Login | Register
SearchMy Stuff
My ProfileMy PreferencesMy Mates RSS Feed
Monday 12th March 2012

Driven: Porsche Boxster S

Hot off the Geneva show stand Chris Harris has already tried the all-new Boxster...



Steering feel - this is a story about steering feel. How you respond to Porsche's third generation Boxster can probably be anticipated by your reaction to reading the stuff people like me excrete after trawling the adjectives bag. All of it is done in an effort to describe the sensation of holding a steering wheel in a moving vehicle. At this point I can promise that this review will not contain the word nuggety.

New proportions finally make sense of concept
New proportions finally make sense of concept
The new Boxsterdoesn't have much steering feel. There - I've said it. It is possibly the most complete open-top sports car ever made, and it is possibly the best car Porsche currently produces. But for these purposes I can only plunder the thesaurus to make reference to absent sensations: wriggle, squirm, fidget, chatter, patter or writhe (god I hate writhe). The Boxster does none of them.

And yes, the much debated electric power steering fitted to the 991 makes its second appearance in the new Boxster, codename 981. Like the 911, this is an all-new platform with extensive use of aluminium and high-strength steel. The shell is 87kg lighter, yet it is 40 per cent stiffer. The roof uses magnesium alloy sections and despite being physically bigger and carrying more passive safety equipment, the car is lighter than its predecessor - between 25kg and 35kg depending on model.

Familiar favourites
The 2.7-litre motor in the base car is an all-new direct injection flat-six producing 265hp and 206lb ft. Meanwhile the 3.4-litre engine in the S is a revised version of the engine from the last 987 model with slightly increased outputs - 315hp and 265lb ft. Both have variable valve lift and timing.

Brakes look puny within 20-inch wheels: aren't
Brakes look puny within 20-inch wheels: aren't
I'm going to concentrate on the S, because that's the one I spent the day in. It was running the spangly, optional 20-inch wheels, fitted with optional PASM (Porsche Active Suspension Management) and a smattering of other options.

Does anyone not agree that this car finally delivers on the styling promise laid down by the original concept in 1993? It's not as dainty, but in stretching the wheelbase 60mm, pulling the front track out 40mm and the rear 18mm - not to mention making the car longer (32mm) and lower (13mm) with a shorter front overhang (minus 27mm) Porsche has taken the Boxster to an LA tuning shop and given it the full number. Where once the wheels hid apologetically within swollen panels, they now push confidently outwards and the whole car sits down into the road surface. To me, it's the best looking Porsche since the Carrera GT.

Theory of relativity
It takes about 10 seconds to spot the steering. The wheel is slightly dead in the hands compared to the old car - it doesn't feel unnatural, just mute. At this point I would sympathise with anyone who went all Bannatyne and announced they were oot. But I would also plead with them to hang around and give it time. In this instance it is always wise to recall the parable of the Caterham R500 and the Porsche GT3 RS. After a drive in the Caterham, jumping into the RS will reveal it as being too heavy and completely lacking in steering weight, communication and feel. For about 10 minutes. Once your body adjusts to the change in circumstances - like eyes emerging from a dark cinema on a bright summer's day - the Porsche will soon feel quite different.

Longer wheelbase, shorter overhangs - good
Longer wheelbase, shorter overhangs - good
Point the Boxster into a turn and it does two things completely at odds with the expectations laid-down by that initial numbness. It turns with unusual speed and efficiency, then clips the very point on the road you'd been aiming for. Repeat this process for 15 minutes and, like me, you'll be left guppy-like with admiration. This car doesn't do over- or understeer at normal road speeds. Its Pirelli P-Zeros have so much grip, the centre of mass is so well positioned and traction is so good it just carves its way through switchbacks with sparkling finesse. It's only when you're in the middle of such a sequence, placing this car as accurately as any other you can remember, that you have to ask yourself what you are missing with this newfangled electric rack. The answer is simple: wriggle, squirm, fidget, chatter, patter and writhe. Yes, I miss them too, but they fade into insignificance within the overall Boxster experience.

That searing motor makes great noise and pulls very hard from 3,000rpm all the way to 7,500rpm. There is talk of turbocharged four-cylinder motors in the future, but they just won't be able to match the sharpness of an atmospheric boxer-six. Matched with a chassis apparently impervious to understeer it gives you so much confidence to endlessly trim cornering lines. This is helped no-end by the proper manual transmission. Not a doctored PDK from the 991, but a stick-shift from the dark ages: three pedals and endless, blip-tastic joy.

