Junior Doctors' Pay Claim Poll

Poll: Junior Doctors' Pay Claim Poll

Total Members Polled: 1014

Full 35%: 11%
Over 30% but not 35%: 2%
From 20% to 29%: 6%
From 10% to 19%: 18%
From 5% to 9%: 42%
From 1% to 4%: 10%
Exactly 0%: 5%
Don't know / no opinion / another %: 6%
Author
Discussion

Dixy

2,938 posts

206 months

Tuesday 7th May
quotequote all
!. it has been bust for decades
2. Are you talking about the trusts, deaneries, surgeries or The NHS. 1948 is the best answer.
3. regularly, but the one of the main reasons the JDs are unhappy is that they are moved workplace at least once a year, every year
4. Redundancies are required when you are overstaffed not when struggling to retain staff


djc206

12,418 posts

126 months

Tuesday 7th May
quotequote all
Digga said:
djc206 said:
ClaphamGT3 said:
I went for 1-4% which is where many qualified professions are placing their pay awards at the moment.

I would suggest to the GMC that they introduce a compulsory economics module to the 1st year BMed syllabus
How has qualified professional pay held up against inflation over the past decade? Mine has ever so slightly exceeded inflation.
Remind me when the NHS last;
  1. went bust
  2. got taken over
  3. closed workplaces
  4. announced mass’s redundancies
I heard you the first time, you still haven’t answered my question so I don’t feel like answering any more of yours having already pointed out that the NHS does close workplaces and that can involve redundancies.

spaximus

4,241 posts

254 months

Tuesday 7th May
quotequote all
I know that some struggle to understand but the NHS and JD is shambolic.

They train in an area have to have somewhere to live, qualify and then more often than not apply to work in the area they have trained in.

Sadly there are not enough training places for these newly qualified and some find themselves having to move miles away, give notice on their rental and try to find somewhere to rent in the new area.

Often the deaneries are so large you cannot live in one area and get to work so have to move again and again.

However for the PA's now coming out after just two years "medical training" they get jobs in the area they trained in are not asked to move and in the short term earn more than a JD and people wonder why there is unhappiness.

The latest from the negotiations with the government is things are moving but there is still a feeling they are kicking the can down the road for Labour to sort out.

We will see but more will leave if they do not sort out pay and many other issues like training places and conditions required to keep staff

pavarotti1980

4,981 posts

85 months

Thursday 16th May
quotequote all
Just attended a meeting which also had the chair of a local LMC. GPs are voting for immediate industrial action.
They (entire PCNs) are also in the process of formally refusing to sign shared care agreements or write prescriptions for drugs which have been started or recommended by a specialist in hospital ("amber and green plus" drugs) and bumping all patients back to hospitals for drugs which are not "routine". SO unless you want your bog standard run of the mill drugs it will be a trip to hospital to get them. And quelle surprise there is no capacity in secondary care to take on mass prescribing either

borcy

3,067 posts

57 months

Thursday 16th May
quotequote all
pavarotti1980 said:
Just attended a meeting which also had the chair of a local LMC. GPs are voting for immediate industrial action.
They (entire PCNs) are also in the process of formally refusing to sign shared care agreements or write prescriptions for drugs which have been started or recommended by a specialist in hospital ("amber and green plus" drugs) and bumping all patients back to hospitals for drugs which are not "routine". SO unless you want your bog standard run of the mill drugs it will be a trip to hospital to get them. And quelle surprise there is no capacity in secondary care to take on mass prescribing either
Why are they refusing to write prescriptions for those type of drugs?

pavarotti1980

4,981 posts

85 months

Thursday 16th May
quotequote all
borcy said:
Why are they refusing to write prescriptions for those type of drugs?
Because they do not have the capacity and all of a sudden no expertise to be able to manage their monitoring **allegedly**

Edit: They have also made a recent discovery that they think there is not a provision within the existing GP contract to provide these services

borcy

3,067 posts

57 months

Thursday 16th May
quotequote all
pavarotti1980 said:
borcy said:
Why are they refusing to write prescriptions for those type of drugs?
Because they do not have the capacity and all of a sudden no expertise to be able to manage their monitoring **allegedly**

Edit: They have also made a recent discovery that they think there is not a provision within the existing GP contract to provide these services
Would their capacity and expertise increase if the contract was changed to give them more income?

pavarotti1980

4,981 posts

85 months

Thursday 16th May
quotequote all
borcy said:
Would their capacity and expertise increase if the contract was changed to give them more income?
Of course not lol

I do sympathise with the lack of capacity in the sense that the numbers of GP trainees is not sufficient to replace natural wastage through retirement etc.

spaximus

4,241 posts

254 months

Thursday 16th May
quotequote all
The government will fast track things so Physicians Assistant, Paramedic or often referred to as Primary Care Emergency Practitioners and in Health centre Pharmacists will get full prescribing rights to change things.
Not sure this is safe but neither is using them as cut price Dr’s anyway.
How this fits with Starmer saying today he has been speaking with Dr’s and he is saying they can easily get 40000 new appointments per week and he is pledging this will happen by having evening and weekend extra working but nothing about how he will stop Dr’s leaving but it is another thing to be funded by non doms

