elise vs VX220
Author
Discussion

matt173407

Original Poster:

515 posts

260 months

Friday 5th August 2005
quotequote all
Cant decide on another elise or the VX220 get some nice fairly new Vx's quite cheap

any got a good comparison of the 2

steff

1,421 posts

294 months

Friday 5th August 2005
quotequote all
are you blind?

cfoster

115 posts

266 months

Friday 5th August 2005
quotequote all
HI Mate what car do you drive.


ERRRRRR a VAUXHALL VX220... You know the sporty 2 seater one


Or


A LOTUS!!!!


I know you should look past the badge, but if you have the money get the lotus and increase your kudos no end!

This story has always stuck in my mind, I'd just bought a new Astra 2.2 SRI 3dr cost me about 14k and my mate bought an old BMW Compact for 5k. Now my Astra was quicker better equip level bla bla bla but when ever we were out and some bird asked us what we drive they always got excited about the fact my mate had a BMW.

Same as the Lotus and VX, when some one asks you what you drive just watch their reaction when you say a lotus!!

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Friday 5th August 2005
quotequote all
What's your budget mate. Then we can help you.

Basically the car itself is inherently "the same" - same tub & chassis, different mountings for the engine, and heavier in the 220 IIRC.

Driving dynamics - no idea, never driven a 220.

VFM - 220's seem to offer excellent value, but then the Elise market is very competitive right now and you'll get a superb S1 for low 220 money. If you're going to be paying nearer 20k or over, for me there's only one choice, regardless of the 220 turbo's credentials.

The badge DOES make a difference. You're buying into a different kudos with a Lotus.

Mrs Boggy

94 posts

265 months

Friday 5th August 2005
quotequote all
cfoster said:
HI Mate what car do you drive.


ERRRRRR a VAUXHALL VX220... You know the sporty 2 seater one


Or


A LOTUS!!!!


I know you should look past the badge, but if you have the money get the lotus and increase your kudos no end!

This story has always stuck in my mind, I'd just bought a new Astra 2.2 SRI 3dr cost me about 14k and my mate bought an old BMW Compact for 5k. Now my Astra was quicker better equip level bla bla bla but when ever we were out and some bird asked us what we drive they always got excited about the fact my mate had a BMW.

Same as the Lotus and VX, when some one asks you what you drive just watch their reaction when you say a lotus!!


I agree with Cfoster, me and Boggy went to a car show over at Canary Wharf in June and there was the Lotus stand and also a stand including the Vauxhall VX220... all I can say is GET A LOTUS!

sneakypete

173 posts

260 months

Friday 5th August 2005
quotequote all
I had the same choice. Get the Lotus. Cfoster is right. Everybody at Lotus hates the GM car.


Or consider the Opel badged version 'Speedster' is so much cooler!

Yeh, what's your budget?

jig

244 posts

270 months

Friday 5th August 2005
quotequote all
The VX I drove had a lot of understeer - yes, even more than my lardy S2 and I was told by an instructor that it was set up like that 'cos they expected Vx owners to want it to be a bit more user friendly - dunno how true that is...

Still a Lotus tho!

GKP

15,099 posts

272 months

Friday 5th August 2005
quotequote all
VX220 is no longer being made, therefore it's obsolete. Nuff said

boggy

4,603 posts

266 months

Friday 5th August 2005
quotequote all
Afternoon all,

While the Vx is a great little car I'm afraid your buying a Imitation Lotus it's as simple as that (Well that's what everyone's going to be saying anyway) I'm so sorry if I've Pisse* anyone off who owns a Vx but it's the truth why wouldn't you want to buy a Lotus in the first place ?

Boggy

>> Edited by boggy on Friday 5th August 13:51

boggy

4,603 posts

266 months

Friday 5th August 2005
quotequote all
Hi all,

Here's one for you & should put a big smile on your face !!!

www.pistonheads.com/sales/46778.htm

Boggy

__Lee__

7,520 posts

274 months

Friday 5th August 2005
quotequote all
When I saw this thread I thought it was a interesting comparison but the thread has just descended into 'I own a Lotus and you own a Vauxhall, so I'm obviously better than you'. Probably best not to mention the Rover bits then.

I thought driving the Elise was all about the cars legendary dynamics rather than badge snobbery.

Most people have no idea that the VX220 is based on the Elise, also would you mind if your car was based on a car which is famed for it stunning dynamics?.

How about a decent comparison.

The VX220 Turbo engine is fantastic (drove one over a short distance) but the Elise has much sharper, focused handling apparently (I haven't driven one).

So if anyone has driven both it would be good to compare them.

DanL

6,591 posts

296 months

Friday 5th August 2005
quotequote all
My 2p (may stretch to 5p, depending on when I stop typing. )

First off, make sure to drive them both and see which you prefer. That said, it depends on your budget;

1) If you're comparing the S1 Elise to the VX, they're worlds apart. The VX is much more 'refined' (considering both cars come with pretty much naff all in the way of comfort, this is something of an achievement!). You may also find the S1 roof arrangement off-putting. It's very, very obvious that the VX is a generation on from the Elise.

