RE: Porsche Boxster

RE: Porsche Boxster

Monday 29th November 2004

Porsche Boxster

Steve Bennett takes a shine to Porsche's second-generation roadster


Note to any manufacturer either currently in the roadster market or looking to join: get hold of the new Porsche Boxster. Drive it, take it to pieces, and examine in minute detail. Ask: "Can we compete on any level?"

Shuffle off with tail between legs.

Note to prospective buyers currently in the market for a roadster: there can only be one reason for not buying a Boxster. You don't like Porsches (although not quite liking how it looks is just about acceptable). On every other level the Boxster has the opposition well and truly stuffed.

From sheer outright pace, handling and performance to build quality and stunning attention to detail, the Boxster kicks dirt in the face of its other Teutonic rivals not to mention the likes of the Honda S2000 and the Nissan 350Z Sorry, did someone say TVR?

That good, huh? Yes, it's that good but even we would concede that, in some parts of the UK, there are just too many of them around and that, perhaps, they do attract a certain 'type.' Ah, but don't all roadsters? There's a definite 'look at me' appeal to a roadster.

However, this isn't a sociology debate. Sports cars have always attracted poseurs as much as those of us who love driving. But you know that, when Porsche develops a new car, it's not for them it's for us - if you see what I mean.

Exterior

Typically, the new Boxster is all about evolution than revolution. No great surprise coming, as it does, hot on the heels of the 997. Porsche has taken flak on both counts but you have to admire the company's commitment to design and concept in these fickle times.

And before you accuse me of brown-nosing I have to confess that I'm not even a fan of the shape. That said it is less 'blobby' and rather more muscular than its predecessor - rather like the 997 over the 996. The wheel arches are more pronounced as are the sills, sideskirts and air scoop, oh, and of course the headlights. Other than that, though, you really would be hard-pressed to spot the difference.

Under the skin

It's all under the skin. Just as the previous Boxster shared parts with the Previous 911, so does the new car. Indeed the new car shares 30 per cent of its components with the 997 including most of its front end, the doors and a fair amount of the interior including the excellent seats. Still it's difficult to get sniffy about it in the way that, for example, dim-witted Jaguar drivers might get upset when they discover their Jaguar X-Type is a re-bodied Ford Mondeo. Besides it's this parts sharing that keeps prices in the 'within reach' area.

Other bits in common with the 997 are the optional active suspension system and the ceramic brakes, both of which have a big dynamic influence on the Boxster. However first acquaintance comes from actually climbing and settling in.

Interior

The interior is stunning, taking the Boxster way beyond current Mercedes/BMW levels with a new look in leather and high quality coated surfaces, of which Porsche is particularly proud.

Engine and performance

Naturally there are new engines, although here we'll concentrate on the 3.2-litre engine in the Boxster S. changes include:

  • Revisions to inlet and exhaust systems.
  • Power up by 20bhp to 276bhp at 6200rpm.
  • Torque up to from 229lb-ft at 4,600rpm, to 236lb-ft from 4,600rpm to 6,000rpm.

Rest assured it feels good and chunky. Inevitably, though, the Boxster has put on a few pounds so outright performance has barely changed: top speed is now pegged at 166mph with the 0-60mph sprint coming up in 5.5 secs. 

While there wasn't much wrong with the old Boxster dynamically, it's fair to say that much is expected of the new car. A stiffer bodyshell is a good starting point for the Porsche chassis gurus to work their suspension magic, although the choice of 19-inch wheels might be a questionable one for Brit buyers. However, that's the package we happily jumped into at the Boxster launch in Austria and, to be fair, there were some fairly gnarly roads to contend with.

Driving dynamics

With the component parts dealt with, as ever it all comes down the way they work together. After the glowing intro, you won't be surprised that they all get on rather well in a chatty, convivial sort of way -- although some have accused the steering of being somewhat introverted.

The days of stroppy supercars are long gone and typically actually driving the Boxster is no more demanding than your average saloon. The relationship between throttle, clutch, gearbox etc is precision Porsche. Light, direct but in no way awkward and above all obviously linked. It makes for a fluid, satisfying driving experience from the outset and with so much electronic gubbins involved it’s actually a pretty neat trick. So straight off the Boxster flatters the driver.

