Why no LPG cars from manufacturers?

Why no LPG cars from manufacturers?

Author
Discussion

4sure

2,438 posts

212 months

Monday 22nd November 2010
quotequote all
Max_Torque said:
Compo_Simmonite said:
House uses LPG as gas so the take off from the tank is at the top. Vehicles use it as a liquid so the tank take off needs to be at the bottom. That means you cann't simply use an exisitng house LPG tank to fill up a vehicle tank. It needs a bottom take off and therefore is plain to HMRC that you are using unduty paid LPG which they treat the same as running on red diesel. There was some suggestion that LPG tank installers are obliged to inform government of any installation with bottom take offs but don't know it this is urban myth.
LPG tanks require planning permission so maybe it's the council inspector who shops bottom take offs to HMRC.


Paul H
Well, what if one of my "top" take offs, just happened to have a pipe welded inside of it, that just happened to run down to the bottom of the tank internally........... ;-)
or mount(rotate) the tank the other way up (slip the installer £50).....easy.

or so i believe. wink

Edited by 4sure on Monday 22 November 16:49

Bibbs

3,733 posts

211 months

Monday 22nd November 2010
quotequote all
HSV GTS E3

6.2 V8, and has LPG option.

site said:
The E3 range's engine line-up remains largely unchanged, the ClubSport drawing power from the 317kW LS3 V8 and the GTS powered by the top-shelf 325kW version of the same engine.

All models in the HSV family except for the ClubSport R8 Tourer are now available with an LPI system (for an extra $5990), allowing the engine to operate on both LPG and regular unleaded petrol.
http://www.themotorreport.com.au/50825/hsv-e-series-3-e3-range-launched-in-australia

blank

3,467 posts

189 months

Monday 22nd November 2010
quotequote all
HellDiver said:
Compo_Simmonite said:
A few years back a mate had a "factory" LPG Vectra SRi. When it stopped working he took it back to main agents who had no idea about how it worked. Seems Vauxhall farmed out the converions to a specialist company and the main agent would have to arrange transportation of his car to them for rectification.
Vauxhall gas conversions were, and are still done by Vauxhall Special Vehicle Operations at Millbrook - the same guys that produce the Police-spec cars.
Were. But not any more I don't think. They did do some Subarus aswell IIRC.


You won't find many purely LPG vehicles as it's pretty impractical.

There are plenty of dual fuel ones around but not sure which ones you can get in this country.

Companies like BRC and Landi Renzo tend to produce the "OEM" kits.

Compo_Simmonite

391 posts

188 months

Monday 22nd November 2010
quotequote all
HellDiver said:
Compo_Simmonite said:
A few years back a mate had a "factory" LPG Vectra SRi. When it stopped working he took it back to main agents who had no idea about how it worked. Seems Vauxhall farmed out the converions to a specialist company and the main agent would have to arrange transportation of his car to them for rectification.
Vauxhall gas conversions were, and are still done by Vauxhall Special Vehicle Operations at Millbrook - the same guys that produce the Police-spec cars.
Thats the people smile
Same mate was working as courier and had a CNC Combi van on loan off a dealer freind of his. Nowhere to fill up as the tank wasn't rated high enough for the place lorries fill up with CNC. You can have a pump installed at home but it take overnight to fill a tank and cost was quite high plus you had to declare to HMRC / pay duty seperate.

Paul H

Compo_Simmonite

391 posts

188 months

Monday 22nd November 2010
quotequote all
4sure said:
Max_Torque said:
Compo_Simmonite said:
House uses LPG as gas so the take off from the tank is at the top. Vehicles use it as a liquid so the tank take off needs to be at the bottom. That means you cann't simply use an exisitng house LPG tank to fill up a vehicle tank. It needs a bottom take off and therefore is plain to HMRC that you are using unduty paid LPG which they treat the same as running on red diesel. There was some suggestion that LPG tank installers are obliged to inform government of any installation with bottom take offs but don't know it this is urban myth.
LPG tanks require planning permission so maybe it's the council inspector who shops bottom take offs to HMRC.


Paul H
Well, what if one of my "top" take offs, just happened to have a pipe welded inside of it, that just happened to run down to the bottom of the tank internally........... ;-)
or mount(rotate) the tank the other way up (slip the installer £50).....easy.

or so i believe. wink

Edited by 4sure on Monday 22 November 16:49
If I had LPG for home use I'd definatley sort out a vehicle take off (you also need a pump which adds to costs). Even if you declare and pay duty it's still going to be cheaper than filling up at LPG stations.
You can also transfer out of red portable LPG bottles. Again a pump is needed to completley empty a bottle and I'm not sure if cost saving is worth effort.
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/LPG-Autogas-Transfer-Pump-/1...

