Greatest 4/5 seat cars ever?

Greatest 4/5 seat cars ever?

Author
Discussion

Voldemort

6,191 posts

279 months

Wednesday 1st May
quotequote all
RS6


Om

1,811 posts

79 months

Wednesday 1st May
quotequote all
For me, perhaps a Maserati - Gransport or Granturismo. Gorgeous looking 2 door with fantastic engines that also happen to have 4 'useable' seats. Why would you want something that looks dull and saloon like or god forbid a hatchback when you could have these?

Failing that I have always had a thing for the Ferrari Mondial.

RustyMX5

7,245 posts

218 months

Wednesday 1st May
quotequote all
1690cc said:


Sticking with proper full size 4 seaters I would offer up the 500E.
That's weedy. Try this


MightyBadger

2,168 posts

51 months

Wednesday 1st May
quotequote all
Riley Blue said:
The original Mini must be in with a shout, it heralded a whole new genre of motoring for the masses.
Agreed.

CKY

1,436 posts

16 months

Wednesday 1st May
quotequote all
Om said:
For me, perhaps a Maserati - Gransport or Granturismo. Gorgeous looking 2 door with fantastic engines that also happen to have 4 'useable' seats. Why would you want something that looks dull and saloon like or god forbid a hatchback when you could have these?

Failing that I have always had a thing for the Ferrari Mondial.
I think that depends on your definition of 'usable', if your rear occupants are >5 feet tall then their experience won't be overtly comfortable. As for a Mondial, I recall being crammed in to the back of one of those; I had to sit sideways with my feet in the footwell behind the driver and backside parked in the seat behind the passenger, so very uncomfortable and not really a 4 seater - perhaps a 2+1 or 2+0.5?

Om

1,811 posts

79 months

Wednesday 1st May
quotequote all
CKY said:
Om said:
For me, perhaps a Maserati - Gransport or Granturismo. Gorgeous looking 2 door with fantastic engines that also happen to have 4 'useable' seats. Why would you want something that looks dull and saloon like or god forbid a hatchback when you could have these?

Failing that I have always had a thing for the Ferrari Mondial.
I think that depends on your definition of 'usable', if your rear occupants are >5 feet tall then their experience won't be overtly comfortable. As for a Mondial, I recall being crammed in to the back of one of those; I had to sit sideways with my feet in the footwell behind the driver and backside parked in the seat behind the passenger, so very uncomfortable and not really a 4 seater - perhaps a 2+1 or 2+0.5?
For me, useable is something where you can fit a pair of average people in the back for a half hour trip to a pub. I would far rather do this in something like the Maserati than in a dull repmobile, examples of which you can see stretching out into eternity on any street in the land.

Om

1,811 posts

79 months

Wednesday 1st May
quotequote all
I may have changed my mind:


Glenn63

2,841 posts

85 months

Wednesday 1st May
quotequote all
Om said:
I may have changed my mind:

Ooff I’d daily that

CKY

1,436 posts

16 months

Wednesday 1st May
quotequote all
Om said:
CKY said:
Om said:
For me, perhaps a Maserati - Gransport or Granturismo. Gorgeous looking 2 door with fantastic engines that also happen to have 4 'useable' seats. Why would you want something that looks dull and saloon like or god forbid a hatchback when you could have these?

Failing that I have always had a thing for the Ferrari Mondial.
I think that depends on your definition of 'usable', if your rear occupants are >5 feet tall then their experience won't be overtly comfortable. As for a Mondial, I recall being crammed in to the back of one of those; I had to sit sideways with my feet in the footwell behind the driver and backside parked in the seat behind the passenger, so very uncomfortable and not really a 4 seater - perhaps a 2+1 or 2+0.5?
For me, useable is something where you can fit a pair of average people in the back for a half hour trip to a pub. I would far rather do this in something like the Maserati than in a dull repmobile, examples of which you can see stretching out into eternity on any street in the land.
I'd pay to watch 4 average blokes get in to a Ferrari Mondial for a trip back from the pub; they weren't a viable 4 seater when new, so given humanity's penchant for expanding with each passing generation, i'd imagine half the place would be watching the various acts of contortion and bending with increasing hilarity from the hospitality of the bar.

