

45,806 posts

249 months

Wednesday 17th April
quotequote all
Roofless Toothless said:
Chris Craft’s son Jake was a school friend of my younger son. The family lived on a small holding near Chigwell, and some wild times were had up there by the boys, only a few of which have ever been divulged to me. Sadly, Jake died a few years ago, and Chris passed away in 2021.

By coincidence, Chris’s brother Ian was a celebrated gynaecologist and pioneer of in vitro fertilisation, and was the consultant in the neo-natal ICU at the Royal Free hospital where the same son was born. Ian Craft died in 2019.
Thanks for that. Interesting. I bet it was wild if he lived like he drove.

Chris was an exciting driver to watch. I think his idea was to convince other drivers that if there was a gap, he'd go for it regardless of whether it was wide enough or not. The crash happened when he went between two other cars on the left-hander off the bottom straight. He bounced off each car more than once, then went up into the air. It was right where we were standing and the girl I was with screamed right in my ear. She said afterwards that, as we were looking almost straight up, she thought it was going to come down on top of us. It hit the circuit a dozen of so feet in front of us. There is/used to be a bit of embankment there and that was the only thing that stopped it rolling onto us. It was scary. There's supposed to be two reflexes in such a situation: flight or fight. I, for some reason, decided to spectate.

The girl would only go motor racing after that if she was sat in a stand. Sensible girl.

isaldiri

18,732 posts

169 months

Wednesday 17th April
quotequote all
Aids0G said:
It is a shame the move to sustainable fuels cant allow a move to more exciting powertrain formats, even the current hybrid system but with a turbo V8 would be a step forward no reason for the power levels to not get up to 1200-1300hp to help combat the weight of todays cars.
The constraint isn't one of sustainable fuels though but simply that the amount of fuel burn is being limited just for the sake of it rather than the fact that it is sustainable fuels being used. If it was allowed, one wouldn't have an issue to be burning lots of that stuff in a NA v10 nevermind a turbo v8. Limiting the total available power would be a definite retrogade step imo as the cars already have more too much grip vs power. If the power is going to be decreased then there needs to be some way of reducing the available downforce of the cars.

NoddyonNitrous

2,131 posts

233 months

Wednesday 17th April
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
cuprabob said:
Derek Smith said:
Like Senna in Japan?
I think that fewest number of words I've ever seen you write Derek smile
An error.
ISWYDT

Derek Smith

45,806 posts

249 months

Thursday 18th April
quotequote all
NoddyonNitrous said:
Derek Smith said:
cuprabob said:
Derek Smith said:
Like Senna in Japan?
I think that fewest number of words I've ever seen you write Derek smile
An error.
ISWYDT
I write. I get paid for my work. I get paid by the word. Another description of a writer is someone who counts words. Being brief and precise is to be self-destructive. Pleonasms rule.

Byker28i

60,723 posts

218 months

Thursday 18th April
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
NoddyonNitrous said:
Derek Smith said:
cuprabob said:
Derek Smith said:
Like Senna in Japan?
I think that fewest number of words I've ever seen you write Derek smile
An error.
ISWYDT
I write. I get paid for my work. I get paid by the word. Another description of a writer is someone who counts words. Being brief and precise is to be self-destructive. Pleonasms rule.
Should do it in Haku

I write, erase, rewrite
Erase again, and then
I count words

Sandpit Steve

10,238 posts

75 months

Thursday 18th April
quotequote all
Big Nanas said:
Aids0G said:
Hustle_ said:
RichB said:
Aids0G said:
<clip> apparently there is genuine concern that the cars will be unable to provide peak power for a full lap of the majority of circuits...
Quite pathetic isn't it.
What kind of drivetrain can provide peak power for a full lap?
Williams FW15C? would be pretty much as close as possible, banned in 1993 and never raced.
The superb 'Engineering Explained' on YouTube has a brilliant video explaining the difference between the current and '26 PUs.
It's quite techy and a fair bit of whiteboard maths, but it's really worth the watch:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KxDQBVzXWt4

For the sake of the discussion, the pertinent part starts at about 8mins.
Very interesting video. So the new cars will have 3x the electric motor power, but the same sized battery they do now, which means they will have to derate above 300kph on long straights to avoid running out of energy.

I do wonder how they will cope at a circuit such as Monza, where there’s only really two braking zones around the lap. Could the cars start to slow down on the run to the first corner?

carlo996

5,905 posts

22 months

Thursday 18th April
quotequote all
Sandpit Steve said:
Very interesting video. So the new cars will have 3x the electric motor power, but the same sized battery they do now, which means they will have to derate above 300kph on long straights to avoid running out of energy.

I do wonder how they will cope at a circuit such as Monza, where there’s only really two braking zones around the lap. Could the cars start to slow down on the run to the first corner?
Will it make that much difference to the actual racing, I mean there's barely enough to fill a highlights show as it is?

suffolk009

5,484 posts

166 months

Thursday 18th April
quotequote all
Sandpit Steve said:
Big Nanas said:
Aids0G said:
Hustle_ said:
RichB said:
Aids0G said:
<clip> apparently there is genuine concern that the cars will be unable to provide peak power for a full lap of the majority of circuits...
Quite pathetic isn't it.
What kind of drivetrain can provide peak power for a full lap?
Williams FW15C? would be pretty much as close as possible, banned in 1993 and never raced.
The superb 'Engineering Explained' on YouTube has a brilliant video explaining the difference between the current and '26 PUs.
It's quite techy and a fair bit of whiteboard maths, but it's really worth the watch:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KxDQBVzXWt4

For the sake of the discussion, the pertinent part starts at about 8mins.
Very interesting video. So the new cars will have 3x the electric motor power, but the same sized battery they do now, which means they will have to derate above 300kph on long straights to avoid running out of energy.

I do wonder how they will cope at a circuit such as Monza, where there’s only really two braking zones around the lap. Could the cars start to slow down on the run to the first corner?
I think I'll wait for Ted to demostrate the difference with the aid of a packet of gummy bears, a box of tic-taks and a AAA battery.

Derek Smith

45,806 posts

249 months

Thursday 18th April
quotequote all
Byker28i said:
Should do it in Haku

I write, erase, rewrite
Erase again, and then
I count words
Thanks for that.

I love poetry and lyrics. Part of the reason is probably that I'm so rubbish at them.

SturdyHSV

10,121 posts

168 months

Thursday 18th April
quotequote all
Byker28i said:
Should do it in Haku

I write, erase, rewrite
Erase again, and then
I count words
As should you wink

(by my count, that goes 6, 6, 3, whereas Haiku are famously (and definitively) 5, 7, 5 I thought...?)