AA or RAC ?

AA or RAC ?

Author
Discussion

markys

Original Poster:

612 posts

258 months

Monday 30th June 2003
quotequote all
Having put down a deposit on the 4.2 @ adrian blythes last Friday and which I hope to pickup next weekend. Think I will need to invest in some breakdown cover, which is the best, should i have home start etc ?

gixxer1000

786 posts

253 months

Monday 30th June 2003
quotequote all
markys, I have a feeling that the AA are generally better for TVRs. Others will likely confirm (or otherwise) this.

I am a member of the RAC and am not that happy with them for the following 2 reasons:

1) Their policy is to always send a patrol van even if you tell them the car is incapacitated and needs a total lift. This just slows down the process as you need to wait between 30 mins and an hour (usually) for the patrol van to arrive; the driver will immediately say "there's nothing I can do with that car" and then radio for a low-loader; you then wait another 45mins - 1 hour for the recovery truck to arrive. This even winds up the drivers of the initial patrol vans as they hate coming out to TVRs for anything other than simple jobs (flat batteries and the like) as their bonus is affected when they respond to a call but cannot get the car going again. This policy makes the customer and the RAC patrol driver pied off, and is rather stupid.

2) They tend to use contract recovery companies a lot, rather than their own people. My Cerbera needed recovery from home and taken to my dealer a few weeks ago so I booked the lift for 7am. It was mid-week so I figured I'd be on my way to work by 7:30am. The contract company called at 7:30am to say "their driver was in the vicinity but could not find the address". I gave directions and he finally showed up at 8:30am (1.5 hours late). When I questioned the driver on this he started mouthing off at me "It's not my bloody fault", "I'm doing you a favour being here as I was supposed to knock-off an hour ago" etc etc. I was about to tear strips off him (verbally) but thought better of it as I was not accompanying the car to the dealer so didn't want to give this guy an excuse to be less than careful with my car.

This of course is just my experience, but because of it I will not be renewing my membership with the RAC. I used to be in the AA when I had my old Chimaera and never experienced any problems.

Hope this helps


>> Edited by gixxer1000 on Monday 30th June 08:48

GCerbera

5,161 posts

252 months

Monday 30th June 2003
quotequote all
I'm with the AA.

My only experience with them was telling them I had
a car that needed a low loader, but they still sent
a tech, who as Geoff had with the RAC, took one look
and said you're right and called a low loader.

That was due to take another 90 mins.

5 calls from the AA later to apologise for the delay
the 6th call was to say a contractor was going to be
used ( if that was ok with me ) as 'my' lorry had been delayed.

Two more calls from the contractor (one to say he was
lost) and 5 hours after the AA had been called, the car
was picked up ( scratching the underside of the front
of the car as he did so )

That said, I went with the AA as people said it was
better, so goodness knows how bad the RAC would have been?!

mudstud

249 posts

261 months

Monday 30th June 2003
quotequote all
Just tried Norwich union direct - 2/3rds the price of RAC for same service. I asked for and got a transporter but it did take two hours.

mudstud

249 posts

261 months

Monday 30th June 2003
quotequote all
Just tried Norwich union direct - 2/3rds the price of RAC for same service. I asked for and got a transporter but it did take two hours. Lass on the other end of the phone not too sharp either.

markys

Original Poster:

612 posts

258 months

Monday 30th June 2003
quotequote all
We where with the AA but when the other half was pregnant she managed to hit a walking stick in the fast lane of dual carridge way which got stuck on the rear wheel and suspension, she stopped the car phoned the AA and was told that this sort of thing was not covered and would need to arrange something else, very impressed to find that they would not come out to a preggers female stuck in the out side lane of a dual carridge way.

olly

2,174 posts

285 months

Monday 30th June 2003
quotequote all
Just to throw a spanner in the works, Green Flag get my custom for the Cerbera. They have priority over local "Flat bed" recovery companies, so can & will (normally) get a flat bed to you in an hour (AA & RAC quote 2 hours). Ok, they don't fix many by the road, but means your not standing around for 2 hours if/when it needs to go to the dealer.

Olly
(Green Flag(free with WH Warranty) & RAC member)

jamesc

2,820 posts

285 months

Monday 30th June 2003
quotequote all
AA, they are more in tune with the needs of sports car owners. However they offer a better service. I have been a member for 14 years.

James

arcbeer

485 posts

264 months

Monday 30th June 2003
quotequote all
I'm with "Call Assist" as it came with my insurance. Used them once, they again contract out but I told them I needed a low-loader and they sent one first time (no prior inspection).

Only problem I had was 2 break down trucks from 2 different brake down companies broke down on the way to me. Therefore phoned for a truck at 06:15, one eventually arrived at 10:15. Glad I was at home and not stuck on a roadside!

gazzab

21,108 posts

283 months

Monday 30th June 2003
quotequote all
I have used AA once to recover my car after a blow out. They were a blow out !
They refused to send a low loader until their tyre company came out. I told them that they wouldnt have S02s 18 35... They insisted they would. an hour later the tyre co rang me. Told me that they didnt have those tyres. AA then rang me and told me I needed a low loader. 2 hrs later a Low Loader arrived. So I sat at the edge of the road for over 3 hrs !

mike_e

585 posts

264 months

Tuesday 1st July 2003
quotequote all
Bigger company doesn't mean better service, quite the reverse in my opinion. Both the RAC and AA use local independants for vehicle recovery, which means they will receive a bill. They will send their patrol person out first in case he can solve the problem.

The RAC left me stranded for 8 hours once. Patrolman turned up after 45 mins, looked at it for all of 5 mins then called a low loader which took over 7 hours to appear.

Alf Essex

1,467 posts

262 months

Tuesday 1st July 2003
quotequote all
I'm with the RAC but have also got AA cover which came with my new Tuscan.

Recently I got a puncture on the Tuscan and when I asked the RAC that I needed a low loader to take the Tuscan to a TVR approved dealership (ie one that supplies the right type of tyre - won't go to kwik fit!) they said speak to the AA!!!

So called the AA and normally they don't take cars more than 10 miles but were fine to take mine a full 30...because they understand TVR's. They turned up on time with the low loaded and I couldn't have been happier with their level of customer service.

Alan.

whitey

2,508 posts

285 months

Tuesday 1st July 2003
quotequote all
The AA have a "fair play" policy that if you call them out 5 or more times within 2 years they charge you another £40 on renewal. As I recently found out.

jellison

12,803 posts

278 months

Tuesday 1st July 2003
quotequote all
RAC helped me twice in one day last week - not tiv, (40 yt old car!) and have had a few call outs for tiv - one flat battery, on ran out of full, + a tow of over 100miles all within 18months - no extra dosh asked for......