Can Sir Keir Starmer revive the Labour Party? (Vol. 2)

Can Sir Keir Starmer revive the Labour Party? (Vol. 2)

Author
Discussion

borcy

3,328 posts

58 months

Wednesday 22nd May
quotequote all
768 said:
Bit surprised to hear Starmer say there are issues in the culture of the NHS and it needs to change.

He's right. I'm just shocked he'd admit it.
He's let Wes Streeting make various statements to that effect over the past 18 months. Very much we don't hero worship the nhs just because we're labour.
Not sure if stamer has said it before.

monkfish1

11,176 posts

226 months

Wednesday 22nd May
quotequote all
Mr Penguin said:
On the one hand they are all in politics to make the country a better place,
Really? Please tell me you dont believe that?

anonymoususer

6,082 posts

50 months

Wednesday 22nd May
quotequote all
Summer General Election Thursday 4th July

fatjon

2,283 posts

215 months

Wednesday 22nd May
quotequote all
Murph7355 said:
IME the selective nature of them pretty much ends at "do you have £10k a term".
Nope. My kids had to pass some pretty challenging tests or no place offered. A good proportion failed and didn’t get places despite having the cash.

Sway

26,509 posts

196 months

Wednesday 22nd May
quotequote all
fatjon said:
Murph7355 said:
IME the selective nature of them pretty much ends at "do you have £10k a term".
Nope. My kids had to pass some pretty challenging tests or no place offered. A good proportion failed and didn’t get places despite having the cash.
Indeed. Tbf to Murph, some do indeed allow you in 'regardless' (within reason!) - with 'supplemental' fees if the entrance exams aren't passed.

Mine did, and still does, work quite differently. If you pass, they move heaven and earth to find a way to get you in. In my case, it was the now destroyed assisted place scheme, with a scholarship taking up the shortfall. Still nearly broke mum with uniform/sports kit/equipment/trips spending!

One of the most satisfying things I've done is chucking them a term's worth of fees to the bursary fund. Admittedly, it needed a little bit of inheritance coming through for me to be able to though.

MC Bodge

21,990 posts

177 months

Wednesday 22nd May
quotequote all
turbobloke said:
MC Bodge said:
Every time that they wheel out Rees-Mogg, less frequently nowadays, a collective nausea must rise in the population.
In left-wing activists and Labour's rumpies maybe, others don't notice and/or likely to be more tolerant of diverse personalities.
Are you a real person?

turbobloke

104,589 posts

262 months

Thursday 23rd May
quotequote all
MC Bodge said:
turbobloke said:
MC Bodge said:
Every time that they wheel out Rees-Mogg, less frequently nowadays, a collective nausea must rise in the population.
In left-wing activists and Labour's rumpies maybe, others don't notice and/or likely to be more tolerant of diverse personalities.
Are you a real person?
Are you capable of non-juvenile discussions online? Rhetorical question.

Mabbs9

1,117 posts

220 months

Thursday 23rd May
quotequote all
turbobloke said:
MC Bodge said:
turbobloke said:
MC Bodge said:
Every time that they wheel out Rees-Mogg, less frequently nowadays, a collective nausea must rise in the population.
In left-wing activists and Labour's rumpies maybe, others don't notice and/or likely to be more tolerant of diverse personalities.
Are you a real person?
Are you capable of non-juvenile discussions online? Rhetorical question.
I find these weird dislikes for people pretty unpleasant. Rees-Mogg is very different to me but I judge him on his substance rather than what he looks or sounds like. It's a grim undercurrent when we judge others by their appearances. I thought our society was a long way to stamping that out.

President Merkin

3,587 posts

21 months

Thursday 23rd May
quotequote all
And on his substance, how do you find him?

DeejRC

5,892 posts

84 months

Thursday 23rd May
quotequote all
I never quite get the obsession with WRM. He’s an MP for a remote part of Somerset and he doesn’t hold a major position in govt. He doesn’t say much on defence, foreign policy, the economy, energy or even that much on domestic policy. His entire 2 things and the 2 things which ppl seem to obsesses about over him is he’s not overly a fan of the EU and migrants. Two things which frankly baffle me as to their perceived place in voter priority/importance, as everytime the question has been asked of the public, they have replied that they aren’t!
So all that’s left is he looks a bit weird and posh.
I just don’t get it.

hidetheelephants

25,425 posts

195 months

Thursday 23rd May
quotequote all
DeejRC said:
I never quite get the obsession with WRM. He’s an MP for a remote part of Somerset and he doesn’t hold a major position in govt. He doesn’t say much on defence, foreign policy, the economy, energy or even that much on domestic policy. His entire 2 things and the 2 things which ppl seem to obsesses about over him is he’s not overly a fan of the EU and migrants. Two things which frankly baffle me as to their perceived place in voter priority/importance, as everytime the question has been asked of the public, they have replied that they aren’t!
So all that’s left is he looks a bit weird and posh.
I just don’t get it.
You don't have to look far to discover he's a religious fundamentalist of a quite unpleasant kind.

