M3 E46 MPG

M3 E46 MPG

Author
Discussion

nottyash

Original Poster:

4,670 posts

196 months

Wednesday 17th December 2008
quotequote all
Well after picking up my M3 last weekend and driving it the 290 miles to work I was managing just over 31MPG around 80MPH.
When I upped my speed slightly I still averaged over 29MPG
At a 10 mile stretch on the M1 near Nottingham there are average speed cameras and a 50MPH speed limit. I set it on cruise to 50MPH and reset the MPG computer......After 10 miles....47.8MPG!!!
I am amazed at the MPG these cars achieve, and am so happy i bought it. A trip to the pumps and some mathematics proves the figures right.

Does everyone else get this or are you all heavy footed?


Cactussed

5,292 posts

214 months

Wednesday 17th December 2008
quotequote all
I get similar figures from my E36...

unzippy

67 posts

239 months

Wednesday 17th December 2008
quotequote all
Well I never!

I imagine if you drove at 40mph in 6th it would be even better?


If you bought Polo Bluemotion you could get even better mpg...

rolleyes

duff

984 posts

200 months

Wednesday 17th December 2008
quotequote all
unzippy said:
Well I never!

I imagine if you drove at 40mph in 6th it would be even better?


If you bought Polo Bluemotion you could get even better mpg...

rolleyes
The point is that it's capable of good mpg, probably thanks in part to the 6 speed 'box. If you're doing lots of motorway miles then this is useful - just because you have an M car doesn't mean you have to use the power all of the time, so the fact that it CAN be economical is good. I'm sure there are plenty of Subaru owners who'd love to get 40mpg on their motorway commute.

smaller

1,003 posts

204 months

Wednesday 17th December 2008
quotequote all
I also got one last weekend, and have managed about 25mpg. But then I'm driving it in the way God intended.

How can you not hoon it in the first week of ownership?

Twincharged

1,851 posts

206 months

Wednesday 17th December 2008
quotequote all
smaller said:
I also got one last weekend, and have managed about 25mpg. But then I'm driving it in the way God intended.

How can you not hoon it in the first week of ownership?
Well he sort of explained with the 50mph limit and the speed cameras. Owning an M Car doesn't require you to drive like your trousers are on fire everywhere. I know the first few weeks of ownership it is tempting, but better still is keeping your licence so you can enjoy the car for longer wink

Toilet Duck

1,329 posts

186 months

Wednesday 17th December 2008
quotequote all
nottyash said:
Well after picking up my M3 last weekend and driving it the 290 miles to work I was managing just over 31MPG around 80MPH.
When I upped my speed slightly I still averaged over 29MPG
At a 10 mile stretch on the M1 near Nottingham there are average speed cameras and a 50MPH speed limit. I set it on cruise to 50MPH and reset the MPG computer......After 10 miles....47.8MPG!!!
I am amazed at the MPG these cars achieve, and am so happy i bought it. A trip to the pumps and some mathematics proves the figures right.

Does everyone else get this or are you all heavy footed?
This is a pointless test. You might as well reset the MPG counter, put the car in neutral and coast down a massive hill and see what amazing MPG figure you get. I've got a diesel shopping trolley for work, if I put that in neutral on a slope the real time MPG counter has shown an indicated 180MPG, but of course this figure is just as 100% useless as it has no bearing on reality.

Taking your "reading" does not include accelerating up to 50mph or the stop/start journey on the way to the motorway etc, its absolutely pointless. Try doing the same test but starting your car from cold, reseting the counter and then drive to the motorway and do your 50mph test. Who drives at 50mph on the motorway for 10 miles anyway in the real world?

M3's do not achieve good MPG, its as simple as that. For what its worth, my total average is 24 point something (can't remember exactly), and can get 28MPG on the motorway if driving on empty roads with cruise on at sensible speeds (MPG includes starting car from cold and driving from my house to the motorway). I really don't see why some M3 (and other performance car) owners are obsessed with MPG figures.

Toilet Duck

1,329 posts

186 months

Wednesday 17th December 2008
quotequote all
duff said:
The point is that it's capable of good mpg
But its NOT capable of "good" MPG unless you think somewhere in the region of low-mid 20's is a "good" MPG


duff said:
I'm sure there are plenty of Subaru owners who'd love to get 40mpg on their motorway commute.
I'm sure if you did 30mph in top gear in a Subaru or coasted down a hill in neutral you would get 40MPG. These tests would be as equally useful as the 40MPG "achieved" by the M3 in this post.

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

225 months

Wednesday 17th December 2008
quotequote all
I agree, these cars will average 25mpg for someone doing quite a few miles, and for someone who is not sat in traffic very often it will be around the 20mpg mark.

Unless the whole tank full is steady motorway work 30mpg per tank is going to be a very rare thing.

unzippy

67 posts

239 months

Wednesday 17th December 2008
quotequote all
Exactly, I use the train for work and the M3 for fun, I get just under 200 miles to a tank.

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

225 months

Thursday 18th December 2008
quotequote all
unzippy said:
Exactly, I use the train for work and the M3 for fun, I get just under 200 miles to a tank.
I have an E320 Estate for most things and keep the M3 for when I'm on my own and want to have fun, I am averaging around 18ish, and get about 200 miles to a tank.

