Just a Thought...Speed
Author
Discussion

shorty123

Original Poster:

376 posts

266 months

Friday 15th July 2005
quotequote all
I was pootling around devon yesterday and spotted something very interesting... Nearing Newton Abbot- coming from Dartmouth, i spotted the usual speed camera signs but then i noticed in the distance some bright red numbers, when i got closer i realised this was actually one of those solar powered speed warning signs, except this one actually showed your current speed... Ive never seen one of these and wondered how this would improve safety as some people would see how fast they could go through it for fun, i know i might be tempted if there was no traffic around :boxedin:

Has anyone else seen these? The only down-side i can see is that there is only space on the display for 2 digits, thus 99mph is the max speed measured.

Cue the onslaught...

bosscerbera

8,188 posts

272 months

Friday 15th July 2005
quotequote all
I've been known to give in to temptation....

On some you get a face if you exceed the limit.

shorty123

Original Poster:

376 posts

266 months

Friday 15th July 2005
quotequote all
bosscerbera said:


On some you get a face if you exceed the limit.



Lets hope the bloke that makes em is a PHer and puts a face on when the limit is exceeded

Now that would be funny

>> Edited by shorty123 on Friday 15th July 10:53

justinp1

13,363 posts

259 months

Friday 15th July 2005
quotequote all
shorty123 said:

bosscerbera said:


On some you get a face if you exceed the limit.




Lets hope the bloke that makes em is a PHer and puts a face on when the limit is exceeded

Now that would be funny

>> Edited by shorty123 on Friday 15th July 10:53


We live in hope, what is more likely is that the comes up when it is a member of the local plod who has inadvertantly wandered over the speed limit, or was merely testing the capabilities of his vehicle.

I heard the new versions of those also included built in speed cameras.... eek

Aparantly as you drive past after showing your speed it flashes up a two fingered 'V' sign and emmits the ASDA cash in back pocket 'bottom slapping' sound.

May be just an urban legend that one though...

Raify

6,556 posts

277 months

Friday 15th July 2005
quotequote all
I passed one of these just after one of my favourite corners when I had my Integrale, so I wonder how fast I could get that to display?

launch round corner, and I triggered it at a respectable 76mph (that was on a private road of course, in Lithuania, for all interested Policemen lurkers)

Almost at the exact moment I was punching the air, the friggin' thing flashed at me! Cue a full on D'Oh! moment, and 14 days of fretting / considering sabotage...

iaint

10,040 posts

267 months

Friday 15th July 2005
quotequote all
Went through one of these last week in the Jeep - speedo showing ~34, showed me and 29. Useful calibration device!

Andrew Noakes

914 posts

269 months

Friday 15th July 2005
quotequote all
There's another variation which just flashes you a sign saying 'Slow Down' if it thinks you're going too fast. There's one on the A25, near Redhill if I remember. Trouble is the thing says Slow Down if you drive past it at 40mph - this on a road with a 40mph limit and where 40mph is perfectly reasonable. And that's 40mph by my speedo, which probably means 37mph actual.

tinman0

18,231 posts

269 months

Friday 15th July 2005
quotequote all
They've actually discovered that these speed signs reduce accidents, rather than gatsos which reduce nothing.

Apparently people take more notice to signs that inform you rather than boxes that punish you.

The speed signs around here are limited to 46mph in the 30 zones. I think they do this to stop people like me trying them out at 2am. They also do it because I'm sure at higher speeds they are unreliable. One got me doing 96! (over a speed hump in a high street!) I was doing nothing like 96.

s2ooz

3,005 posts

313 months

Friday 15th July 2005
quotequote all
They are limited to 50mph to discourage "tests"

My local counciller made a great opportunity to put herself on the front page of the paper for putting one near 2 schools.

one week later it stopped working. thats £20,000 down the drain.

They got it working again occassionally, and it effects drivers to slow down - sorry, brake for no reason.

also its innaccurate, same speed every time on my speedo - different reading.

Ive yet to get a reply to my letter stating the new 30mph limit is rediculous and should be variable depending on when the lollypop ladies switch on the yellow beacons.

