ok, I know what you are going to say....
ok, I know what you are going to say....
Author
Discussion

littlelady

Original Poster:

3 posts

243 months

Wednesday 16th August 2006
quotequote all
like I say, to save all of those responses that are instantly going to tell me I will become 'Big Ronnies' play thing... let me put it into context:

I was banned on a totting system for 6 months which is still running... I have not driven on the public road at all since I have been banned. A few months ago, myself and friends were taking our cars (mine is a TVR) down to the nurburgring... I asked a friend to drive the car all the way to the ring, with me as a passenger.... however....

whilst going though the port of dover, I took over the driving just before passport control to drive the car on to the ferry... the reason for this was the front lip is very low on the car and the other person didn't want to be responsible for damaging it as we boarded(this has occurred before)... and they will testify to this if necessary

... if any of you have ever driven in dover, you would know that it is like driving in the worlds largest industrial park...

literally as I am driving to find which lane we need to be in to board I get a shout from a police man to pull over ... I have been caught 'speeding' doing 30mph (seriously)...!!!

... apparently they have nothing better to do and it is a 20mph zone! (..that's a whole other thread...)

anyway... they tell me that the port of dover does not come under the road traffic act (i.e no points will be imposed)... and that I may get a fine. I hadn't heard anything and so thought no more about it.

However, I have now recieved a call saying that they want me to go down for an interview... as I have been shown as driving whilst banned! It's not even a road!!!

obviously slightly crapping myself so if anyone has any useful advice....


Davel

8,982 posts

289 months

Wednesday 16th August 2006
quotequote all
Unlucky!

Can't really help but good luck...

Presumably you wouldn't be insured at the time either, if banned?

Edited by Davel on Wednesday 16th August 16:35

james_j

3,996 posts

286 months

Wednesday 16th August 2006
quotequote all
If the area in which you were driving doesn't come under the RTA I would guess you'll be OK. (I'm no expert in this though.) I expect they have assumed you drove all the way.

Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Wednesday 16th August 2006
quotequote all
I was going to say "Try telling the truth...and that you didn't think you were driving in an area prohibited to you..." but I expect that some better advice would be to discuss this with a lawyer...

cooperman

4,428 posts

281 months

Wednesday 16th August 2006
quotequote all
Just take a solicitor with you or, simply answer 'no comment' to any and all questions they might ask.
Alternatively, wait until they come and arrest you, then demand a solicitor before making any comment at all.
Unless, perhaps, you could get an address abroad and reply to their correspondence by stating that that is your current address, please address any further correspondence there, thank you.

littlelady

Original Poster:

3 posts

243 months

Wednesday 16th August 2006
quotequote all
well thats just it, at the time they tell me that it doesn't come under the RTA, and then when I spoke to the person on the phone and told him the truth he told me that the RTA does apply but not for issuing points... how does that work??? Surely, it either applies or it doesn't???

beside the port of dover police is a whole little army in itself... found this on wikipedia

"The Port of Dover Police is a small non-Home Office police service which provides police services to the Port of Dover, Kent, England.

As of 2004, the PoD Police had an establishment of one Chief Officer, three Inspectors, six Sergeants and thirty-eight Constables. The force investigate all offences committed in the port area but receive specialist support and assistance from Kent Police when required.

Officers of this force are sworn in as constables under section 79 of the Harbours, Docks and Piers Clauses Act 1847. As a result, officers have the full powers of a constable on any land owned by the Dover Harbour Board and at any place within one mile of any owned land.

Officers in this force wear similar uniforms to their colleagues in other forces throughout the country."

Sound like their own private army!!!

Dwight Vandriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Wednesday 16th August 2006
quotequote all
The offence of speeding and driving whilst disqualified is committed on A ROAD and this was not enlarged to include PUBLIC PLACE under MV (Comprehnsive Insurance) Regs 2000 which added PP to certain offences.

Road is defined under Section 192 (1) Road Traffic Act 1988 as any highway and ANY OTHER ROAD to which the public has access and includes bridges over which roads run.

It would appear applying logic that certain parts of Dover Docks will be classed as a road, i.e. the entrances but can it be said from the area where cars are parked awaiting embarkation and a prohibited area to the general public, only those that are to embark allowed. If this is so then there is an argument that from here to the loading ramp of the ship is restricted to only a certain class of public then it is not a road and RT Acts do not apply. Signing of this area could be important.

Would also want to know what street lighting about. Does it comply to make a 30 mph restricted road? Is there a Traffic Regulation Order for the alleged speed limit? Just what does it define as the road?

or are they relying on some Docks Board Byelaw offence which may not carry in itself points and further disqualification ?

Too complex to be more precise and as stated it may well be worth getting a legal eagle involved as DD is pretty heavy.

dvd





vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Wednesday 16th August 2006
quotequote all
I suspect that it may come under the Road Traffic Act (the definition of a road is very loose under the RTA), they probably mean that the speed limit isn't enforceable for points under the Road Traffic Regulation Act, which is an entirely different matter.