Manual box great, electric parking brake less so
Manual box great, electric parking brake less so
Manual labour
In fact the only blot for me is Porsche's insistence on running the brake pedal so bloody high relative to the throttle: unless the brakes are close to boiling it makes rolling from brake to throttle too difficult. The brakes themselves (330mm steels at the front) are predictably brilliant and way over-engineered for road use. No doubt they will melt at a track day, but that's both obvious and meaningless for a car of this type.

Nope, running fast over the Route Napoleon and its tributary D-roads I was locked in this car's spell. With the PASM set to comfort (Sport is too firm) and the car in Sport Plus mode (sharper throttle, reduced ESP intervention), it rode coarse surfaces with real sophistication but never felt heavy or ponderous in rapid direction changes. It was grippy without being tedious and also gave great confidence. Moreover, it was pleasant going fast and slow: roof-down at a cruise the Boxster can warm your bottom and play tunes, a few seconds later it gives access to what must be one of the best road car chassis out there. As a basis for a new Cayman, it's mouth-watering stuff.

Each one goes 'kerching' when pushed
Each one goes 'kerching' when pushed
By far the worst thing about the car for me is the infernal electronic handbrake. It's completely counter-intuitive in a three-pedal machine, it will only engage with the foot-brake pressed and it seems to only exist to extract new combinations of expletives from exasperated drivers. For me, it's a much bigger problem than the electric steering, but then your average photo shoot does contain an unnatural quantity of three-point-turns, so maybe I'm being a little over-sensitive. Whoever canned the manual handbrake but issued a stay of execution for the idiotic Sport Chrono clock needs lobotomising.

Coasting along
Even when you're carping about these few negatives, the car counters with more impressive details. The stop-start hardware is painless and alongside regenerative braking and a coast function for the motor (the moment it spots a coasting situation, it cuts to idle) and that direct injection system it makes for a very efficient 170mph car. Of course I thrashed it mercilessly all day and got it down below 20mpg, but in real life, this is a 30mpg machine. The boggo 2.7 does 180g/km, which is mind-boggling really.

So on first acquaintance, the Boxster is better looking, a little bit quicker, more capable in the turns and offers 10mm more telescopic longitudinal adjustment of the steering column - whatever that means. In the context of the marketplace only one of these really matters: on looks alone the Boxster could plug the hole created by slow 991 sales in the UK. If people choose to buy it based on the way it drives, so long as they can get their heads around the steering, they will own another great Porsche.

Oh, Porsche gave us a cereal bar to eat on our travels. It was nuggety. I lied.


PORSCHE BOXSTER S
Engine:
3,463cc flat-six
Transmission: 6-speed manual/7-speed dual-clutch auto (PDK), rear-wheel drive
Power (hp): 315@6,700rpm
Torque (lb ft): 265@4,800rpm
0-62mph: 5.1 sec (PDK 5.0 sec, PDK + Sport Plus 4.8 sec)
Top speed: 174mph (PDK 173mph)
Weight (DIN): 1,320kg (PDK 1,350kg)
MPG: 32.1 (PDK 35.3, both figures NEDC combined)
CO2: 206g/km (PDK 188g/km)
Price: £45,384

 

Chris Harris
2 3 ... 8 9
Reply to Topic
Author Discussion

Pheedbak

Original Poster:

654 posts

101 months

[news] 
Friday 9th March 2012 quote quote all
Ive taken a concensus amongst the ph tech team and we all still want. smile

stefan1

824 posts

116 months

[news] 
Friday 9th March 2012 quote quote all
I saw the car in the flesh today at the Geneva Motor Show. Agree with Chris completely on looks - it is stunning. I liked the old car; this one can snap knicker elastic at 20 yards.

Great to read about how it drives - I have one coming hopefully in May so cannot wait.

Cheers

Garlick

40,596 posts

124 months

[news] 
Friday 9th March 2012 quote quote all
Have you been staring at your screen waiting for this? hehe

andyman_2006

135 posts

74 months

[news] 
Friday 9th March 2012 quote quote all
really like the look of this, wheels look great, brakes look a bit tiny behind them tho!

stefan1

824 posts

116 months

[news] 
Friday 9th March 2012 quote quote all
Garlick said:
Have you been staring at your screen waiting for this? hehe
smile Good timing - got back from Geneva about 10 minutes ago! First port of call is always PH, don't you know!