Paul H

Bonefish Blues

27,056 posts

224 months

Friday 31st December 2010
quotequote all
Can I resurrect this thread and ask a slightly different question:

Are there any manufacturers who offer LPG as a factory fit option? I ask because we are allowed to spec our company cars with manufacturer options at our own cost. Given I do c33k miles pa, it's an interesting option, given what's happening to fuel prices.

I know Subaru used to do this, in fact I found this: http://subaru.womoco.co.uk/news/major-lpg-initiati... but their site is so hard to navigate I've given up trying see whether it's still going.

Anyone know any other manufacturers who do this (assuming Subaru still do?).

otolith

56,466 posts

205 months

Friday 31st December 2010
quotequote all
Bonefish Blues said:
Are there any manufacturers who offer LPG as a factory fit option?
http://www.proton.co.uk/ecologic/


Bonefish Blues

27,056 posts

224 months

Friday 31st December 2010
quotequote all
otolith said:
Bonefish Blues said:
Are there any manufacturers who offer LPG as a factory fit option?
http://www.proton.co.uk/ecologic/
Please god no, have mercy on me yikes

carl_w

9,217 posts

259 months

Friday 31st December 2010
quotequote all
Shuvi Tupya said:
How many have exploded? None as far as i am ware.
http://www.yorkshirepost.co.uk/news/It-wasn39t-my-...

topsparks

1,202 posts

248 months

Friday 31st December 2010
quotequote all
Just goes to show that smoking is bad for you!,I run a T5 volvo on gas,no problems still goes like a rocket and still goes off the clock!,also a 02 Disco 2 V8,cheaper to run than a diesel and sounds like my Griff (no centre box)

paintman

7,710 posts

191 months

Friday 31st December 2010
quotequote all
Interesting newspaper report.
Esp when they put what they think happened:
'It is thought a leak in the pipe from the filler to the petrol tank allowed gas to seep into the car which ignited when he lit up'.

Must be a Daily Wail training groundlaugh

otolith

56,466 posts

205 months

Friday 31st December 2010
quotequote all
Bonefish Blues said:
otolith said:
Bonefish Blues said:
Are there any manufacturers who offer LPG as a factory fit option?
http://www.proton.co.uk/ecologic/
Please god no, have mercy on me yikes
hehe

That's the problem, I'd only want the sort of LPG car that would otherwise be ruinously expensive.

shovelheadrob

1,564 posts

172 months

Friday 31st December 2010
quotequote all
I have been using LPG for years, American V8s really see the savings! Biggest problem is that only a year ago I was paying around 45p a litre, today I just had to pay 82p a litre (motorway services) the savings are shrinking!
I don't think any manufacturer other than Proton now offers a "factory" LPG car in the UK, however if you want an American pick-up then http://www.switchtopropane.com/pickups.html

AndyLB

428 posts

165 months

Friday 31st December 2010
quotequote all
I don't think the public as a whole "get" lpg, I've used it for about three years now, the kit fitted wasn't brilliant, nor was the installer, but having done over 30,000 miles I've saved back twice the cost of the installation. If you mention lpg to joe public, unless they're a caravanner or live in a remote area, they haven't a clue.

Too few LPG filling stations, too many valve seat erosion rumours from old and not enough dispensation on road tax. If LPG had been given the fanfare of electric/hybrid then it probably would have been really successful, but then the government would have taxed the ar$e out of it as with anything.

shovelheadrob

1,564 posts

172 months

Friday 31st December 2010
quotequote all
This may or may not be true, I heard that the government signed a paper many years ago as part of a "green" initiative to allow the sale of LPG for road use at a much lower duty rate than petrol or diesel due to the lower emmisions. The deal was somewhere along the lines of, for the next ten years LPG duty will only be allowed to increase by 1p per litre per year above any increase implemented on other road fuels. I think that this "deal" expired last year & the only reason that the duty has not caught up with other fuels is that it is still very much a minority thing so the revenue generated would not be huge in the scale of things.
Remember when they told us all to buy a diesel car when diesel was quite a lot cheaper than petrol?