RE: New Tesla Model 3 Performance gets 510hp

RE: New Tesla Model 3 Performance gets 510hp

Author
Discussion

biggbn

23,595 posts

221 months

Sunday 28th April
quotequote all
JackJarvis said:
Familymad said:
Amazing how polarising EV’s are to petrolheads. This appears to be more prevalent with Tesla threads with really oddly passionate responses not applied to a BMW i4 or a Nissan Leaf etc.

So is it purely the Musk effect?
It's standard PH snobbery. If the general public like something and it's very popular then it's vitally important we look down our powerfully built noses at it.
No snobbery here. I drive a Mini nono

911Spanker

1,261 posts

17 months

Sunday 28th April
quotequote all
JackJarvis said:
Familymad said:
Amazing how polarising EV’s are to petrolheads. This appears to be more prevalent with Tesla threads with really oddly passionate responses not applied to a BMW i4 or a Nissan Leaf etc.

So is it purely the Musk effect?
It's standard PH snobbery. If the general public like something and it's very popular then it's vitally important we look down our powerfully built noses at it.
No it isn't. For me I didn't grow up with Teslas. It was BMWs, Mercedes and Porsches that caught my imagination as a 5 year old. Loved Peugeots too.

Tesla is a bit too "new boy" for my liking with no history/brand for me. So I don't desire one.

And I only buy cars with my heart - I am not the sort of person who buys a car solely to save money. It's a nonsense IMO.

James6112

4,439 posts

29 months

Sunday 28th April
quotequote all
911Spanker said:
JackJarvis said:
Familymad said:
Amazing how polarising EV’s are to petrolheads. This appears to be more prevalent with Tesla threads with really oddly passionate responses not applied to a BMW i4 or a Nissan Leaf etc.

So is it purely the Musk effect?
It's standard PH snobbery. If the general public like something and it's very popular then it's vitally important we look down our powerfully built noses at it.
No it isn't. For me I didn't grow up with Teslas. It was BMWs, Mercedes and Porsches that caught my imagination as a 5 year old. Loved Peugeots too.

Tesla is a bit too "new boy" for my liking with no history/brand for me. So I don't desire one.

And I only buy cars with my heart - I am not the sort of person who buys a car solely to save money. It's a nonsense IMO.
Buying a Tesla isn’t ’solely to save money’
A lot would say they are far superior in many respects, compared to BMW/Merc/Porsche/Peugeot

slopes

38,848 posts

188 months

Sunday 28th April
quotequote all
911Spanker said:
JackJarvis said:
Familymad said:
Amazing how polarising EV’s are to petrolheads. This appears to be more prevalent with Tesla threads with really oddly passionate responses not applied to a BMW i4 or a Nissan Leaf etc.

So is it purely the Musk effect?
It's standard PH snobbery. If the general public like something and it's very popular then it's vitally important we look down our powerfully built noses at it.
No it isn't. For me I didn't grow up with Teslas. It was BMWs, Mercedes and Porsches that caught my imagination as a 5 year old. Loved Peugeots too.

Tesla is a bit too "new boy" for my liking with no history/brand for me. So I don't desire one.

And I only buy cars with my heart - I am not the sort of person who buys a car solely to save money. It's a nonsense IMO.
I think there is an awful lot of snobbery goes on around ph, you only have to look at any thread criticising cyclists for an example and god forbid you should ever criticise His Holiness, Sir Lewis of Hamilton.

However i agree you raise a valid point, to some people Tesla is a Jonny Come Lately and a lot of people, such as yourself, value history of a brand above latest fad for an example so that they can see reliability, commitment etc and i totally get that.
For me, electric cars represent a different future and whilst i love the likes of Ferrari, Porsche, Lamborghini etc i also like the posibillities that eletric cars represent and i just happen to like the lack of faff in the Tesla cabin over some other cars, such as the Taycan. smile


911Spanker

1,261 posts

17 months

Sunday 28th April
quotequote all
James6112 said:
911Spanker said:
JackJarvis said:
Familymad said:
Amazing how polarising EV’s are to petrolheads. This appears to be more prevalent with Tesla threads with really oddly passionate responses not applied to a BMW i4 or a Nissan Leaf etc.

