107 / C1 / Aygo experiences?

107 / C1 / Aygo experiences?

Author
Discussion

Bobupndown

Original Poster:

1,862 posts

44 months

Saturday 28th October 2023
quotequote all
Will be getting a small used car for our son as a learner next year and considering options.
Anyone any experience of one of these trio?

Bobupndown

Original Poster:

1,862 posts

44 months

Saturday 28th October 2023
quotequote all
Where are the water leaks from, lights, door seals?

Bobupndown

Original Poster:

1,862 posts

44 months

Sunday 29th October 2023
quotequote all
I think these are probably the modern(ish) equivalent to the classic minis I drove in my teens, a bit under powered but fun to drive flat out on back roads with decent handling.
Are there any common engine or mechanical issue worty of note? I believe they are chain driven and quite reliable.

Bobupndown

Original Poster:

1,862 posts

44 months

Monday 30th October 2023
quotequote all
itcaptainslow said:
I’ve a bit of experience with these, especially the Mk1, as I used to manage a Citroen dealership a dozen years ago, and now run a C1 as a daily. My partner has also had a couple, and my Dad has a Mk2 C1 currently.

Mk1 issues;
  • Early neglected ones are starting to rot around the rear inner & outer sills.
  • The petrol engine can suffer from piston slap and use oil - they’ll carry on running forever like this, though.
  • Water pumps leak, it’s a cheap, easy repair though.
  • Clutches aren’t particularly robust, they don’t last too long and tend to bite high. They’re an easy one to replace, though, and Exedy do a modified, uprated clutch which seems good.
  • They suffer from water ingress into the interior via the high level brake light, rear lights, door & boot seals and door membranes. Don’t use silicone - it’s a bodge. Buy the uprated seal kit from X8R for around £130, I’ve fitted one of these and mine hasn’t leaked a drop, since.
  • Later Mk1’s have a modified gear linkage and a nicer stereo with Bluetooth. This stereo however is impossible to replace for an aftermarket unit due to the weird wiring harness used (ask me how I know).
  • Sometimes instrument packs fail and cause weird and wonderful electrical faults, quite a rare thing, though.
Regarding the Mk2, I strongly recommend avoiding the 1.2 EB wet belt engine. It’s economical and torquey, but predictably, the wet belt breaks up and blocks the oil pump. PSA are on about the fourth revision of the belt now. They need special tools to change, and while not as horrendous as the Ecoboost, still aren’t an especially nice job.

I sound full of doom and gloom, but they’re hardy little things that are very cheap to run, fun to drive (if somewhat slow) and easy to fix. I’d highly recommend them.
Thanks that's very helpful.

Bobupndown

Original Poster:

1,862 posts

44 months

Wednesday 1st November 2023
quotequote all
What's the 'real world driving' mpg like on these?

Bobupndown

Original Poster:

1,862 posts

44 months

Wednesday 1st November 2023
quotequote all
I think one of these is definitely on the list of possibilities. Son says he likes the Peugeot but not the Citroen, not sure there's a massive difference tbh!

Eldest son had a VW Up as his first car which was a great little runabout too so any of the Up/Mii/Citigo triplets would do as well.

I think it will come down to what's available and price / condition when we're looking in the spring.

Bobupndown

Original Poster:

1,862 posts

44 months

Tuesday 14th November 2023
quotequote all
There seems to be a common report of great engine, weak clutch. I wonder is the clutch replacement a big / expensive job on these?

Bobupndown

Original Poster:

1,862 posts

44 months

Monday 18th March
quotequote all
Well after much online researching today we went and bought a 2016 108, 5 door, 1 litre with just 49000 miles on it and in immaculate condition. Little difference in price over later 107s, it seemed to be the sensible option to get the later updated model with the more modern ice, it will certainly be appreciated by its new teenage owner. Can't wait to do the handover now!