Is it illegal to wedge a fuel pump open
Discussion
Breadvan72 said:
Ilovejapcrap said:
leigh1050 said:
I use my filler cap to hold the latch open.
Have done for years, last week a college was in work van and amazed by this ! Seriously how can people not think to do that !
fttm said:
Usually pump 3/400 ltrs a day into my truck which is hardly strenuous , why anyone who has seen the consequences of leaving a pump unattended would want to "wedge one open " beggars belief , never take the piss out of dumb ass Americans again if you follow this practice .
everyone in Germany does itdecent sized country with lots of drivers, lots of through traffic
I've never heard of an incident, not to say they've never happened
MrsMiggins said:
What consequences? Care to elaborate?
Are you saying that the other countries which allow the latch to be used are being irresponsible?
Do you really need the consequences spelling out?Are you saying that the other countries which allow the latch to be used are being irresponsible?
It's not a matter of irresponsible or not it's a matter of risk and the the likelyhood of a hazardous event occuring.
Removing the latch removes the potential for human error in one aspect of the filling operation.
an exploding petrol station? probably if it happened anywhere in Germany
a big fuel spill? probably if it happened anywhere local (25 million people in Rhine/Ruhr area)
example: a camper van set a petrol station on fire, it was big news in all the german papers, websites etc (elec. fault in the van)
a big fuel spill? probably if it happened anywhere local (25 million people in Rhine/Ruhr area)
example: a camper van set a petrol station on fire, it was big news in all the german papers, websites etc (elec. fault in the van)
Edited by Hugo a Gogo on Monday 5th October 10:04
Hugo a Gogo said:
an exploding petrol station? probably if it happened anywhere in Germany
a big fuel spill? probably if it happened anywhere local (25 million people in Rhine/Ruhr area)
example: a camper van set a petrol station on fire, it was big news in all the german papers, websites etc (elec. fault in the van)
Exploding petrol station is the worst case scenario and would likely result in multiple fatalities so yes.a big fuel spill? probably if it happened anywhere local (25 million people in Rhine/Ruhr area)
example: a camper van set a petrol station on fire, it was big news in all the german papers, websites etc (elec. fault in the van)
Edited by Hugo a Gogo on Monday 5th October 10:04
Do you regularly read the German papers/websites?
Devil2575 said:
Hugo a Gogo said:
an exploding petrol station? probably if it happened anywhere in Germany
a big fuel spill? probably if it happened anywhere local (25 million people in Rhine/Ruhr area)
example: a camper van set a petrol station on fire, it was big news in all the german papers, websites etc (elec. fault in the van)
Exploding petrol station is the worst case scenario and would likely result in multiple fatalities so yes.a big fuel spill? probably if it happened anywhere local (25 million people in Rhine/Ruhr area)
example: a camper van set a petrol station on fire, it was big news in all the german papers, websites etc (elec. fault in the van)
Edited by Hugo a Gogo on Monday 5th October 10:04
Do you regularly read the German papers/websites?
Devil2575 said:
Exploding petrol station is the worst case scenario and would likely result in multiple fatalities so yes.
Do you regularly read the German papers/websites?
If using a match, pound coin, etc as a substitute latch is as dangerous as you claim, then presumably, going by your usual logic, you're in favour of making it a criminal offence? Since they video drivers anyway, it's easy for petrol stations to send the footage of the Latch Criminal to the police (it's not like they're already drowning in silly footage from st-stirring cyclists' compo cams). Maybe force petrol stations to send the footage by law, just to make sure.Do you regularly read the German papers/websites?
Clearly, when something that makes life easier for millions of drivers theoretically results in a dangerous outcome in a very small number of cases, then the best response is always to ban it outright, rather than to try to find ways of preventing it from leading to the dangerous outcome. Insulate the pump from static shocks? No! Some other innovation? Absolutely not! No initiative must ever be used. Always ban, ban, ban. We don't want to be in any way helpful to drivers, because they should be cycling instead.
The great thing is that nearly everything drivers do can be labelled as "dangerous", in that it will probably result in some sort of injury to someone if done enough millions of times. Then it's an easy home run: say it needs to be banned ("if it saves just one life..."), and characterise anyone who disagrees as callous and not thinking about children enough. Then move onto something else. Wait, I've got one! Parking on slopes is "dangerous" because the driver might leave the handbrake off. While we could solve this problem with technology, it would be much more fun to ban parking on slopes altogether...
Devil2575 said:
Hugo a Gogo said:
an exploding petrol station? probably if it happened anywhere in Germany
a big fuel spill? probably if it happened anywhere local (25 million people in Rhine/Ruhr area)
example: a camper van set a petrol station on fire, it was big news in all the german papers, websites etc (elec. fault in the van)
Exploding petrol station is the worst case scenario and would likely result in multiple fatalities so yes.a big fuel spill? probably if it happened anywhere local (25 million people in Rhine/Ruhr area)
example: a camper van set a petrol station on fire, it was big news in all the german papers, websites etc (elec. fault in the van)
Edited by Hugo a Gogo on Monday 5th October 10:04
Do you regularly read the German papers/websites?
filled up my car tonight, left it filling while I cleaned the windows - clicked the lock open tab, nobody died
Hugo a Gogo said:
yes I do
filled up my car tonight, left it filling while I cleaned the windows - clicked the lock open tab, nobody died
I once drank a whole bottle of scotch whiskey. I didn't die therefore it is safe.filled up my car tonight, left it filling while I cleaned the windows - clicked the lock open tab, nobody died
So presumably you rely on the auto cut-off function to prevent overfilling?