So is it purely the Musk effect?
It's standard PH snobbery. If the general public like something and it's very popular then it's vitally important we look down our powerfully built noses at it.
No it isn't. For me I didn't grow up with Teslas. It was BMWs, Mercedes and Porsches that caught my imagination as a 5 year old. Loved Peugeots too.

Tesla is a bit too "new boy" for my liking with no history/brand for me. So I don't desire one.

And I only buy cars with my heart - I am not the sort of person who buys a car solely to save money. It's a nonsense IMO.
Buying a Tesla isn’t ’solely to save money’
A lot would say they are far superior in many respects, compared to BMW/Merc/Porsche/Peugeot
Not for me they aren't. I am not into modern cars and I can't ever see a time I will drive a Tesla.

Saying that, maybe when they sink to being £2k station stter territory (probably 2 years away) I may consider one but that's about it.

They hold no appeal whatsoever. I want a car, not a transportation device.

Familymad

687 posts

218 months

Sunday 28th April
quotequote all
18months…

Baldchap

7,700 posts

93 months

Sunday 28th April
quotequote all
James6112 said:
911Spanker said:
JackJarvis said:
Familymad said:
Amazing how polarising EV’s are to petrolheads. This appears to be more prevalent with Tesla threads with really oddly passionate responses not applied to a BMW i4 or a Nissan Leaf etc.

So is it purely the Musk effect?
It's standard PH snobbery. If the general public like something and it's very popular then it's vitally important we look down our powerfully built noses at it.
No it isn't. For me I didn't grow up with Teslas. It was BMWs, Mercedes and Porsches that caught my imagination as a 5 year old. Loved Peugeots too.

Tesla is a bit too "new boy" for my liking with no history/brand for me. So I don't desire one.

And I only buy cars with my heart - I am not the sort of person who buys a car solely to save money. It's a nonsense IMO.
Buying a Tesla isn’t ’solely to save money’
A lot would say they are far superior in many respects, compared to BMW/Merc/Porsche/Peugeot
Those of us that have owned them are clearly guilty of neither brand snobbery nor Musk-hate (though he is a cock).

Those of us that have owned them know they're badly built, the customer service is awful and the cars are disappointing to drive in many cases (and I have driven the fastest ones of them all barring the Y). One trick pony is the phrase that springs to mind and there's currently a class action building steam over Tesla's fraudulent activity around selling FSD.

Those of us who have owned them KNOW they are not superior in many respects to the incumbent manufacturers like BMW/Merc/Porsch.

I categorically would never buy another product from that company ever again.

biggbn

23,595 posts

221 months

Sunday 28th April
quotequote all
911Spanker said:
JackJarvis said:
Familymad said:
Amazing how polarising EV’s are to petrolheads. This appears to be more prevalent with Tesla threads with really oddly passionate responses not applied to a BMW i4 or a Nissan Leaf etc.

So is it purely the Musk effect?
It's standard PH snobbery. If the general public like something and it's very popular then it's vitally important we look down our powerfully built noses at it.
No it isn't. For me I didn't grow up with Teslas. It was BMWs, Mercedes and Porsches that caught my imagination as a 5 year old. Loved Peugeots too.

Tesla is a bit too "new boy" for my liking with no history/brand for me. So I don't desire one.

And I only buy cars with my heart - I am not the sort of person who buys a car solely to save money. It's a nonsense IMO.
I'm also a 'buy with heart' guy, but that doesn't put me off EV. I have no particular attachment to the ICE and if I could afford it I'd love an electric mini and I'm also really attracted to the Polestar 2. The 'newness' of many of the EV brands doesn't concern me at all, if someone makes something I like, that's all that matters to me.

