RE: Driven: Audi RS3 Sportback

RE: Driven: Audi RS3 Sportback

Wednesday 9th March 2011

Driven: Audi RS3 Sportback

At £40k, Audi's new RS3 'hatch' has some pretty tasty rivals


There's a lot to like about Audi's new RS3 Sportback - but it has serious competition at the price
There's a lot to like about Audi's new RS3 Sportback - but it has serious competition at the price
Without wishing to sound too much like some sort of automotive Gok Wan, it seems that, for the aspiring hot-hatch-about-town of the 'teenies', 300 is the new 200. (Are you Gok Wan? Ed.)

RS3 Sportback has a 'bespoke' flavour...
RS3 Sportback has a 'bespoke' flavour...
Two decades ago, you were doing distinctly well if you could muster 150bhp from your fast hatch. Then, at the turn of the century, Honda got all feisty and brought the fast hatch top-end up to 200bhp (all right, 197bhp, but close enough), while Audi had the original S3 with its 210bhp turbocharged 1.8.

Now, though, we live in a world where even a front-wheel-drive Ford Focus can summon more than 300bhp. So the 335bhp Audi RS3 Sportback doesn't seem quite as outrageously powerful as it would have done a few years ago, despite churning out damn near as many gee-gees as a BMW M3 would have done just five years ago.

It's not just power that's been on the up, though; even in its most basic trim (and we suspect few buyers will escape the Audi dealership without having first ticked-off several thousands of pounds of options) the RS3 still costs £39,900. Which is a lot of money to pay for a hatchback, however hot it is.

...and goes like stink. Is that enough?
...and goes like stink. Is that enough?
It's a measure of just how far up the performance car food chain the RS3 is being positioned that Audi's press material cites the Mercedes C63 AMG and BMW M3 as 'rivals', against which the £15k cheaper RS3 represents conspicuously good value.

In some respects this is a clever trick for Audi to play. On the one hand it subtly distances the car from its most obvious competitors - the likes of the Ford Focus RS500 or the Subaru STi Cosworth - while at the same time emphasising the car's premium credentials. On the other hand, it does set up the RS3 against some fairly serious competition.

The big question, then, is this: can the RS3 cut it as a bargain alternative to the fast German saloon norm, or us it really just a hot hatch with a painfully heavy price tag?

Even the engine is well-dressed
Even the engine is well-dressed
First impressions, it has to be said, are good. The basic performance stats of 0-62mph in 4.6secs and an electronically governed top speed of 155mph are spot on the mark, while 332lb ft of torque available 1600rpm and 5300rpm provides serious real-world punch, especially when overtaking. And the RS3 comfortably bests its more glamorous V8 German cousins when it comes to economy, with a claimed 31mpg on the combined cycle (no, we don't care all that much about economy, but when fuel prices are nudging £1.40 per litre it does become a little bit important).

There are the sort of bespoke touches you would expect of a fast German, too - the five-cylinder 2.5-litre turbocharged motor is made with vermicular graphite (makes it lighter, apparently), while the front wings are of carbon fibre reinforced plastic. The suspension is 25mm lower and the car sits on a wider, 1564mm track, too.

RS3 could be any hot Audi from here
RS3 could be any hot Audi from here
These are all definitely moves in the right direction, but it doesn't really feel specialised enough to compete with its higher-end rivals. The whole effect is a bit too reliant on flared wheel arches, a deep front spoiler and chunky 19-inch wheels to differentiate itself sufficiently from more ordinary Audis - and that sounds like the sort of tricks a hot hatch would employ to us.

On the road it's another case of nearly-but-not-quite for the RS3. Its offbeat five-pot thrum is distinctive, its thrust undeniable, and its four-wheel-drive traction and grip are unquestionable, but it just isn't as involving, as enjoyable as you hoped it would be.

It covered the ground on our twisty Alpes-Maritimes test route with searing pace, and you would emerge from a particularly challenging section filled with the tingling buzz of adrenaline. But that excitement came more from sheer speed and the sense of having attacked a road with some fairly precipitous drops on it than from anything innate to the RS3's dynamic behaviour.

Sportback adds practicality around to
Sportback adds practicality around to
The problem, as is so often the case with fast Audis, is that the RS3 just doesn't flow with you down the road. It feels safe, grippy and predictable, but there's precious little sense of adjustability to the chassis, whether on the approach to, in the middle of, or exiting a corner.

