Which?
Author
Discussion

PJ S

Original Poster:

10,842 posts

258 months

Saturday 15th June 2013
quotequote all
Plain and simple, which one would you give the nod to?

Following on from my previous thread, my quest to jump in at a higher end than initially considered has come to a grinding halt, due mainly to lack of surplus links in Seiko Japan for the watches that I was interested in.
So, reverting back to the my original budget, I figured I'd go for the VSA Ground Force, and duly put one in a shopping basket, after enquiring with Switzerland about availability and price of the metal bracelet to replace the rubber band.
NOS (so full 3 year warranty) but something was nagging at me to not proceed just yet.

Looking through images I noticed a vast difference in appearances, but then I found a few that weren't catalogue ones, and the owner had bothered to light it properly or white balance his camera!
Sure enough, the stark silver dial stood out, like the poorer resolution catalogue ones - I crinkled my nose trying to figure could I live with it or was it a deal breaker?
I love the second markers displayed as numbers, absolutely love it, but the image I had in my head based on the one in the original thread linked above, was of something more creamy/ivory.
Alas poor Yorick.....oops, sorry, don't know why I started reciting Shakespeare there......I was back to square one again.

Fast forward a week, almost, and I'm now looking at these three with a lustful eye.







So chaps, any advice, opinions, etc on these three?

Edited by PJ S on Tuesday 2nd July 20:31

JRewing

17,551 posts

210 months

Saturday 15th June 2013
quotequote all
Personally I'd have the Oris. I just prefer the look and respect the brand.

marcosgt

11,506 posts

207 months

Saturday 15th June 2013
quotequote all
JRewing said:
Personally I'd have the Oris. I just prefer the look and respect the brand.
I usually agree with JRewing, but the Oris is my least favourite - Too much blue and the face looks printed - Very bland, imho.

The Bulova's an interesting mechanism, with the sweeping hand on a quartz watch (although perhaps that's not one of those now I look at the name), but I rather like the small amount of blue and the waffle dial on the Victorinox, so I might be tempted to that...

M

PJ S

Original Poster:

10,842 posts

258 months

Saturday 15th June 2013
quotequote all
marcosgt said:
I usually agree with JRewing, but the Oris is my least favourite - Too much blue and the face looks printed - Very bland, imho.

The Bulova's an interesting mechanism, with the sweeping hand on a quartz watch (although perhaps that's not one of those now I look at the name), but I rather like the small amount of blue and the waffle dial on the Victorinox, so I might be tempted to that...
The Bulova is an automatic - you're thinking of the Precisionist, which are the very high beat quartz.
I quite like it (there's a silver version, which is nice but it's silver - same as what put me off the VSA Ground Force) for the fact the numbers are raised and look solid, but the VSA Officer's Day Date is very nice with the blue second's hand set against the white face.

Some large images showing the solidity of the numbers rather than the usual screen printing - http://www.chrono24.com/en/bulova/accutron-gemini-...

The Oris I may have over-indulged in tweaking before putting it up - here's how it was before I modified it.

Edited by PJ S on Sunday 16th June 16:18

PJ S

Original Poster:

10,842 posts

258 months

Saturday 15th June 2013
quotequote all
marcosgt said:
I usually agree with JRewing, but the Oris is my least favourite - Too much blue and the face looks printed - Very bland, imho.

The Bulova's an interesting mechanism, with the sweeping hand on a quartz watch (although perhaps that's not one of those now I look at the name), but I rather like the small amount of blue and the waffle dial on the Victorinox, so I might be tempted to that...
The Bulova is an automatic - you're thinking of the Precisionist, which are the very high beat quartz.
I quite like it (there's a silver version, which is nice but it's silver - same as what put me off the VSA Ground Force) for the fact the numbers are raised and look solid, but the VSA Officer's Day Date is very nice with the blue second's hand set against the white face.

Some large images showing the solidity of the numbers rather than the usual screen printing - http://www.chrono24.com/en/bulova/accutron-gemini-...

The Oris I may have over-indulged in tweaking before putting it up - here's how it was before I modified it.

Edited by PJ S on Sunday 16th June 16:20

marcosgt

11,506 posts

207 months

Saturday 15th June 2013
quotequote all
It's the least 'recognised' watch brand, but even allowing for the slightly more interesting looking dial on the Oris in the un-modified image, I still prefer the Victorinox personally.

Oris make some nice watches, but that one doesn't do anything for me. The Bulova's OK, but I prefer the Victorinox.

M

Adam B

29,761 posts

285 months

Sunday 16th June 2013
quotequote all
First one for me too, last one looks gaudy as hell sorry

sparkyhx

4,200 posts

235 months

Sunday 16th June 2013
quotequote all
hmm - toughy - I quite like them all.

bulova as a brand has history, ORIS is also a good brand and well respected, I like the Victorinox design but no real history but I think they iuse decent movements

I assume the Bulova is a GMT which is an added complic ation the others don't have.

Edited by sparkyhx on Sunday 16th June 21:47

JRewing

17,551 posts

210 months

Sunday 16th June 2013
quotequote all
marcosgt said:
I usually agree with JRewing, but the Oris is my least favourite - Too much blue and the face looks printed - Very bland, imho.

The Bulova's an interesting mechanism, with the sweeping hand on a quartz watch (although perhaps that's not one of those now I look at the name), but I rather like the small amount of blue and the waffle dial on the Victorinox, so I might be tempted to that...

M
Well M, we usually do agree but we don't always have to!

By the way, I think you'll be interested to see what I have incoming (expected to arrive by Tuesday).

PJ S

Original Poster:

10,842 posts

258 months

Monday 17th June 2013
quotequote all
sparkyhx said:
hmm - toughy - I quite like them all.

bulova as a brand has history, ORIS is also a good brand and well respected, I like the Victorinox design but no real history but I think they iuse decent movements

I assume the Bulova is a GMT which is an added complic ation the others don't have.
Yeah, each has their own desirable element(s).

The GMT function on the Bulova is not something I'll use, and wasn't even part of the reason I like it - the design is what grabs me.
Ironically, Bulova is owned by Citizen, yet uses an ETA movement - 2893, iirc - the other two, both use a 2836.

Of the three, the Oris is the most expensive (relative) and the one which has the least amount of decent photos on Google image, so hardest to gauge how vibrant the blue is on the dial.

Edited by PJ S on Tuesday 2nd July 20:32

PJ S

Original Poster:

10,842 posts

258 months

Wednesday 19th June 2013
quotequote all
Decision made - I'll "announce" its arrival once it's sitting in front of me.

marcosgt

11,506 posts

207 months

Thursday 20th June 2013
quotequote all
JRewing said:
marcosgt said:
I usually agree with JRewing, but the Oris is my least favourite - Too much blue and the face looks printed - Very bland, imho.

The Bulova's an interesting mechanism, with the sweeping hand on a quartz watch (although perhaps that's not one of those now I look at the name), but I rather like the small amount of blue and the waffle dial on the Victorinox, so I might be tempted to that...

M
Well M, we usually do agree but we don't always have to!

By the way, I think you'll be interested to see what I have incoming (expected to arrive by Tuesday).
Ooh interest piqued smile

M

PJ S

Original Poster:

10,842 posts

258 months

Tuesday 2nd July 2013
quotequote all
Victorinox Swiss Army Officer's Day Date Mechanical has been acquired and sitting in front of me.
Need to get a link or two, then we're good to go into wrist-wearing mode. hehe