Tindersticks

60 posts

1 month

Sunday 28th April
quotequote all


There are a lot of people who have no interest in EV's who seem to spend a lot of time in EV threads telling everyone that.

cerb4.5lee

30,835 posts

181 months

Sunday 28th April
quotequote all
Tindersticks said:
There are a lot of people who have no interest in EV's who seem to spend a lot of time in EV threads telling everyone that.
I have to be honest, and I dislike myself a bit for that as well. I'm not a fan of Tesla, yet I keep chatting about the bloody things though!

Gordon Hill

884 posts

16 months

Sunday 28th April
quotequote all
Baldchap said:
James6112 said:
911Spanker said:
JackJarvis said:
Familymad said:
Amazing how polarising EV’s are to petrolheads. This appears to be more prevalent with Tesla threads with really oddly passionate responses not applied to a BMW i4 or a Nissan Leaf etc.

So is it purely the Musk effect?
It's standard PH snobbery. If the general public like something and it's very popular then it's vitally important we look down our powerfully built noses at it.
No it isn't. For me I didn't grow up with Teslas. It was BMWs, Mercedes and Porsches that caught my imagination as a 5 year old. Loved Peugeots too.

Tesla is a bit too "new boy" for my liking with no history/brand for me. So I don't desire one.

And I only buy cars with my heart - I am not the sort of person who buys a car solely to save money. It's a nonsense IMO.
Buying a Tesla isn’t ’solely to save money’
A lot would say they are far superior in many respects, compared to BMW/Merc/Porsche/Peugeot
Those of us that have owned them are clearly guilty of neither brand snobbery nor Musk-hate (though he is a cock).

Those of us that have owned them know they're badly built, the customer service is awful and the cars are disappointing to drive in many cases (and I have driven the fastest ones of them all barring the Y). One trick pony is the phrase that springs to mind and there's currently a class action building steam over Tesla's fraudulent activity around selling FSD.

Those of us who have owned them KNOW they are not superior in many respects to the incumbent manufacturers like BMW/Merc/Porsch.

I categorically would never buy another product from that company ever again.
And so here we have a real life example of someone who HAS owned a Tesla and found the whole ownership experience terrible in every way, this will all get conveniently ignored.

911Spanker

1,261 posts

17 months

Sunday 28th April
quotequote all
Tindersticks said:
There are a lot of people who have no interest in EV's who seem to spend a lot of time in EV threads telling everyone that.
Every single thread on PH seems to about the hateful things...

People who are into EVs should sod off to here:

https://www.speakev.com/

wink

cerb4.5lee

30,835 posts

181 months

Sunday 28th April
quotequote all
Baldchap said:
Those of us who have owned them KNOW they are not superior in many respects to the incumbent manufacturers like BMW/Merc/Porsch.
I don't see a lot of that on here though in fairness, and on here they tend to get touted as the "best car in the world" and the "best thing since sliced bread" for some reason.

I personally prefer honesty though, and if something is crap, then say that it is crap I reckon. Who in the right mind would ever think that a Tesla competes with a BMW/Merc for example? It is laughable for me.

Gordon Hill

884 posts

16 months

Sunday 28th April
quotequote all
cerb4.5lee said:
Baldchap said:
Those of us who have owned them KNOW they are not superior in many respects to the incumbent manufacturers like BMW/Merc/Porsch.
I don't see a lot of that on here though in fairness, and on here they tend to get touted as the "best car in the world" and the "best thing since sliced bread" for some reason.

I personally prefer honesty though, and if something is crap, then say that it is crap I reckon. Who in the right mind would ever think that a Tesla competes with a BMW/Merc for example? It is laughable for me.
They are the modern day skateboard.

Familymad

687 posts

218 months

Sunday 28th April
quotequote all
I’ve owned 4 EV’s and the Tesla is the 4th. It’s a late 2023 Chinese built MY LR.

It’s been faultless bar a tyre and done 13k miles. 9 supercharger visits and the rest at home. IOS, app and long range driving just epic and easy. It just works.

