Errr... how can this happen, the car that couldn't slow down
Errr... how can this happen, the car that couldn't slow down
TOPIC CLOSED
TOPIC CLOSED
Author
Discussion

lightstepper

Original Poster:

318 posts

251 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
From BBC News

***

Accelerator jam car hits 135mph
A motorist drove for 60 miles at speeds of 135mph after the accelerator on his BMW car jammed and his brakes failed.
Kevin Nicolle, 25, was on the A1 near Thirsk in North Yorkshire when the car started to accelerate.

"I was in tears most of the time on the phone to the police - I really could see myself dying," he told the BBC.

He was forced to drive on the hard shoulder to avoid crashing but eventually lost control and hit a roundabout near Blyth, but was unhurt.

I remember the 999 lady saying 'he's crashed

Kevin Nicolle

Speaking to BBC Five Live Mr Nicolle said: "I was travelling down the motorway and I came to traffic in front of me.

"I took my foot off the accelerator because it's automatic - but I wasn't slowing down at all.

"I hit the brakes. They were braking ok, they were keeping me at about 70mph.

"So I phoned up the police after I called the AA and they said straight away 'stick your hazard lights on and headlights on - we've go a helicopter on route to you'."

Police patrol cars were also sent but struggled to catch up with the BMW 318.

I survived the accident but I thought I was going to die in the fire

Kevin Nicolle

Mr Nicolle said: "Then the brakes started burning out - I could see smoke coming from the brakes."

He tried to put the car into neutral but the gears were jammed.

Mr Nicolle was in constant contact with the police on a hands-free phone.

As he approached Blyth he saw a sign for a roundabout.

"There was a load of cars parked waiting to go onto the roundabout, so I went on the inside on the hard shoulder to try to get around it.

"But doing that sort of speed there was no chance and I hit the roundabout head on.

"I remember the 999 lady saying 'he's crashed'.

"I survived the accident but I thought I was going to die in the fire."

But miraculously he walked away completely unhurt - and said he is now considering giving up driving for good.

Mr Nicolle said the police took the car away for tests and BMW said they would carry out a full investigation

***

I am not going to be too critical as I am not familiar with the car, but surely one could simply kill the ignition as a last resort, depress the clutch, bring it out of gear and coast it - I cant understand why this man couldnt stop.

Edited for gender mistake

>> Edited by lightstepper on Saturday 11th March 12:11

225

1,331 posts

257 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
Must be drive by wire? Reason eneough not to buy an automatic! Lucky fella.

gorvid

22,371 posts

256 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
lightstepper said:
surely one could simply kill the ignition as a last resort, depress the clutch, bring it out of gear and coast it - I cant understand why this woman couldnt stop.


This is what I thought too, also he was aware enough to call the AA and the Police...

I too made a gender mistake...

>> Edited by gorvid on Saturday 11th March 15:18

Raffles

1,931 posts

261 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
well it was an autoimatic. But I'm not sure whay she couldn't turn off the ignition. Must have been a reason...

Piglet

6,250 posts

286 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
Small point, it was a bloke called Kevin not a woman!

munky

5,328 posts

279 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
lightstepper said:
I am not going to be too critical as I am not familiar with the car, but surely one could simply kill the ignition as a last resort, depress the clutch, bring it out of gear and coast it - I cant understand why this woman couldnt stop.


Crazy isn't it. No clutch in an auto though. And it wasn't a woman.

lightstepper

Original Poster:

318 posts

251 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
Piglet said:
Small point, it was a bloke called Kevin not a woman!



Oh yeah - must put contact lenses in

225

1,331 posts

257 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
Kill the ignition, steering would lock and then you WILL crash.

paulie-mafia

3,321 posts

254 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
Yeah I read about this yesterday. Strikes me as very odd! The Sun reported it as 135mph too, but also mentioned it was a 318i - doubtful he was actually going that fast unless I'm missing something?!

FourWheelDrift

92,398 posts

315 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
225 said:
Kill the ignition, steering would lock and then you WILL crash.


Not if the police clear the motorway ahead and get him to drive in the centre of the motorway keeping it straight then cut the ignition, they could also have come up with any number of methods of keeping the car from hitting the barriers depending on what was available. Besides he still crashed later on.


Still they could make a film of it, they could get someone like Sandra Bullock to drive the car which is unable to cut it's Speed or it'll crash, and get someone like Keanu Reeves to try to save her from Speeding, whilst the police fanny about trying to help her cut her Speed, we could call it "The Car That Couldn't Slow Down"

racefan_uk

2,935 posts

287 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
225 said:
Kill the ignition, steering would lock and then you WILL crash.


Not if you just flicked it back to the first ignition point, it would kill the ignition but not lock the wheel.

He should have done that when it first happened when the brakes were still working. Better to try it at 70mph rather than 135!

speedychrissie

2,994 posts

270 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
225 said:
Kill the ignition, steering would lock and then you WILL crash.


really?
in my car (ok, not quite as complex electrics as a BMW but same principal) teh steering lock will come off if you just turn on the electrics (ie engine doesnt have to be running). so i owuld have been able to kill the ignition and then just turn the key to put the electrics on. hey presto, a car that is slowing, and steers!

is this not the case in teh 3 series?

apache

39,731 posts

315 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
racefan_uk said:
225 said:
Kill the ignition, steering would lock and then you WILL crash.


Not if you just flicked it back to the first ignition point, it would kill the ignition but not lock the wheel.

He should have done that when it first happened when the brakes were still working. Better to try it at 70mph rather than 135!


exactly, can't understand this one at all, even putting the handbrake on would have bought some time

atomicrex

862 posts

258 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
My pug will automatically kill the throttle if you press the brake, as its supposed to stop this very problem

Annoying when it comes to left foot braking though

225

1,331 posts

257 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
I suppose when he realised he should have done but he was probably too busy trying to find out what the police meant by switching on the indicators....

lightstepper

Original Poster:

318 posts

251 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
Sounds a bit extreme, but I am wondering if he was caught speeding at something rediculous by a scamera van and played out the rest of it? I just cant see how all this would have played out by itself. There are so many ways to kill a car if this happens.

A damaged car replaced with insurance is better than a driving ban or whavever if your job depends on it...

apache

39,731 posts

315 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
I'm kinda surprised he wasn't done for dangerous driving, I mean, using a phone at 135??

motco

17,669 posts

277 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
The steering will NOT lock unless you take the key out!

This story is a repeat one one about 4 or 5 years ago where a lorry driver made the same claim on the M1. It was smelly then and this is just as iffy. The lorry driver was later shown to be lying and I suspect that this story will go the same way. There is nothing to stop anyone turning off the ignition and knocking into neutral even on an auto. It's my guess that this is a ploy to get off a speeding ticket. BMW will move heaven and earth to prove it fake, of course.

apache

39,731 posts

315 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
motco said:
The steering will NOT lock unless you take the key out!

This story is a repeat one one about 4 or 5 years ago where a lorry driver made the same claim on the M1. It was smelly then and this is just as iffy. The lorry driver was later shown to be lying and I suspect that this story will go the same way. There is nothing to stop anyone turning off the ignition and knocking into neutral even on an auto. It's my guess that this is a ploy to get off a speeding ticket. BMW will move heaven and earth to prove it fake, of course.


I think I'd take the punishment rather than headbutt a roundabout at 135

atomicrex

862 posts

258 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
apache said:
motco said:
The steering will NOT lock unless you take the key out!

This story is a repeat one one about 4 or 5 years ago where a lorry driver made the same claim on the M1. It was smelly then and this is just as iffy. The lorry driver was later shown to be lying and I suspect that this story will go the same way. There is nothing to stop anyone turning off the ignition and knocking into neutral even on an auto. It's my guess that this is a ploy to get off a speeding ticket. BMW will move heaven and earth to prove it fake, of course.


I think I'd take the punishment rather than headbutt a roundabout at 135


In for a penny in for a pound!
TOPIC CLOSED
TOPIC CLOSED