The schools are only a danger area 8-9:30am, 12-2pm 3-4:30pm, 40 weeks of the year.
- in total thats just 7% of the actual time in a year it NEEDS to be a 30 or less.

If the lolly ladies aren't there, use the money to make LED variable speed limit signs instead!!!!!!! grrr.

Horse_Apple

3,795 posts

271 months

Friday 15th July 2005
quotequote all
We have a few around here in North London.

Very good idea in my book.

They are not offensive and pray on your intellect and common sense and guilt.

They certainly seem to work better than cameras which just p1ss people off.

Its an electronic version of a police me telling you that you are being silly and must drive more carefully as compared to one who is offensive and fines you. Which one are you ultimately going to agree with and listen to?

>> Edited by Horse_Apple on Friday 15th July 15:25

GOM

1,650 posts

257 months

Friday 15th July 2005
quotequote all
shorty123 said:
I was pootling around devon yesterday and spotted something very interesting... Nearing Newton Abbot- coming from Dartmouth, i spotted the usual speed camera signs but then i noticed in the distance some bright red numbers, when i got closer i realised this was actually one of those solar powered speed warning signs, except this one actually showed your current speed... Ive never seen one of these and wondered how this would improve safety as some people would see how fast they could go through it for fun, i know i might be tempted if there was no traffic around

Has anyone else seen these? The only down-side i can see is that there is only space on the display for 2 digits, thus 99mph is the max speed measured.

Cue the onslaught...



If it's the one I passed today - same stretch of road - there is a 20 limit in the village. If you can get round the bend at the bottom of the hill at more than 99, you're a better man than me gunga!!!

Personally I think they are brilliant idea, designed to make people think and they seem to work.



charlieromeo

153 posts

259 months

Friday 15th July 2005
quotequote all
tinman0 said:
They've actually discovered that these speed signs reduce accidents, rather than gatsos which reduce nothing.


The diameter of your wallet?

sadako

7,080 posts

267 months

Friday 15th July 2005
quotequote all
Its when you make the speed sign go that you need to ease off a little

Mikey G

4,891 posts

269 months

Friday 15th July 2005
quotequote all
They were trying out one of these round my way a couple of weeks ago, the scamera partnership were there at the time playing with it. At the time i was following a numpty up the road which was a 30 limit, as the sign wasnt setup properly it kept giving a red warning that you were speeding even though the speed showing was 29 mph, this caused said numpty infront to slow down, and slow down, a n d s l o w d o w n further until it read 10 mph and still flashing red before panicking numpty realised that something wasnt right with it and carried on as normal

totnesmonster

428 posts

280 months

Saturday 16th July 2005
quotequote all
Ah, the Halwell speed trap, it's been there a couple of years now. It does stop reading at 45mph though (so I've heard), i.e. if you do 50 through it, it still reads 45mph

shorty123

Original Poster:

376 posts

266 months

Sunday 17th July 2005
quotequote all
s2ooz said:
They are limited to 50mph to discourage "tests"

one week later it stopped working. thats £20,000 down the drain.



£20,000 for a bit of metal and a few hundred LED's... christ on a bike they need to get another manufacturer. There are lots of the "SLOW DOWN" signs in Bristol now - suppose thats where some of my inflated Council Tax is going


GetCarter

31,239 posts

308 months

Sunday 17th July 2005
quotequote all


More silly stuff here

www.stevecarter.com/ooops/ooops.htm

Steve

mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

284 months

Sunday 17th July 2005
quotequote all
There are a lot in Derbyshire.

Transport Research Laboratory found they're thee times more effective than cameras for reducing speeds.

Which begs the question why aren't speed cameras being replaced by these devices as a matter of urgency.....?

We all know the answer. They don't harvest cash to feed the government.

parrot of doom

23,075 posts

263 months

Sunday 17th July 2005
quotequote all
shorty123 said:
£20,000 for a bit of metal and a few hundred LED's... christ on a bike they need to get another manufacturer. There are lots of the "SLOW DOWN" signs in Bristol now - suppose thats where some of my inflated Council Tax is going




Design costs, installation costs (including power), clerical costs.....