996 sps

6,165 posts

217 months

Thursday 18th December 2008
quotequote all
Nottyash as long as your happy good for you, sounds like some are a bit bitter that you stated the MPG, i'm interested don't have the luxury of 2 cars and can not wait to buy an E46 M3, and will be driving to Birmingham and Manchester in it fairly often.

Looking at one tommorrow all going well.

duff

984 posts

200 months

Thursday 18th December 2008
quotequote all
Toilet Duck said:
duff said:
The point is that it's capable of good mpg
But its NOT capable of "good" MPG unless you think somewhere in the region of low-mid 20's is a "good" MPG


duff said:
I'm sure there are plenty of Subaru owners who'd love to get 40mpg on their motorway commute.
I'm sure if you did 30mph in top gear in a Subaru or coasted down a hill in neutral you would get 40MPG. These tests would be as equally useful as the 40MPG "achieved" by the M3 in this post.
I think you're missing the point. What I'm saying is that cars that offer similar performance to an M3 (eg an Impreza) will be unlikely to achieve as good an mpg under the same conditions. I get mid 20's overall and that's fine, but if I have a long M'way drive I'll get mid 30's - my friend who owns an Impreza would never get over 30mpg.

You don't buy these sorts of cars if you worry too much about mpg however given the nature of the car it's mpg when driven sensibly is quite impressive, which I think is all the OP was pointing out.



Rawhide

964 posts

214 months

Thursday 18th December 2008
quotequote all
I got 31mpg when I first picked my car up and was suprised and impressed. However I was driving on the motorway like miss Daisy and had reset the trip from warm.

I was going to post my suprise but found subsequently that the MPG is nowhere near as good if you include the cold engine running periods in the equation.

My commute is almost 15 miles of straight slow moving traffic around 40mph and I can only achieve 23ish mpg. Thats with minimal right foot due to the traffic conditions.

Factor in the cold start and the MPG performance drops off quite a lot.

cosmos_steve

49 posts

218 months

Thursday 18th December 2008
quotequote all
My average fuel consumption on my e46 M3 is 18.4mph (over last 4 months). This includes the occasional motorway trip, but mostly a heavy traffic congested commute across London.

mat205125

17,790 posts

214 months

Thursday 18th December 2008
quotequote all
Toilet Duck said:
duff said:
I'm sure there are plenty of Subaru owners who'd love to get 40mpg on their motorway commute.
I'm sure if you did 30mph in top gear in a Subaru or coasted down a hill in neutral you would get 40MPG. These tests would be as equally useful as the 40MPG "achieved" by the M3 in this post.
For the same peak BHP, there is not a Scooby or an Evo ever made that will match an E36 or E46 M3 for average miles per gallon on a "normal" commute.

M3's are thirsty when you press on, however can return good mpg on a run. A scooby or evo will just drink and drink and drink. Also, given that they have a hip flask instead of a fuel tank, the "quicker" evo will be beaten by a blue motion on a long run due to the frequency of the fuel stops - come on tortoise!! wink

nottyash

Original Poster:

4,670 posts

196 months

Thursday 18th December 2008
quotequote all
Wow, Some people are missing the point completely.
When i drive fast i achieve 23 MPG. When I drive on the UK roads at UK road speeds I achieved the figures stated.
I have A Toyota Starlet Glanza turbo which is only a 1.3 and that isnt as good on the 300 mile trips (average 28mpg).

Those who mentioned Subarus I can vouch as I had one and it was terrible.

I am not a penny pincher trying to save the planet, only mentioning what an achievment this engine is.

JNW1

7,803 posts

195 months

Thursday 18th December 2008
quotequote all
I agree that the E46 M3 is relatively efficient given the performance it provides but I can't see anyone getting average mpg figures starting with a 3 unless they're doing a lot of motorway miles and sticking to the speed limit (which is fine but why buy an M3 to do that?).

I reckon my M3 CS beats the combined figure by about 10% providing I don't do too many short runs or round town driving but being realistic mid-20's is where it's at. Like I say, not bad given the performance although to be fair the heavier 335i has similar urge in a straight line and in day to day driving would be at least 5 mpg better if the combined figures are to be believed; such is progress....!

M3RMS

1,134 posts

214 months

Friday 19th December 2008
quotequote all
I've had a couple of E46 M3's now and as yet have not managed to achieve 30mgp on any journey - including some long, boring, traffic heavy, 200 mile trips up to Manchester.

The best I got was 29mpg once but censored me it was dull and not something I would ever set out deliberately to acheive. But fair enough to any of you who are trying to keep the fuel bills down.

I don't drive like a lunatic but I do try and make the most of one of my all-time favourite cars. That's why I bought it. The result seems to be 21/22 mpg on average.

My advice would be to turn off the mpg display. And the one that tells you how many miles are left. They're never going to deliver good news!!!

M3RMS

1,134 posts

214 months

Friday 19th December 2008
quotequote all
nottyash said:
I set it on cruise to 50MPH and reset the MPG computer......After 10 miles....47.8MPG!!!
My honest opinion would be that your trip computer needs recalibrating. I remember doing something similar myself once in one of those 50mph restriction areas and I think it gave me low 30 something. I can't see any scenario where 35+ is acheivable, unless you're coasting.

But I'm off on another jaunt this weekend so will see if I can replicate and report back on Monday!

I have got it in my head that my old Manual returned slightly better mpg than my current SMG. But I'd imagine that's bull censored

Anyway, enjoy the car! And get your foot to the floor man!!!

Cheers
RS