Good BMW indie near Leeds
Good BMW indie near Leeds
Author
Discussion

The_Doc

6,104 posts

246 months

Wednesday 18th February 2009
quotequote all
Mr Whippy said:
ted 191 said:
If you need a main dealer to reprogram things, speak to Kim, the after sales manager at Scotthall, and tell him Chris sent you
Sounds like an option to explore, Scotthall are actually the closest garage to me pretty much... thanks Chris.

My only other bugbear with BMW is their parts department close at midday on a Saturday, and I don't get up until then hehe
Don't bother with Scothall. Rubbish "airport lounge" style service desk, rubbish communication with the mechanics, purely profit driven approach to service jobs (as opposed to helping you getting back on the road) Unhelpful in service booking. Unhelpful in courtesy car. Unhelpful chauffeur driver (I can take you 1.5 miles to town, but not 1.5 miles to Meanwood) Extortionate hourly rate and padding of simple jobs out to whole hours. Unwilling to accept they are wrong when an attempt at solving a problem doesn't work (you still are made to pay for the part)

Do you want me to continue? These are my experiences above. Fact.

Seriously, I wouldn't p*ss on them if they were on fire.

Mr Whippy

Original Poster:

32,453 posts

267 months

Thursday 19th February 2009
quotequote all
speed8 said:
They always have M cars there, prices are good and you can get a courtesy car if you need one (although it won't be a new spangly thing). I'll be booking in soon to get the car serviced before sale.

How you finding the Z4?
The Z4 is going ok. Just niggles and jobs to get sorted really. The garage I got it from were 100% useless, so I don't really want to use them because no doubt they'll make a small problem worse rolleyes (decided, much like with my Peugeot, that DIY is always the best option, I don't feel I can trust anyone to do a good job despite them being PAID to do it, grrr) Will try B&M though as they sound good smile


Generally very fun though, not THAT fast, if you are not 100% on the boil it's not that much quicker than things like an ST170 Focus... ie, leave a roundabout smoothly (read slower because it's slippy) in 3rd vs an ST170 screaming off in 2nd into the understeer, and you won't make any headway until you are at speeds where you want to start slowing down anyway...

But that isn't why I bought it anyway. Even my 306 HDi was maybe easier to go a fair bit quicker on alot of roads but that is why in the end I changed cars. Easy speed isn't a positive thing in my book, I wanted a challenge so that to go quickly I actually have to try hard!


Currently, stupidly, looking at ESS superchargers... fairly cheap all said and done hehe

Dave

Edited by Mr Whippy on Thursday 19th February 09:41

Mr Whippy

Original Poster:

32,453 posts

267 months

Thursday 19th February 2009
quotequote all
The_Doc said:
Mr Whippy said:
ted 191 said:
If you need a main dealer to reprogram things, speak to Kim, the after sales manager at Scotthall, and tell him Chris sent you
Sounds like an option to explore, Scotthall are actually the closest garage to me pretty much... thanks Chris.

My only other bugbear with BMW is their parts department close at midday on a Saturday, and I don't get up until then hehe
Don't bother with Scothall. Rubbish "airport lounge" style service desk, rubbish communication with the mechanics, purely profit driven approach to service jobs (as opposed to helping you getting back on the road) Unhelpful in service booking. Unhelpful in courtesy car. Unhelpful chauffeur driver (I can take you 1.5 miles to town, but not 1.5 miles to Meanwood) Extortionate hourly rate and padding of simple jobs out to whole hours. Unwilling to accept they are wrong when an attempt at solving a problem doesn't work (you still are made to pay for the part)

Do you want me to continue? These are my experiences above. Fact.

Seriously, I wouldn't p*ss on them if they were on fire.
I've read a few poor reports from lots of BMW dealerships on Z4-forum...

I guess like any garage that gets too big and seperated from the customer then communication standards start to slip and costs/administration increase and make it less what a person having their P&J worked on wants from a garage.

Personally I'm tempted to just do the lot DIY after the next oil service, as I know I can trust me 100% every time biggrin

I'm so untrusting infact, I want to buy a tyre machine to do those as well hehe

Tis just the electronics gubbins, but Carsoft looks pretty good now I read into it all a bit more, cough.

Dave

Edited by Mr Whippy on Thursday 19th February 09:46

speed8

5,122 posts

299 months

Thursday 19th February 2009
quotequote all
Mr Whippy said:
The_Doc said:
Mr Whippy said:
ted 191 said:
If you need a main dealer to reprogram things, speak to Kim, the after sales manager at Scotthall, and tell him Chris sent you
Sounds like an option to explore, Scotthall are actually the closest garage to me pretty much... thanks Chris.

My only other bugbear with BMW is their parts department close at midday on a Saturday, and I don't get up until then hehe
Don't bother with Scothall. Rubbish "airport lounge" style service desk, rubbish communication with the mechanics, purely profit driven approach to service jobs (as opposed to helping you getting back on the road) Unhelpful in service booking. Unhelpful in courtesy car. Unhelpful chauffeur driver (I can take you 1.5 miles to town, but not 1.5 miles to Meanwood) Extortionate hourly rate and padding of simple jobs out to whole hours. Unwilling to accept they are wrong when an attempt at solving a problem doesn't work (you still are made to pay for the part)

Do you want me to continue? These are my experiences above. Fact.