The gearbox can be a bit finicky out of really slow corners, too, the ratios of the 7-speed S tronic twin-clutch effort making the car too eager in first and too lethargic in second.

In the RS3's dynamic defence, however, both the gearbox and chassis are more comfortable with fast flowing sections of road, and the fact that the gearbox doesn't change up automatically at the red line is a welcome nod to the enthusiast driver.

Nice in red, too...
Nice in red, too...
It's one of few genuine nods to the hardcore driving enthusiast, though. Like the TT RS and RS5 before it, the RS3 seems to represent a further move away from hardcore performance in favour of something a little softer - and arguably more civilised.

That's not necessarily a bad thing, mind. An RS3 will appeal to those who want to enjoy a fast, safe, comfortable and well-built car, and who want to know that there are deep reserves of grip and pace available should they wish to plumb them. Those who want that nth degree of driver involvement, however, probably ought to look elsewhere. Still, the RS3 has an undeniably wide spread of abilities, and Audi will no doubt find more than enough buyers for the 500 or so it plans to bring to Blighty.

As for whether the RS3 is a hot hatch or a super-saloon, I'm going to have to draw a woolly conclusion on this one and say neither. Just as the 'Sportback' bodystyle won't be easily pigeon-holed into any one category (Audi has chosen it mainly to distance the car further from the TT RS than if it had a three-door body), so the RS3 doesn't seem to sit easily into any one category. It's definitely too refined and sophisticated to be called a hot hatch, but it's a few cylinders and several percentage points of commitment short of bearing comparison with an M3 or C63.



Author
Discussion

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

54 months

Wednesday 9th March 2011
quotequote all
What a really nice looking, tidy little car. Shame Audi's are usually driven by ccensoredks.

kbee540

197 posts

208 months

Wednesday 9th March 2011
quotequote all
Looks a pretty nice motor...for £35k with all the trimmings. For £40k+, no thanks. Taking the pi$$ methinks.

B.J.W

5,782 posts

215 months

Wednesday 9th March 2011
quotequote all
PSBuckshot said:
What a really nice looking, tidy little car. Shame Audi's are usually driven by ccensoredks.
Excellent, yet another well informed and constructive post to kick this thread off in the best possible way.

There have been some right tts joining PH recently rolleyes


daveknott5

731 posts

219 months

Wednesday 9th March 2011
quotequote all
In the real world (traffic jams, motorways, rain, snow etc) this car makes real sense. OK so it's not going to allow lots of power oversteer like an M3 or C63 AMG, but how often do you really get a chance to drive like that in everyday driving?

My main problem with it is that it's just too expensive for what it is. Knock off £10k from the price please Mr Audi and that'd be about right in terms of pricing for what it is in my opinion.....

The 1 Series M Coupe is also over-priced for what it is by the way..... It seems in these tough economic times, the petrol companies and the car companies are inflating prices day by day...........

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

54 months

Wednesday 9th March 2011
quotequote all
B.J.W said:
Excellent, yet another well informed and constructive post to kick this thread off in the best possible way.

There have been some right tts joining PH recently rolleyes
Sorry for having an opinion. I forgot they're not allowed.

Reardy Mister

13,757 posts

222 months

Wednesday 9th March 2011
quotequote all
Thats a good article Riggers. Nice job.

RedWhiteMonkey

6,837 posts

182 months

Wednesday 9th March 2011
quotequote all
PSBuckshot said:
What a really nice looking, tidy little car. Shame Audi's are usually driven by ccensoredks.
Nice enough looking but not that different from a normal A3 as far as I can see, although it looks like Audi have been rather taken with some of the design features from the Citroen DS3 design. Wheels are quite err… funky.

Please don’t believe everything Mr Clarkson says.

B.J.W

5,782 posts

215 months

Wednesday 9th March 2011
quotequote all
kbee540 said:
Looks a pretty nice motor...for £35k with all the trimmings. For £40k+, no thanks. Taking the pi$$ methinks.
As the review states, a bit of a half way house. Having said that, considering the RS4's retailed at £50k new, is 15k less for the '3' version really taking the piss?

Not a car that floats my boat - but then I wouldn't spend £40k on a new car and be then first to take the massive hit on depreciation. My guess is that the RS3 will make more of a case for itself when it is 3 years old and down to £25k.

Ed.

