Lamborghini 2+2 Supercar Yay or Nay?

[Tuvra]

After my last photoshop effort of a 2+2 Lamborghini coupe got (rightly) slaughtered on a recent thread, I thought I would have another go now my skills have sharpened. One poster claimed I had photoshopped and ruined a Estoque when in fact it was a Maser GT i actually ruined. Heres my attempt at "ruining" an Estoque:

Original Estoque Starting Point:

Pillarless 2+2 Lamborghini Supercar.


Restyled Edition.

So the Question is Yay or Nay?

Edited by Tuvra on Monday 20th February 12:40

[Tuvra]

It was more about the shape than the skills

I was about to cut it down length wise, but when I opened the window back up I found it strangely attractive, hence the question. Its an odd looking thing admittedly, I must have that Cadillac off TG stuck in my brain