981 GT4

Author
Discussion

gtsralph

1,189 posts

145 months

Sunday 1st December 2019
quotequote all
ChrisW. said:
There must also be some reason why the 718GT4 Clubsport has retained the 981 engine which is untimed for racing.
I think it is simply because the new engine just wasn't ready in time for 2019 season, particularly considering a 6-9 months lead-time to finalise Clubsport design, test, procure components etc to meet their Daytona Roar deadline.

TDT

4,952 posts

120 months

Sunday 1st December 2019
quotequote all
gtsralph said:
ChrisW. said:
There must also be some reason why the 718GT4 Clubsport has retained the 981 engine which is untimed for racing.
I think it is simply because the new engine just wasn't ready in time for 2019 season, particularly considering a 6-9 months lead-time to finalise Clubsport design, test, procure components etc to meet their Daytona Roar deadline.
Yep this is true, but it’s also true that the new engine will not go into the 718 Clubsport for this cars lifecycle.

So non-motorsport engine in the 718… lol. Remember all the foolish conversation about that last time… discuss…

As Chris says though, the 3.8 will show out being the easier unit to modify. It ran 430hp in the 911 GTS and easily can get to 430 in the GT4 with just bolt-ons. Take it to 4.0, 4.25 or 4.5 and you’ve got nearly 500hp. All cost money but the block is all but bulletproof.

Ride can easily be sorted to at least match the 718, just a PASM tune as the hardware is exactly the same. So 981 owner have loads of options, DSC, KW, Ohlins, JRZ.

Tyres are the same, and most of the 718 performance gain in laptime is from the tyres. So a wash.

718 has cleaner aero, not sure this will make much difference to most people, sounds like a lot of these cars won’t see the track anyway.

Apart from the rear wing, 718 does look good though, nice visual update. It has grown on me as I have the privilege of spending time up close and personal with a 718 Clubsport. More to come.

The Spyder is the one to have, no question… it’s a new thing.… but it’s ethos has changed. Is that for good or bad?

Edited by TDT on Sunday 1st December 09:39

Twinfan

10,125 posts

105 months

Sunday 1st December 2019
quotequote all
I thought I read that the rear suspension on the 718 GT4 was different, more like the GT3 in design?

I also think the new 4.0 is a big unknown as yet, it's a bit early to be writing it off...

TDT

4,952 posts

120 months

Sunday 1st December 2019
quotequote all
Twinfan said:
I thought I read that the rear suspension on the 718 GT4 was different, more like the GT3 in design?
No it’s different than the rest of the 718 range.
But it’s a GT4 setup… exactly the same as the 981 GT4. I’ve been under the cars, and you can see it in the press pack cut aways.

Twinfan said:
I also think the new 4.0 is a big unknown as yet, it's a bit early to be writing it off...
Not writing it off, but it’s is more complicated as more going on, more computer controls for auto-start-stop and cylinder de-activations. Sure it can all be worked around it’s a less old school approach and there may be less margin in it in the current configuration in the GT4/Spyder and the 911 won’t be getting it apparently.
So to get more power Porsche will give us more exotic stuff, titanium parts etc… this won’t be as easy to get a hold of as an IPD plenum, GT3 TB and Cobb tune.
But we’ll see.

Taffy66

5,964 posts

103 months

Sunday 1st December 2019
quotequote all
Very interesting info Tyrone about the similarities between the 981 GT4 and 718 GT4..I'd wrongly assumed that there would have been some minor hardware changes on top of software updates..It makes perfect sense to me to fit a DSC controller to a 981 GT4 along with some of the aforementioned engine updates up to 430PS..
The new Spyder is a different proposition as it has been seriously updated over the 981 version..Whether or not this is a good or bad thing depends on the owners usage.

Twinfan

10,125 posts

105 months

Sunday 1st December 2019
quotequote all
Gotcha.

I think for existing owners it makes sense to stick with what you've got. For me, having a brand new car to my spec is worth the extra £15k-ish. I refuse to pay overs too.