Much will depend on the set up at the docks as to whether it is a road or not under the act & ultimately it may be that a court would decide that.

Edited by vonhosen on Wednesday 16th August 17:31

Cider Andy

1,889 posts

256 months

Thursday 17th August 2006
quotequote all
As far as the legal aspects go, I cannot comment, but I can give some info about the port.

The 'roads' within the Port of Dover are very well defined, from the port entrance to each each embarkation ramp, either by permanent physical means (kerbs, armco, fencing), temporary means (cones - lots of them) or visible means (painted lines). The entire port seems to have 20mph speed limit (certainly the areas in which sea passengers can drive) which is well signposted throughout. There's also one of those digital displays near the entrance showing 'your speed is', although sometimes it does not seem to display anything, perhaps it is only triggered beyond the speed limit. Some of the roads have names on sat nav units (The Fan, Dock Exit Road, Back Road, Camber Way), I don't know what significance this has, if any.

The 20MPH limit would seem reasonable to me. There are quite a few places where traffic from one lane has to join another and there are several checkpoints, some with barriers, that you may be required to stop at. In fact it's quite difficult in some parts of the port to reach 20MPH because these checkpoints are so close together. There are also places near the piers where traffic leaving the port by sea and that coming in have to cross paths. However, there are also a couple of places where 20MPH seems a bit slow.

greatgranny

9,519 posts

257 months

Thursday 17th August 2006
quotequote all
I have been doing some design work for various ports around the country and when designing road markings have been told that they are not public highway and markings do not necessarily have to comply with TSRGD 2002 and Chapter 5. Don't know if this helps.
Also this means that any speed limit is advisable and not enforceable without a TRO.
Similar to speed limits posted in car parks etc.

^Slider^

2,874 posts

280 months

Thursday 17th August 2006
quotequote all
I would suspect that for the speed aspect there is no order covering the area of the docks and as such points cannot be accrued as there is no order in force. (but there may be an order burried in ports legislation which is enforceable but not point accruing)

But for the disqual bit i would say it would be a road at the material time if the public have access upon payment or otherwise, and as the public have paid and been given access then it would become a road for the purpose of the road traffic act.

eliminator

762 posts

286 months

Thursday 17th August 2006
quotequote all
Is it possible that they don't know that you didn't drive all the way to the Port as well as within the confines of the Port?

^Slider^

2,874 posts

280 months

Thursday 17th August 2006
quotequote all
There is that posibibility, but driving is driving, no matter how far that drive was.

An interview is always required for driving whilst disqual.

Where is the interview? Is it with the lacal Bib or ports police?

eliminator

762 posts

286 months

Thursday 17th August 2006
quotequote all
The point I was making was that they may not have a case for driving within the port (it not being a road), but may be investigating whether they have a case of driving on roads to the port?

BliarOut

72,863 posts

270 months

Thursday 17th August 2006
quotequote all
Is there a requirement for the ports vehicles to display tax and do they have to comply with MOT requirements if they work only in this area?

If they're exempt could it be argued that it's not a road?

^Slider^

2,874 posts

280 months

Thursday 17th August 2006
quotequote all
I think it is a road. As the public have access at the material time upon payment or otherwise. The interview will be to establish that A) they were driving and B) they knew they were subject to a ban.

As for Tax the road needs to be a public road such as it is reparable at the publics expense.

There is different definitions and Tax, insurance, MOT and driving license have different points.

I think that it fits the definition of a road and as such is subject to the disqual at the port.

Arguing that its not a road will be fruitless. As it will either be a road or not. I suspect that it is and it cannot be argued otherwise if it is indeed a road.

Does that make sense?

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Thursday 17th August 2006
quotequote all
They say that all roads within the docks are covered by the Road Traffic Act, in accordance with the provisions of the Dover Harbour Act 1963. Anyone got access to this Act ?

www.doverport.co.uk/corporate.asp?skey=5&ckey=102

BliarOut

72,863 posts

270 months

Thursday 17th August 2006
quotequote all
^Slider^ said:
I think it is a road. As the public have access at the material time upon payment or otherwise. The interview will be to establish that A) they were driving and B) they knew they were subject to a ban.

As for Tax the road needs to be a public road such as it is reparable at the publics expense.

There is different definitions and Tax, insurance, MOT and driving license have different points.

I think that it fits the definition of a road and as such is subject to the disqual at the port.

Arguing that its not a road will be fruitless. As it will either be a road or not. I suspect that it is and it cannot be argued otherwise if it is indeed a road.

Does that make sense?
It does indeed. I was just thinking of the scenario where they run forklifts without number plates such as in a factory loading area.

SS2 seems to have the definitive answer though.

thinfourth

1,189 posts

252 months

Thursday 17th August 2006
quotequote all
from another angle

A few months ago you say

Therefore would it not come under the NIP thingy

^Slider^

2,874 posts

280 months

Thursday 17th August 2006
quotequote all
NOIP doesnt apply for driving whislt disqualified.