How important is aircon on an Elise S2?

How important is aircon on an Elise S2?

Author
Discussion

cloudzilla

Original Poster:

39 posts

191 months

Sunday 26th April 2009
quotequote all
I've heard conflicting views on the importance of aircon for both daily use and when it comes to resale. I've even heard some people say it's one of the most unreliable parts of an Elise.

I'd appreciate any views... would you buy an Elise without aircon?

Thanks!

limpsfield

5,893 posts

254 months

Sunday 26th April 2009
quotequote all
When I was looking for mine a year ago I initially considered it a must have - but ended up buying without it.

My car is a second/third car so only really used for fun but I have still done around 5000 miles since last July. I don't regret not having aircon at all - but then when I am in it the roof is usually off. Heater works fantastically well in mine - the cool air is hardly freezing but okay.

I suppose if you were buying as a daily driver then it is more important but again when I have used mine early in the morning in winter it has not needed much to demist the screen.

In summary - I think nice to have but if I found the right car for me and it didn't have aircon it would not be a deal breaker - and it wasn't.

bogie

16,402 posts

273 months

Sunday 26th April 2009
quotequote all
depends on intended useage I guess

I had one for 6 years, 2 of which it was an only car, daily driver for 25K miles a year on business

on a hot summers day, stuck in traffic, suit n tie, on the way to a client, I would have killed for aircon

the same when ive been stuck in traffic for an hour in the blazing summer sun on the way to LeMans

however if I was buying again, and it was going to be a weekend car/track toy Id just buy the earliest, lightest Elise I could...its an expensive game trying to make one of the later 900Kg + cars go fast, when youve an extra 200kg to lug around

however, if its your only car, and you do a lot of business miles, Id suggest getting the latest spec car you can with all the latest creature comforts, such as aircon and sound deadening

bordseye

1,989 posts

193 months

Sunday 26th April 2009
quotequote all
Essential in my view. maybe I've gone soft but I wouldnt buy any car without aircon these days and certainly not a sweat box like the Lotus.

The heater control box on Lotus is cr*p so even when it works as well as it ever will, the air coming out of the vents will be heated when the heater is turned off. Did the measurements once with a temp probe - the air in the vent outlets was 10C above ambient. OK on a spring day but if you ever want to drive the car in hot sunshine and an outside temp of (say) 30C, the inside will become an unbearable 40C. Likely this problem will come up when you are on holiday, the boots full so the hood is up and you're on the continent. God knows what it must be like in an Exige without aircon.

As for reliability - well its a Lotus. My aircon has been back to the dealer and even to the factory a total of 4 times before the dealer (not the factory) found it had been assembled without seals. Once that was corrected it works well.

Resale? Depends on the buyer. Some people will attacht more importance to a loud exhaust than aircon

Sparxy

74 posts

189 months

Sunday 26th April 2009
quotequote all
Everything what Bogie said (he knows his stuff!)

However I think it also depends on what model you are looking at.

If you're getting the 111R or SC then the decision is easier. Additional weight affects 0 - 60's most of all, the 0 - 100 will be less noticeable. But with 190 PS or 220Ps you really won't notice the additional weight.

However if you are going for the 111S (s2) or just the S I'd really save as much weight as possible.

I have a 111S S2 with a few mods and I'm about 100KG lighter than the 111R and SC. I'm also about 20ps less than a 111R but I'll give them a run for their money :-) That's if I can change gear smoothly though....damn gear box is pants compared to the Yota engine...blaghhh!

Mine isn't a daily driver so can be less practical. I run stupid things like a lower ride height, front splitter, sticky tyres, annoying loud exhaust and induction kit but then I only spend the time I want to in mine.

For your daily driver....what he said...as much comfort as possible or you'll soon fall out of love the your liz.


The Bandit

788 posts

196 months

Sunday 26th April 2009
quotequote all
Sparxy said:
Everything what Bogie said (he knows his stuff!)

However I think it also depends on what model you are looking at.

If you're getting the 111R or SC then the decision is easier. Additional weight affects 0 - 60's most of all, the 0 - 100 will be less noticeable. But with 190 PS or 220Ps you really won't notice the additional weight.

However if you are going for the 111S (s2) or just the S I'd really save as much weight as possible.

For your daily driver....what he said...as much comfort as possible or you'll soon fall out of love the your liz.

Pretty much sums it up really thumbup

Dont have a/c in my S as i wanted it as basic as possible,but then its a weekend car that has the roof off almost permanently wink

Stu_00

1,529 posts

220 months

Monday 27th April 2009
quotequote all
I do not have it and when it is hot prefer to have the roof off. Alough I do have a daily driver with Aircon when I have my suit on.

So agree with the above, depends what you use it for. Personally I think communting in the Elise is waste of time, better to get cheap run around and save the beast for the weekend, your appreciate more that way.


Stu_00

1,529 posts

220 months

Monday 27th April 2009
quotequote all
I do not have it and when it is hot prefer to have the roof off. Alough I do have a daily driver with Aircon when I have my suit on.

So agree with the above, depends what you use it for. Personally I think communting in the Elise is waste of time, better to get cheap run around and save the beast for the weekend, your appreciate more that way.


SeanyD

3,377 posts

201 months

Monday 27th April 2009
quotequote all
Mine doesnt have aircon, and on a sunny day with the roof off, I'd give my left arm for it, Elise is a real suntrap and temperature can get sky high if you're sitting at lights in the sun.

