Dieting help for an obese person with zero willpower
Dieting help for an obese person with zero willpower
Author
Discussion

smiffy180

6,029 posts

176 months

Thursday 30th May 2013
quotequote all
Hoofy ya cheeky bd! hehe

I'll have you know my fiancée is a rather nice curvy with massive knockers wink
And no I can't post a pic because she wants to trim up. Then I'll get one on my car and pretend I'm in max power magazine spin

As for this woman if she doesn't mind spending dosh as it seems, what about that diet chef where they deliver the meals and you microwave them and loose weight? She doesn't have to do fk all then except pay smile

SSC!

1,849 posts

206 months

Thursday 30th May 2013
quotequote all
You say you are offering to help but are you also willing to cook all her meals for her, as her daily diet suggests she goes nowhere near the kitchen appliances.


grumbledoak

32,466 posts

259 months

Thursday 30th May 2013
quotequote all
Offer her a deal: NO exercise but NO sugar and NO alcohol. Three months.

There's no way she can work off the weight with the sugar load she has. At least this sounds easy. If she does get past cold turkey the weight will fall off her, which might be enough to make her try a bit more.

mattikake

5,105 posts

225 months

Thursday 30th May 2013
quotequote all
TheJimi said:
A wholesale diet change isn't going to happen, it's just not feasible. That is obviously the medium-long term goal, but going nuclear straight off the bat is going to be utterly counter-productive.
It's the only feasible option for an addict... but first she needs it drilled in that she is an addict and addicted as much as any drug user such as a cocaine or heroin user. They are only ever cured by going teetotal.

TheJimi said:
She, like most in her position, has drifted in and out of various diets and bouts of exercising.
...otherwise ^this happens. Again and again and again. See? wink

The fix really is as simple as it is obvious. The hard bit is in breaking down the addicted-brain's barriers. "Addiction always speaks in the voice of excuses". Repeat that to her, everytime you hear an excuse. ANY reason she can come up with to slack, no matter how petty or feasible, is an excuse. 100%. Your battle (as is mine with new people all the time) is to get her to recognise the addiction, the excuses and how her mind works. Drill. Repeat. Nag. Pester. Push.

mu0n

2,348 posts

159 months

Thursday 30th May 2013
quotequote all
It can be pretty difficult to give up the comforts when you're depressed.

Is she depressed? Might be worth tackling the depression before her diet because diets and depression rarely work.

Rach*

8,824 posts

242 months

Thursday 30th May 2013
quotequote all
smiffy180 said:
Hoofy ya cheeky bd! hehe

I'll have you know my fiancée is a rather nice curvy with massive knockers wink
And no I can't post a pic because she wants to trim up. Then I'll get one on my car and pretend I'm in max power magazine spin

As for this woman if she doesn't mind spending dosh as it seems, what about that diet chef where they deliver the meals and you microwave them and loose weight? She doesn't have to do fk all then except pay smile
Noooo not diet chef! My friend just wasted a fortune on meals that were all high GI and she was starving and having sugar crashes all the time.

smiffy180

6,029 posts

176 months

Thursday 30th May 2013
quotequote all
Rach* said:
Noooo not diet chef! My friend just wasted a fortune on meals that were all high GI and she was starving and having sugar crashes all the time.
Fair enough I've only seen the advert smile

Rach*

8,824 posts

242 months

Thursday 30th May 2013
quotequote all
smiffy180 said:
Rach* said:
Noooo not diet chef! My friend just wasted a fortune on meals that were all high GI and she was starving and having sugar crashes all the time.
Fair enough I've only seen the advert smile
I should probably add something constructive....

She can only change if she wants to, she can look at her diet sheet and know she's eating a load of st. But she needs to bring the change about from within herself.
Be a good friend, don't nag or criticize.

Walking is an awesome fat burner, can you join her for a walk after work or something?

Funk

27,487 posts

235 months

Thursday 30th May 2013
quotequote all
I used the MFP app for a month or so and it gave me a surprising insight into my daily calorie consumption. Without actually really changing what I eat or my (extremely) low activity levels I've dropped around a stone in the last 2-3 months.

I now find myself thinking automatically about things like portion size, fat and calorie content whereas before I just carried on regardless. My weight took a long time to go on, it will take a long time to come off - and I don't really even feel like I'm 'dieting', I've just changed how much I eat mainly.

