Broadband is confusing. Help me!
Broadband is confusing. Help me!
Author
Discussion

ol

Original Poster:

2,387 posts

239 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
I've been looking to put broadband in a house i'm rennovating, and am getting really confused with all the options...

BT told me the maximum 'line speed' was 2 meg, Sky told me i can get 'up to' 8 meg (but up-to is a very wishy washy term...) with a 40gig cap.

I use the internet a lot, and stream lots of video.

Someone was telling me about 'mobile broadband' where you put a USB stick in the computer and bob's your uncle. Is this as good as it sounds??

The house is in a remote village in Northumberland, and i can't get Virgin or cable, and there's no Orange phone reception there either.

Any advice or direction would be much apreciated!

Ta

ol

Original Poster:

2,387 posts

239 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
OK and i realise that i spelt confusing wrong in the thread title!!!!

neil_bolton

17,113 posts

295 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
ol said:
OK and i realise that i spelt confusing wrong in the thread title!!!!
Moved to Computers forum and edited the title for you thumbup

Davi

17,153 posts

251 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
ol said:
I've been looking to put broadband in a house i'm rennovating, and am getting really confused with all the options...

BT told me the maximum 'line speed' was 2 meg, Sky told me i can get 'up to' 8 meg (but up-to is a very wishy washy term...) with a 40gig cap.

I use the internet a lot, and stream lots of video.

Someone was telling me about 'mobile broadband' where you put a USB stick in the computer and bob's your uncle. Is this as good as it sounds??

The house is in a remote village in Northumberland, and i can't get Virgin or cable, and there's no Orange phone reception there either.

Any advice or direction would be much apreciated!

Ta
The up to speed is just that - so if BT tell you that you can get 2 meg, sky are in effect telling you that you can get 2 meg as well - they are just making it sound a lot better. Depends on your distance from exchange etc etc etc but if BT say 2 meg max line speed, 2 meg is the max you'll get even if you go for an "up to 20 meg" package.

ol

Original Poster:

2,387 posts

239 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
Thanks Neil.

Davi - yeah thats what i thought. So what other options are available to me?

I've never used mobile broadband and dont know anyone who has...

Davi

17,153 posts

251 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
ol said:
Thanks Neil.

Davi - yeah thats what i thought. So what other options are available to me?

I've never used mobile broadband and dont know anyone who has...
afraid I can't help on the mobile broadband, never used it. A mate has Satellite broadband which is super stupidly fast, but it cost him more than my car so probably not that viable hehe

ETA just had a thought - is that what you meant by sky? satellite would obviously not be affected by the BT exchange figures... paperbag

Edited by Davi on Thursday 24th July 12:43

FlossyThePig

4,143 posts

274 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
If the property has a phone line and a postcode check it out with SamKnows.

BT do a simpler test.

If BT say you can get 2Mbps the property isn't that isolated, that's all I can get at the moment.

Hugh

Edited by FlossyThePig on Thursday 24th July 12:48

Fetchez la vache

5,914 posts

245 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
FlossyThePig said:
If the property has a phone line and a postcode check it out with SamKnows.

BT do a simpler test.
Yep, and even then treat that with a pinch of salt. The BT link above states a 2mb line, though due to the distance from exchange, I can get a max of 1mb, as stated by the BT engineer who tested from the house.

It's all lies, I tell you, lies!


Edit: Spelling

Edited by Fetchez la vache on Thursday 24th July 12:50

neil_bolton

17,113 posts

295 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
Mobile Broadband works well with the following proviso: Your milage may vary.

Essentially its ste if you don't get a good signal, you'll frequently be dropped to GPRS which is no better than a normal dialup modem.

However, if you have good reception, you'll get the full whack, which IIRC can see you get up to 3.4Mbps.

Worth checking the T+Cs to see if you can return it if its ste reception when you get it home.

A friend uses it solely and is very happy, and I've used it on occasion (via my mobile phone) and its been useful.

ETA: All depends on the carrier.

Edited by neil_bolton on Thursday 24th July 12:51

voyds9

8,490 posts

314 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
Writing this on a wireless broadband dongle. Speed acceptable for surfing, long latency times and small usage limits (£15/month with a 3Gb cap), but it is great for me as I work in 4 different regions and can connect anywhere, but at home a fixed broadband is usually better.

mcflurry

9,192 posts

284 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
neil_bolton said:
Worth checking the T+Cs to see if you can return it if its s***e reception when you get it home.
If you get one from tmobile online, rather than a shop, they give a 14 day nmoney back guarantee if it doesn't work at home smile

I have a wireless 3.6meg connection here, and it is fast once it starts downloading. There is a huge latency before it acts on your clicks though.

Fetchez la vache

5,914 posts

245 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
mcflurry said:
neil_bolton said:
Worth checking the T+Cs to see if you can return it if its s***e reception when you get it home.
If you get one from tmobile online, rather than a shop, they give a 14 day nmoney back guarantee if it doesn't work at home smile

I have a wireless 3.6meg connection here, and it is fast once it starts downloading. There is a huge latency before it acts on your clicks though.
Agree with that, I tried a Three dongle, but no signal, even though the map in the shop had me covered. I took it back within 3 days and good job I did, as the shop said they only had a 3 day trial, even though Three said 14. Shop also played every con in the book to try to get me to keep / pay for it too...

ol

Original Poster:

2,387 posts

239 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
Thanks for the tips,

I tried the Samknows speed test for the new house line, and it's saying the line will only give me 0.5Mbps which i'm guessing is rubbish!!!

I just did a speed test on the broadband at my old house, which is saying i get: Download - 1136 kbps Upload - 226 kbps - so that's what i've used for the past few years.

I'm not good with kb/mb etc so what does it all mean!?! ie is 0.5mbps the same as 500 kbps??


I'm so confused by it all. I just want fast broadband where i can stream videos and download e-mail attachments quickly.


What would you do in my situation???

Munter

31,331 posts

272 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
If your sending a lot of data up and down look for an ISP that will not punish you for it. Virgin regularly chop me down to 1/2 dialup speed for sending lots of data around the place. They swear they dont do it on ADSL, but it only happens after I do big downloads for work....

I'm always tempted by demon as they were one of the 1st ISPs and used to be more helpful than others I believe. Not heard a lot from them in years though...

Davi

17,153 posts

251 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
Munter said:
If your sending a lot of data up and down look for an ISP that will not punish you for it. Virgin regularly chop me down to 1/2 dialup speed for sending lots of data around the place. They swear they dont do it on ADSL, but it only happens after I do big downloads for work....

I'm always tempted by demon as they were one of the 1st ISPs and used to be more helpful than others I believe. Not heard a lot from them in years though...
Believe me, demon is not just their name, it's their attitude as well. Biggest bunch of s I've ever had the displeasure of dealing with. Constant (and I do mean constant) problems with no customer service to resolve them. One of my friends is also being taken to court by them for refusing to pay for 3 months connection when he had no connection - yep, 3 whole months down time and they still think he should pay for it!

fastfreddy

8,577 posts

268 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
Worth adding that if you're considering mobile broadband and you think you are in a fringe area, buy a dongle with an external antenna socket and you can then buy a high gain antenna which you can put on the outside of your house and pull the signal in.

I'm using Vodaphone mobile broadband for £15/month flat rate. I got the standard Vodaphone dongle but then bought an additional Sierra Wireless one which allows me to swap the SIM card if I need to use the external antenna when I'm out in a remote location and I know I'm going to have a problem getting a good strong signal.

It's been a very reliable service and I haven't yet been in a location where I couldn't get the fastest connection speed.

Munter

31,331 posts

272 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
ol said:
What would you do in my situation???
Find somewhere selling the Mobile broadband things and see if you can test one at home/return if if you cant get signal.

For you it sounds like it'll be faster anyway, plus you can take it out and about if you have a laptop. It's a WinWin if it works.

P.s. whos your mobile provider and do you get good signal. If you do, start with them.

ol

Original Poster:

2,387 posts

239 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
Munter said:
ol said:
What would you do in my situation???
Find somewhere selling the Mobile broadband things and see if you can test one at home/return if if you cant get signal.

For you it sounds like it'll be faster anyway, plus you can take it out and about if you have a laptop. It's a WinWin if it works.

P.s. whos your mobile provider and do you get good signal. If you do, start with them.
Unfortunately it's Orange and i dont get phone reception there!!! I'm currently on hold with them trying to disconnect it.

I presume if i get no Orange reception for my mobile i wouldnt be able to get their broadband either?

plasticpig

12,932 posts

256 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
ol said:
Thanks for the tips,

I tried the Samknows speed test for the new house line, and it's saying the line will only give me 0.5Mbps which i'm guessing is rubbish!!!

I just did a speed test on the broadband at my old house, which is saying i get: Download - 1136 kbps Upload - 226 kbps - so that's what i've used for the past few years.

I'm not good with kb/mb etc so what does it all mean!?! ie is 0.5mbps the same as 500 kbps??


I'm so confused by it all. I just want fast broadband where i can stream videos and download e-mail attachments quickly.


What would you do in my situation???
Find and buy diffrent house. Did it not occur to you to check this before buying? You wont actually know what speed you can get until you buy a broadband package or get a BT engineer to test the line.

For sattelite broadband you really need a 2 way link. Typically you will be paying around £1000 for setup and equipment and then around £150 a month for a connection that will give you 256 upload and 1024k download. You can get a 1024k upload and 2046 download service but last time I looked this was mega money. Forget it if you wont to do online gaming though as there is too much latentcy. This may also cause problems for streaming video.

ol

Original Poster:

2,387 posts

239 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
plasticpig said:
ol said:
Thanks for the tips,

I tried the Samknows speed test for the new house line, and it's saying the line will only give me 0.5Mbps which i'm guessing is rubbish!!!

I just did a speed test on the broadband at my old house, which is saying i get: Download - 1136 kbps Upload - 226 kbps - so that's what i've used for the past few years.

I'm not good with kb/mb etc so what does it all mean!?! ie is 0.5mbps the same as 500 kbps??


I'm so confused by it all. I just want fast broadband where i can stream videos and download e-mail attachments quickly.


What would you do in my situation???
Find and buy diffrent house. Did it not occur to you to check this before buying? You wont actually know what speed you can get until you buy a broadband package or get a BT engineer to test the line.

For sattelite broadband you really need a 2 way link. Typically you will be paying around £1000 for setup and equipment and then around £150 a month for a connection that will give you 256 upload and 1024k download. You can get a 1024k upload and 2046 download service but last time I looked this was mega money. Forget it if you wont to do online gaming though as there is too much latentcy. This may also cause problems for streaming video.
Bugger, that's way too expensive.

Maybe i should just sell the house, as i obviously didnt realise i should make the choice of where to live based on Oranges ability to provide services!