Vasco

16,487 posts

106 months

Thursday 16th May
quotequote all

Can't help continuing to think that the doctors need to accept they won't get everything at the present time.
Accept what is on offer and get Starmer to sort it out.

gangzoom

6,344 posts

216 months

Friday 17th May
quotequote all
spaximus said:
nothing about how he will stop Dr’s leaving but it is another thing to be funded by non doms
A significant number of UK trainnes coming out of medical school still don't know where they are starting this first jobs in August yet (2.5 months away), and GP trainees finishing their training are struggling to find jobs in some areas.

gangzoom

6,344 posts

216 months

Friday 17th May
quotequote all
Vasco said:

Can't help continuing to think that the doctors need to accept they won't get everything at the present time.
Accept what is on offer and get Starmer to sort it out.
An agreement looks like it coming, some movement is already happening. I don't think the 35% headline figure will be reached but it looks like 10-20% may become the agreed position.

https://www.bma.org.uk/our-campaigns/sas-campaigns...

Vasco

16,487 posts

106 months

Friday 17th May
quotequote all
I know I've said it all along but they should never have said that they wanted 35%.
It just got people's backs up as totally unrealistic. It should have been their AIM not Claim.

Gary C

12,559 posts

180 months

Friday 17th May
quotequote all
Vasco said:
I know I've said it all along but they should never have said that they wanted 35%.
It just got people's backs up as totally unrealistic. It should have been their AIM not Claim.
Totally agree.

Makes you think the people leading this had another agenda...

BikeBikeBIke

8,233 posts

116 months

Friday 17th May
quotequote all
Vasco said:
I know I've said it all along but they should never have said that they wanted 35%.
It just got people's backs up as totally unrealistic. It should have been their AIM not Claim.
Working for a monopoly is never a good way to get the correct market rate for your job. That's the fundamental problem.

spaximus

4,241 posts

254 months

Friday 17th May
quotequote all
gangzoom said:
A significant number of UK trainnes coming out of medical school still don't know where they are starting this first jobs in August yet (2.5 months away), and GP trainees finishing their training are struggling to find jobs in some areas.
You are correct and it shows a side the public do not get.
My Daughter was fortunate when she qualified and got to stay and work in her chosen area where she had trained.
She still had to work in hospitals that were spread out so nearest was 25 mins from home furthest almost an hour and half.
Some of her friends changed several times in the first few years.
The new way of getting a position is stupid and really shows a lack of consideration to Dr.s.
As for Gp positions, again she has several friends who are Gp’s not partners and in one they lost two Gp,s and have replaced with PA’s as they are half the cost of a Gp, but are half the person which is shameful.
There are Gp vacancies but they in areas where they don’t want to move to.

sawman

4,925 posts

231 months

Friday 17th May
quotequote all
gangzoom said:
spaximus said:
nothing about how he will stop Dr’s leaving but it is another thing to be funded by non doms
A significant number of UK trainnes coming out of medical school still don't know where they are starting this first jobs in August yet (2.5 months away), and GP trainees finishing their training are struggling to find jobs in some areas.
This is at least as big an issue as the pay erosion, really needs sorting out. 12000 applications for 4000 gp training posts leaves 8000 highly skilled young docs looking elsewhere for gainful employment

pghstochaj

2,420 posts

120 months

Friday 17th May
quotequote all
sawman said:
gangzoom said:
spaximus said:
nothing about how he will stop Dr’s leaving but it is another thing to be funded by non doms
A significant number of UK trainnes coming out of medical school still don't know where they are starting this first jobs in August yet (2.5 months away), and GP trainees finishing their training are struggling to find jobs in some areas.
This is at least as big an issue as the pay erosion, really needs sorting out. 12000 applications for 4000 gp training posts leaves 8000 highly skilled young docs looking elsewhere for gainful employment
There are only about 10,000 medical graduates in total, per annum?

pghstochaj

2,420 posts

120 months

Friday 17th May
quotequote all
gangzoom said:
Vasco said:

Can't help continuing to think that the doctors need to accept they won't get everything at the present time.
Accept what is on offer and get Starmer to sort it out.
An agreement looks like it coming, some movement is already happening. I don't think the 35% headline figure will be reached but it looks like 10-20% may become the agreed position.

https://www.bma.org.uk/our-campaigns/sas-campaigns...
That's for speciality doctors, not junior doctors.

JDs will be entering into mediation:

https://www.pulsetoday.co.uk/news/politics/governm...

sawman

4,925 posts

231 months

Friday 17th May
quotequote all
pghstochaj said:
There are only about 10,000 medical graduates in total, per annum?
Yes but potential GP trainees will have been through foundation years, may have started (and possibly finished) or not been able to access specialist training in a secondary care setting, so the pool of applicants could be from a post grad pool of 10 years or so of medical school graduates