We're still in the 'getting to know you' stage here. Flicking through the gears, getting a feel for the clutch and exploring the engine's power band and torque curve. Sharp bursts of acceleration in second and third, feeling the unique noise and thrust of the trademark flat six. 

Push a little harder and the incredible balance of the Boxster - mid-engined rather than rear-engined like the 911 - is obvious. This is where the PASM starts to work its magic. Dormant at cruising speed, it wakes up when it senses the driver is pushing on a bit. Each damper then effectively does it's own thing, responding to what each individual wheel is doing and controlling the stance, roll and pitch of the car. This continues through cornering into braking and acceleration. Brake up to and into a corner and the PASM supports the front of the car, keeping the weight transfer in check. Combined with the effective braking capabilities of either the 318mm steel or ceramic discs, the six pot calipers, plus the inherent mid-engined balance, and you have a braking set-up that inspires a level of confidence beyond most.

The PASM can be selected manually and is complemented by a sports setting that sharpens up throttle response too. Given that PASM can work out for itself when it's required, and that the throttle response feels about as sharp as the new razor I sliced myself on this morning, then it seems hardly worth it. Particularly since it just makes the low speed ride fairly unpleasant.

The engine, while not having the sheer grunt of the 3.6 and 3.8-litre units in the 911, still has that elasticity that allows you to hang on to a gear from low to peak revs, handy on the Austrian mountain roads that we're climbing. It sounds fantastic too moving the air with a sort of hollow ripple rising to a full of yowl.

String together a sequence of bends whether known or unknown, and the blend of steering input, chassis response and power delivery contrives to produce something as close to sports car nirvana as we've yet to experience. The engine doesn't smother the chassis or vice versa, while the electronics, for once, feel analogue rather than digital.

So there you have it. It's that good. The undisputed king of the roadsters and now the standard reference point for what makes a sports car.

Author
Discussion

RoadsterRaks

Original Poster:

1,868 posts

257 months

Monday 29th November 2004
quotequote all
Well I like it

gemini

11,352 posts

264 months

Monday 29th November 2004
quotequote all
Beautiful car

Just every arse has one!

Alex

9,975 posts

284 months

Monday 29th November 2004
quotequote all
Still looks too girly for me. I may be tempted by the Boxster coupe, if it appears.

Glenn McMenamin

2,305 posts

238 months

Monday 29th November 2004
quotequote all
THE most complete sports car EVER !!!


(and i Don't even own one !!)



G.

anniesdad

14,589 posts

238 months

Monday 29th November 2004
quotequote all
Fantastic motor and great value for money if you don't go daft on the options.

dinkel

26,942 posts

258 months

Monday 29th November 2004
quotequote all
"The engine, while not having the sheer grunt of the 3.6 and 3.8-litre units in the 911 . . ."

My guess - for what it's worth - : 997 dissapears and will stay in supersport (turbo and all) mode only and the Boxter takes over. Midengine and all: way to go her doctor . . .

v8 anyone

A shame you see 'em a lot. But hey, I see a lot of 911s as well. Maybe that's because I live near the dutch importer . . .

Buffalo

5,435 posts

254 months

Monday 29th November 2004
quotequote all
Its nice to see this one looks a lot more like the original concept and you can actually tell front from back!

I have a model of the concept and it a much nicer car to look at than the current model - its nice that Porsche got back on track with this version IMO.

v15ben

15,794 posts

241 months

Monday 29th November 2004
quotequote all
Yes, I had a look at one in the local OPC on Sunday.
I have to say that I prefer the look of the new model compared to the 986 model.
It still seems like this is a very complete sports car and I for one would love to own one.

Thought I'd add a pic of the one I looked at, give a slightly different view to the above pics:

gofasterrosssco

1,238 posts

236 months

Monday 29th November 2004
quotequote all

Gorgeous car, but Porsche look to be playing a dangerous game; give this car the engine and a few "tweeks" from the new 911 and suddenly the 911 would seem overpriced, oddly engineered (rear engine) and probably slow in comparison. Ofcourse they would never be so stupid as to do this.