(And I'd seen on Twitter that Chris had been driving the car today.)

Advertisement

Vladimir

6,917 posts

42 months

[news] 
Friday 9th March 2012 quote quote all
20 inch wheels on a Boxster?


smartypants

21,589 posts

53 months

[news] 
Friday 9th March 2012 quote quote all
Hmm, it looks like a fat MR2 and those wheels are awful.


0a

12,682 posts

78 months

[news] 
Friday 9th March 2012 quote quote all
It's strange I just don't get the looks thing, to my eyes it looks like further mild evolution of a blobby shape, but I'm sure it'll sell like hotcakes so what do I know!

Jimmy No Hands

2,518 posts

40 months

[news] 
Friday 9th March 2012 quote quote all
Those rear brakes look ridiculous. Reminds me of barryed up corsas on 19 inch halfords alloys with their drum brakes. Ugh.

Garlick

40,596 posts

124 months

[news] 
Friday 9th March 2012 quote quote all
stefan1 said:
smile Good timing - got back from Geneva about 10 minutes ago! First port of call is always PH, don't you know!

(And I'd seen on Twitter that Chris had been driving the car today.)
Good man! I was referring to Pheedback as it happens but great to read you always visit us first smile

Very lucky to have a car coming your way. Have you specced yet?

Raja

4,787 posts

119 months

[news] 
Friday 9th March 2012 quote quote all
Electric handbrake! I remember driving one of their cars with some stupid switches to change gear. Some things are just stupid.

Not sure about the wheels either but the car looks good.

Rawwr

14,292 posts

118 months

[news] 
Friday 9th March 2012 quote quote all
Those 20" wheels look ridiculously large in proportion to the rest of the car.

VeeDub Geezer

460 posts

38 months

[news] 
Friday 9th March 2012 quote quote all
Lovely, lovely looking thing. Looks over-wheeled on the 20s in my opinion though.

SonnyM

3,053 posts

77 months

[news] 
Friday 9th March 2012 quote quote all
We need a Chris Harris video masterpiece to accompany this. Afterall the best roadster in the world doesn't come along that often...

SonnyM

3,053 posts

77 months

[news] 
Friday 9th March 2012 quote quote all
andyman_2006 said:
really like the look of this, wheels look great, brakes look a bit tiny behind them tho!
The only way to fudge it is to have the black calipers option.

wormus

5,956 posts

87 months

[news] 
Friday 9th March 2012 quote quote all
Sorry, I just don't get Boxters. They are simply gay aren't they?

Pheedbak

Original Poster:

654 posts

101 months

[news] 
Friday 9th March 2012 quote quote all
Garlick said:
Good man! I was referring to Pheedback as it happens but great to read you always visit us first smile

Very lucky to have a car coming your way. Have you specced yet?
What can i say. Just out celebrating a particularly decent sprint with the boys and it was agreed we should run one as a tech mule.

Ps. Its pheedbak as in l33t h4x0r smile

stefan1

824 posts

116 months

[news] 
Friday 9th March 2012 quote quote all
Garlick said:
stefan1 said:
smile Good timing - got back from Geneva about 10 minutes ago! First port of call is always PH, don't you know!

(And I'd seen on Twitter that Chris had been driving the car today.)
Good man! I was referring to Pheedback as it happens but great to read you always visit us first smile

Very lucky to have a car coming your way. Have you specced yet?
Yes, about 2 weeks ago. Platinum Silver, 19 inch wheels (the 20s do look oversized, even on the 911s I saw today), ceramic brakes and some smart two tone leather. Should look great.

Cheers

arkenphel

281 posts

89 months

[news] 
Friday 9th March 2012 quote quote all
A Porsche with no feedback? The only reason I've ever wanted a Porsche has been erased. Pah!

menguin

2,971 posts

105 months

[news] 
Saturday 10th March 2012 quote quote all
It looks like the terrible drawings of cars with massive wheels turned at a 90 degree angle. It doesn't need 20" wheels to look good!!!
2 3 ... 8 9
Reply to Topic