Hoofy

79,718 posts

308 months

Thursday 30th May 2013
quotequote all
smiffy180 said:
Hoofy ya cheeky bd! hehe

I'll have you know my fiancée is a rather nice curvy with massive knockers wink
And no I can't post a pic because she wants to trim up. Then I'll get one on my car and pretend I'm in max power magazine spin
biggrin Sorry.

I look forward to photos. Got the tissues ready.

Hoofy

79,718 posts

308 months

Thursday 30th May 2013
quotequote all
throt said:
Why does anyone need a bloody mid morning snack and a supper before beddie byes.
Well, in a way, you're right. Hunger's just a feeling... Oh boo-fking-hoo. She's hungry. I've been hungry since December 2011. She won't die unless she's already very ill, just recovering from an op or has a bodyfat% below 5 in which case we wouldn't be having this conversation. Tell her to just eat half of what she's eating now and don't change that pattern of eating for 2 years.

goldblum

10,272 posts

193 months

Thursday 30th May 2013
quotequote all
Hoofy said:
Tell her to just eat half of what she's eating now and don't change that pattern of eating for 2 years.
I'm afraid that will still probably be too much.

BlackVanDyke

9,932 posts

237 months

Friday 31st May 2013
quotequote all
SparkPeople is a bit nauseating on first impression but it's very, very, VERY good at helping people like your colleague take stock of where they are and work out what to do next.

I agree, this lady is only going to cope with tiny changes made gradually - I'd be inclined to start not by removing anything per se but by trying to add some fresh, tasty fruit/veg to her day, precut bags as it sounds like she doesn't really cook much, if necessary. Hopefully that and encouraging her to drink a lot more (cold water) will help her feel full and be a big step towards dropping the bags of crisps.


SunDiver

780 posts

263 months

Saturday 1st June 2013
quotequote all
Hoofy said:
Dinner
2 McDonalds plain cheeseburgers - 600kcals
1 large fries - 300kcals
1med diet coke - 1kcal
= 901kcals
Rather frighteningly, McDonalds' website lists large fries as 755kcals alone...!

Hoofy

79,718 posts

308 months

Saturday 1st June 2013
quotequote all
SunDiver said:
Rather frighteningly, McDonalds' website lists large fries as 755kcals alone...!
Even worse, then! Maybe the portion is bigger than I thought. How far out were my other estimates? biggrin

Alex106

1,007 posts

222 months

Saturday 1st June 2013
quotequote all
Hoofy said:
SunDiver said:
Rather frighteningly, McDonalds' website lists large fries as 755kcals alone...!
Even worse, then! Maybe the portion is bigger than I thought. How far out were my other estimates? biggrin
Their nutrition calculator suggests the large fries are 460. Cheeseburger comes in at 295. So 600 calories for two wasnt a bad guess!

ETA: http://www.mcdonalds.co.uk/ukhome/meal_builder.htm...

davepoth

29,395 posts

225 months

Saturday 1st June 2013
quotequote all
As always, it's an easy sum, Calories In has to be less than Calories Out.

The way most people try to do it is to cut down Calories In. That's hard to do quickly, your body wants the food too much. Calories out is just as important.

The stairs are a good first step, and shifting all that bulk will burn a lot of calories. Little things like that, putting movement into her lifestyle (which at a guess is drive to work, sit at desk, drive to M&S, Drive back, sit at desk, drive to McDs, drive home, sit to watch TV, bed) is the most important thing. Even walking to get the sandwich at lunch would be a good start.

Of all the things to cut out, she needs to start with the supper first IMO. The body will lay all of that down as fat overnight as it won't get burnt off.

LordGrover

34,117 posts

238 months

Saturday 1st June 2013
quotequote all
rofl

Hoofy

79,718 posts

308 months

Sunday 2nd June 2013
quotequote all
Alex106 said:
Hoofy said:
SunDiver said:
Rather frighteningly, McDonalds' website lists large fries as 755kcals alone...!
Even worse, then! Maybe the portion is bigger than I thought. How far out were my other estimates? biggrin
Their nutrition calculator suggests the large fries are 460. Cheeseburger comes in at 295. So 600 calories for two wasnt a bad guess!

ETA: http://www.mcdonalds.co.uk/ukhome/meal_builder.htm...
party Once upon a time, I could recall all the main sports car BHPs. Nowadays, I seem to be good at guestimating kcals of food.

TheJimi

Original Poster:

27,422 posts

269 months

Wednesday 19th June 2013
quotequote all
An update:

Since I started this thread (and started helping her) she has lost a stone smile


I'm pretty chuffed smile