But then again, a 'boxster coupe'. Will be great for the potential buyer, but could backfire on sales??

gofasterrosssco

1,238 posts

236 months

Monday 29th November 2004
quotequote all

Gorgeous car, but Porsche look to be playing a dangerous game; give this car the engine and a few "tweeks" from the new 911 and suddenly the 911 would seem overpriced, oddly engineered (rear engine) and probably slow in comparison. Ofcourse they would never be so stupid as to do this.

But then again, a 'boxster coupe'. Will be great for the potential buyer, but could backfire on sales??

anniesdad

14,589 posts

238 months

Monday 29th November 2004
quotequote all
It's a baby CGT is what it is, looking at the two side by side the oher day. If I asked my Wife which was the more expensive, she wouldn't have had a clue. To think the CGT is 10 times more expensive than the Boxster is quite unbelievable really.

The CGT I saw by the way, had some uneven carbon weave in between the 2 seats, and it caught the light, meaning it actually looked at odds with the rest of the weave. Just a minor point but this would do my head in if I'd shelled out £300K+ for the car as it was in a very noticeable area.

Melv

4,708 posts

265 months

Monday 29th November 2004
quotequote all
Saw one at Reading yesterday -the Boxster has grown up!!

Mel

paultje

1,042 posts

239 months

Monday 29th November 2004
quotequote all
Nice motor....lets hope the engines are robust!!
Can't be a pleasant feeling looking at the new car if your old one went phut!!

ocho

605 posts

237 months

Monday 29th November 2004
quotequote all
Interesting comment on it looking like a baby CGT - I'm sure I saw a CGT kit for the Boxster advertised somewhere recently. I think there were even some pictures and IIRC it was quite convincing without looking too closely...

anniesdad

14,589 posts

238 months

Tuesday 30th November 2004
quotequote all
I would add the CGT is much much wider, much much lower and has a more agressive overall profile. But if you had glaucoma, I suppose you might not know the difference.

dinkel

26,942 posts

258 months

Tuesday 30th November 2004
quotequote all
Am I the only one who thinks the future Boxter will be the next 911? And the 911 steps up to supercar territory with the turbo / 450+ lump?

Will the Cayenne v8 fit in? Boxter+ maybe?

anniesdad

14,589 posts

238 months

Tuesday 30th November 2004
quotequote all
I would have thought it fair to say that some 911 variants are "supercars" anyway. I personally am not convinced that Porsche will kill the 911 completely. In fact I thought they were doing a feasability study on a further production model, being possibly a 4 door 928'alike.

FestivAli

1,088 posts

238 months

Tuesday 30th November 2004
quotequote all
Damn. This always happens. I just start to like the model about to be replaced. The 986 Boxter S, 2003 model in a thick yellow - yum. The new one? Err, maybe. I read the interior is a pain, too many buttons on the console as per new Carrera. What Porsche needs to do is forget about a Boxter coupe and make another 928. Sonourus V8, plush cabin with manual or auto - a proper grand tourer that can seat four for blasting around Europe in. Price it at around 60 thousand pounds - compete with the aesthetically challenged 6, cramped XK8/R (although I love that car so much)and opinion dividing Maserati Coupe, and you can't go wrong.

Now, give me a '67 911 (dark silver with Fuchs alloys), a 928 GTS (Black will do), the aforementioned Boxter, a silver Carrera GT and hell, why not, a Tungsten Cayenne S (Turbo seems a bit excessive for mudplugging). Anyone?

jeremyadamson

1,867 posts

259 months

Tuesday 30th November 2004
quotequote all
I've just been talking to a sales guy at Chiswick Porsche centre.....he said (off the record) that the Boxster S is a better drive than the 997 Carrera 2, and that quite a few 911 C2 orders have been changed to high spec Boxster S ones, following the launch night and test drive. He did go on to say that the 911 Carrera S is another story though!

MTY4000

327 posts

243 months

Tuesday 30th November 2004
quotequote all
Looks fantastic (and I'm sure it will be hoot to drive), I too am keen to see the coupe... intial pictures looked amazing.

And a great article by Steve Bennnet. Pistonheads really is producing a great product these days.