Even a Maserati GranTurismo is snug in the rear for someone of 6 feet tall, amusing really when you look at the length of the bloody things...

bodhi

10,641 posts

230 months

Wednesday 1st May
quotequote all
Sticking to the original 4 seater brief it would be this for me:



An enormous amount of fun and from running one of the cooking models for a while can confirm you can get 4 adults in one, as long as they're flexible enough for the entry process (ooh err matron etc etc).

Marquezs Stabilisers

1,270 posts

62 months

Wednesday 1st May
quotequote all
ThunderSpook said:
My 911 has 4 seats.
I once had to do Sharjah to Abu Dhabi and back, wedged into the rear of a 996. It was not in the least comfortable, even turned through 90 degrees. You can, but it's not fun...

Marquezs Stabilisers

1,270 posts

62 months

Wednesday 1st May
quotequote all
Pressed send too early. I'd have to nominate my own car: huge boot, space for five grown ups, fast as you'll ever need.


biggbn

23,627 posts

221 months

Wednesday 1st May
quotequote all
Pistom said:
Anything with poor fuel economy is out as a car can't be great if it's thirsty all the time. It could be good but not truly great.

Anything which is small or uncomfortable is out as - what's the point of an uncomfortable car when there's more comfortable ones. They can be fun and practical but not truly great

Obviously it can't be and EV as they're solution to a problem we haven't got. They've got lots of great qualities but are not yet truly great.

That leaves a lot of possibles - I guess at the top of the list - it would probably be this.



2cv and Renault 4/5 mk1 are small but epically comfortable. I'd daily either. One of the great forgotten people's cars is the mk1 Panda, a perfect piece of industrial design, right down to its flat glass, rubber mat floors and hammock dash and seats. I'd love another 750l !!!

LankyMcTally

307 posts

98 months

Wednesday 1st May
quotequote all
Discendo Discimus said:
For me it's the BMW E39 M5 in Oxford green with the baseball tan interior.

Can't afford one myself, or to fuel one, or to maintain one, but gosh they got it right with that car.
My chosen spec too.


V 02

2,061 posts

61 months

Wednesday 1st May
quotequote all
Aston Martin Rapide, just because it is one of the best big GT cars to have ever been built, and a hugely underrated car to drive and own.



Edited by V 02 on Wednesday 1st May 23:59

PomBstard

6,820 posts

243 months

Wednesday 1st May
quotequote all
Porsche 928 GTS
BMW E28 M5
HSV GenF2 GTSR - manual, rwd, 650bhp with seats for 5 adults

And probably lots of others too but those three for now

B'stard Child

28,469 posts

247 months

Thursday 2nd May
quotequote all
Marquezs Stabilisers said:
Pressed send too early. I'd have to nominate my own car: huge boot, space for five grown ups, fast as you'll ever need.

Looks like a thread title change has opened up the options to include 5 seats biggrin

Probably because no one reads the thread title anyway

B'stard Child

28,469 posts

247 months

Thursday 2nd May
quotequote all
Marquezs Stabilisers said:
ThunderSpook said:
My 911 has 4 seats.
I once had to do Sharjah to Abu Dhabi and back, wedged into the rear of a 996. It was not in the least comfortable, even turned through 90 degrees. You can, but it's not fun...
I had to do Kings Lynn to Norwich (so 30 miles) I’ll walk next time - they are sears in name only for anyone over the age of 5

Chris944_S2

1,920 posts

224 months

Thursday 2nd May
quotequote all
EVO gave the 2018 Cupra R 4/5, that would probably be my pick.
https://www.evo.co.uk/seat/leon/cupra-r

Rob 131 Sport

2,570 posts

53 months

Thursday 2nd May
quotequote all
LankyMcTally said:
Discendo Discimus said:
For me it's the BMW E39 M5 in Oxford green with the baseball tan interior.

Can't afford one myself, or to fuel one, or to maintain one, but gosh they got it right with that car.
My chosen spec too.

I much prefer the styling of the E34 as the E39 was a touch bland.

In this particular model, the Green is great, although I much prefer a black interior to brown.