2) If you're comparing an old S2 to the VX, you may find the engine in the Elise disappointing. The Elise has a fair bit of poke in first and second, but third gear is something of a let down - the extra torque from the 2.2 GM unit is very obvious in higher gears. On the other hand, the roof arrangements are broadly comparable. Engine noise in the Elise is much more intrusive, but you may like this depending on how "raw" you want the experience to be.

3) If you're comparing a newer S2 (with short tail roof) to a VXT. Once again, the VX may be the more refined car (depending on options they both have fitted), and it will be the faster car in a straight line. If you're thinking of residuals, at the £17k price point the VX will probably do slightly worse than the Elise, but maybe not by much.

4) If you're thinking of spending £20k+ on the car, for God's sake, buy the badge. You'll lose a packet on the VX in comparison to the Elise.

In summary? I'd take a VX over an S1 Elise without having to think too hard about it. S2 vs VX? Harder, and depends on the price point really. £13k, I'd probably plump for the VX, as the car should be newer, and in better condition. 16k, I'd be tempted to go with the S2.

The girls/pub talk think could well be a valid point. On the one hand, the Vauxhall won't cut it whilst chatting. On the other, it'll work if you park it outside.

Well, there's my thoughts.

Dan

piooly

1,176 posts

256 months

Friday 5th August 2005
quotequote all
I have tried both and ended up with a Elise sport 160 series 1.

Way I look at it is the VX is basically a series 2 elise. The roof alone on the VX is far better than the S1 elise and thats a major factor. I'd always have a S2 over the VX.

Why I bought the S1 then???? Its got more power to weight at 227 bhp/ton than the VX turbo's 225 bhp/ton for starters. I just find the lotus more enjoyable in every aspect except the roof. Then it has a lotus badge. It just sounds so rubbish when you have to explain which Vauxhall you have, with the Lotus, you just say A lotus, you dont even need to say elise, Lotus is cool enough !

DanL

6,591 posts

296 months

Friday 5th August 2005
quotequote all
boggy said:
why wouldn't you want to buy a Lotus in the first place ?
Couldn't let this one slide.

I *did* want a Lotus. I wanted one so much, in fact, that after finding the S1 Elise crap in comparison to the VX, I held off buying the VX until I'd driven a couple of S2 Elise too. If the S2 Elise was as good a day to day car as the VX (for *my* requirements - I'm not a driving God, and I don't do track days), I'd have had one like a shot. Sadly, the K series engine sucks.

Whilst I'm banging on about the whole badge snobbery thing, I'd put reasonable money on every VX owner having driven the Elise before deciding. I'm pretty certain the reverse isn't true.

Cheers,

Dan

shot2bits

1,273 posts

259 months

Friday 5th August 2005
quotequote all
This has been done on the VX forum as well...

www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?t=170258&f=104&h=0

Check it out for opinions from the dark side

BigAndy69

117 posts

262 months

Friday 5th August 2005
quotequote all
I've read the VX thread and most seemed to choose the Vauxhall coz its chepaer. Comments like "you get used to the looks" dont really inspire me! When I was looking to buy 8 months ago it was a simple choice - had to be a Lotus.

Andy

boggy

4,603 posts

266 months

Friday 5th August 2005
quotequote all
__Lee__ said:
When I saw this thread I thought it was a interesting comparison but the thread has just descended into 'I own a Lotus and you own a Vauxhall, so I'm obviously better than you'. Probably best not to mention the Rover bits then.

Err Don't you mean Toyota ? Elise 111R

I thought driving the Elise was all about the cars legendary dynamics rather than badge snobbery.

Most people have no idea that the VX220 is based on the Elise, also would you mind if your car was based on a car which is famed for it stunning dynamics?.

How about a decent comparison.

The VX220 Turbo engine is fantastic (drove one over a short distance) but the Elise has much sharper, focused handling apparently (I haven't driven one).

So if anyone has driven both it would be good to compare them.



I have driven both and I do agree with some of your point's, however the Vx Under steers way more then any Elise I've ever driven also it just doesn't feel the same

Boggy

>> Edited by boggy on Friday 5th August 15:28

matt173407

Original Poster:

515 posts

260 months

Friday 5th August 2005
quotequote all
I just sold my Elise 111s and regretting now and was tempted for a good priced VX but your right no competition what was i thinking vauxhall / Lotus!!!

I shall keep my eye out for a good priced S2 !

thanks

TangoAlpha

1,175 posts

285 months

Friday 5th August 2005
quotequote all
DanL said:
Whilst I'm banging on about the whole badge snobbery thing, I'd put reasonable money on every VX owner having driven the Elise before deciding. I'm pretty certain the reverse isn't true.

I did...I drove two S1 Elises and a VX and chose the VX.

boggy

4,603 posts

266 months

Friday 5th August 2005
quotequote all
Hi Tim,

Did you not try a S2 then ? may be you need a car that's a little easier to live with (I know I did)

Boggy