2,173 posts

238 months

Wednesday 9th March 2011
quotequote all
It will be interesting to see if any future RS's follow the way of the RS4 and R8 when this 'S line plus' position sells so well, enthusiasts are a minority of car buyers.

mat205125

17,790 posts

213 months

Wednesday 9th March 2011
quotequote all
Looks like a fastasticly capable car on paper, and I'm really looking forward to hearing what evo might think about the way it drives ...... Even better, for someone to trust me with a set of keys for an hour.

I'm not even 50% convinced by Audi's marketting spin of trying to pass the car off as a cheap alternative to an M3 or C63 AMG, however. I fail to see this as anything by a ludicrously expensive hot hatch - Odd, however, that I've actually convinced myself somehow that the imminent 1 Series M Coupe is actually quite reasonably priced??????? The comparison of the BMW 1 Series M, and the RS3 will be one of the most interesting ones to watch later this year IMO, and it'd be made even more interesting by chucking the RS Focus into the mix too.

Hate the red stripe round the rim's perimeter BTW, but that is very subjective of course.

marctwo

3,666 posts

260 months

Wednesday 9th March 2011
quotequote all
This is the car I have always wanted.

Shame about the wheels hurl

mat205125

17,790 posts

213 months

Wednesday 9th March 2011
quotequote all
Ed. said:
It will be interesting to see if any future RS's follow the way of the RS4 and R8 when this 'S line plus' position sells so well, enthusiasts are a minority of car buyers.
yes

A great term, and very valid question!

Why waste millions developing bespoke "scalpels" for driving enthusiasts, when similar stats and sales can be acheived with a breathed on "hammer" garnished in RS logos and tinsel.

Oddball RS

1,757 posts

218 months

Wednesday 9th March 2011
quotequote all
I'm sure its a great motor, i'm just not feeling it though, it looks boring next to a Golf, which isn't easy to do, and those wheels are, well i really can't say it on here.

george h

14,707 posts

164 months

Wednesday 9th March 2011
quotequote all
Does this mean we will be getting faster Golfs/Leons appearing soon?

Hopefully they will come with nicer alloy wheels.

Johnnytheboy

24,498 posts

186 months

Wednesday 9th March 2011
quotequote all
This does seem to fit the bill for my next car rather well. Apart from the wheels...

B.J.W

5,782 posts

215 months

Wednesday 9th March 2011
quotequote all
marctwo said:
This is the car I have always wanted.

Shame about the wheels hurl
The new beemer would be a very interesting head to head.

I would be just as interested in a comparison between the RS4 and RS3. Even after 3 years, the former is still as capable as the current generation M3, so if the PH boys are saying that the RS3 is not quite up to beating Bavaria's best, then it is hard to justify paying up to £40k for the RS3 when you can buy a mint, low mile, RS4 for under £30k. (unless you absolutely have to have a brand new 40k performance hatch - in which case I'd save myself 15k and buy a Focus RS)

Presuming Ed

1,396 posts

208 months

Wednesday 9th March 2011
quotequote all
I've always thought the A3 sportback a good looking car and this builds on that. Its subtle and yet bloody pokey. I would assume that the people who buy this car aren't looking for M3 dynamics as they probably have another car in the garage that provides that. I'd like the option of a manual rather then DSG only but thats really the only criticism I'd put at this car. I bet as a day to day driver it'll be hard to beat.

fathomfive

9,916 posts

190 months

Wednesday 9th March 2011
quotequote all
So, one of these for £40k or the Golf diesel from another thread for £35k?


Reardy Mister

13,757 posts

222 months

Wednesday 9th March 2011
quotequote all
mat205125 said:
The comparison of the BMW 1 Series M, and the RS3 will be one of the most interesting ones to watch later this year IMO,
yes

Good point. It seems Audi are happy to lean more towards the I want to look sporty and dangerous, just dont make my car actually sporty or dangerous customer category, than BMW's bigger engines with more cyclinders and rear drive approach. Have they really been confusing capable with enjoyable all this time or is it deliberate?

Riggers, how come we dont get many comparison news pieces?


Dan S

944 posts

230 months

Wednesday 9th March 2011
quotequote all
Hmm, Audi launch in Monaco. Are Audi trying to convince themselves, and indeed punters, that the RS3 is more exclusive than it is and thus worth the mental asking price.

They can market this up all they want but its ridiculously over priced, and I mean RIDICULOUSLY. Seems VAG have brand delusions of grandeur. Will the badge monkeys buy it? Probably.