Still damn good without it all the same. biggrin

Loudman

381 posts

217 months

Monday 27th April 2009
quotequote all
Mine doesn't have it, only a problem a couple of days a year, personally I wouldn't really see it as an advantage in a lightwieght sports car let alone a must have.

steveott

56 posts

187 months

Monday 27th April 2009
quotequote all
My 111s S2 is my daily drive and the only car im insured on. I dont have aircon.

Do you need aircon? Err no way is it important, if its hot you have the roof off.

This is the UK after all - unless your going to drive around in the only two hot weeks in the summer with the roof on - theres really no need for it. Even having the windows down would be ok.

kambites

67,620 posts

222 months

Monday 27th April 2009
quotequote all
My S2 is a daily driver and I intentionally got a car without air con, largely because I didn't want the hassle or the extra weight. I do have a garage though. I can't say I've ever regretted not having it.

Edited by kambites on Monday 27th April 11:29

cloudzilla

Original Poster:

39 posts

191 months

Monday 27th April 2009
quotequote all

Thanks for all the great advice!

RobM77

35,349 posts

235 months

Monday 27th April 2009
quotequote all
I bought my car secondhand and it's got air con. It's a daily driver and to be honest I wouldn't miss it if I didn't have it. It demists the car a little quicker on damp days, but most of the time if it's warm enough to need air con you'll have the roof off! It is jolly effective though at what it does and has never caused me any trouble. A little pointless though IMHO for my own personal use.

R-Racer

119 posts

196 months

Monday 27th April 2009
quotequote all
Would not buy one without A/C. Drive mine all year round in all conditions,no probs at all,in my mind,the advantages cancel out the extra few kilos.


Mrs Muttleysnoop

1,412 posts

185 months

Monday 27th April 2009
quotequote all
Not got aircon in the Sportsracer, if it is hot then roof off. Muttley used our S1 111s and the s/r daily to work. Slight drift here but yesterday we went to North Weald from Suffolk, beautiful hot day and loads of people in convertables with the roof up, why buy a convertable and keep the roof up? grrrrrrrrrrrrr.

NJS25

446 posts

250 months

Monday 27th April 2009
quotequote all
The Elise was originally concieved without a roof, I treat mine as such, the roof only goes on if it's raining properly. If it's dry or mildly moist roof stays off, a thermal hat, gloves and fleece are all you need. Anything over 50mph you don't get wet anyway.

As a daily driver you could always remove the carpets to save them from getting wet, wet carpets will add a good couple of kilos to the car wink

Seriously, an elise can be very warm on a hot day, but if you have roof off then aircons not going to function properly anyway. I have used my car as a daily driver in the past, commuting 300miles each way and stuck in traffic it's not ideal for a suit and tie, but I'm not sure what help the aircon would have been as the roof was off. If you need to commute significant distances for formal occassions, my advice would be to dress casual and take the change of clothes with you.

In an elise I really don't think aircon matters, the exige on the other hand makes more sense.

So in summary, if you really want aircon, buy an exige biggrin

Regards, Neil

RobM77

35,349 posts

235 months

Monday 27th April 2009
quotequote all
I should add to my comments above that I never drive in traffic - that may change my mind, but currently as a daily driver I don't ever use my aircon.

griffter

3,990 posts

256 months

Tuesday 28th April 2009
quotequote all
If you're talking K series cars and you limit your search to cars with a/c you'll have a very limited choice.

Having said that, I wanted a/c as - yes the roof should be off, yes, a/c adds a bit of weight and yes it's something else to go wrong but - if I'm out with one of my kids and they get too hot/sunburnt I can put the roof on, turn on the a/c and everybody's happy. That way I get to use the car more as I'm not worrying "what if?..."

The extra weight can't be more than 20/30 kgs? So that'll omly come into play when I'm under hard acceleration or going very fast round a corner. Both far less frequent than the constant sitting in a hot cabin.

If it goes wrong, I guess worst case is the compressor? That must be a Rover / Freelander part. If I don't want to repair it, remove compressor, new alternator belt and plug the pipes.

One of the nice things about a/c is that the a/c switch can be used as a fan overide switch (I normally wire my own, but no need with a/c).

So I say it's nice to have it; the benefits (to me at least) outweight any perceived disadvantages.

Actually I've just installed an insulated alcantara headliner to keep the heat in on cold day and the heat out on warm days.

I'm also thinking that tracking the car can be hard work - hot work in summer - and roof/a/c on might make it a more comfortable experience. Even Lemans racers have a/c these days!

bogie

16,402 posts

273 months

Tuesday 28th April 2009
quotequote all
Lotus HVAC set-up in a K engined car is 15Kg and cuts out at full throttle to save the 8bhp it saps in power

the heater in HVAC equipped cars is far superior to those without

in an early S2, with no aircon/pre-HVAC (came in with the 111S) the heater is so poor, you will struggle to heat the cabin in winter etc

However cars with aircon seem to have a much more powerful heater and fan set-up which works a treat...sure its still not like a Volvo in winter, but thats not the point - it actually works LOL wink

so they are other plus sides for a daily driver Elise to have aircon - saves you wearing coat and gloves INSIDE the car in winter LOL wink