Horrific looking bike/car accident

Horrific looking bike/car accident

Author
Discussion

parrot of doom

Original Poster:

23,075 posts

248 months

Saturday 14th May 2005
quotequote all








I don't know the story behind this, but I hope nobody was killed.....

FunkyNige

9,447 posts

289 months

Saturday 14th May 2005
quotequote all
I'm confused, it doesn't look like they cut anyone from the wreckage so maybe the car was stationary? In that case the biker may have flown over the top of the car and survived.

petros

2,441 posts

243 months

Saturday 14th May 2005
quotequote all
How come it's indoors? Is it a marketing or advertising gimick ? If it's a real accident, ouch.

Davey S1

13,272 posts

268 months

Saturday 14th May 2005
quotequote all
That has to be a mock up for a road safety campaign.

Balmoral Green

42,275 posts

262 months

Saturday 14th May 2005
quotequote all
Davey S1 said:
That has to be a mock up for a road safety campaign.
More likely the real thing being used for a road safety campaign. Would like to know the outcome, biker may have survived if thrown clear as the bike went in, I doubt anyone in the car would have lived.

silverback mike

11,292 posts

267 months

Saturday 14th May 2005
quotequote all
Looking at that I would say it is a mock up.

Psychobert

6,316 posts

270 months

Saturday 14th May 2005
quotequote all
silverback mike said:
Looking at that I would say it is a mock up.


I'd agree.. Speaking as someone who has seen a few of these for real, I've never seen a bike end up inside a car. It could well be a real incident thats been staged to look more dramatic by placing the bike where they have. With the pattern of damage on the car, I'd say if a bike hit it, the rider may well have not survived. The driver of the car ought to have done, but any passenger is unlikely to have.

groomi

9,324 posts

257 months

Saturday 14th May 2005
quotequote all
It has to be a mock up. How would the roof have squashed in from the opposite side of the impact?

mandat

4,208 posts

252 months

Saturday 14th May 2005
quotequote all
I agree that the picture looks staged.

The one below is taken at a real accident.





>> Edited by mandat on Saturday 14th May 22:39

silverback mike

11,292 posts

267 months

Saturday 14th May 2005
quotequote all
mandat said:
I agree that the picture looks staged.

The one below is taken at a real accident.



Click on the link below to see the other side of the car in this accident. BEWARE,the image in the link is very graphic and is not work safe.

[url]www.ogrish.com/archives/2004/november/OGRISH-dot-com-wypadek_2.jpg[/url]


Different pictures.......The first picture shows a fiat, the other is a merc 190...
Attention to details........

andywaterfall

972 posts

298 months

Saturday 14th May 2005
quotequote all
...and they're both pics of offsides

Wacky Racer

39,668 posts

261 months

Saturday 14th May 2005
quotequote all
Psychobert said:

The driver of the car ought to have done....



mandat

4,208 posts

252 months

Saturday 14th May 2005
quotequote all
silverback mike said:


Different pictures.......The first picture shows a fiat, the other is a merc 190...
Attention to details........


Your'e quite right. I noticed this myself after posting it, therefore I removed the link to the second picture.

76vette

99 posts

242 months

Sunday 15th May 2005
quotequote all
Shots of bike accidents.....hmmmm, they don't make me feel that brilliant. If anyones got a shot of a black VFR meshed with a Merc van - I strongly suggest they keep it too themselves.
Had to sit at a traffic light at the scene of a massive, truly nasty shunt in Wilmslow near me today....actually watching firemen talking to/checking life-signs on a passenger in a foul incident at a major crossroads. 6 police cars, 2 ambulances, me praying for the lights to change so I could leave. Metal on metal is very very saddening...

Hilts

4,546 posts

296 months

Sunday 15th May 2005
quotequote all
Totally Staged.

My mate T-boned a car in Hungary and his bike literally exploded (Ducati 900). I don't think there's any way for that bike to penetrate that far into the car and still be in that shape.

And no blood.

silverback mike

11,292 posts

267 months

Sunday 15th May 2005
quotequote all
76vette said:
Shots of bike accidents.....hmmmm, they don't make me feel that brilliant. If anyones got a shot of a black VFR meshed with a Merc van - I strongly suggest they keep it too themselves.
Had to sit at a traffic light at the scene of a massive, truly nasty shunt in Wilmslow near me today....actually watching firemen talking to/checking life-signs on a passenger in a foul incident at a major crossroads. 6 police cars, 2 ambulances, me praying for the lights to change so I could leave. Metal on metal is very very saddening...


Absolutely....I have dealt with quite a few. Not nice at all.

spaximus

4,306 posts

267 months

Sunday 15th May 2005
quotequote all
When I was a trainee mechanic in Doncaster, I was at colleage with a copper from the Accident investigation unit. He brought some pictures of an accident on the long straight road from Bawtry to Tickhill. A car had pulled out and a bike had gone into the side of the car exactly like the first picture. It killed three people two in the car one bike rider and did indeed turn the car onto its side and pushed it down the road.
On the first day at colleage the tutor told us one by one to stand up and introduce ourselves, after we had done this he then said if this year is the same as every other I have taught two of you will be dead by the year end, he was wrong it was three all fron accidents.

Psychobert

6,316 posts

270 months

Sunday 15th May 2005
quotequote all
Wacky Racer said:

Psychobert said:

The driver of the car ought to have done....






Sorry, I meant was unlikely to have survived. Wasn't implying that they deserved to be injured or anything..

EmmaP

11,758 posts

253 months

Sunday 15th May 2005
quotequote all
I do not believe that a bike could have penetrated the side of the car. It is too light to have had the force to do so. It also looks in too good shape at the rear. I would have thought that its front end would have been bent sideways on impact.

I imagine that any rider would have taken instant flying lessons. Whether or not they would have survived would depend very much on what actually brought them to a stop, ie. kerb, oncoming vehicle, and the force of the impact.

I think that photographs of true events would have been far more shocking and educational.

Neil_H

15,401 posts

265 months

Sunday 15th May 2005
quotequote all
Hilts said:

And no blood.


Well they're not exactly going to leave blood on it when using it for a safety campaign are they?

The oddest thing IMHO is there's no passenger door on the Golf, if there was it would have taken the impact and been bent inside. I can't see any trace of it. Maybe the car was stationary with the door open at the time?

Without knowing more details it's difficult to say whether it's real, the strangest things can happen in crashes, see BMW + house incident a few weeks back. I do think it would be odd to use a mock up of an unlikely accident in a safety campaign.