PistonHeads > Gassing Station > Other Marques > Kit Cars > Iconic Motors a restyled Cobra
Reply to Topic
Author Discussion

fuoriserie

Original PosterOriginal Poster

2,821 posts

96 months

[news] 
Saturday 7th November quote

singlecoil

2,566 posts

73 months

[news] 
Saturday 7th November quote
That's very nice



Being quite old, though, I prefer the original restyled Cobra


jgmadkit

418 posts

76 months

[news] 
Saturday 7th November quote
Not a bad effort I suppose, although the first thing that came to mind when I saw it was the Walt Disney cartoon character Droopy!

Needs to lose the front splitter, spoils things imho.


Joe T

413 posts

51 months

[news] 
Saturday 7th November quote
Mmm, I like AC's
Reading through the site I am surprised they have put there name to this.

Maybe it would look cleaner without the front splitter, not sure about the screen either.




JONSCZ

238 posts

64 months

[news] 
Saturday 7th November quote
more vids here.....

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uYEoozsMQz4

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dg18bebD9Hk&fea...


Oh, and it appears to be $600k.....!!!!!!!!! eek

Jon

Edited by JONSCZ on Saturday 7th November 22:28

Advertisement

jas xjr

2,220 posts

66 months

[news] 
Saturday 7th November quote
Sorry but that's fugly

kennyrayandersen

58 posts

2 months

[news] 
Saturday 7th November quote
fuoriserie said:
interesting

Tony427

793 posts

60 months

[news] 
Saturday 7th November quote
I like the flip front bonnet, and nothing else.............and thats from someone who refuses to put boat anchors in his builds.

Cheers,

Tony


thescamper

131 posts

53 months

[news] 
Sunday 8th November quote
No No And thrice No looks like it came from the Morgan Aero school of design. Definitely not for me I'm afraid.

seansverige

164 posts

9 months

[news] 
Sunday 8th November quote
I'd say sympathetically updating an icon is actually more demanding than a clean sheet design, and these guys aren't up to it. The front wings look like they're been overinflated, the headlights are oversized blobs, and they see to have tweaked the grille opening and surface profile. Badly.

In fairness, Ford's own Cobra Concept missed the mark too.



The pity is that it looks like a lot of effort has been put into the engineering design details. I'll admit that I don't really see the point of a computer controlled filler cap, but would have thought they could do good business selling the side exhausts as aftermarket items.

This sort of stuff really isn't my cup of tea but IF you must do this sort of thing, why not give this guy a call?



http://www.racerxdesign.com/kc427.html

singlecoil

2,566 posts

73 months

[news] 
Sunday 8th November quote
seansverige said:
This sort of stuff really isn't my cup of tea but IF you must do this sort of thing, why not give this guy a call?



http://www.racerxdesign.com/kc427.html
Maybe because it's just a sketch, rather than an actual car?

seansverige

164 posts

9 months

[news] 
Sunday 8th November quote
singlecoil said:
Maybe because it's just a sketch, rather than an actual car?
And? Did you check the rest of his website - he HAS built bodykits etc, so has successfully taken things beyond two dimensions and lends this some credibility. There's also a link to Regalis Motors, although this seems to be nothing more than a website.

Regardless it's a pretty well developed sketch which is a damn site prettier than the Iconic Motors effort and I doubt will be the last 're-imagining' of the Cobra we see.

singlecoil

2,566 posts

73 months

[news] 
Sunday 8th November quote
Well, the sketch may be pretty but it's not of a car that could actually be built and run. Very similar to the fashion sketches that show impossibly thin and tall models.

Just look at the size of those front wheels!

seansverige

164 posts

9 months

[news] 
Sunday 8th November quote
I'm not going to accelerate the onset of RSI explaining exactly what a sketch like this is for and is supposed to achieve within the design process; you might want to read the design story of an individual model on a site like cardesignnews.com or carbodydesign.com.

Of course it couldn't be built exactly as is: that's why it's called a sketch, not a measured drawing. As far as design sketches go is not only not as exaggerated as the fashion sketches you refer to but less so than many other development sketches of cars that have made it to production.

I did not suggest that this was a blueprint - with regards to the Iconic, the front end treatment in the sketch is recognisably a Cobra but far better resolved and could survive the transition to reality recognisably intact.

singlecoil

2,566 posts

73 months

[news] 
Sunday 8th November quote
seansverige said:
I'm not going to accelerate the onset of RSI explaining exactly what a sketch like this is for and is supposed to achieve within the design process; you might want to read the design story of an individual model on a site like cardesignnews.com or carbodydesign.com.

I think I'll decline that, if you don't mind, at least until I am so bored that I am very bored indeed. I really couldn't care less why people feel the need to draw pictures of things that couldn't exist in reality, I'm sure they feel that they've got a good reason, but it all seems very pointless to me.

I'll take a real car over a 'sketch' anytime.

seansverige

164 posts

9 months

[news] 
Sunday 8th November quote
singlecoil said:
I'll take a real car over a 'sketch' anytime.
The former is impossible without the latter. Your argument is that unless every sketch is correct in every detail it has no worth at all: if we extend that to it's logical conclusion this means the design must be complete in every detail before pen is put to paper: sort of design it before actually designing it. The sketch does give a good idea how a finished item might look but would obviously be revised as the detailed design process developed.

There are those who think a flashy drawing is the be all and end all, and will impress others. This is patently nonsense, but it doesn't follow that all sketches are by definition without merit. You don't understand this design methodology or what role sketching plays in it: fine. You don't want to familiarise yourself with it: also fine, but then you forfeit the right to whine about it.

And if you think those wheels were big.... Mazda Kazamai sketch vs. reality

...and, at the end of the day, it's a concept so even the real things wheels probably still aren't anywhere near production feasible wink

singlecoil

2,566 posts

73 months

[news] 
Sunday 8th November quote
singlecoil said:
I'll take a real car over a 'sketch' anytime.
Reply to Topic