TDT

4,952 posts

120 months

Sunday 1st December 2019
quotequote all
Taffy66 said:
Very interesting info Tyrone about the similarities between the 981 GT4 and 718 GT4..I'd wrongly assumed that there would have been some minor hardware changes on top of software updates..It makes perfect sense to me to fit a DSC controller to a 981 GT4 along with some of the aforementioned engine updates up to 430PS..
The new Spyder is a different proposition as it has been seriously updated over the 981 version..Whether or not this is a good or bad thing depends on the owners usage.
Yep.

Ref suspension I’ve got a DSC on order… thanks Black Friday. So can wait to do a full review. Also driving the new 718 twins on Thursday. Will probably drive my 981 GT4 there in order to have immediate comparisons.

Twinfan said:
Gotcha.

I think for existing owners it makes sense to stick with what you've got. For me, having a brand new car to my spec is worth the extra £15k-ish. I refuse to pay overs too.
Yep, allows more people to have one, which is a good thing.

To me ultimately the 718 GT4 shows what a good job Porsche did on 981 the first time out with the core formula.
However it proves even more that Porsche are limiting this car to keep it under GT3. Of course it’s their hierarchy… I wonder if the GT4 RS will really break out of the chains, and at what £££.
By that time the new 992 GT3 and maybe RS will be out so the GT4 RS will have more room to play in.

Twinfan

10,125 posts

105 months

Sunday 1st December 2019
quotequote all
I think the biggest limit is the maximum torque in order to use the existing manual gearbox. The 718 GT4 has it spread over a wider range, but the maximum is the same.

It's it really that expensive to develop a new box? They've done a whole new engine which most cost more. So they're potentially using that as a forced restriction to maintain the GT3 superiority?

GT4RS will be PDK only IMHO, as the current manual box won't be able to take a torque increase.

Edited by Twinfan on Sunday 1st December 14:50

04BAP

Original Poster:

113 posts

57 months

Sunday 1st December 2019
quotequote all
Some very good points been raised, look forward to the RS version and would love to have one but in reality that's not going to happen so will enjoy the 981 GT4 for what it is, will one day make the step up to a 991.2 GT3 as that is the only car on offer that interests me at the moment

Twinfan

10,125 posts

105 months

Sunday 1st December 2019
quotequote all
I considered a 991.2 GT3, but I'd want a Touring. So I'll take a new 718 GT4 at half the price instead thanks smile

av185

18,560 posts

128 months

Sunday 1st December 2019
quotequote all
04BAP said:
Some very good points been raised, look forward to the RS version and would love to have one but in reality that's not going to happen so will enjoy the 981 GT4 for what it is, will one day make the step up to a 991.2 GT3 as that is the only car on offer that interests me at the moment
The 981 GT4 and 991.2 GT3 make a good contrasting pair.

arcamalpha

1,076 posts

165 months

Sunday 1st December 2019
quotequote all
Anyone know the white car at porsche bristol? Good history?

ChrisW.

6,347 posts

256 months

Sunday 1st December 2019
quotequote all
I believe the 50% increase in downforce of the 718GT4 amounted to around 12Kg's at what speed ? 200 kph ?

Yes I also will be very interested to see the spec of the GT4RS ... and dto be fair, I would be very happy with the latest PDK.

I'm certainly not writing off the new 4.0l engine ... it is great that Porsche listened and gave us NA whilst integrating particulate filters ... I really hope that these do not cause the same issues that they have in many diesel cars.

Maybe this makes the best possible case for the electric sports car ?

All we need is the power generating capacity ... but unless storage capacity for weight increases, these will be either lightweight short range, or comparative heavyweights ... and we all know the costs of this.

Even though we live in a golden age, I believe most of us do have an energy conscience. Why waste it ?

Of course, product lifecycle plays a very relevant part of the big picture.

Andyoz

2,890 posts

55 months

Sunday 1st December 2019
quotequote all
arcamalpha said:
Anyone know the white car at porsche bristol? Good history?
Not sure but it looks nice.

It's interesting there's alot of private sales with similar 10-15k mileage heading into the low £70's.

I wonder which seller will go sub £70k first?