I don’t love it, I don’t even like it, but I do think it’s a brilliant family hack and my wife’s favourite car we have owned. I took her out of a 2023 RRS P400 and gave her this.

The paint quality is soft/thin. Panel fit and finish as good as the RRS (the boot is better aligned than the RRS) Interior is squeak free, but not a LR feel. I get the VAT back and claim the lease again company profits. BIK is cheap. Can’t really fault it for white goods motoring. I spent the savings on an R500 for the garage…

I also struggle with Musk, but I don’t really value (know) any of the CEO’s from manufacturers who I routinely buy things from. I buy based on the product and this EV is the best for what I need it for.

Would I rather own and drive a Taycan. Probably, until I come to drive more than 200 miles. But it’s not £450 a month with more useable space than a Defender 110.


Terminator X

15,141 posts

205 months

Sunday 28th April
quotequote all
Tindersticks said:
There are a lot of people who have no interest in EV's who seem to spend a lot of time in EV threads telling everyone that.
Look at the Urus thread, everyone hammering it. Best you get over there and tell them to stop.

TX.

delta0

2,355 posts

107 months

Sunday 28th April
quotequote all
911Spanker said:
Tindersticks said:
There are a lot of people who have no interest in EV's who seem to spend a lot of time in EV threads telling everyone that.
Every single thread on PH seems to about the hateful things...

People who are into EVs should sod off to here:

https://www.speakev.com/

wink
But then pistonheads would have to change its name to modern classics and then classics.

911Spanker

1,261 posts

17 months

Sunday 28th April
quotequote all
delta0 said:
911Spanker said:
Tindersticks said:
There are a lot of people who have no interest in EV's who seem to spend a lot of time in EV threads telling everyone that.
Every single thread on PH seems to about the hateful things...

People who are into EVs should sod off to here:

https://www.speakev.com/

wink
But then pistonheads would have to change its name to modern classics and then classics.
No it wouldn't...

Baldchap

7,700 posts

93 months

Sunday 28th April
quotequote all
cerb4.5lee said:
Baldchap said:
Those of us who have owned them KNOW they are not superior in many respects to the incumbent manufacturers like BMW/Merc/Porsch.
I don't see a lot of that on here though in fairness, and on here they tend to get touted as the "best car in the world" and the "best thing since sliced bread" for some reason.

I personally prefer honesty though, and if something is crap, then say that it is crap I reckon. Who in the right mind would ever think that a Tesla competes with a BMW/Merc for example? It is laughable for me.
It is 100% natural behaviour to want your purchase to be 'right', and we all know people who's 'whatever' is the best, right up until they get rid of it, then the next thing is the best. Cars are expensive so it's only natural that these would follow this trend for the majority of buyers.

It is human nature to a degree to want to demonstrate that we made the right choice and that other people should do it too, as it reinforces our own hopes and beliefs.

The real clincher for me is, if money was no object, would they still own that car? I'm confident the majority of Tesla owners would not. They therefore are a compromise, and perhaps not as great as the evangelists would have us believe.

I'm not anti EV, I 100% owned a Tesla and paid a spectacular amount of my own money to do so (far more than my Alpina, for example). No rental, no company car discount, actual hard cash (or bank transfer). The 'being electric' part was absolutely fine. A full 'tank' every morning and obviously the straight line pace. Sadly the product was not up to scratch as something to live with evey day, and this is something those of us who are minded to look for still see to this day. Worth noting I'm comparing their top offering to equivalently priced manufacturers, not their cheapest model to an Astra or whatever.

All my opinion (and we all know what opinions are like!) and I'm happy for anyone to enjoy what they own (as they absolutely should), but the level of evangelism isn't warranted based on my personal experience.

limpsfield

5,893 posts

254 months

Sunday 28th April
quotequote all
cerb4.5lee said:
I personally prefer honesty though, and if something is crap, then say that it is crap I reckon. Who in the right mind would ever think that a Tesla competes with a BMW/Merc for example? It is laughable for me.
I sold a bmw and replaced it with a Tesla, so me for one.