CarsAreBad2572 said:
Devil2575 said:
Exploding petrol station is the worst case scenario and would likely result in multiple fatalities so yes.
Do you regularly read the German papers/websites?
If using a match, pound coin, etc as a substitute latch is as dangerous as you claim, then presumably, going by your usual logic, you're in favour of making it a criminal offence? Since they video drivers anyway, it's easy for petrol stations to send the footage of the Latch Criminal to the police (it's not like they're already drowning in silly footage from st-stirring cyclists' compo cams). Maybe force petrol stations to send the footage by law, just to make sure.Do you regularly read the German papers/websites?
Clearly, when something that makes life easier for millions of drivers theoretically results in a dangerous outcome in a very small number of cases, then the best response is always to ban it outright, rather than to try to find ways of preventing it from leading to the dangerous outcome. Insulate the pump from static shocks? No! Some other innovation? Absolutely not! No initiative must ever be used. Always ban, ban, ban. We don't want to be in any way helpful to drivers, because they should be cycling instead.
The great thing is that nearly everything drivers do can be labelled as "dangerous", in that it will probably result in some sort of injury to someone if done enough millions of times. Then it's an easy home run: say it needs to be banned ("if it saves just one life..."), and characterise anyone who disagrees as callous and not thinking about children enough. Then move onto something else. Wait, I've got one! Parking on slopes is "dangerous" because the driver might leave the handbrake off. While we could solve this problem with technology, it would be much more fun to ban parking on slopes altogether...
I simply said the worst case scenario was pretty bad, but whether it is likely or not is another matter.
The issue is how much inconvenience vs the level of risk. Banning parking on a slope woud cause massive inconvenience and would be in reality be unworkable. Making people hold the fuel filler handle while filling is a minor inconvenience given the potential severity of the worst case scenario. It's not even something I've ever heard anyone complaining about till I came on PH.
Devil2575 said:
Hugo a Gogo said:
yes I do
filled up my car tonight, left it filling while I cleaned the windows - clicked the lock open tab, nobody died
I once drank a whole bottle of scotch whiskey. I didn't die therefore it is safe.filled up my car tonight, left it filling while I cleaned the windows - clicked the lock open tab, nobody died
So presumably you rely on the auto cut-off function to prevent overfilling?
If you had drunk a whole bottle of Scotch every week, perhaps previously in another job, two and even three times a day, for the last 20 years
if every time you drunk a bottle of Scotch you saw several other people doing the same, or even every time you walked past the offy
if every Scotch shop where you lived supplied funnels with their bottles of Scotch specifically to let people to down it in one go,
if you had never heard of 'in-one-go-Scotch-drinking' ever causing any harm,
then that analogy might apply, and you might consider shotgunning Scotch to be perfectly safe
Hugo a Gogo said:
Devil2575 said:
Hugo a Gogo said:
yes I do
filled up my car tonight, left it filling while I cleaned the windows - clicked the lock open tab, nobody died
I once drank a whole bottle of scotch whiskey. I didn't die therefore it is safe.filled up my car tonight, left it filling while I cleaned the windows - clicked the lock open tab, nobody died
So presumably you rely on the auto cut-off function to prevent overfilling?
If you had drunk a whole bottle of Scotch every week, perhaps previously in another job, two and even three times a day, for the last 20 years
if every time you drunk a bottle of Scotch you saw several other people doing the same, or even every time you walked past the offy
if every Scotch shop where you lived supplied funnels with their bottles of Scotch specifically to let people to down it in one go,
if you had never heard of 'in-one-go-Scotch-drinking' ever causing any harm,
then that analogy might apply, and you might consider shotgunning Scotch to be perfectly safe
Besides, go out on many high streets on a Friday night and you will see people drinking vast quantities of alcohol over the course of a few hours. They don't die, I don't personally don't know of anyone who has died of alcohol poisoning, yet that isn't evidence that people cannot and do not die from drinking too much in a single session.
Whether or not the risks of taking your hand off the pump when filling up outweight the inconvenienece or not, the fact that you don't know anyone who has died as a result isn't proof that it is safe.
I read this and see a few comments about mobiles - The issue with mobiles isnt the radio transmittions - its to do with the battery contacts - There are specific regulations governing electrical equipment around fuel pumps - Ex rated for a start to ensure that the equipment doesnt interact with the environment and trigger an explosion.
Ex rated is constructed 1 to prevent an explosion and 2 to contain any that occur within the confines of the equipment casing.
With your average mobile the main issue is with the battery contacts - if you flex a phone enough you will cause arcs at the battery contacts - these arcs are hot enough to ignite petrol fumes and then the phone case isnt strong enough to contain the resultant effect.
It a risk situation the odds of it happening are low but the consequence is high so the rsk has to be managed hence the reason its frowned upon to be using a phone next to a fuel pump.
Ex rated is constructed 1 to prevent an explosion and 2 to contain any that occur within the confines of the equipment casing.
With your average mobile the main issue is with the battery contacts - if you flex a phone enough you will cause arcs at the battery contacts - these arcs are hot enough to ignite petrol fumes and then the phone case isnt strong enough to contain the resultant effect.
It a risk situation the odds of it happening are low but the consequence is high so the rsk has to be managed hence the reason its frowned upon to be using a phone next to a fuel pump.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff