Is Quattro worth the increased weight and price?
Discussion
Whilst looking for a suitable car to replace my Golf R I have been looking at lease deal on an Audi A4 S Tronic 2.0 Tdi 190 Quattro in Scuba blue with extended black pack and it looks very nice too. The S5 is beyond my price bracket but S4 is starting to look more sensible.
I have noticed in the specs that the Quattro does 0-60 in 8.9 while the FWD does it in 7.7 secs, the Quattro is also considerably more expensive but after loving the DSG and 4WD in the Golf R I am reluctant to go for a front driver.
Has anyone got experience of either FWD or Quattro in an A4? the cars are brand new as per the lease agreement
I have noticed in the specs that the Quattro does 0-60 in 8.9 while the FWD does it in 7.7 secs, the Quattro is also considerably more expensive but after loving the DSG and 4WD in the Golf R I am reluctant to go for a front driver.
Has anyone got experience of either FWD or Quattro in an A4? the cars are brand new as per the lease agreement
Quattro is definitely worth it IMO.
A couple of years back I had an A4, 2.0 FWD as a courtesy car for the day and found it very torque-steery and prone to spinning the wheels whilst going nowhere, luckily it was a warm, dry day as I wouldn't have wanted to drive it in the wet, I've also had 2.0, FWD A3 as a courtesy car and whilst I thought it was better than the A4 there's still too much drama under power.
At the time I had an A3, 3.2 quattro DSG and it was a relief to get back in it for it's fuss-free traction.
As for A4 with quattro, I now have an S4, (quattro/s-tronic) and it's in a different league to the FWD A4 and not just because of the engine, but that it can get the power down, even in the wet without ending up on the other side of the road.
Personally I've never really liked FWD cars, always had RWD cars until the A3, and the only Audis I would buy would be quattros.
If you can get the S4 then do so because it is, without a doubt the most capable all-rounder I've ever driven.
A couple of years back I had an A4, 2.0 FWD as a courtesy car for the day and found it very torque-steery and prone to spinning the wheels whilst going nowhere, luckily it was a warm, dry day as I wouldn't have wanted to drive it in the wet, I've also had 2.0, FWD A3 as a courtesy car and whilst I thought it was better than the A4 there's still too much drama under power.
At the time I had an A3, 3.2 quattro DSG and it was a relief to get back in it for it's fuss-free traction.
As for A4 with quattro, I now have an S4, (quattro/s-tronic) and it's in a different league to the FWD A4 and not just because of the engine, but that it can get the power down, even in the wet without ending up on the other side of the road.
Personally I've never really liked FWD cars, always had RWD cars until the A3, and the only Audis I would buy would be quattros.
If you can get the S4 then do so because it is, without a doubt the most capable all-rounder I've ever driven.
catso said:
Quattro is definitely worth it IMO.
A couple of years back I had an A4, 2.0 FWD as a courtesy car for the day and found it very torque-steery and prone to spinning the wheels whilst going nowhere, luckily it was a warm, dry day as I wouldn't have wanted to drive it in the wet, I've also had 2.0, FWD A3 as a courtesy car and whilst I thought it was better than the A4 there's still too much drama under power.
At the time I had an A3, 3.2 quattro DSG and it was a relief to get back in it for it's fuss-free traction.
As for A4 with quattro, I now have an S4, (quattro/s-tronic) and it's in a different league to the FWD A4 and not just because of the engine, but that it can get the power down, even in the wet without ending up on the other side of the road.
Personally I've never really liked FWD cars, always had RWD cars until the A3, and the only Audis I would buy would be quattros.
If you can get the S4 then do so because it is, without a doubt the most capable all-rounder I've ever driven.
My dealer was trying to lead me down the S4 road but fuel bills worried me. I got a 3.0Tdi quattro avant with all the trimmings instead, and have to say it's the best car I've owned by miles. Effortless performance (I think 0-60 in about 5.5 or thereabouts I'm not counting) great mid-range, all the other quattro benefits and about 50mpg on a run. It even sounds not to shabby for a diesel.A couple of years back I had an A4, 2.0 FWD as a courtesy car for the day and found it very torque-steery and prone to spinning the wheels whilst going nowhere, luckily it was a warm, dry day as I wouldn't have wanted to drive it in the wet, I've also had 2.0, FWD A3 as a courtesy car and whilst I thought it was better than the A4 there's still too much drama under power.
