WHAT ARE YOU DOING TOMORROW (WEDS) NIGHT?? (Gatwick Area)

WHAT ARE YOU DOING TOMORROW (WEDS) NIGHT?? (Gatwick Area)

Author
Discussion

Harsh

4,551 posts

212 months

Wednesday 1st August 2007
quotequote all
Not exactly.

It's an M car, there's a little more to it than that.
but it's not worth getting into a slanging match over,

my point remains why make your point by dissing other cars?

Stephanie Plum

2,783 posts

212 months

Wednesday 1st August 2007
quotequote all
Harsh said:
very well, still mourning the loss of FB5K for another year.....i'm sure i'll cope....just!

you going to Goodwood on Sunday?
i know furryballer is.........
No can't make it - off to watch Bogie in a sprint smile

PS Aren't you doing the Milau run? That'll give you a quick fix......

Harsh

4,551 posts

212 months

Wednesday 1st August 2007
quotequote all
Stephanie Plum said:
Harsh said:
very well, still mourning the loss of FB5K for another year.....i'm sure i'll cope....just!

you going to Goodwood on Sunday?
i know furryballer is.........
No can't make it - off to watch Bogie in a sprint smile

PS Aren't you doing the Milau run? That'll give you a quick fix......
good point actually, yes Milau.......

Thanks young lady, you've brightened up my day!!

Stephanie Plum

2,783 posts

212 months

Wednesday 1st August 2007
quotequote all
Harsh said:
Stephanie Plum said:
Harsh said:
very well, still mourning the loss of FB5K for another year.....i'm sure i'll cope....just!

you going to Goodwood on Sunday?
i know furryballer is.........
No can't make it - off to watch Bogie in a sprint smile

PS Aren't you doing the Milau run? That'll give you a quick fix......
good point actually, yes Milau.......

Thanks young lady, you've brightened up my day!!
That's brightened up mine biglaugh

joust

14,622 posts

260 months

Wednesday 1st August 2007
quotequote all
Fat Arnie said:
random ramblings
So you think a Caterham R300 could keep up with my Noble. rofl

Oh please, stop being a stupid person, or was the fact that you woulnd't accept a Noble not your point?

My point, because you seem to be stuggling, is if my Noble (power to weight ratio of 400bhp per tonne) qualifies, but I decided to turn up in the X5 (165bhp/tonne) what you going to do? Ignore me?

Elitest crap like yours won't go anywhere. Even my local TVR Car Club positivly asked me to take the Z4M to one of their meets.

Fat Arnie

Original Poster:

1,655 posts

264 months

Thursday 2nd August 2007
quotequote all
Justin,

You seem to have some kind of chip on your shoulder here, otherwise you would understand this club is for people who own cars such as Nobles, Elises, Caterhams etc. Its primary mission is not to become an elitest one make club.

I'm not sure where I made any comment on the basis of perfomance of an M12 vs. an R300, neither do I recall specifically saying a Noble would not be welcome. Having discovered (much to my surprise) the weight of an M12 is 1200kgs, I have edited the website accordingly. It should be noted however that the power to weight ration of a humble R300 is higher than an M12.

The main point however is the fact that you ALSO own an X5. This is of complete irrelevence, however if you ONLY owned an X5, or only ever intended turning up to a club meet or event in your X5, which was the implied basis of your original query, then the club is probably not for you as you would have little in common with the other members, only being able to speak about a car you own.

If you chose to attend in your X5 when the weather is less than ideal (I have been known to attend in a tintop when my car (which has zero weather protection) has been off the road or its been raining/snowing) then that's fine. Everyone else is in the same boat. On that note, how do you imagine people with race cars (i.e. not road legal)are going to attend? - we don't actually expect them to trailer them to the meet.

Besides that, if the drive fron Sanderstead to Copthorne is a big issue in anything other than an X5 or Z4 then am forced to draw the conslusion you are a car collector rather than a driver.

So please dont invent quotes and question my intelligence. All you are doing is stiffleing the purpose of this event, whihc is to get like minded people together.

And given you seem to have so much free time in which to comment on this thread, I trust we will be seeeing you at the next meeting on August 29th?

Fat Arnie

Original Poster:

1,655 posts

264 months

Thursday 2nd August 2007
quotequote all
Now I have said that, how do I lock this thread and move on?

joust

14,622 posts

260 months

Friday 3rd August 2007
quotequote all
Excuse me. It was you who said my Z4M or X5 doesn't have "any sporting pretentions". Exactly how does a car with more than 300bhp have anything else?

You were also the person that said you only wanted cars "in a largley similar performance envelope, especially on track". You then babbled on about some record in a CSR260 around the Top Gear track which doesn't even appear on the official times.

I was pointing out that clearly my Noble wouldn't be therefore eligable because even a R300 would have serious issues staying with it on the road, never mind a track, and therefore what about your poor old 1.6 Caterham owners?

If you are in any way representive of the people that goes, you can keep your elitist views with you, you won't be seeing me at such a narrow minded meet. Cars are there to be enjoyed, and if you can't appreciate exactly why having 355bhp in a 2 tonne barge isn't exactly what being a petrol head is all about, then quite frankly you shouldn't even be on this site.

Fat Arnie

Original Poster:

1,655 posts

264 months

Friday 3rd August 2007
quotequote all
I wanted to close this thresd, but feel this debate should continue.

A Z4M or an X5 is not a proper sports car. You can't do anything to set the car up without throwing major components of the standard car away. There are also thousands of both Z4Ms and X5s on the road.

You'll notice that proper sportcars like those designed by Lee Noble as well as Chapman and Gordon Murray are produced in much smaller quantities.

That's to some degree what makes them special.

Now if you understood Jeremy Clarkson, you would understand that he is a big chap, and he can't fit in a Caterham, Westfield or Radical, which is why they do not appear on his Fastest Laps board. CArs only get up there if he can have a go. If you've been to the Top Gear filming, you'd realise this. All 3 of those cars have been around the circuit, a Radical SR3 blitzing everything ever to go around there less the 2004 Renault RS24 driven by Kovalainen when dressed as the Stig. Jeremy, you see, doesn't like cars he can't fit into, especially if his wife does like them. Francie, his wife, of course own's a Caterham. The CSR lap is at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f6hjM1VrElE and remember, the CSR is not a particularly quick car, the R500 it repalced was a good bit quicker. And there are many other road legal Caterhams which are quicker than that. I do belive that lap time is 7.6 seconds faster than a Stig piloted M12 however. (also in the dry)

Moving on, I don't understand your point:

"I was pointing out that clearly my Noble wouldn't be therefore eligable because even a R300 would have serious issues staying with it on the road, never mind a track, and therefore what about your poor old 1.6 Caterham owners?"

What I do know, is that if you drive your Noble at anything aproaching its true envelope of capability on the road, assuming it is at least as fast as an R300, then you probably should not have a driving licence. And do remember that an R300 is only a 1.8, the extra 200cc's throwing only about 5 bhp into the mix.

Yesterday I saw a clip on TV of a guy moaning about designer clothes (I don't remember what program it was on, might have been a News Knight repeat.

His concept of making designer clothing obsolete and people walking around in Tee-shirts with a recent bank statement printed on the front instead, would be matched well in my opinion by the fact that some BMW owners could walk around with dyno plots of their X5 printed on their chest.

I can't quite belive that it is a BMW owner making an alegation of "elitist views"

And remember, at two tonnes, you appear to have only 177.5bhp/tonne. Thats hot hatch territory.

So Justin, if you don't wish to come and play with us because our kind of toys don't excite you, then that's fine. But do you have to keep going on about it? Nobody is interested.

Fat Arnie

Original Poster:

1,655 posts

264 months

Friday 3rd August 2007
quotequote all
Oh an dthe figure at the bottom of the page here http://www.radicalextremesportscars.com/media/trac...
indicate that the M12 is not really that much quicker than a Caterham Acadamy on Michelin Pileups with just 120bhp

Engine: 1600 K-Series
Max Power (bhp/rpm): 120 @ 6100
Max Torque (lbs ft/rpm): @ 5350
Weight: 550kg
0-60mph: 5.9 Seconds
Power-to-weight: 227 bhp-per-tonne
Top Speed: 112mph

TON70

531 posts

233 months

Friday 3rd August 2007
quotequote all
Stephanie Plum said:
Harsh said:
very well, still mourning the loss of FB5K for another year.....i'm sure i'll cope....just!

you going to Goodwood on Sunday?
i know furryballer is.........
No can't make it - off to watch Bogie in a sprint smile

PS Aren't you doing the Milau run? That'll give you a quick fix......
Sorry to hijack this but is there an organised run to the Milau that I've missed? (Mental note to oneself... visit these forums more often!!)

Stephanie Plum

2,783 posts

212 months

Saturday 4th August 2007
quotequote all
TON70 said:
Stephanie Plum said:
Harsh said:
very well, still mourning the loss of FB5K for another year.....i'm sure i'll cope....just!

you going to Goodwood on Sunday?
i know furryballer is.........
No can't make it - off to watch Bogie in a sprint smile

PS Aren't you doing the Milau run? That'll give you a quick fix......
Sorry to hijack this but is there an organised run to the Milau that I've missed? (Mental note to oneself... visit these forums more often!!)
Do you know the FB5K boys?

Harsh

4,551 posts

212 months

Saturday 4th August 2007
quotequote all
The Tuscan Rat said:
Would I be welcome in the TVR Tuscan, its a small lightweight 2 door, 2 seats sports car, that, as the company is god knows where is not made any more per annum.

Harsh, You could be My passenger !!! ( Or would that make the car to heavy )
that sounds like a plan, although with my bulk 'lightweight' would indeed no longer apply!

same problem with Nancy's S2000...

  • note to self* when trying to trim weight off the car, look at the driver!