Strictly Come Dancing 2014 (Official Thread)
Discussion
richtea78 said:
She can do ballroom. It's just not as good as Frankies. Frankie has barely improved all series though. She started well and got a bit better. The others improved massively
Yes. Exactly so. I think Ash has different (but no less valid, I must stress) judging criteria than some of us. ash73 said:
Remarkable set of scores for Caroline. Are we going to have a series winner that can't do ballroom?
There's an amazing amount of artistry and technique to her dances, especially to her show dance. It doesn't have to be giddy and wild to be good. Her show dance conveyed a story and emotions in a way I don't think the others did.It's not really a contest of who's improved the most though, or shouldn't be necessarily. I appreciate everybody likes a story of someone going from no experience to being great but the dancers are supposed to be judged on how good they are.
Edited by Blakewater on Saturday 20th December 21:32
ash73 said:
You can argue about whether such and such should be in the competition but it's not their fault; and once they are there I think you should judge them on their merit. Pixie by a country mile, Frankie a delicious second choice.
You also should account for the improvement. Otherwise you would do it all on the first night s3fella said:
I reckon someone on production team has had a word with Greg, as his reaction to Caroline's final dance there was rather different! He'd even moved himself right up to the camera, so he could be seen properly!
Agree again!Noticed the same & suspected he was given words.
Wish they would ship him out of the Beeb not that I watch all those damn cookery programmes!
Gassing Station | TV, Film, Video Streaming & Radio | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff