Strange One? Blown water pipe 996tt
Strange One? Blown water pipe 996tt
Author
Discussion

Leigh996tt

Original Poster:

3,858 posts

256 months

Monday 21st March 2011
quotequote all
So, after shedding most of the coolant on Saturday, I was hoping for a simple fix of just a pipe popping back on.

Turns out to be just that, but the pipe in question is the metal one that has a pressed in fitting onto the top of the engine behind the alternator. Not one I've heard of failing before and wondered if this is not normally a weakness.

Just have to wait for a new pipe to arrive from the motherland and then have the engine part taken to an OPC for it to be fitted due to specialist tools required.

And just as the weather was getting nice frown

Sunnysidebb

1,385 posts

198 months

Monday 21st March 2011
quotequote all
Apparently its a fault that is becoming more frequent as our cars age.
There are 7 pipes in all that are "Glued" in place and the glue is going brittle.
The Americans seem to suffer this more than us, perhaps due to more climate heat degrading the glue quicker??.

Frank

Edited by Sunnysidebb on Monday 21st March 17:58


Edited by Sunnysidebb on Thursday 5th May 18:19

Leigh996tt

Original Poster:

3,858 posts

256 months

Monday 21st March 2011
quotequote all
Sunnysidebb said:
There are 7 pipes in all that are "Glued" in place and the glue is going brittle.
So they're 'glued in' and not 'pressed in' Frank?

Are they're any others than the ones you refer to that would be 'pressed in' as this is what the guys at Malton have said is the problem?



EvoSlayer

1,952 posts

216 months

Monday 21st March 2011
quotequote all
Have a word with Gary (Mr Freefall) he had the same issue with the bonded water pipes and his are now fixed (permanently). I believe it could be a motor out job though unfortunately.

Rockster

1,515 posts

191 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2011
quotequote all
Leigh996tt said:
So they're 'glued in' and not 'pressed in' Frank?

Are they're any others than the ones you refer to that would be 'pressed in' as this is what the guys at Malton have said is the problem?
Isn't 7 enough for you?

As sunnysidebb correctly pointed out these pipes are glued/epoxied in and over time this glue/epoxy can fail and when it does the pipe comes loose and of course this is a big coolant leak that dumps alot of coolant out of the engine in no time.

This happens every so often to owners in the USA most often it seems from those that track their cars. A real danger is coolant (water/anti-freeze) is slippery and in IIRC at least one case a car lost traction when a fitting let go and dumped coolant on a rear tire or just ahead of a rear tire and the car spun. The car behind trying to avoid hitting the lead car lost control and crashed killing a person in the 2nd car. Other owners have just spun and a few have left the track and a few have hit things.

It is an engine out job to gain access to all pipes/fittings that are glued/epoxied to fix these proper.

Sincerely,

Rockster.

Edited by Rockster on Tuesday 22 March 00:14

D900SP

459 posts

214 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2011
quotequote all


2007 GT3 RS we recently repaired that had the coolant pipe issue.

rog007

5,832 posts

255 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2011
quotequote all
Glad to hear things are moving along Leigh; thank goodness for quality warranties eh! You've just confirmed Porsche will be getting a 'bag of sand' of my hard earned at the end of the year to extend the warranty once again.

However, what with the failure to design protection for the radiators and now this; who signed off the final design of the 996; do we have his/her name; are they still employed by Porsche? I think we should be told! redcard

Leigh996tt

Original Poster:

3,858 posts

256 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2011
quotequote all
Rockster said:
Isn't 7 enough for you?
Sure is, but I had to ask wink

Terrible news about the fatality.

EvoSlayer said:
Have a word with Gary (Mr Freefall) he had the same issue with the bonded water pipes and his are now fixed (permanently). I believe it could be a motor out job though unfortunately.
Assume they have used an alternative method of bonding the pipes in then?

rog007 said:
Glad to hear things are moving along Leigh; thank goodness for quality warranties eh! You've just confirmed Porsche will be getting a 'bag of sand' of my hard earned at the end of the year to extend the warranty once again.
Just a waiting game now Rog. Warranties, they do make sense sometimes biggrin

Thanks to all for your comments.

Sunnysidebb

1,385 posts

198 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2011
quotequote all
I have been in contact with ken on this issue and as I have said before , there is an alternative fix for these pipes. When he finds a bit of time he is going to let me kno what the fix is as I would prefer to have them replaced before they fail regardless if paid for by warranty or not.
Frank

Edited by Sunnysidebb on Thursday 5th May 18:20

Leigh996tt

Original Poster:

3,858 posts

256 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2011
quotequote all
Thanks for that Frank, TBH I thought Ken may have picked up on this thread but if he misses it I'll give him a shout.

Leigh996tt

Original Poster:

3,858 posts

256 months

Wednesday 23rd March 2011
quotequote all
Update:

This is the part that let go. Hopefully from the picture you can see the hook shape bonded in pipe that divorced itsself from the main cast alloy piece. A permanent solution to this particular connection has been done by welding in it place. Guess that only leaves 6 more to go biggrin

Hopefully it's going to be re-assembled tonight ready for collection tomorrow so a big thanks to Sam at Malton for chucking in the extra hours to get this done so fast.


Homer J

789 posts

249 months

Wednesday 23rd March 2011
quotequote all
Excellent news Leigh.

Well done to Samsonite as well thumbup

Does this mean you'll be at the Big Breakfast in Das Uber Beetle and not the Clio thenbiggrin

Leigh996tt

Original Poster:

3,858 posts

256 months

Wednesday 23rd March 2011
quotequote all
Homer J said:
Excellent news Leigh.

Well done to Samsonite as well thumbup

Does this mean you'll be at the Big Breakfast in Das Uber Beetle and not the Clio thenbiggrin
Ha, yes, just as I was getting used to the turbo'd Clio biggrin

Mr Freefall

2,323 posts

289 months

Wednesday 23rd March 2011
quotequote all
Leigh996tt said:
So they're 'glued in' and not 'pressed in' Frank?

Are they're any others than the ones you refer to that would be 'pressed in' as this is what the guys at Malton have said is the problem?
Yep they are glued in. Over time the resin gives up and they pop out. I think there are 8 pipes of this nature that can let go.

I have had one let go, and its quite common in the hotter states if the USA where temps are in the 90 -100 for part of the year.

You can get the pipe welded in, we are going have a look at doing this on my car now the k24/18g conversion is underway, but, it’s an engine out job.

You can buy a set of new connectors, there is a fabricator in the US that is making them and I think he was even selling them on eBay. However, if you were to fit them, you would have to heat up all your pipes to extract them, and clean all the glue off, then get them welded in. Remember. Its ally, so you would have to be really carful heating them all up and then welding them all up again, as the heat would be really hot to do this.

We are going to look at welding up the pipes in situe, using the Porsche parts on the car to save all this work.

Failing that, you have the Porsche part put back in, but it has been noted that the fit is not that good in some cases, and it’s the resin that make the seal, not a tight fitting joint.

HTH

Gary

D900SP

459 posts

214 months

Thursday 24th March 2011
quotequote all


Better photos of the welded in pipes.

Leigh996tt

Original Poster:

3,858 posts

256 months

Thursday 24th March 2011
quotequote all
Mr Freefall said:
Yep they are glued in. Over time the resin gives up and they pop out. I think there are 8 pipes of this nature that can let go.

I have had one let go, and its quite common in the hotter states if the USA where temps are in the 90 -100 for part of the year.

You can get the pipe welded in, we are going have a look at doing this on my car now the k24/18g conversion is underway, but, it’s an engine out job.

You can buy a set of new connectors, there is a fabricator in the US that is making them and I think he was even selling them on eBay. However, if you were to fit them, you would have to heat up all your pipes to extract them, and clean all the glue off, then get them welded in. Remember. Its ally, so you would have to be really carful heating them all up and then welding them all up again, as the heat would be really hot to do this.

We are going to look at welding up the pipes in situe, using the Porsche parts on the car to save all this work.

Failing that, you have the Porsche part put back in, but it has been noted that the fit is not that good in some cases, and it’s the resin that make the seal, not a tight fitting joint.

HTH

Gary
Very helpful thanks. Do let me/us know how yours progresses.