Men still have some rights
Men still have some rights
Author
Discussion

wolves_wanderer

Original Poster:

12,959 posts

268 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
Taken from http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/477


BBC News said:
Woman loses frozen embryos fight

A woman left infertile after cancer treatment cannot use her frozen embryos to have a baby, the European Court of Human Rights has ruled.

Natallie Evans started IVF treatment with her then partner Howard Johnston in 2001 but he withdrew consent for the embryos to be used after they split up.

Ms Evans went to the Strasbourg court after exhausting the UK legal process.

The European Court represented Ms Evans' last realistic chance to use the embryos.

Her legal team had asked the judges to consider whether the UK law, which now requires her six stored embryos to be destroyed, was a breach of her human rights.


The key thing for me was just to be able to decide when, and if, I would start a family
Howard Johnston


In the court's judgement, decided by a panel of seven judges, said: "The Court, like the national courts, had great sympathy for the plight of the applicant who, if implantation did not take place, would be deprived of the ability to give birth to her own child."

But it was ruled that, even in such exceptional circumstances as Ms Evans', the right to a family life - enshrined in article eight of the European Convention of Human Rights - could not override Mr Johnston's withdrawal of consent.

It also ruled that the embryos did not have an independent right to life.

Reacting to the judgement, Howard Johnston, from Gloucester, said: "It seems that common sense has prevailed.

"The key thing for me was just to be able to decide when, and if, I would start a family."

But he added: "I'm not thinking about this in terms of a victory."

Cancer diagnosis

The UK's Court of Appeal and High Court had both ruled that Ms Evans, who is in her early 30s, could not use the embryos and she failed in her bid to take the case to the House of Lords.

Ms Evans, from Wiltshire, underwent IVF treatment following a diagnosis of ovarian cancer in which the embryos were created and placed in storage.

She has argued that Mr Johnston, from Gloucester, had already consented to their creation, storage and use, and should not be allowed to change his mind.

Current UK laws require both the man and woman to give consent, and allow either party to withdraw that consent up to the point where the embryos are implanted.

The embryos can remain in storage until October 2006, which is when the five-year maximum storage period under the law expires.


Thank God for that. Whilst I have every sympathy with the woman who has just lost her last chance of having a child, how can it possibly be right for the chap to be forced into having a child (and presumerably having to support it for the next 18 years.) I wonder if it would have got this far if the situation was reversed and he wanted to pinch the embryos...

JagLover

46,848 posts

266 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
A tricky situation this and I feel too sorry for the woman in question to celebrate this decision.

It is a shame a compromise could not have been achieved whereby the man could be guaranteed he would not be financially liable, just as sperm donors have

Code Monkey

3,318 posts

288 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
And adoption is not a simple consideration to this woman becaus of what?

skibum

1,032 posts

268 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
JagLover said:
A tricky situation this and I feel too sorry for the woman in question to celebrate this decision.

It is a shame a compromise could not have been achieved whereby the man could be guaranteed he would not be financially liable, just as sperm donors have


I think it was more that if she had been allowed to go ahead, he would know that he had kids out there and would then feel responsible for them - emotionally rather than just on the money side of things. He didnt want that responsibility and it would have been a little unfair to burden him with it..... IMHO anyway

Mrs Fish

30,018 posts

289 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
Code Monkey said:
And adoption is not a simple consideration to this woman becaus of what?


Because it won't be her biological child.

wolves_wanderer

Original Poster:

12,959 posts

268 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
Code Monkey said:
And adoption is not a simple consideration to this woman becaus of what?
Because in this brave new world in which we live, if something can be given a spurious "Human Rights" aspect then people automatically assume it is OK. Stupid bint should have frozen her eggs not an embryo.

JagLover

46,848 posts

266 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
wolves_wanderer said:
Code Monkey said:
And adoption is not a simple consideration to this woman becaus of what?
Because in this brave new world in which we live, if something can be given a spurious "Human Rights" aspect then people automatically assume it is OK. Stupid bint should have frozen her eggs not an embryo.


She was in a relationship at the time. I think it is a bit harsh to describe her as a 'stupid bint'

staceyb

7,107 posts

255 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
wolves_wanderer said:
Code Monkey said:
And adoption is not a simple consideration to this woman becaus of what?
Because in this brave new world in which we live, if something can be given a spurious "Human Rights" aspect then people automatically assume it is OK. Stupid bint should have frozen her eggs not an embryo.


I was just thinking the same thing, the guy wasn't even her husband when they had the embryos frozen. I feel sorry for her but I can't help thinking that if it had been the other way around ie the bloke wanted children and wanted to use the embryos because they were just as much his as the were hers, then he would have been shot down in flames by the media and not held up on a pedestal like she has.

