boardman fs pro vs giant anthem x4 / x5

[Rob_T]

looking at getting my first mountain bike and have narrowed it down to these 2 (or 3) models.

does anyone have specific experience of them and can offer an informed opinion as to which to go for. they are both the same sort of prices.

i currently have a giant defy advanced 3 roadbike, and want the 'equivalent' in mtb for use riding round the chilterns (specifically off road - only on road to get to the places i'm going to offroad).

please don't offer any '... but have you not considered a trek / specialised / orange etc etc' response!!!!

[Rob_T]

thanks for the comments. seems the boardman is the sensible buy, however i went out and bought the giant this lunchtime. i'm confident it will be fine!