Seriously, I wouldn't p*ss on them if they were on fire.
I've read a few poor reports from lots of BMW dealerships on Z4-forum...

I guess like any garage that gets too big and seperated from the customer then communication standards start to slip and costs/administration increase and make it less what a person having their P&J worked on wants from a garage.

Personally I'm tempted to just do the lot DIY after the next oil service, as I know I can trust me 100% every time biggrin

I'm so untrusting infact, I want to buy a tyre machine to do those as well hehe

Tis just the electronics gubbins, but Carsoft looks pretty good now I read into it all a bit more, cough.

Dave

Edited by Mr Whippy on Thursday 19th February 09:46
I agree about ScottHall. I use them for parts only. I asked them about a job as I didn't really have the time for it and they wanted £400 to fit a £20 quid part. I decided to find the time to do it (only took me a couple of hours in the end).

Jagdpanther

19,633 posts

245 months

Thursday 19th February 2009
quotequote all
speed8 said:
Yeah, sadly the coupe is going (not that I want to sell it). The simple reason being that since Juniorspeed8 arrived I haven't really used it and don't want it to just sit in the garage.

Thought about replacing it with a 911 or an M6 with the way prices are just now but while he's still in a pram it would probably get used just as much as the coupe (and the 6 wouldn't fit in the garage). Practicality suggests something like a Golf R32 for a year or two as I fancy smallish and nippy rather than big and fast. The 4WD will help when I go off snowboarding too.

frown
Price of M5's are coming down nicely, 4 doors too smile it's almost sensible hehe

Bemmer

1,195 posts

228 months

Thursday 19th February 2009
quotequote all
As mentioned before CRAMAG at www.cramag.com Near Leeds&Bradford Airport They have been there Donkeys years and seem good,and have some nice cars on sale.

speed8

5,122 posts

299 months

Thursday 19th February 2009
quotequote all
Jagdpanther said:
speed8 said:
Yeah, sadly the coupe is going (not that I want to sell it). The simple reason being that since Juniorspeed8 arrived I haven't really used it and don't want it to just sit in the garage.

Thought about replacing it with a 911 or an M6 with the way prices are just now but while he's still in a pram it would probably get used just as much as the coupe (and the 6 wouldn't fit in the garage). Practicality suggests something like a Golf R32 for a year or two as I fancy smallish and nippy rather than big and fast. The 4WD will help when I go off snowboarding too.

frown
Price of M5's are coming down nicely, 4 doors too smile it's almost sensible hehe
I know but it's the size thing. I want something that Paola will drive if I borrow her car. She's only just got used to driving a diesel Jag estate and parking in the drive. If I ask her to squeeze an M5 sized thing in and out of the garage she'll have a canary. Golf seems sensible as most other things that size are FWD, only other smallish thing is the 130i but not entirely keen on them.

Could always get a Mk1 Escort (always fancied one) biggrin

Mr Whippy

Original Poster:

32,453 posts

267 months

Thursday 19th February 2009
quotequote all
135Ci!

You know it makes sense. Remap to get 400bhp under the bonnet. Fingers crossed that in a year or so it will surprise us with cult classic future status and good residual performance (no bad thing right now, and a nice thing after having an E36 M Coupe!)

If an R32 is on the cards, how about the A3 Quattro 3.2... cheaper for much the same thing and a lot more understated. Not sure if they drive much differently though.

Tough choice as there is alot around in your price range scratchchin

Dave

Edited by Mr Whippy on Thursday 19th February 20:21

mccraddock

1 posts

157 months

Monday 20th May 2013
quotequote all
How did you find B&M Care?

I've got an airbag problem and initially took it to Grove Lane Garage. They advised that the problem related to the wire leading to the positive battery terminal or airbag control unit. I rang Cramag but they couldn't help but told me contact B&M.

I've read some mixed reviews about B&M on other forums, although on here the reviews are positive.

Was also considering Mad4Mini who reckon it was a wiring issue and that I was looking at £200-300 just for the part.(?)

johnfm

13,751 posts

276 months

Tuesday 21st May 2013
quotequote all
Richard at BMW care is a decent, straight up guy.

I have just had wife's car serviced by him.

They rang to let me know rear brakes will need doing soon. I have the discs and pads at home. They will fit them for £50 + Vat. Hardly worth doing it myself at those prices.

All that jazz

7,632 posts

172 months

Tuesday 21st May 2013
quotequote all
B&M were definitely thorough when I had my 330Cd. There was quite a lot that needed fixing on it and they provided me with a long list of advisories about them all when I picked it up after it'd been in for service.

FlashmanChop

1,300 posts

232 months

Friday 31st May 2013
quotequote all
I think the business model that is german autocare is spot on - I have found that the guys they employ are at the top of their game (from my experiences) and now they have a new facility to bring everything under a nice roof its a good customer experience. I find their honesty pleasant.

philmots

4,664 posts

286 months

Sunday 2nd June 2013
quotequote all
I find its worth the trip to Autohaus in York..

Guys are ex master and senior techs, got full Autologic etc.

StuB

6,695 posts

265 months

Tuesday 4th June 2013
quotequote all
Mr Whippy said:
Currently, stupidly, looking at ESS superchargers... fairly cheap all said and done hehe

Dave
Do IT!