Mrs Fish

30,018 posts

289 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
wolves_wanderer said:

Stupid bint should have frozen her eggs not an embryo.


I agree, should have frozen her eggs

david968s

415 posts

261 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
Turn the situation around. Child grows up knowing that their biological father wanted nothing to do with them and wanted to deny them their existence.

I think that all things considered, the right decision was made. I feel sorry for the woman, but lots of people have to live with not being able to have children - such is life. It wouldn't be fair on the man or the child to have to live with the consequences of the decision going the other way.

wolves_wanderer

Original Poster:

12,959 posts

268 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
JagLover said:
wolves_wanderer said:
Code Monkey said:
And adoption is not a simple consideration to this woman becaus of what?
Because in this brave new world in which we live, if something can be given a spurious "Human Rights" aspect then people automatically assume it is OK. Stupid bint should have frozen her eggs not an embryo.


She was in a relationship at the time. I think it is a bit harsh to describe her as a 'stupid bint'
Maybe it is [slightly] harsh but the chap wasn't her husband and I find it nauseating that she made the assumption that her "right" to have a child is not only more important than his right to choose, but in fact completely invalidates his contribution.

JagLover

46,848 posts

266 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]


That is something sperm donors are able to deal with.

If however there is even the slightest chance he would be financially liable then I fully support his right to deny the woman use of these eggs..

wolves_wanderer

Original Poster:

12,959 posts

268 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
staceyb said:
I feel sorry for her but I can't help thinking that if it had been the other way around ie the bloke wanted children and wanted to use the embryos because they were just as much his as the were hers, then he would have been shot down in flames by the media and not held up on a pedestal like she has.
Spot on.

Code Monkey

3,318 posts

288 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
JagLover said:
anonymous said:
[redacted]


That is something sperm donors are able to deal with.

If however there is even the slightest chance he would be financially liable then I fully support his right to deny the woman use of these eggs..


It is something that the sperm donors choose to deal with...

choice is the critical thing in all this.



>> Edited by Code Monkey on Tuesday 7th March 11:30

PESTY

42,655 posts

287 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
JagLover said:
A tricky situation this and I feel too sorry for the woman in question to celebrate this decision.

It is a shame a compromise could not have been achieved whereby the man could be guaranteed he would not be financially liable, just as sperm donors have


The mans solicitor cleared this up. In UK law the man would be the legal father. that means he would be legaly and moraly the childs father with all that entails.

A very tough case indeed. The woman could have had some of her embrios fertilised by donors as well as her boy friend but now its obviously too late.

Rememeber the woman had equal rights to call it off. they both had to agree in writing. if it was the other way around and she didnt want it and he did the same rule would aply.

wolves_wanderer

Original Poster:

12,959 posts

268 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
JagLover said:
anonymous said:
[redacted]


That is something sperm donors are able to deal with.

If however there is even the slightest chance he would be financially liable then I fully support his right to deny the woman use of these eggs..
Imagine if one of your exes had the chance now to have [at least one] of your kids now. Would you like that? Or is it OK as long as you don't have to support it? Personally I wouldn't want a mini_wanderer running about the place whether it was costing me or not.

Einion Yrth

19,575 posts

275 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]

Hmm.... careful with that one, it's tantamount to suggesting that I should be able to require someone I got pregnant to terminate the pregnancy.

TeamD

5,060 posts

263 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
JagLover said:
That is something sperm donors are able to deal with.


But they have already made the decision that they will not be in a relationship with the recipient. The chap in this case quite probably agreed to the process in the belief that the resulting embryos would only be used in the context of his and her relationship, not for her to have children once she had ceased to be in that relationship.

As everyone has said, freezing the eggs would have been the most rational approach to the situation. One wonders what the reason was and where the advice came from that encouraged them to do otherwise?

themaskedavenger

676 posts

279 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
Its a tricky one and I think the right decision has been made but from the other point of view at some point the Man made the decision to fertilise the eggs.

Now if that had been directly inside the woman then they would have a child by now it just happens that they have not finished the journey (sorry cant think of a better way of saying that). Should the decision be made when you decide to fertilise the egg or later?

You could (if you could stretch things that far) that if you got someone pregnant then spilt up you could force them to have an abortion.......its a real stretch of imagination that one I admit!

fruitcake

3,850 posts

257 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
This is a man practicing his legal and moral right - he doesn't want to have children and therefore shouldn't have to. I don't agree with the monitary argument either.

Forcing someone to do something they don't want to do because a woman says it should happen like that is a breach of his civil liberties. She may as well be asking for his house or his car or one of his testicles in a jar. She has no legal or moral right to demand something of his because she wants it.

Choose a sperm donor, love. And then shut the fk up.