PistonHeads.com Forum

RE: Pic Of The Week: E63 AMG Takes On M5 And XFR

RE: Pic Of The Week: E63 AMG Takes On M5 And XFR

Friday 7th October 2011

Pic Of The Week: E63 AMG Takes On M5 And XFR

Super-saloons shining in the Spanish sun(set). Smashing


Click to preview
Click to preview
Today's POTW features three undeniably super super-saloons, but which is the, er, super-est? Well, according to our chums over on Autocar magazine, they reckon it ain't the new M5.

Which, as far s super-saloon group tests go, rather re-writes the form book. In fact, we reckon that the giving of the nod to the E63 AMG (now with 5.5-litre twin-turbo power, remember, just like the M5), is quite an historic victory for the big Merc, no matter how slender the margin - and it is a skin-of-teeth type victory.

As for the Jaguar? Well, it comes in third place but is by no means disgraced (and quite right, too).

But as well as a no-doubt controversial verdict, the group test in this week's issue of Autocar also allows us to present you with this rather pretty picture. You can see more of them, and read more about the whys and wherefores of the test, by downloading Autocar's digital edition (or by going to an actual shop to buy an actual, printed copy - we hear such things are still possible...)

Normal (1280x1024)
WideScreen (1440x900)
SuperSize (2048x1536)

Author
Discussion

Frimley111R

Original Poster:

7,221 posts

143 months

Friday 7th October 2011
quotequote all
XFR all day long for me please!

leon9191

748 posts

102 months

Friday 7th October 2011
quotequote all
The Jag for its looks, the AMG for its NA motor and the BM because its an M5 and the power. I dont think I could split these enough to choose just one.

Varsity

86 posts

92 months

Friday 7th October 2011
quotequote all
The more I see the Jaaaaaag, the more I like it.

The Merc and BMW seem to lack soul.

markCSC

2,955 posts

124 months

Friday 7th October 2011
quotequote all
leon9191 said:
AMG for its NA motor
Read the article above. It's a 5.5 V8 TURBO! smile

BigI

80 posts

98 months

Friday 7th October 2011
quotequote all
Not the best pow it has to be said,
Advertisement

Craiglamuffin

306 posts

89 months

Friday 7th October 2011
quotequote all
BigI said:
Not the best pow it has to be said,
I agree. V.cheesy. Speaking of which, anyone remember the old 80s framed pics of a Testarossa on a tron-like red grid background? Think they did a 959 as well and sold them in places like B&Q. Now there's a POTW.

Mostyn

13 posts

77 months

Friday 7th October 2011
quotequote all
BigI said:
Not the best pow it has to be said,
+1

soad

27,050 posts

85 months

Friday 7th October 2011
quotequote all
Mostyn said:
BigI said:
Not the best pow it has to be said,
+1
+2


thewheelman

2,194 posts

82 months

Friday 7th October 2011
quotequote all
Varsity said:
The more I see the Jaaaaaag, the more I like it.

The Merc and BMW seem to lack soul.
No car has "soul", it's just one of those daft things that people like Clarkson say.

V8 TEJ

197 posts

70 months

Friday 7th October 2011
quotequote all
Craiglamuffin said:
I agree. V.cheesy. Speaking of which, anyone remember the old 80s framed pics of a Testarossa on a tron-like red grid background? Think they did a 959 as well and sold them in places like B&Q. Now there's a POTW.
Yep I remember those. Were used on various 'Supercars' calenders too IIRC.

franki68

4,031 posts

130 months

Friday 7th October 2011
quotequote all
Varsity said:
The more I see the Jaaaaaag, the more I like it.

The Merc and BMW seem to lack soul.
I havent driven the new m5,nor the xfr but i have drven the xkr extensively and the e63 extensively and trust me ,if cars did have souls the e63 definitely has one.

Matt_P

98 posts

108 months

Friday 7th October 2011
quotequote all
Gotta feel sorry for BM....

E60 M5 = lairy V10 that car hacks declare is amazing for that 1 day of the year and not good enough the other 364........................

So

F10 M5 = Brilliant (Better than the merc indeed) 364 days of the year but we want it to be brilliant on the special 1 day!

Cant really win can they!

Side point: Can't wait for the M6 to come as its apparently 15% more focussed in every area than the M5. Should be a corker

Oh - and my e28 M5 is perfect what ever day it is! Can't beat the daddy!



dasherdiablo1

1,899 posts

130 months

Friday 7th October 2011
quotequote all
The Jag looks stunning against both the Merc & BMW. I'm sure the BMW has sublime handling but the Jag really does look good.

ludicrous speed

959 posts

103 months

Friday 7th October 2011
quotequote all
soad said:
Mostyn said:
BigI said:
Not the best pow it has to be said,
+1
+2
+57

Matt_P

98 posts

108 months

Friday 7th October 2011
quotequote all
dasherdiablo1 said:
The Jag looks stunning against both the Merc & BMW. I'm sure the BMW has sublime handling but the Jag really does look good.
Agree but really cant stand the jags new face lifted daylight LEDs - way too big!

ludicrous speed

959 posts

103 months

Friday 7th October 2011
quotequote all
Just seen another saloon which would have made a much better potw.....


torres del paine

1,586 posts

130 months

Friday 7th October 2011
quotequote all
Varsity said:
The more I see the Jaaaaaag, the more I like it.

The Merc and BMW seem to lack soul.
Explain why the Jag has soul and the other two do not without coming across as a clueless sheep.

nelly_h

138 posts

88 months

Friday 7th October 2011
quotequote all
It took me a while to get to like the looks of the XF, and just when I did they updated it.

The look of the new XF front and rear lights are a step backwards in my eyes. They've managed to make it look less modern somehow frown

thewheelman

2,194 posts

82 months

Friday 7th October 2011
quotequote all
torres del paine said:
Varsity said:
The more I see the Jaaaaaag, the more I like it.

The Merc and BMW seem to lack soul.
Explain why the Jag has soul and the other two do not without coming across as a clueless sheep.
He maybe sometime, he's probably online looking at some Haynes manuals, to find where they put the soul....

wink

Edited by thewheelman on Friday 7th October 13:57

ludicrous speed

959 posts

103 months

Friday 7th October 2011
quotequote all
torres del paine said:
Explain why the Jag has soul and the other two do not without coming across as a clueless sheep.
cos it's red