At the time I had an A3, 3.2 quattro DSG and it was a relief to get back in it for it's fuss-free traction.
As for A4 with quattro, I now have an S4, (quattro/s-tronic) and it's in a different league to the FWD A4 and not just because of the engine, but that it can get the power down, even in the wet without ending up on the other side of the road.
Personally I've never really liked FWD cars, always had RWD cars until the A3, and the only Audis I would buy would be quattros.
If you can get the S4 then do so because it is, without a doubt the most capable all-rounder I've ever driven.
Easternlight said:
Another vote for Quattro here. Had a 2.0TFSI and it was a royal PITA trying to pull out at wet junctions just would spin and tramp, where as my S4 that I replaced it with is like the wheels are glued to the road, rarely seen the TC light come on in 4 years.
I've gone from a FWD 2.0 TFSi A5 to a quattro TDi A5, I agree, the FWD was a pain at junction, you struggle to get traction in the damp, I never spin the wheels in the quattro. The fuel economy isn't as good as a FWD but I'm not arsed.Adrian E said:
If you're not used to the pain of adblue SCR injection on a Euro 6 diesel and you don't do that many miles, I'd steer well clear of the diesel option in any case.
The new S4 should be fab although it may be spec sensitive on the drive select options as to how well it handles
I don't find the adblue a problem at all, my A5 has a 20l tank, I've filled it once. Get the adblue from a commercial fuel supplier, its half the price of Halfords.The new S4 should be fab although it may be spec sensitive on the drive select options as to how well it handles
Quattro is expensive in terms of initial cost, running costs, tyres, fuel, tax and servicing. In proper winter conditions you'd be safer with winter tyres than 4WD, quattro will get you going but won't help you stop but I agree that it will nullify torque steer on a powerful front wheel driver. I have owned loads of 4WD cars and currently run an SQ5 and RS4 B8, but I live in the Peak District and have to suffer more snow than most, when I move to Devon I will be liberated. I genuinely believe it's a waste of money in everyday driving, triumph of marketing. I know it won't go down well here but it's my considered view after many years and much money spent that if you want a powerful car and enjoy driving get a RWD and fit winters for the winter. Sorry!
Easternlight said:
Another vote for Quattro here. Had a 2.0TFSI and it was a royal PITA trying to pull out at wet junctions just would spin and tramp, where as my S4 that I replaced it with is like the wheels are glued to the road, rarely seen the TC light come on in 4 years.
My wife had a Jetta with that engine and I agree entirely; trying to pul away with any enthusiasm was a pain.She's now got an A4 Quattro 3.2 and loves it. I've been droning on about how good my old 2002 A4 3.0 quattro Sport was so she bit the bullet and has even said she'd only want another quattro when it comes to replacing it.
Marketing or not, it feels far more planted and steady even under normal driving conditions.
Blue62 said:
Quattro is expensive in terms of initial cost, running costs, tyres, fuel, tax and servicing. In proper winter conditions you'd be safer with winter tyres than 4WD, quattro will get you going but won't help you stop but I agree that it will nullify torque steer on a powerful front wheel driver. I have owned loads of 4WD cars and currently run an SQ5 and RS4 B8, but I live in the Peak District and have to suffer more snow than most, when I move to Devon I will be liberated. I genuinely believe it's a waste of money in everyday driving, triumph of marketing. I know it won't go down well here but it's my considered view after many years and much money spent that if you want a powerful car and enjoy driving get a RWD and fit winters for the winter. Sorry!
Pretty much this. If you live where it snows often. Then why not if you want.But given in the UK it tends to snow every other year and even then it only stays for MAYBE a week. Is it worth all the other costs for the other 713 days?
Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff