Validating a Business Idea..
Validating a Business Idea..
Author
Discussion

WTD

Original Poster:

818 posts

264 months

Monday 7th October 2013
quotequote all
I'm looking to validate a business idea, by laying it out here publicly and asking the good folks in the business forum - Is this a good idea.

My idea, is to work with small businesses/one man bands to produce a custom spreadsheet based solution for an exact need that they have (solve a specific problem they face every day), at a very low fixed cost.

If you need to collect data from a form, slice it and dice it, then display it graphically on a webpage? I can do that.

If you need a very specific invoice template with some funky automation hooked up into it, then I can do that too.

I'm an "absolute wizard"* when it comes to developing spreadsheets for automating tasks and presenting data clearly and effectively.

There is some geeky seed in my DNA that means I enjoy working on spreadsheets, and if I could turn that into a business somehow I would be as happy as the cat that got the cream.

The only doubt in my mind, is this. Is there a genuine demand for a service like this? Would YOU use something like this??

Many thanks in advance :-)

  • actual words used by my first client...

Hoofy

80,189 posts

313 months

Monday 7th October 2013
quotequote all
Useful and interesting in theory but I suspect non-IT people don't know what is possible so assume it isn't possible and do things the manual way.

You may get business working with an accountancy firm who deals with small businesses. As part of their understanding of a given business, they may identify ways of streamlining processes which is where you would come in.

Frimley111R

19,436 posts

265 months

Monday 7th October 2013
quotequote all
I have no idea what you are talking about and I suspect your target marketing won't either unless you can give examples and provide a clear and concise description of what it is you can do.

PetrolTed

34,468 posts

334 months

Monday 7th October 2013
quotequote all
Create a website/page detailing the service you offer and with a very simple contact form to get in touch with you.

Buy a few hundred visitors via Google Adwords and see how many of those contact you.

Idea validated for about £50 and you don't have to deliver on those first inquiries necessarily.

Myc

306 posts

192 months

Monday 7th October 2013
quotequote all
I would say the business you are proposing could work but probably only on a supplementary income basis.

We use excel here at work and there's been several occasions were a service such as yours could've saved us many man hours taken out of our core efforts.

However I would be sure to check you really are as good as you think you are.

In my previous couple of companies when compared to other staff I was pretty good at excel and the "go to" guy when people needed help with Excel, moved to new company and when compared to other staff I discovered I was pretty basic at excel, having now spent some time with Excel trainers I realise I am little more than an ape pressing the = button occasionally.

You would hate to walk into a business proclaiming to be an Excel Evangelist only to find out you had overestimated your abilities.

Alternatively look at becoming an Excel Programming contractor, used to be quite in demand a few years ago.

V8mate

45,899 posts

220 months

Monday 7th October 2013
quotequote all
Hoofy said:
You may get business working with an accountancy firm who deals with small businesses. As part of their understanding of a given business, they may identify ways of streamlining processes which is where you would come in.
This is the answer.

The OP needs to sell himself to the professionals, not the end-user businesses. Small firms of accountants will know what they want but may not have the time, skill or wherewithal to create the template in question themselves. Easier for them to sub it out than spend an evening sweating over their previously unopened copy of 'Excel 97'.

V8mate

45,899 posts

220 months

Monday 7th October 2013
quotequote all
...and now you know who your customers are, you validate your business idea by asking them if they'd use such a service!

WTD

Original Poster:

818 posts

264 months

Monday 7th October 2013
quotequote all
Thanks guys, some very valid and useful points raised!

Fotic

719 posts

160 months

Monday 7th October 2013
quotequote all
There are a hundred and one people offering similar services on peopleperhour.com - perhaps you could cut your teeth on there.

V8mate

45,899 posts

220 months

Monday 7th October 2013
quotequote all
Fotic said:
There are a hundred and one people offering similar services on peopleperhour.com - perhaps you could cut your teeth on there.
I wouldn't even think to look on somewhere like that. The OP needs to get out there and network himself and his skills. It's atruist game; often, the kind of stuff he could be doing would be confidential... would you want to send a client's business data to Gupta?

LooneyTunes

9,539 posts

189 months

Monday 7th October 2013
quotequote all
Anyone who can clearly spec what they need (based on REAL inputs, not what they think they've got, and an understanding of what technology can deliver) can probably do it themselves.

Those who can't will almost certainly do one or all of the following:
1) Baulk at the cost
2) Take an age (and consume a lot of your non-billable/pre-sale time) agreeing a spec
3) Decide "that's not quite what I asked for!" when you deliver exactly what was agreed
4) Have sky high expectations of future support (i.e. lots of minor mods and queries, FOC).

Unless you can find a niche, I really think you'd struggle to make a living wage from it - especially when you've taken into account cost of sales.

205alive

6,087 posts

207 months

Monday 7th October 2013
quotequote all
Yes, I would use a service like this. When I see wizardy output from excel it amazes me.

Although I can use a wide range of software, my excel 'skillz' are amoebic. I fear it. If I could have someone on tap who could create custom docs for me and tell me what I need in order to get a result, it would be a real benefit.

(Bookmarked)

jammy_basturd

29,778 posts

243 months

Monday 7th October 2013
quotequote all
Why Excel? Regardless of how powerful it can become when using VBA and clever formulae it always amazes me at how people bend it to fit a purpose instead of letting it just be a spreadsheet application.

I imagine this is a case of making the technology fit the situation, rather than choosing the best technology for the requirements.


Also, how are you going to market this business?