S600BSB

5,339 posts

108 months

Thursday 23rd May
quotequote all
hidetheelephants said:
DeejRC said:
I never quite get the obsession with WRM. He’s an MP for a remote part of Somerset and he doesn’t hold a major position in govt. He doesn’t say much on defence, foreign policy, the economy, energy or even that much on domestic policy. His entire 2 things and the 2 things which ppl seem to obsesses about over him is he’s not overly a fan of the EU and migrants. Two things which frankly baffle me as to their perceived place in voter priority/importance, as everytime the question has been asked of the public, they have replied that they aren’t!
So all that’s left is he looks a bit weird and posh.
I just don’t get it.
You don't have to look far to discover he's a religious fundamentalist of a quite unpleasant kind.
Be classy if he was under a bit of pressure come election night!

Sway

26,509 posts

196 months

Thursday 23rd May
quotequote all
hidetheelephants said:
DeejRC said:
I never quite get the obsession with WRM. He’s an MP for a remote part of Somerset and he doesn’t hold a major position in govt. He doesn’t say much on defence, foreign policy, the economy, energy or even that much on domestic policy. His entire 2 things and the 2 things which ppl seem to obsesses about over him is he’s not overly a fan of the EU and migrants. Two things which frankly baffle me as to their perceived place in voter priority/importance, as everytime the question has been asked of the public, they have replied that they aren’t!
So all that’s left is he looks a bit weird and posh.
I just don’t get it.
You don't have to look far to discover he's a religious fundamentalist of a quite unpleasant kind.
There's a reasonable number of those in the House.

But Deej's point still stands - he may well be a fundy - but frankly who cares? Minor backbencher with fk all input on anything, whose constituents seem to like him.

bitchstewie

52,291 posts

212 months

Thursday 23rd May
quotequote all
hidetheelephants said:
You don't have to look far to discover he's a religious fundamentalist of a quite unpleasant kind.
Quite.

Grenfell and some other appalling comments all hidden behind a plummy accent that seems to appeal to some "know your betters" types.

President Merkin

3,587 posts

21 months

Thursday 23rd May
quotequote all
Sway said:
Minor backbencher with fk all input on anything, whose constituents seem to like him.
You have something of a habit of pissing in peope's pockets and telling them it's raining. It's distasteful on a couple of levels, the fundamental one being the perpetuation of falsehoods & the other, taking people for fools, Mogg may be a backbencher but he remains an influential voice on the right. You know this. We know this, Stop it.

DeejRC

5,892 posts

84 months

Thursday 23rd May
quotequote all
So a largely back bench MP, in the middle of nowhere, holds a private religious belief which he hasn’t advocated for in the public sphere. A belief shared by millions (billions?) of others around the world which isn’t part of UK political life.
Again, I don’t get it. Either why anyone pays attention to him positively or negatively. It would be like me caring if Andy Burnham supported City or Utd.

bitchstewie

52,291 posts

212 months

Thursday 23rd May
quotequote all
He was a Government Minister and gets a disproportionate amount of airtime for a "largely back bench MP, in the middle of nowhere".

You're being disingenuous.

Electro1980

8,479 posts

141 months

Thursday 23rd May
quotequote all
DeejRC said:
holds a private religious belief which he hasn’t advocated for in the public sphere.
Yes he has, repeatedly. His views on gay marriage:

“I’m a Catholic, I take the teaching of the Catholic church seriously. Marriage is a sacrament and the view of what marriage is is taken by the church, not parliament.”
“I support the teaching of the Catholic church. The marriage issue is the important thing, this is not how people arrange their lives.”

119

7,182 posts

38 months

Thursday 23rd May
quotequote all
What is so offensive about that?

turbobloke

104,589 posts

262 months

Thursday 23rd May
quotequote all
119 said:
What is so offensive about that?
Nothing. What does teaching within Islam say? Does it get an airing?