Which Honda for a 19000 mile per year commute

Which Honda for a 19000 mile per year commute

Author
Discussion

benson1980

Original Poster:

85 posts

124 months

Sunday 4th October 2015
quotequote all
Hi all. Just after a bit of advice. I currently own a S2000 but I will be starting a new job in the not too distant future which will be an 80 mile round trip, pretty much all motorway. I like my Hondas so the obvious choice would be a Civic or Accord I guess.

I have always much preferred petrols to diesels, due to refinement and less heavy bills; however obviously at this mileage I have been looking at the 2.2 cdti civic, but also the 1.8 vtec.

I know this is going to come down to personal preference at the end of the day, but I'm thinking 45mpg in a petrol (plus about a grand less buying, for equivalent age and mileage), versus maybe mid fifties in a diesel and I'd only be saving £300 to £400 per year if diesel and petrol prices stay the same. This seems a small price to pay for what I presume is going to be reduced bills. Am i missing other benefits? Has anyone on here had both?

That said, any other Hondas that I've missed? It needs to be family friendly (by that just five doors and a reasonable boot will do me) but it would be a bit of a waste lugging about a massive car (hence why I'm slightly put off by the Accord Estate even though buying prices are more favourable than the Civic).


DuraAce

4,240 posts

159 months

Sunday 4th October 2015
quotequote all
45 from a 1.8 petrol is bit hopeful isn't it? You might get 45 in ideal conditions but cant expect to average over a full tank surely?

Diesel for me without question. You'll be increasing miles and decreasing value so get handy with the DIY and your running costs will plummet.

benson1980

Original Poster:

85 posts

124 months

Sunday 4th October 2015
quotequote all
Dunno, some googling would suggest 45mpg on a run. Maybe a bit optimistic though?

I am handy with the DIY so that isn't an issue.

Willy Nilly

12,511 posts

166 months

Monday 5th October 2015
quotequote all
I used to do more than that in a Skoda Favorit and was working some pretty long hours as well. I'd not even consider it an issue in any modern car and have done 400 miles in my Jazz in a day no problem, it rolls along at 80 in a surprisingly relaxed manner.

tozerman

1,175 posts

226 months

Wednesday 7th October 2015
quotequote all
benson1980 said:
Dunno, some googling would suggest 45mpg on a run. Maybe a bit optimistic though?
45MPG from a 1.8, easy, just drive sensibly and you can get up to 50 MPG, done thousands of miles in these 1800's so accurate figures.

Cheers.....Tony..

HayesDC2

285 posts

131 months

Thursday 8th October 2015
quotequote all
According to an online calculator I get about 42.8 mpg from my DC2.

havoc

29,923 posts

234 months

Thursday 8th October 2015
quotequote all
Can I ask a silly question - why a Honda?
- The old Civic diesels were shocking.
- The early CTDi's weren't especially economical
- The later CTDi's are actually pretty good
- The iDTEC has more to go wrong...DPFs, for example, which the CTDi managed without.
(This from conversations with Honda techs...)

...and you'll struggle to get 40mph out of the 1.8i petrol Civic (for example) unless you drive like an absolute saint. Plus that engine will feel a little gutless on an M-way commute...


Depending on budget, I'd be looking at a late E46 330d or an E90 330d (or an Alpina D3). 45+ mpg easy but plenty of power and comfort/toys. Going newer/smaller, I bet you'll get a deal on a Golf GTD (Mk6 or Mk7 to get the proper GTi chassis), or consider a 123d?

Alternatively, on the petrol front I'd be thinking about a modern 1.6T hot hatch, e.g. Fiesta ST - these should be able to return 40+mpg real-world.

GreenArrow

3,550 posts

116 months

Friday 9th October 2015
quotequote all
Oh my how predictable.

Why does the answer to everything have to be a BMW or a Golf GTD?...the Op likes Hondas, he is doing 80 miles a day on a motorway, so a workhorse Honda seems sensible to me and of course a 1.8 petrol will do 40 MPG.

If it were my cash, I think an old Accord CDTI would be the way to go. They seem to cover starship mileages with no problem and are cheap as buttons to buy these days, leaving some cash in the bank for a weekend car which is more interesting!

havoc

29,923 posts

234 months

Friday 9th October 2015
quotequote all
Have you seen my car history?

I like Hondas - I've owned 6 of them over 15 years, but I'm not blinkered to the fact that their petrols do not make for relaxing/effective M-way munchers and their diesels were behind the curve vs the best from BMW and PSA.

I also don't think modern Hondas are as reliable as they used to be...

...so I certainly wouldn't buy one for a high-mile commute. My answers may be predictable but that's for a reason - the BMW 2.0d is one of the best everyday diesels out there and the 3.0d is a genuinely good engine full-stop. Add-in BMW toys/build quality/residuals and they do make a good ownership proposition.

benson1980

Original Poster:

85 posts

124 months

Saturday 10th October 2015
quotequote all
Thanks for the input. I did consider the Accords and have driven one for a week or so a while back. Lovely car but I have a niggle at the back of my mind that diesels will spring up expensive faults somewhere down the line. I also have more confidence servicing a little petrol car myself than a diesel. I'm currently considering a little Aygo ( I know its not a Honda but Toyota would probably be the next choice- anything but German really), cheap as chips road tax, good mpg. I'm not massively fussed about creature comforts. Then maybe a weekend car as well, to replace the S2000, that is now sold frown

arcticfire

1,827 posts

118 months

Friday 16th October 2015
quotequote all
Perhaps one thing to consider for that mileage is that the Accord seats are excellent. Nothing worse than a sore back!

gazzarose

1,158 posts

132 months

Sunday 25th October 2015
quotequote all
I do a bit less mileage than you, about 15k a year, and I was worried about Dpfs blocking. After doing the research it seems I'm just the right side of justifying the diesel. My commute is at least 30 mins each way on the motorway and after a year all seems good. I tend to drive it slowly for a tank or 2, getting ~50mpg, then enjoy it the next tank or 2, getting ~42mpg. Mines the 180hp Type S diesel Accord Tourer and it's quick enough to be fun on country roads (wont be a patch on the S2000, I've got a 2.0 Mx5 for fun), but for a family bus it's been great. The seats are excellent, and it's nice and quiet which is all you need on a motorway.