Awkward design details on production cars

Awkward design details on production cars

Author
Discussion

Muddle238

3,920 posts

114 months

Wednesday 31st March 2021
quotequote all
Anything where lights mask other lights. Was about 100 yards behind a Tesla Model 3, the brake lights completely mask the indicator, which looks to be a single tiny LED.

Likewise the DRLs on a Nissan Qashcum completely mask the front indicators which are just inboard IIRC.

KTF

9,837 posts

151 months

Thursday 1st April 2021
quotequote all
Muddle238 said:
Anything where lights mask other lights. Was about 100 yards behind a Tesla Model 3, the brake lights completely mask the indicator, which looks to be a single tiny LED.

Likewise the DRLs on a Nissan Qashcum completely mask the front indicators which are just inboard IIRC.
From memory I think the DRL turns off when the indicator is in use then back on again afterwards. They are not the only manufacturer that does this.

carlove

7,585 posts

168 months

Thursday 1st April 2021
quotequote all
KTF said:
From memory I think the DRL turns off when the indicator is in use then back on again afterwards. They are not the only manufacturer that does this.
The facelift Qashqai does this, but the pre-facelift didn’t and the indicator is really hard to see behind the DRLs.


I have also noticed the Model 3 has a tiny rear indicator, which isn’t the easiest to see, it’s LED which helps though.

cmvtec

2,188 posts

82 months

Thursday 1st April 2021
quotequote all
Muddle238 said:
Anything where lights mask other lights. Was about 100 yards behind a Tesla Model 3, the brake lights completely mask the indicator, which looks to be a single tiny LED.

Likewise the DRLs on a Nissan Qashcum completely mask the front indicators which are just inboard IIRC.
Mk5 Golf was particularly bad for this.

Rear indicator completed encapsulated by the circular brake light.

Muddle238

3,920 posts

114 months

Thursday 1st April 2021
quotequote all
cmvtec said:
Muddle238 said:
Anything where lights mask other lights. Was about 100 yards behind a Tesla Model 3, the brake lights completely mask the indicator, which looks to be a single tiny LED.

Likewise the DRLs on a Nissan Qashcum completely mask the front indicators which are just inboard IIRC.
Mk5 Golf was particularly bad for this.

Rear indicator completed encapsulated by the circular brake light.
Likewise the B6 Passat was also terrible for it.

I’m sure there are regulations about minimum distances between certain lights, I’m guessing to aid visibility. It staggers me that some of these light cluster designs get signed off.

Davyf

155 posts

58 months

Thursday 1st April 2021
quotequote all
Subaru Impreza spark plugs.....

BMW N47 Timing chain.....

Certain models of Peugeot & Renault where the sump bung is recessed which means that all of the oil and all the bits that gather in the sump (on cars which are not regularly looked after) do not drain, I often wonder if this is a built in design to make sure the engine will fail and maybe create sales of parts or even a replacement car....

ncbbmw

410 posts

185 months

Tuesday 6th April 2021
quotequote all
Likewise the DRLs on a Nissan Qashcum completely mask the front indicators which are just inboard IIRC.

From memory I think the DRL turns off when the indicator is in use then back on again afterwards. They are not the only manufacturer that does this.



Only on the models with LED headlamps, the halogen headlamps have in-headlamp indicators and the DRL's stay on

GroundEffect

13,855 posts

157 months

Tuesday 6th April 2021
quotequote all
Fastpedeller said:
I may be correct in saying the manufacturers already have the facelift designed before the original arrives onto the market?
The styling will be frozen about 18 months before production. So, unless the facelift is coming out very quickly, that's not the case.

The engineering - depending on the level of facelift - will be started before the initial product gets to market.

ncbbmw

410 posts

185 months

Tuesday 6th April 2021
quotequote all
Nickbrapp said:
ae2006 said:
ae2006 said:
Good that i found this thread, i spotted a new DRL design trend seeing Mercedes EQCs and Golf 8s on the street. The monobrow, how they look like:




What i see:
Round 2
Please, stop





Edited by ae2006 on Saturday 27th March 21:01
I have a feeling that originally both MB and Vw wanted the logo to be illuminated aswell but wasn’t it stopped under some EU regulation to do with unnecessary light pollution or something ridiculous like that? I suppose it would look better if it had gone all the way across
I watched a review of the MB on YouTube and apparently although European Lighting regs allow a full strip without gaps German Law doesn't so being a German brand they built it with the gaps.

The New Nissan Ariya has an illuminated Nissan Emblem but it goes off when you drive the car.



Cyder

7,069 posts

221 months

Tuesday 6th April 2021
quotequote all
ncbbmw said:
Likewise the DRLs on a Nissan Qashcum completely mask the front indicators which are just inboard IIRC.

From memory I think the DRL turns off when the indicator is in use then back on again afterwards. They are not the only manufacturer that does this.



