Goodbye Armco?
Author
Discussion

esselte

Original Poster:

14,626 posts

298 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
I've noticed on a few motorways now that the armco of the central barrier is being replace by what looks like a small concrete wall.Is this happening all over the place or just around here (Derbyshire ,Lincolnshire,Humberside)?

scorp

8,783 posts

260 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
M18 motorway near me (doncaster) has been closed to 2 lanes for the last couple of months while they put up a concrete central barrier. God knows what impact that would have in a high speed crash, i guess it stops people getting onto the opposing lane though.

esselte

Original Poster:

14,626 posts

298 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
scorp said:
M18 motorway near me (doncaster) has been closed to 2 lanes for the last couple of months while they put up a concrete central barrier. God knows what impact that would have in a high speed crash, i guess it stops people getting onto the opposing lane though.


It's going on on the M180 as well.There's about 6 miles of lane 3 closed on each side.They seem to be using a "continual casting" sort of machine.

paulie-mafia

3,321 posts

254 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
Presumably this is cheaper than replacing the old armco with new stuff? Strikes me as pretty dangerous as a high speed impact with a concrete wall would mean the vehicle absorbing the impact and potentially flipping into the air?

r5gttgaz

7,897 posts

251 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
I live near Forrest Pines golf course (spotted a vanquish in there on sat) and it seems the concrete barriers are going from J4 right up to where the M181 meets, I really dont like the look of them.

scorp

8,783 posts

260 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
Mate of mine managed to trigger all the speedcams in the temporary 50 zone of the m18 the other day. 2x £60 fine and 2x 3 points in the space of 2 minutes.

J1mmyD

1,823 posts

250 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
I'd be interested to hear from anyone who has detailed knowledge of this. My understanding was that Armco was great for car sized vehicles, but less effective with HGVs and even 4x4's. The 'steel rope' barriers were good at dispersing crash energy and slowing cars, but again were less effective with vehicles that had a higher centre of gravity.

Maybe these concrete barriers are more effective in some way?

(By the way, is it just coincidence that the two named motorways have a lot of commercial traffic as they provide the route to Immingham and the docks?)

esselte

Original Poster:

14,626 posts

298 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
From the Contract Journal:


"The concrete step barrier is now the Highways Agency's (HA) preferred option for future motorway barrier installations and replacement works.

HA interim advice note 60/50 states: "Evidence indicates that where the average annual daily traffic exceeds 25,000 vehicles/day there are significant benefits from a maintenance viewpoint in using rigid concrete rather than deformable steel barriers on busy motorways and dual carriageways. These benefits include significant health and safety benefits for road maintenance and traffic management operatives, as fewer safety barrier repair and maintenance operations are required."

One of the key benefits of the steel barrier is its ability to contain vehicles up to 13t, such as coaches and heavy goods vehicles.


The containment strength of steel barriers is vehicles up to 1.5t.

Initially, the change in the HA's policy will apply only to motorways, but may be extended to busy dual carriageways.

The HA's decision has been welcomed by Britpave. Its director David Jones said: "The safety, maintenance and financial arguments for using the concrete steo barriers are compelling. They eliminate cross-over accidents. Despite evidence of vehicular impact on the M25 concrete barriers, their inherent strength and robustness has meant no repair or replacement is necessary.""


paulie-mafia

3,321 posts

254 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
On a related note, imagine if all of the taxes we pay to drive our cars was spent on the road network. Aside from shiny new armco, think of all the amazing stuff we'd have - smooth, hole free, anti-spray road surfaces, high visibility digital signage, satellite guidance for safe hands-free cruising.....

Well we can dream, huh!

J1mmyD

1,823 posts

250 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
r5gttgaz said:
I live near Forrest Pines golf course (spotted a vanquish in there on sat) and it seems the concrete barriers are going from J4 right up to where the M181 meets, I really dont like the look of them.


All down to Sargents for ice cream?

dilbert

7,741 posts

262 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
I'm guessing, but I'd say that the concrete barriers don't need replacing when they absorb (or reflect) the impact. Obviously the replacement costs a fortune, and keeps happening. The concrete barriers are probably more expensive to install, but overall they are cheaper.

>> Edited by dilbert on Tuesday 7th March 14:37

esselte

Original Poster:

14,626 posts

298 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
Do you think a car would just rebound back into traffic if it hit a concrete barrier.Would the concrete absorb the energy as normal steel barriers do?

mrandy

828 posts

249 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
armco kills bikers so good ridance......

r5gttgaz

7,897 posts

251 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
J1mmyD said:
r5gttgaz said:
I live near Forrest Pines golf course (spotted a vanquish in there on sat) and it seems the concrete barriers are going from J4 right up to where the M181 meets, I really dont like the look of them.


All down to Sargents for ice cream?



No way ! Blyton is much better.

dilbert

7,741 posts

262 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
esselte said:
Do you think a car would just rebound back into traffic if it hit a concrete barrier.Would the concrete absorb the energy as normal steel barriers do?


I don't know anything about this, but I'd wager that there is a much higher chance that a car hitting a concrete barrier would reenter the main traffic stream. That's not because of the barrier it's self, but because the vehicle would slow over a longer distance.

In some ways that may be safer, because it gives more chance for people to take avoiding action.

Overall I'd say that if you have a wide verge, the armco is better, but if there's little or no verge then it has to be concrete.

Notwithstanding, that's got to be a bit "finger in the air".

r5gttgaz

7,897 posts

251 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
mrandy said:
armco kills bikers so good ridance......


I dont like the decapitating properties of the steel rope barriers.

scorp

8,783 posts

260 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
Seems the government are favouring this because its cheaper to repair, irrespective of the increased risk of death if your unlucky enough to hit these at 70+ mph.

Einion Yrth

19,575 posts

275 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
r5gttgaz said:
mrandy said:
armco kills bikers so good ridance......


I dont like the decapitating properties of the steel rope barriers.

I don't imagine a bloody great concrete wall is exactly a stroll in the park.

Parrot of Doom

23,075 posts

265 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
I can't imagine the primary reason for installing these barriers is cost. I've seen very little in the engineering of new motorways that suggests that saving money is a priority over safety.

dilbert

7,741 posts

262 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
Hay bales, anyone?