Onetrackmind

813 posts

214 months

Monday 2nd December 2019
quotequote all
When is the 982 GT4 out of warranty. I’m in the UAE and most of the GT4 cars here are 2016s so these come out of warranty soon, meaning there should be a drop in value, hopefully. I’m considering getting out of my 996 turbo and into a 981 GT4.

Twinfan

10,125 posts

105 months

Monday 2nd December 2019
quotequote all
TDT said:
As Chris says though, the 3.8 will show out being the easier unit to modify. It ran 430hp in the 911 GTS and easily can get to 430 in the GT4 with just bolt-ons. Take it to 4.0, 4.25 or 4.5 and you’ve got nearly 500hp. All cost money but the block is all but bulletproof.
Been thinking about this. As I say above, the gearbox in the 981 GT4 is the issue for tuning as you'd be using it over its rated torque capacity. It might be fine, but it might not. In the 911 GTS the engine was paired with PDK or the 911's 7-speed manual so it wasn't an issue.

Taffy66

5,964 posts

103 months

Monday 2nd December 2019
quotequote all
Twinfan said:
Been thinking about this. As I say above, the gearbox in the 981 GT4 is the issue for tuning as you'd be using it over its rated torque capacity. It might be fine, but it might not. In the 911 GTS the engine was paired with PDK or the 911's 7-speed manual so it wasn't an issue.
Just make sure 2016 GT4s with the welded 3rd gear has already had the updated version done as the recall campaign..Once Porsche find its been tuned above the 310 lb/ft gearbox torque limit i can't see them honouring it.

gtsralph

1,189 posts

145 months

Monday 2nd December 2019
quotequote all
TDT said:
As Chris says though, the 3.8 will show out being the easier unit to modify. It ran 430hp in the 911 GTS and easily can get to 430 in the GT4 with just bolt-ons. Take it to 4.0, 4.25 or 4.5 and you’ve got nearly 500hp. All cost money but the block is all but bulletproof.
Not with "just" bolt-ons, you need a tune. People like Jake Raby have been building large capacity engines since the 9x6 era and there is no reason to suppose the 9A2 crankcase is any worse and indeed with improved oiling and variable exhaust camshaft it will have more potential than the 9A1.

With the larger capacity engines, whilst they all seem to be tried and tested by the builders, they will be increasing the bore, so thinner cylinder walls and what is the longevity of whatever cylinder liner they are able to apply? This was my main concern when looking at an Ehresmann big-bore. Better in my view to go with more aggressive cam profiles and improving the gas flow by machining the heads, essentially leaving the bottom end alone. But of course the ECU only supports up to 8.1k rpm so there is a limit to building a screamer.

The ECU for the 718 will be broken in the new year and off we go again. Maybe 450PS without low cell manifolds. The new issue will be the GPF and it's ability to handle the flow rate, but it is a large cross section design so better able to do so.

In Germany, tuners are likely to find their market more constrained than previously because penalties for running outside emissions certificate (non TUV or "export") kit is likely to be more rigorously tested and penalised in the current green environment.

My two penny worth.

Twinfan

10,125 posts

105 months

Monday 2nd December 2019
quotequote all
TDT said:
Twinfan said:
I thought I read that the rear suspension on the 718 GT4 was different, more like the GT3 in design?
No it’s different than the rest of the 718 range.
But it’s a GT4 setup… exactly the same as the 981 GT4. I’ve been under the cars, and you can see it in the press pack cut aways.
AP claims it's all new for the 718 here: (Skip to 6:40)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qqW-cQPL6tE

Top Gear also claim it's new (https://www.topgear.com/car-reviews/porsche/gt4-2dr-auto/first-drive):

"The suspension package is largely carried over. The front end has much in common with the 911 GT3, including the brakes (carbon ceramics are on the options list), but now more GT3 has made it into the back axle, too, including the subframe, upside-down dampers, longitudinal and transverse control arms and ball joints. It’s all in the name of control and precision."

av185

18,560 posts

128 months

Monday 2nd December 2019
quotequote all
So the rear suspension on the718 GT4 is nothing like the 981 GT4 then.