Only on the models with LED headlamps, the halogen headlamps have in-headlamp indicators and the DRL's stay on
You’re right on the LED lamp, but wrong on the halogen headlamp.
On the halogen lamp the DRL dims to the brightness of the side light when the indicator is turned on to improve the visibility of the indicator bulb.

ncbbmw

410 posts

185 months

Wednesday 7th April 2021
quotequote all
Cyder said:
ncbbmw said:
Likewise the DRLs on a Nissan Qashcum completely mask the front indicators which are just inboard IIRC.

From memory I think the DRL turns off when the indicator is in use then back on again afterwards. They are not the only manufacturer that does this.



Only on the models with LED headlamps, the halogen headlamps have in-headlamp indicators and the DRL's stay on
You’re right on the LED lamp, but wrong on the halogen headlamp.
On the halogen lamp the DRL dims to the brightness of the side light when the indicator is turned on to improve the visibility of the indicator bulb.
Oh right, I've never looked that closely, I will have to check and see if my Leaf does that.

Miserablegit

4,038 posts

110 months

Saturday 10th April 2021
quotequote all
Just walked past a golf plus - really odd design of the front windscreen - rather than being flush it’s recessed at the bottom - must be an aero reason for it so I wonder how hideous the aero must be for this to be needed


carlove

7,585 posts

168 months

Saturday 10th April 2021
quotequote all
swisstoni said:
Citroen gave up trying to flog big cars here years ago unfortunately.
Read yesterday that Citroen is going to sell the DS9 here, and it went on sale on Thursday, I can't imagine they'll sell many at all, maybe 3, but I quite like that they're giving it a go. If I had the money and was looking at a big saloon, I think I'd have a look.

RammyMP

6,802 posts

154 months

Saturday 10th April 2021
quotequote all
carlove said:
swisstoni said:
Citroen gave up trying to flog big cars here years ago unfortunately.
Read yesterday that Citroen is going to sell the DS9 here, and it went on sale on Thursday, I can't imagine they'll sell many at all, maybe 3, but I quite like that they're giving it a go. If I had the money and was looking at a big saloon, I think I'd have a look.
I’d wait a couple of years and then buy one for a fraction of the cost new! I always liked the C6 but never had the nerve to buy one!

carlove

7,585 posts

168 months

Saturday 10th April 2021
quotequote all
RammyMP said:
carlove said:
swisstoni said:
Citroen gave up trying to flog big cars here years ago unfortunately.
Read yesterday that Citroen is going to sell the DS9 here, and it went on sale on Thursday, I can't imagine they'll sell many at all, maybe 3, but I quite like that they're giving it a go. If I had the money and was looking at a big saloon, I think I'd have a look.
I’d wait a couple of years and then buy one for a fraction of the cost new! I always liked the C6 but never had the nerve to buy one!
I've always liked the C6 too, I pestered my Dad to get one years ago (I would have been about 14) but he got an Alfa 159, not often an Alfa is the sensible choice!
The C6 was sold when saloons were still popular, I've not got high hopes of the DS9 outselling the 5 Series, but I do agree, those that get sold will be a good purchase in a few years.

RammyMP

6,802 posts

154 months

Saturday 10th April 2021
quotequote all
carlove said:
RammyMP said:
carlove said:
swisstoni said:
Citroen gave up trying to flog big cars here years ago unfortunately.
Read yesterday that Citroen is going to sell the DS9 here, and it went on sale on Thursday, I can't imagine they'll sell many at all, maybe 3, but I quite like that they're giving it a go. If I had the money and was looking at a big saloon, I think I'd have a look.
I’d wait a couple of years and then buy one for a fraction of the cost new! I always liked the C6 but never had the nerve to buy one!
I've always liked the C6 too, I pestered my Dad to get one years ago (I would have been about 14) but he got an Alfa 159, not often an Alfa is the sensible choice!
The C6 was sold when saloons were still popular, I've not got high hopes of the DS9 outselling the 5 Series, but I do agree, those that get sold will be a good purchase in a few years.
You’ve got me looking at DS7 Crossbacks now!

MrGTI6

3,166 posts

131 months

Saturday 10th April 2021
quotequote all
Miserablegit said:
Just walked past a golf plus - really odd design of the front windscreen - rather than being flush it’s recessed at the bottom - must be an aero reason for it so I wonder how hideous the aero must be for this to be needed

I've noticed the same on the SEAT Altea. I've always assumed this was due to the wipers parking vertically. Perhaps the Golf Plus was based on the Altea, though it's worth noting that the Golf Plus' wipers park horizontally.

Cyder

7,069 posts

221 months

Saturday 10th April 2021
quotequote all
It reduces wind noise at the expense of A pillar visibility by minimising vortices as air goes up the windscreen and tries to spill around the A pillar I think (I’m not an aero engineer so one may be along soon to correct me).

Flumpo

3,819 posts

74 months

Saturday 10th April 2021
quotequote all
An interior one for a change, but I can’t get my head round none of the buttons/edges lining up in the new 3 series centre.


ajprice

27,705 posts

197 months

Saturday 10th April 2021
quotequote all
Flumpo said:
An interior one for a change, but I can’t get my head round none of the buttons/edges lining up in the new 3 series centre.

That's one for the 'These pictures make my teeth itch' thread in the Lounge hehe