Fotic

719 posts

160 months

Monday 7th October 2013
quotequote all
V8mate said:
I wouldn't even think to look on somewhere like that. The OP needs to get out there and network himself and his skills. It's atruist game; often, the kind of stuff he could be doing would be confidential... would you want to send a client's business data to Gupta?
Wow. What makes him anymore trustworthy than 'Gupta'?

Alec

333 posts

257 months

Tuesday 8th October 2013
quotequote all
PetrolTed said:
Create a website/page detailing the service you offer and with a very simple contact form to get in touch with you.

Buy a few hundred visitors via Google Adwords and see how many of those contact you.

Idea validated for about 50 and you don't have to deliver on those first inquiries necessarily.
This times a thousand. See here for some more advice, http://www.startupbros.com/3-steps-to-validate-you...

jammy_basturd

29,778 posts

243 months

Tuesday 8th October 2013
quotequote all
Alec said:
PetrolTed said:
Create a website/page detailing the service you offer and with a very simple contact form to get in touch with you.

Buy a few hundred visitors via Google Adwords and see how many of those contact you.

Idea validated for about 50 and you don't have to deliver on those first inquiries necessarily.
This times a thousand. See here for some more advice, http://www.startupbros.com/3-steps-to-validate-you...
I'm not so sure Google Adwords is the best option. What key phrases would you go for?

It seems like this is an idea that would mainly spread through word of mouth, so IMO you'd be better off using more social marketing avenues. Create your landing page, then search for Twitter statues containing the word Excel (or similar), do the same for LinkedIn and of course get it out amongst your friends on Facebook. You won't even need to spend a penny to get leads.

PetrolTed

34,468 posts

334 months

Tuesday 8th October 2013
quotequote all
The beauty of adwords is the speed with which you can get some relevant visitors to your site to test conversion rate.

You might well choose other channels in the future, but if you want 100 visitors in the next few days then just pay a few quid and do it. You could have an answer by the end of the week.

This is not necessarily your final or only channel, it's a means of validating your idea.

I did this myself last week - got several hundred visitors to a site to test out an idea and found it needs more work. This is before I've embarked on any real marketing or development other than creating a minimally viable website.

Quick, cheap, got the answer I needed.

Xaero

4,063 posts

246 months

Tuesday 8th October 2013
quotequote all
PetrolTed said:
Create a website/page detailing the service you offer and with a very simple contact form to get in touch with you.

Buy a few hundred visitors via Google Adwords and see how many of those contact you.

Idea validated for about £50 and you don't have to deliver on those first inquiries necessarily.
I was beaten to it, although I personally wouldn't even bother with the quick website for even faster testing. Just put an ad out there and send people to a blank page, if you have lots of impressions but not many clicks, then the idea (or your wording of the advert) is questionable. If you get a decent conversion rate, then move onto the next step (set up a website to take orders, but before people enter their credit card details say it's not available) but do take their email address to let them know when it is. Nothing like an email list full of people who already want to buy whatever your idea is.

jammy_basturd

29,778 posts

243 months

Tuesday 8th October 2013
quotequote all
PetrolTed said:
The beauty of adwords is the speed with which you can get some relevant visitors to your site to test conversion rate.

You might well choose other channels in the future, but if you want 100 visitors in the next few days then just pay a few quid and do it. You could have an answer by the end of the week.

This is not necessarily your final or only channel, it's a means of validating your idea.

I did this myself last week - got several hundred visitors to a site to test out an idea and found it needs more work. This is before I've embarked on any real marketing or development other than creating a minimally viable website.

Quick, cheap, got the answer I needed.
I agree to a certain extent. I know the idea is to create an MVP and to test a certain hypothesis about that idea, but I'd say that from day one you should be marketing to your intended audience. If you don't then you might get 100 click throughs from your GAd, and not much uptake, which you might interpret to mean that your idea isn't viable. On the other hand you might have just got your GAd keyphrases or advert text wrong.


Xaero said:
I was beaten to it, although I personally wouldn't even bother with the quick website for even faster testing. Just put an ad out there and send people to a blank page, if you have lots of impressions but not many clicks, then the idea (or your wording of the advert) is questionable. If you get a decent conversion rate, then move onto the next step (set up a website to take orders, but before people enter their credit card details say it's not available) but do take their email address to let them know when it is. Nothing like an email list full of people who already want to buy whatever your idea is.
It should only take an hour or two to create a basic landing page with a sign up form. Maybe another hour or two to set up some A/B testing if you really wanted. I'd say it's well worth spending at least an hour creating a landing page if you're going to spend £100 on GAds purely for the extra analytics that can be gathered.

V8mate

45,899 posts

220 months

Tuesday 8th October 2013
quotequote all
Xaero said:
I was beaten to it, although I personally wouldn't even bother with the quick website for even faster testing. Just put an ad out there and send people to a blank page, if you have lots of impressions but not many clicks, then the idea (or your wording of the advert) is questionable. If you get a decent conversion rate, then move onto the next step (set up a website to take orders, but before people enter their credit card details say it's not available) but do take their email address to let them know when it is. Nothing like an email list full of people who already want to buy whatever your idea is.
Do you know how hard it is to get a web user to the stage of reaching for their wallet to complete a checkout? Nothing like pissing people off who'll never come back, I'd argue.

I certainly wouldn't elect to buy something from a tinpot, half-arsed website and, even if you persuaded me to risk a purchase, to then give you my email address after you've let me down.

The page Alec linked to was very interesting, but is not suitable for every business. Especially, I'd argue, if it's entirely novel.